Comparison of electrical thresholds of intradental nerves and jaw-opening reflex in the cat

Intradental mechano-nociceptors serve as sentinels that prevent tooth damage

Pain is the anticipated output of the trigeminal sensory neurons that innervate the tooth's vital interior 1,2 ; however, the contribution of intradental neurons to healthy tooth sensation has yet to be defined. Here, we employ in vivo Ca 2+ imaging to identify and define a population of myelinated high-threshold mechanoreceptors (intradental HTMRs) that detect superficial structural damage of the tooth and initiate jaw opening to protect teeth from damage. Intradental HTMRs remain inactive when direct forces are applied to the intact tooth but become responsive to forces when the structural integrity of the tooth is compromised, and the dentin or pulp is exposed. Their terminals collectively innervate the inner dentin through overlapping receptive fields, allowing them to monitor the superficial structures of the tooth. Indeed, intradental HTMRs detect superficial enamel damage and encode its degree, and their responses persist in the absence of either PIEZO2 or Na v 1.8 3,4 . Optogenetic activation of intradental HTMRs triggers a rapid, jaw opening reflex via contraction of the digastric muscle. Taken together, our data indicate that intradental HTMRs serve as sentinels that guard against mechanical threats to the tooth, and their activation results in physical tooth separation to minimize irreversible structural damage. Our work provides a new perspective on the role of intradental neurons as protective rather than exclusively pain-inducing and illustrates additional diversity in the functions of interoreceptors.

Applications of sensory and physiological measurement in oral-facial dental pain

Dentists regularly employ a variety of self‐report and sensory techniques to aid in the diagnosis and treatment of tooth‐related disease. Many of these techniques leverage principles borrowed from psychophysics, the quantitative measurement of the relationship between stimuli and evoked sensations, which falls under the larger umbrella of quantitative sensory testing (QST). However, most clinicians fail to meet the bar for what could be considered quantitative sensory testing, and instead focus on qualitative and dichotomous “yes/no” aspects of sensory experience. With our current subjective measurements for pain assessments, diagnosis and treatment of dental pain in young children and individuals (any age) with severe cognitive impairment rely extensively on third‐party observations. Consequently, the limitation of inadequate pain diagnosis can lead to poor pain management. In this review, it discusses mechanisms that underlie acute and chronic dental pain. It details the measurement of somatosensory responses and pulpal blood flow as objective measures of tooth health and pain. It proposes that bridging these varied methodologies will significantly improve diagnosis and treatment of orofacial pain and pathology. It concludes that improving the precision of sensory measurements could yield important improvements in diagnostic challenges in pulpal pathology for noncommunicative and cognitively impaired individuals.

Nociceptive thermal threshold testing in horses - effect of neuroleptic sedation and neuroleptanalgesia at different stimulation sites

Background

Aim of the study was to compare the effect of neuroleptic sedation with acepromazine and neuroleptanalgesia with acepromazine and buprenorphine on thermal thresholds (TT) obtained at the nostrils and at the withers. The study was carried out as a randomized, blinded, controlled trial with cross-over design. Thermal thresholds were determined by incremental contact heat applied to the skin above the nostril (N) or the withers (W). Eleven horses were treated with saline (S), acepromazine (0.05 mg/kg) (ACE) or acepromazine and buprenorphine (0.0075 mg/kg) (AB) intravenously (IV). Single stimulations were performed 15 minutes prior and 15, 45, 75, 105, 165, 225, 285, 405 and 525 minutes after treatment. Sedation score, gastrointestinal auscultation score and occurrence of skin lesions were recorded. Data were analysed with analysis of variance for repeated measurements.

Results

There were no significant differences in TT between N and W with all treatments. The TT remained constant after S and there was no difference in TT between S and ACE. After AB there was a significant increase above baseline in TT until 405 minutes after treatment. Restlessness occurred 30–90 minutes after AB in 7 horses. All horses had reduced to absent borborygmi after AB administration for 165 to 495 minutes.

Conclusion

Thermal stimulation at both described body areas gives comparable results in the assessment of cutaneous anti-nociception in horses. There is no differential influence of neuroleptic sedation or neuroleptanalgesia on TTs obtained at N or W. Buprenorphine combined with acepromazine has a long lasting anti-nociceptive effect associated with the typical opioid induced side effects in horses.

Striatal Inhibition of Nociceptive Responses Evoked in Trigeminal Sensory Neurons by Tooth Pulp Stimulation

The noxious evoked response in trigeminal sensory neurons was studied to address the role of striatum in the control of nociceptive inputs. In urethane-anesthetized rats, the jaw opening reflex (JOR) was produced by suprathreshold stimulation of the tooth pulp and measured as electromyographic response in the digastric muscle, with simultaneous recording of noxious responses in single unit neurons of the spinal trigeminal nucleus pars caudalis (Sp5c). The microinjection of glutamate (80 ηmol/0.5 μl) into striatal JOR inhibitory sites significantly decreased the Aδ and C fiber–mediated–evoked response (53 ± 4.2 and 43.6 ± 6.4% of control value, P < 0.0001) in 92% (31/34) of nociceptive Sp5c neurons. The microinjection of the solvent was ineffective, as was microinjection of glutamate in sites out of the JOR inhibitory ones. In another series of experiments, simultaneous single unit recordings were performed in the motor trigeminal nucleus (Mo5) and the Sp5c nucleus. Microinjection of glutamate decreased the noxious-evoked response in Sp5c and Mo5 neurons in parallel with the JOR, without modifying spontaneous neuronal activity of trigeminal motoneurons ( n = 8 pairs). These results indicate that the striatum could be involved in the modulation of nociceptive inputs and confirm the role of the basal ganglia in the processing of nociceptive information.

The effects of noxious dental heating on the jaw-opening reflex and trigeminal Fos expression in the ferret

Previous studies have established that the activation of peripheral nociceptors alters the central processing of nociceptive stimuli. In this study, we examined whether noxious heating of the dental pulp enhances the nociceptive jaw-opening reflex (JOR) and the expression of the immediate early gene c-fos in chloral hydrate/pentobarbital-anesthetized ferrets. We hypothesized that the application of noxious heat to the dental pulp, a procedure that evokes a preferential activation of pulpal C-fibers, will enhance JOR responses to electrical stimulation of the tooth pulp and that this enhanced response will be associated with the expression of Fos protein in discrete regions of the trigeminal nucleus. Consistent with our predictions, we observed that noxious heat conditioning enhanced the JOR as indicated by an increase in the magnitude of the signal averaged digastric electromyogram response evoked by electrical stimuli applied to either a heat-conditioned maxillary canine or the contralateral nonconditioned canine. The enhancement in JOR responses was independent of temporal summation of the electrical stimulus for test stimuli delivered at either 1.0 or 0.1 Hz. Sensitization of the JOR was associated with an increase in the number of immunohistochemically identified Fos-positive nuclei in trigeminal caudalis (Vc) and the transition zone between trigeminal interpolaris and caudalis (Vi/Vc) ipsilateral to the site of stimulation compared with sham stimulated animals. These findings suggest that neuronal populations in Vc and Vi/Vc play a role in the enhanced reflex responses to tooth pulp stimulation and may contribute to the pain and hyperalgesia associated with a symptomatic pulpitis.

Effects of alternating and direct electrical current application on the odontoblastic layer in human teeth: an in vitro study

AIM

The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of a low intensity alternating current on the odontoblasts and odontoblast layer and compare this with the effects of a direct current.

METHODOLOGY

Teeth extracted for orthodontic reasons were immersed in physiological saline stabilized with thymol crystals. Within 1 h of extraction, an alternating or direct current was applied on the crown in the direction of the apex of the tooth for 120-360 s. The current doses were 12, 30, 60, 600, 1800, 3600, 7200, 24,000 and 144,000 microC. The teeth were fixed in Bouin or Baker fluids, the pulps removed, dehydrated and immersed in paraffin, then sectioned, stained with haematoxylin and eosin, and studied under a light microscope.

RESULTS

Neither direct nor alternating current, similar to that applied in electrical caries diagnosis caused histological changes in the odontoblasts.

CONCLUSIONS

There was no difference between direct and low intensity alternating current in the response of the odontoblast.

Neurokinin-1 receptor expression in the mature dental pulp of rats

Substance P induces inflammatory reactions in peripheral tissues including the dental pulp, but its regulatory effects in target tissues are dependent on receptor signalling. Here the expression of the substance-P receptor neurokinin-1 (NK1) in the mature molar pulp of the rat was examined in order to localize the main target areas for substance P. A polyclonal antibody directed against the C-terminal of the receptor was used, and immunohistochemistry was performed by the avidin-biotin peroxidase complex method. The results showed that the NK1 receptor was intensely expressed along vessel-like structures in the odontoblast and subodontoblast layer. A granulated and diffusely distributed NK1-receptor labelling was found along larger blood vessels in the root pulp and pulp proper. NK1 receptor-positive cells were frequently observed in the cell-rich zone beneath the odontoblast layer. The results indicate that, in the mature rat molar pulp, the main targets for substance P acting through the NK1 receptors are tissues related to blood vessels in the odontoblast and subodontoblast area. Furthermore, the expression of NK1 receptors on cells located in the subodontoblast area could indicate that substance P also affects cell functions in this area.

Differential effects of noxious conditioning stimulation of the cheek by capsaicin on human sensory and inhibitory masseter reflex responses evoked by tooth pulp stimulation

In this study, we investigated whether selective activation of nociceptive primary afferent fibers by capsaicin would induce modulations on tooth-pulp-evoked sensory or inhibitory masseter reflex responses in healthy human subjects. The contribution of central N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor mechanisms in capsaicin-induced effects on sensory or reflex responses was evaluated by dextromethorphan, an NMDA-receptor antagonist. The inhibitory masseter reflex was evoked by electrical stimulation (constant current, single pulses) of the upper incisor while the subject was biting at 10% of his maximal force. The sensation of the tooth pulp stimulation was evaluated by visual analogue scale (VAS). The magnitude, duration, and the the latency of the reflex were determined by bite force measurements. The inhibitor masseter reflex could be induced by non-painful tooth pulp stimulation, and the inhibition was enhanced as a function of increasing stimulus intensity. Capsaicin (1%) applied topically to the skin of the cheek produced a spontaneous burning pain sensation. During capsaicin treatment, the VAS ratings for the sensation induced by tooth pulp stimulation were significantly reduced, whereas no significant changes were found in the tooth-pulp-induced masseter reflex responses. Double-blind treatment with dextromethorphan at a dose of 100 mg (= the highest does without side-effects) had no effect on sensory or reflex responses. These data indicate that noxious stimulation of the facial skin by capsaicin induces differential effects on tooth-pulp-evoked sensory and inhibitory masseter reflex responses: Sensory responses are strongly attenuated, while masseter reflex responses are not significantly changed. Dextromethorphan at a clinically applicable dose does not influence tooth-pulp-evoked sensory or reflex responses or their modulation by capsaicin. Furthermore, the lack of modulation of the masseter reflex response by capsaicin differs from the capsaicin-induced enhancement of a nocifensive limb flexion reflex described earlier.

Dental innervation: functions and plasticity after peripheral injury

Oral tissues including the periodontal ligament, gingiva, and tooth pulp have a relatively dense sensory innervation and a rich vascular supply. Teeth and supporting tissues are susceptible to tissue injury and inflammation, partly due to lack of collateral blood and nerve supply and to their low compliance. This review focuses on dental nerve functions and adaptive changes in the trigeminal ganglion and tooth pulp after peripheral injuries. An overview of the peptidergic innervation of oral tissues is presented, followed by a discussion of plasticity in neuropeptide expression in trigeminal peripheral neurons after local insults to teeth and peripheral nerve injuries. The functional implications of these adaptive changes are considered, with special reference to nerve regeneration, inflammation, and hemodynamic regulation.

Noxious stimuli do not determine reflex cardiorespiratory effects in anesthetized rabbits

The main purpose of this study is to examine whether the stimulation of an exclusively pain-sensing receptive field (dental pulp) could determine cardiorespiratory effects in animals in which the cortical integration of the peripheral information is abolished by deep anesthesia. In 15 anesthetized (alpha-chloralose and urethan) rabbits, low (3-Hz)- and high-frequency (100-Hz) electrical dental pulp stimulation was performed. Because this stimulation caused dynamic and static reflex contractions of the digastric muscles leading to jaw opening jaw-opening reflex (JOR); an indirect sign of algoceptive fiber activation], experimentally induced direct dynamic and static contractions of the digastric muscle were also performed. The low- and high-frequency stimulation of the dental pulp determined cardiovascular [systolic arterial pressure (SAP): -21.7 +/- 4.6 and 10.8 +/- 4.7 mmHg, respectively] and respiratory [pulmonary ventilation (VE): 145.1 +/- 44.9 and 109.3 +/- 28.4 ml/min, respectively] reflex responses similar to those observed during experimentally induced dynamic (SAP: -17.5 +/- 4.2 mmHg; VE: 228.0 +/- 58.5 ml/min) and static (SAP: 5.8 +/- 1.5 mmHg; VE: 148.0 +/- 75.3 ml/min) muscular contractions. The elimination of digastric muscular contraction (JOR) obtained by muscular paralysis did away with the cardiovascular changes induced by dental pulp stimulation, the effectiveness of which in stimulating dental pulp receptors has been shown by recording trigeminal-evoked potentials in six additional rabbits. The main conclusion was that, in deeply anesthetized animals, an algesic stimulus is unable to determine cardiorespiratory effects, which appear to be exclusively linked to the stimulation of ergoreceptors induced by muscular contraction.

Three groups of afferent pulpal feline nerve fibres show different electrophysiological response properties

Responses were recorded, after the application of four types of stimuli (slow or rapid elevation of temperature, hydrostatic negative pressure through thin dentine, and bradykinin directly applied to exposed pulp), from functional single fibres innervating the cat lower canine tooth pulp, dissected from the inferior alveolar nerve. A total of 278 single pulpal fibres were isolated. A fibres (n = 220) were divided into two groups: one (FA; fast A fibre, n = 160) consisting of those whose conduction velocities (CVs) were more than 2 m/s both inside and outside the tooth pulp, and the other (SA delta; slow A delta fibre, n = 60) consisting of those whose intrapulpal CVs were less than 2 m/s and extrapulpal CVs greater than 2 m/s. Fifty eight C fibres (C) were also found. None of FA, 40% of SA delta and 52% of C responded to continuous heat. None of C, 47% of FA and 45% of SA delta responded to rapid elevation of temperature. None of C, 20% of FA and 20% of SA delta responded to hydrostatic pressure. None of FA, 83% of SA delta and all of C responded to bradykinin. It was found that 21 of 60 SA delta responded to both types of stimuli that reportedly activate only A (rapid heat and hydrostatic negative pressure) or C (continuous slow heat and bradykinin) nerve fibres and that 29 SA delta responded to slow heating and/or bradykinin, similar to C fibres.

The origin of short- and long-latency mylohyoid nerve responses elicited by high-intensity electrical stimulation of intradental nerve in cats

A double reflex response of the mylohyoid nerve to the jaw depressor muscles after electrical stimulation of the intradental nerves was recorded in cats anaesthetized with alpha-chloralose. The threshold value of the long-latency (16-19 ms) response was almost 20 times greater than that of the short-latency (5-8 ms) response. At the threshold intensity of the long-latency response, the short-latency response with shorter latency appeared. After extirpation of the stimulated tooth pulp, the short-latency response with a lower threshold disappeared, whereas the short-latency response with a higher threshold and the long-latency response both persisted and showed no change in threshold or latency. These findings indicate that the low-threshold, short-latency response was due to excitation of pulpal nerve fibres, while the high-threshold, short-latency response and the long-latency response were both due to excitation of extrapulpal afferent fibres as a result of the spread of current outside the tooth.

Response characteristics of tooth pulp-driven postsynaptic neurons in the spinal trigeminal subnucleus oralis of the cat

Neuronal activity in the spinal trigeminal subnucleus oralis in response to electrical tooth stimulation was recorded in the anaesthetized cat in order to compare the electrophysiological characteristics of the oralis neurons with those of subnucleus caudalis and interpolaris neurons recorded in previous studies. The most sensitive oralis neurons had lower thresholds and shorter latencies than the most sensitive caudalis and interpolaris neurons. The thresholds of the oralis neurons were lower and their strength-duration curves flatter than those depicting liminal dental pain in man but similar to those depicting liminal jaw reflexes in the cat. Noxious conditioning stimulus elevated the threshold of only 1 of 10 neurons tested. The converging input from the skin and oral mucosa was from low-threshold mechanoreceptors. The results indicate that the response properties of the subnucleus oralis neurons differ significantly from those of other spinal subnuclei. Human pain thresholds cannot be explained by the liminal response properties of oralis neurons. These neurons might be important in the mediation of liminal reflex events evoked by dental stimuli.

Involvement of afferent nerves in pulpal blood-flow reactions in response to clinical and experimental procedures in the cat

A unilateral resection of the mandibular nerve (n = 20) was made 10-14 days before investigation of the contribution of afferent nerves in vasodilator reactions in the dental pulp. Lower canine teeth were subjected to various stimuli and pulp blood-flow responses monitored by laser Doppler flowmetry. An absence of response to bipolar electrical (5 impulses, 50 microA, 5 ms, 2 Hz) stimulation on the tooth surface was used to demonstrate a successful chronic nerve lesion. Local application of capsaicin (10(-4) M) in a deep dentinal cavity induced a long-lasting increase in pulpal blood flow in control teeth only. Bradykinin (10(-3) M) induced significantly larger responses in control than in denervated teeth (58.3 +/- 9.8% and 24.5 +/- 4.9%, respectively, p less than 0.005, n = 8); in addition, the onset was slower and the duration of the response significantly (60%) shorter than in control teeth. Intermittent grinding of surface dentine instantly increased flow in control teeth by 53.0 +/- 12.5% (n = 12) whereas in denervated teeth the response was delayed and significantly (70%) smaller. Deeper preparation produced responses of similar magnitude in control and denervated teeth (69 and 50%, respectively) but the onset was delayed in denervated teeth. Low-intensity ultrasonic stimulation caused vasodilation in intact teeth (38% increase) but had no effect in denervated teeth. This effect was abolished after local anaesthetic (mepivacaine) injection. Sympathectomy (n = 3) did not influence stimulation-induced blood-flow responses in the dental pulp.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Intradental nerve activity and jaw-opening reflex in response to mechanical deformation of cat teeth

Mechanical stress was applied to canine teeth in anaesthetized cats to excite intradental A-fibres and to produce digastric muscle EMG responses. Activity in the intradental sensory units was recorded by two electrodes, one inserted in a dentinal cavity, the other in contact with the gingival sulcus. A pneumatically driven piston was used to cause a mechanical stress (10-150 N) on the stabilized tooth crown for 30 s, with instantaneous onset and release. Application of a load of 30 N produced a momentary burst of impulses in 2 of 12 teeth; 8 out of 10 teeth responded when 150 N was used. Digastric EMG responses were obtained at and above 60 N. Removal of the coronal pulp or cooling of the tooth crown with ethyl chloride abolished this reflex, whereas percussion of the tooth still produced a digastric response. Our results suggest that load-induced deformation of teeth activates intradental sensory mechanisms and a reflex withdrawal reaction unrelated to periodontal stimulation.

Response characteristics of tooth pulp-driven postsynaptic neurons in the spinal trigeminal subnucleus interpolaris of the cat: comparison with primary afferent fiber, subnucleus caudalis, reflex, and sensory responses

Tooth pulp-evoked single neuron responses were recorded in the spinal trigeminal subnucleus interpolaris of the cat. The thresholds to monopolar electric pulses of varying duration (0.2-20 ms) were determined using a constant current stimulator. The thresholds were comparable with those of primary afferent A-fibers, although the most sensitive primary afferent fibers have lower thresholds. The thresholds and latencies showed that none of the interpolaris neurons received their input solely from intradental C-fibers. The most sensitive subnucleus interpolaris neurons had lower thresholds than the respective subnucleus caudalis neurons studied in our previous work. The thresholds and strength-duration curves of the most sensitive interpolaris neurons and of the tooth pulp-elicited jaw-opening reflex are nearly similar, although the jaw reflex can be elicited at an intensity which is slightly lower than that needed to activate the most sensitive interpolaris neurons of the present sample. The most sensitive interpolaris neurons were activated at current intensities that were below the intensity needed to produce liminal dental pain in man, and the strength-duration curves of these neurons were flatter than the curve depicting liminal dental pain sensation in man. The relationship between stimulus intensity and response magnitude could be well described by power functions, the median exponent of which was 1.251. A conditioning stimulation of the tooth pulp at low intensity produced a short (less than 25 ms) enhancement of the response to the following test stimulus, whereas a high intensity conditioning stimulus produced a longer (greater than 40 ms) suppression of the response to the following stimulus. The threshold of 33% of the neurons was elevated during a noxious tail pinch, and this elevation was not reversed by naloxone, an opioid antagonist. The results indicate that in the trigeminal subnucleus interpolaris there are tooth pulp-driven neurons with an input from intradental A-fibers and that a considerable temporal summation of impulses from primary afferent fibers is needed to activate most of them. Human dental pain thresholds cannot be explained by the liminal response properties of the most sensitive interpolaris neurons, but they may be important in the mediation of near-threshold reflex events. It is possible, however, that the high-threshold interpolaris neurons may have a role in the mediation of sensory responses.

Tooth pulp-evoked activity in the spinal trigeminal nucleus caudalis of cat: comparison to primary afferent fiber, reflex, and sensory responses

Tooth pulp-evoked single-neuron responses were recorded in the spinal trigeminal nucleus caudalis of the cat. The thresholds to monopolar electric pulses of various durations (0.2 to 20 ms) were determined using a constant current stimulator. With stimulus pulse durations of 10 to 20 ms, the thresholds were comparable with those of primary afferent A-fibers, although the most sensitive primary afferent fibers had lower thresholds. Primary afferent C-fibers had higher thresholds than the postsynaptic neurons studied. The threshold for the tooth pulp-elicited jaw-opening response was obtained at a lower stimulus intensity than the liminal response in most postsynaptic neurons of this study. The threshold rise of the postsynaptic trigeminal neurons with decreasing stimulus pulse duration (from 5 to 0.2 ms) was much steeper than that of primary afferent A-fibers or jaw-opening response. The strength-duration curves for tooth pulp-elicited pain sensations in man resemble those of spinal trigeminal neurons. Sixty-two percent of the units had a threshold elevation during a noxious pinch of the tail. The results indicate that the activation of postsynaptic trigeminal neurons requires a considerable temporal summation of primary afferent impulses. The jaw reflex thresholds cannot be explained by the properties of the neurons in the subnucleus caudalis of the trigeminal tract. The results support the concept that dental pain is based on the activation of spinal trigeminal nucleus caudalis neurons receiving their input from intradental A-fibers.

Tooth pulp-evoked jaw-opening reflex in the cat: evidence for central facilitation induced by noxious discharge in the intradental nerve fibers

The tooth pulp-evoked jaw-opening reflex was studied in the barbiturate-anesthetized cat. At liminal intensity of the stimulus, a stable short-latency response was obtained in the digastricus and in the tongue. At a higher stimulus intensity, there occasionally appeared to be a prolonged discharge of variable duration in the digastricus, and a second period of activity in the tongue after a silent period. The threshold intensity for these late discharges was supraliminal for the intradental A-fibers and subliminal for intradental C-fibers. Noxious conditioning stimulation of a tooth led to a temporary decrease of the threshold for the jaw-opening reflex elicited from a contralateral or adjacent tooth; only conditioning stimulation at an intensity producing a marked arousal reaction was effective in this respect. Infiltration of the tooth apex with epinephrine produced a local elevation of the threshold for the tooth pulp-evoked jaw-opening reflex. Distant noxious conditioning stimulation (tail pinch) did not influence the jaw-opening threshold. The results indicated that based on some central mechanisms, conditioning noxious stimulation of a tooth can produce a facilitation of the jaw-opening reflex.

Is the jaw-opening reflex a valid model of pain?

Tooth pulp shock does not produce only pain; low intensity stimulation results in a non-painful sensation that is termed pre-pain. In animals low intensity tooth pulp shock does not evoke escape behavior; the similarity of the animal escape/detection threshold ratio with the human pain/pre-pain threshold ratio is evidence that pre-pain and pain may be present in animals as in humans. Both pre-pain and pain may arise from the activation of a common afferent modality. The TP-JOR does not correlate with the degree of pain experienced under all conditions. The TP-JOR threshold is at or near the sensory detection threshold, at stimulation intensities which evoke pre-pain. Under normal conditions both the magnitude of the TP-JOR response and the degree of pain experienced increase with increasing stimulation intensity. The TP-JOR and the tooth pulp-evoked pain are affected in parallel by sensory habituation and both appear to relay in the rostral trigeminal complex. There are no cases where the TP-JOR is suppressed and pain is still experienced from tooth pulp shock; the suppression of the TP-JOR may therefore be an accurate index of analgesia. However, in humans treatments that produce analgesia have not been shown to produce suppression of the TP-JOR. Thus, the TP-JOR that persists following analgesic treatments is not a reliable index of either analgesia or pain.