Distribution of recurrent inhibition in the human upper limb

Transient increase in recurrent inhibition in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis as a putative protection from neurodegeneration

AIM

Adaptive mechanisms in spinal circuits are likely involved in homeostatic responses to maintain motor output in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Given the role of Renshaw cells in regulating the motoneuron input/output gain, we investigated the modulation of heteronymous recurrent inhibition.

METHODS

Electrical stimulations were used to activate recurrent collaterals resulting in the Hoffmann reflex depression. Inhibitions from soleus motor axons to quadriceps motoneurons, and vice versa, were tested in 38 patients and matched group of 42 controls.

RESULTS

Compared with controls, the mean depression of quadriceps reflex was larger in patients, while that of soleus was smaller, suggesting that heteronymous recurrent inhibition was enhanced in quadriceps but reduced in soleus. The modulation of recurrent inhibition was linked to the size of maximal direct motor response and lower limb dysfunctions, suggesting a significant relationship with the integrity of the target motoneuron pool and functional abilities. No significant link was found between the integrity of motor axons activating Renshaw cells and the level of inhibition. Enhanced inhibition was particularly observed in patients within the first year after symptom onset and with slow progression of lower limb dysfunctions. Normal or reduced inhibitions were mainly observed in patients with motor weakness first in lower limbs and greater dysfunctions in lower limbs.

CONCLUSION

We provide the first evidence for enhanced recurrent inhibition and speculate that Renshaw cells might have transient protective role on motoneuron by counteracting hyperexcitability at early stages. Several mechanisms likely participate including cortical influence on Renshaw cell and reinnervation by slow motoneurons.

Neural control of the healthy pectoralis major from low-to-moderate isometric contractions

The pectoralis major critically enables arm movement in several directions. However, its neural control remains unknown. High-density electromyography (HD-sEMG) was acquired from the pectoralis major in two sets of experiments in healthy young adults. Participants performed ramp-and-hold isometric contractions in: adduction, internal rotation, flexion, and horizontal adduction at three force levels: 15%, 25%, and 50% scaled to task-specific maximal voluntary force (MVF). HD-sEMG signals were decomposed into motor unit spike trains using a convolutive blind source separation algorithm and matched across force levels using a motor unit matching algorithm. The mean discharge rate and coefficient of variation were quantified across the hold and compared between 15% and 25% MVF across all tasks, whereas comparisons between 25% and 50% MVF were made where available. Mean motor unit discharge rate was not significantly different between 15% and 25% MVF (all P > 0.05) across all tasks or between 25% and 50% MVF in horizontal adduction (P = 0.11), indicating an apparent saturation across force levels and the absence of rate coding. These findings suggest that the pectoralis major likely relies on motor unit recruitment to increase force, providing first-line evidence of motor unit recruitment in this muscle and paving the way for more deliberate investigations of the pectoralis major involvement in shoulder function.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This work is the first to investigate the relative contribution of rate coding and motor unit recruitment in the pectoralis major muscle in several functionally relevant tasks and across varying force levels in healthy adults. Our results demonstrate the absence of motor unit rate coding with an increase in EMG amplitude with increases in force level in all tasks examined, indicating that the pectoralis major relies on motor unit recruitment to increase force.

The human central nervous system transmits common synaptic inputs to distinct motor neuron pools during non-synergistic digit actions

KEY POINTS

Neural connectivity between distinct motor neuronal modules in the spinal cord is classically studied through electrical stimulation or multi-muscle EMG recordings. We quantified the strength of correlation in the activity of two distinct populations of motor neurons innervating the thenar and first dorsal interosseous muscles during tasks that required the two hand muscles to exert matched or un-matched forces in different directions. We show that when the two hand muscles are concurrently activated, synaptic input to the two motor neuron pools is shared across all frequency bandwidths (representing cortical and spinal input) associated with force control. The observed connectivity indicates that motor neuron pools receive common input even when digit actions do not belong to a common behavioural repertoire.

ABSTRACT

Neural connectivity between distinct motor neuronal modules in the spinal cord is classically studied through electrical stimulation or multi-muscle EMG recordings. Here we quantify the strength of correlation in the activity of two distinct populations of motor neurons innervating the thenar and first dorsal interosseous muscles in humans during voluntary contractions. To remove confounds associated with previous studies, we used a task that required the two hand muscles to exert matched or un-matched forces in different directions. Despite the force production task consisting of uncommon digit force coordination patterns, we found that synaptic input to motor neurons is shared across all frequency bands, reflecting cortical and spinal inputs associated with force control. The coherence between discharge timings of the two pools of motor neurons was significant at the delta (0-5 Hz), alpha (5-15 Hz) and beta (15-35 Hz) bands (P < 0.05). These results suggest that correlated input to motor neurons of two hand muscles can occur even during tasks not belonging to a common behavioural repertoire and despite lack of common innervation. Moreover, we show that the extraction of activity from motor neurons during voluntary force control removes cross-talk associated with global EMG recordings, thus allowing direct in vivo interrogation of spinal motor neuron activity.

Effects of vibration on cutaneous silent period

Suppression of an ongoing muscle contraction following noxious digital stimulation is called cutaneous silent period (CSP) which is under the influence of several physiological factors. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the influence of group Ia afferents on the cutaneous silent period (CSP) by applying 2-min vibration. CSP was obtained from abductor pollicis brevis muscle after stimulating index finger. The recordings were repeated three times-before, during and after vibration-which was applied over the tendon of flexor carpi radialis muscle. Onset latency, duration and magnitude of total CSP, inhibitory phases I1 and I2, and of the long-loop reflex were measured and compared. Suppression indices of CSP, I1 and I2 increased significantly during and after vibration, indicating significantly less exteroceptive EMG suppression outlasting the time of vibration. Vibration also caused mild shortening of I2 end latency (p = 0.048) and I2 duration (p = 0.019). Our findings indicate that vibration exerts a powerful influence on CSPs and causes reduction in the magnitude of exteroceptive EMG suppression during and after vibration. Although vibration is known to activate Ia afferents, we cannot exclude contribution of other afferents, e.g. mechanoreceptors, as well as pre- or postsynaptic inhibitory effects on ensuing interneurons, or enhanced vibration-related excitatory influence.

Inhibitory interneuron circuits at cortical and spinal levels are associated with individual differences in corticomuscular coherence during isometric voluntary contraction

Corticomuscular coherence (CMC) is an oscillatory synchronization of 15-35 Hz (β-band) between electroencephalogram (EEG) of the sensorimotor cortex and electromyogram of contracting muscles. Although we reported that the magnitude of CMC varies among individuals, the physiological mechanisms underlying this variation are still unclear. Here, we aimed to investigate the associations between CMC and intracortical inhibition (ICI) in the primary motor cortex (M1)/recurrent inhibition (RI) in the spinal cord, which probably affect oscillatory neural activities. Firstly, we quantified ICI from changes in motor-evoked potentials induced by paired-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation in M1 during tonic isometric voluntary contraction of the first dorsal interosseous. ICI showed a significant, negative correlation with the strength of EEG β-oscillation, but not with the magnitude of CMC across individuals. Next, we quantified RI from changes in H-reflexes induced by paired-pulse electrical nerve stimulation to the posterior tibial nerve during isometric contraction of the soleus muscle. We observed a significant, positive correlation between RI and peak CMC across individuals. These results suggest that the local inhibitory interneuron networks in cortical and spinal levels are associated with the oscillatory activity in corticospinal loop.

Visuomotor Correction is a Robust Contributor to Force Variability During Index Finger Abduction by Older Adults

We examined aging-related differences in the contribution of visuomotor correction to force fluctuations during index finger abduction via the analysis of two datasets from similar subjects. Study (1) Young (N = 27, 23 ± 8 years) and older adults (N = 14, 72 ± 9 years) underwent assessment of maximum voluntary contraction force (MVC) and force steadiness during constant-force (CF) index finger abduction (2.5, 30, 65% MVC). For each trial, visual feedback of the force (VIS) was provided for 8–10 s and removed for 8–10 s (NOVIS). Visual gain of the force feedback at 2.5% MVC was high; 12- and 26-fold greater than the 30 and 65% MVC targets. Mean force, standard deviation (SD) of force, and coefficient of variation (CV) of force was calculated for detrended (<0.5 Hz drift removed) VIS and NOVIS data segments. Study (2) A similar group of 14 older adults performed discrete, randomly-ordered VIS or NOVIS trials at low target forces (1–3% MVC) and high visual gain. Study (1) For young adults the CV of force was similar between VIS and NOVIS for the 2.5% (4.8 vs. 4.3%), 30% (3.2 vs. 3.2%) and 65% (3.5 vs. 4.2%) target forces. In contrast, for older adults the CV of force was greater for VIS than NOVIS for 2.5% MVC (6.6 vs. 4.2%, p < 0.001), but not for the 30% (2.4 vs. 2.4%) and 65% (3.1 vs. 3.3%) target forces. At 2.5% MVC, the increase in CV of force for VIS compared with NOVIS was significantly greater (age × visual condition p = 0.008) for older than young adults. Study (2) Similarly, for older adults performing discrete, randomly ordered trials the CV of force was greater for VIS than NOVIS (6.04 vs. 3.81%, p = 0.01). When visual force feedback was a dominant source of information at low forces, normalized force variability was ~58% greater for older adults, but only 11% greater for young adults. The significant effect of visual feedback for older adults was not dependent on the order of presentation of visual conditions. The results indicate that impaired processing of visuomotor information underlies the greater motor variability observed in older adults during lab-based isometric contractions of a hand muscle.

Transposed firing activation of motor units

Muscles are composed of groups of muscle fibers, called motor units, each innervated by a single motoneuron originating in the spinal cord. During constant or linearly varying voluntary force contractions, motor units are activated in a hierarchical order, with the earlier-recruited motor units having greater firing rates than the later-recruited ones. We found that this normal pattern of firing activation can be altered during oscillatory contractions where the force oscillates at frequencies ≥2 Hz. During these high-frequency oscillations, the activation of the lower-threshold motor units effectively decreases and that of the higher-threshold motor units effectively increases. This transposition of firing activation provides means to activate higher-threshold motor units preferentially. Our results demonstrate that the hierarchical regulation of motor unit activation can be manipulated to activate specific motoneuron populations preferentially. This finding can be exploited to develop new forms of physical therapies and exercise programs that enhance muscle performance or that target the preferential atrophy of high-threshold motor units as a result of aging or motor disorders such as stroke and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

Corticospinal excitability of the biceps brachii is higher during arm cycling than an intensity-matched tonic contraction

Human studies have not assessed corticospinal excitability of an upper-limb prime mover during arm cycling. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether supraspinal and/or spinal motoneuron excitability of the biceps brachii was different between arm cycling and an intensity-matched tonic contraction. We hypothesized that spinal motoneuron excitability would be higher during arm cycling than an intensity-matched tonic contraction. Supraspinal and spinal motoneuron excitability were assessed using transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) of the motor cortex and transmastoid electrical stimulation (TMES) of the corticospinal tract, respectively. TMS-induced motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) and TMES-induced cervicomedullary-evoked potentials (CMEPs) were assessed at three separate positions (3, 6, and 12 o'clock relative to a clock face) during arm cycling and an intensity-matched tonic contraction. MEP amplitudes were 7.2 and 8.8% maximum amplitude of the compound muscle action potential (Mmax) larger during arm cycling compared with a tonic contraction at the 3 (P < 0.001) and 6 o'clock (P < 0.001) positions, respectively. There was no difference between tasks during elbow extension (12 o'clock). CMEP amplitudes were 5.2% Mmax larger during arm cycling compared with a tonic contraction at the 3 o'clock position (P < 0.001) with no differences seen at midflexion (6 o'clock) or extension (12 o'clock). The data indicate an increase in the excitability of corticospinal neurons, which ultimately project to biceps brachii during the elbow flexion portion of arm cycling, and increased spinal motoneuron excitability at the onset of elbow flexion during arm cycling. We conclude that supraspinal and spinal motoneuron excitability are phase- and task-dependent.

Corticomotor excitability of arm muscles modulates according to static position and orientation of the upper limb

OBJECTIVE

We investigated how multi-joint changes in static upper limb posture impact the corticomotor excitability of the posterior deltoid (PD) and biceps brachii (BIC), and evaluated whether postural variations in excitability related directly to changes in target muscle length.

METHODS

The amplitude of individual motor evoked potentials (MEPs) was evaluated in each of thirteen different static postures. Four functional postures were investigated that varied in shoulder and elbow angle, while the forearm was positioned in each of three orientations. Posture-related changes in muscle lengths were assessed using a biomechanical arm model. Additionally, M-waves were evoked in the BIC in each of three forearm orientations to assess the impact of posture on recorded signal characteristics.

RESULTS

BIC-MEP amplitudes were altered by shoulder and elbow posture, and demonstrated robust changes according to forearm orientation. Observed changes in BIC-MEP amplitudes exceeded those of the M-waves. PD-MEP amplitudes changed predominantly with shoulder posture, but were not completely independent of influence from forearm orientation.

CONCLUSIONS

Results provide evidence that overall corticomotor excitability can be modulated according to multi-joint upper limb posture.

SIGNIFICANCE

The ability to alter motor pathway excitability using static limb posture suggests the importance of posture selection during rehabilitation aimed at retraining individual muscle recruitment and/or overall coordination patterns.

Short-term synchrony in diverse motor nuclei presumed to receive different extents of direct cortical input

Motor units within human muscles usually exhibit a significant degree of short-term synchronization. Such coincident spiking typically has been attributed to last-order projections that provide common synaptic input across motor neurons. The extent of branched input arising directly from cortical neurons has often been suggested as a critical factor determining the magnitude of short-term synchrony. The purpose of this study, therefore, was to quantify motor unit synchrony in a variety of human muscles differing in the presumed extent of cortical input to their respective motor nuclei. Cross-correlation histograms were generated from the firing times of 551 pairs of motor units in 16 human muscles. Motor unit synchrony tended to be weakest for proximal muscles and strongest for more distal muscles. Previous work in monkeys and humans has shown that the strength of cortical inputs to motor neurons also exhibits a similar proximal-to-distal gradient. However, in the present study, proximal-distal location was not an exclusive predictor of synchrony magnitude. The muscle that exhibited the least synchrony was an elbow flexor, whereas the greatest synchrony was most often found in intrinsic foot muscles. Furthermore, the strength of corticospinal inputs to the abductor hallucis muscle, an intrinsic foot muscle, as assessed through transcranial magnetic stimulation, was weaker than that projecting to the tibialis anterior muscle, even though the abductor hallucis muscle had higher synchrony values compared with the tibialis anterior muscle. We argue, therefore, that factors other than the potency of cortical inputs to motor neurons, such as the number of motor neurons innervating a muscle, significantly affects motor unit synchrony.

Muscle dependency of corticomuscular coherence in upper and lower limb muscles and training-related alterations in ballet dancers and weightlifters

It has been well documented that the 15- to 35-Hz oscillatory activity of the sensorimotor cortex shows coherence with the muscle activity during weak to moderate steady contraction. To investigate the muscle dependency of the corticomuscular coherence and its training-related alterations, we quantified the coherence between electroencephalogram (EEG) from the sensorimotor cortex and rectified electromyogram (EMG) from five upper limb (first dorsal interosseous, flexor carpi radialis, extensor carpi radialis, biceps brachii, triceps brachii) and four lower limb muscles (soleus, tibialis anterior, biceps femoris, rectus femoris), while maintaining a constant force level at 30% of maximal voluntary contraction of each muscle, in 24 untrained, 12 skill-trained (ballet dancers), and 10 strength-trained (weightlifters) individuals. Data from untrained subjects demonstrated the muscle dependency of corticomuscular coherence. The magnitude of the EEG-EMG coherence was significantly greater in the distally located lower limb muscles, such as the soleus and tibialis anterior, than in the upper or other lower limb muscles in untrained subjects ( P < 0.05). These results imply that oscillatory coupling between the sensorimotor cortex and spinal motoneurons during steady contraction differs among muscles, according to the functional role of each muscle. In addition, the ballet dancers and weightlifters showed smaller EEG-EMG coherences than the untrained subjects, especially in the lower limb muscles ( P < 0.05). These results indicate that oscillatory interaction between the sensorimotor cortex and spinal motoneurons can be changed by long-term specialized use of the muscles and that this neural adaptation may lead to finer control of muscle force during steady contraction.

Differential age-related changes in motor unit properties between elbow flexors and extensors

AIM

Healthy adult ageing of the human neuromuscular system is comprised of changes that include atrophy, weakness and slowed movements with reduced spinal motor neurone output expressed by lower motor unit discharge rates (MUDRs). The latter observation has been obtained mostly from hand and lower limb muscles. The purpose was to determine the extent to which elbow flexor and extensor contractile properties, and MUDRs in six old (83 +/- 4 years) and six young (24 +/- 1 years) men were affected by age, and whether any adaptations were similar for both muscle groups.

METHODS

Maximal isometric voluntary contraction (MVC), voluntary activation, twitch contractile properties, force-frequency relationship and MUDRs from sub-maximal to maximal intensities were assessed in the elbow flexors and extensors.

RESULTS

Both flexor and extensor MVCs were significantly (P < 0.05) less (approximately 42% and approximately 46% respectively) in the old than in the young. Contractile speeds and the force-frequency relationship did not show any age-related differences (P > 0.05). For the elbow flexors contraction duration was approximately 139 ms and for the extensors it was approximately 127 ms for both age groups (P > 0.05). The mean MUDRs from 25% MVC to maximum were lower (approximately 10% to approximately 36%) in the old than in the young (P < 0.01). These age-related differences were larger for biceps (Cohen's d = 8.25) than triceps (Cohen's d = 4.79) brachii.

CONCLUSION

Thus, at least for proximal upper limb muscles, mean maximal MUDR reductions with healthy adult ageing are muscle specific and not strongly related to contractile speed.

Renshaw cell recurrent inhibition improves physiological tremor by reducing corticomuscular coupling at 10 Hz

Corticomuscular coherence between the primary motor cortex (M1) and hand muscle electromyograms (EMG) occurs at approximately 20 Hz but is rarely seen at approximately 10 Hz. This is unexpected, because M1 has oscillations at both frequencies, which are effectively transmitted to the spinal cord via the corticospinal tract. We have previously speculated that a specific "neural filter" may selectively reduce coherence at approximately 10 Hz. This would have functional utility in minimizing physiological tremor, which often has a dominant component around this frequency. Recurrent inhibition via Renshaw cells in the spinal cord is a putative neural substrate for such a filter. Here we investigate this system in more detail with a biophysically based computational model. Renshaw cell recurrent inhibition reduced EMG oscillations at approximately 10 Hz, and also reduced corticomuscular coherence at this frequency (from 0.038 to 0.014). Renshaw cell inhibitory feedback also generated synchronous oscillations in the motoneuron pool at approximately 30 Hz. We show that the effects at 10 Hz and 30 Hz can both be understood from the dynamics of the inhibitory feedback loop. We conclude that recurrent inhibition certainly plays an important role in reducing 10 Hz oscillations in muscle, thereby decreasing tremor amplitude. However, our quantitative results suggest it is unlikely to be the only system for tremor reduction, and probably acts in concert with other neural circuits which remain to be elucidated.

Transmission in heteronymous spinal pathways is modified after stroke and related to motor incoordination

Changes in reflex spinal pathways after stroke have been shown to affect motor activity in agonist and antagonist muscles acting at the same joint. However, only a few studies have evaluated the heteronymous reflex pathways modulating motoneuronal activity at different joints. This study investigates whether there are changes in the spinal facilitatory and inhibitory pathways linking knee to ankle extensors and if such changes may be related to motor deficits after stroke. The early facilitation and later inhibition of soleus H reflex evoked by the stimulation of femoral nerve at 2 times the motor threshold of the quadriceps were assessed in 15 healthy participants and on the paretic and the non-paretic sides of 15 stroke participants. The relationships between this reflex modulation and the levels of motor recovery, coordination and spasticity were then studied. Results show a significant (Mann-Whitney U; P<0.05) increase in both the peak amplitude (mean±SEM: 80±22% enhancement of the control H reflex) and duration (4.2±0.5 ms) of the facilitation on the paretic side of the stroke individuals compared to their non-paretic side (36±6% and 2.9±0.4 ms) and to the values of the control subjects (33±4% and 2.8±0.4 ms, respectively). Moreover, the later strong inhibition observed in all control subjects was decreased in the stroke subjects. Both the peak amplitude and the duration of the increased facilitation were inversely correlated (Spearman r = −0.65; P = 0.009 and r = −0.67; P = 0.007, respectively) with the level of coordination (LEMOCOT) of the paretic leg. Duration of this facilitation was also correlated (r = −0.58, P = 0.024) with the level of motor recovery (CMSA). These results confirm changes in transmission in heteronymous spinal pathways that are related to motor deficits after stroke.

Motor unit recruitment and proprioceptive feedback decrease the common drive

It has been documented that concurrently active motor units fire under the control of a common drive. That is, the firing rates show high correlation with near-zero time lag. This degree of correlation has been found to vary among muscles and among contractions performed at different force levels in the same muscle. This study provides an explanation indicating that motor units recruited during a contraction cause an increase in the variation (SD) and a decrease in the degree (amplitude) of the correlation of the firing rates. The degree of correlation is lower in muscles having greater spindle density. This effect appears to be mediated by the proprioceptive feedback from the spindles and possibly the Golgi tendon organs. Muscle spindles in particular respond to the mechanical excitation of the nonfused muscle fibers and provide a discordant excitation to the homonymous motoneurons, resulting in a decrease in the correlation of the firing rates of motor units. The implication of this work is that the decreased correlation of the firing rates in some muscles is not necessarily an indication of a decreased common drive from the CNS, but rather an inhibitory influence of the proprioceptive feedback from the peripheral nervous system. This explanation is useful for understanding various manifestations of the common drive reported in the literature.

Aging, visuomotor correction, and force fluctuations in large muscles

PURPOSE

To determine the contribution of visuomotor correction to increased force fluctuations in the elbow flexor and knee extensor muscles of elderly adults.

METHODS

Young (N = 22, 23 +/- 3 yr) and elderly (N = 23, 74 +/- 7 yr) adults performed constant-force contractions at target forces of 2.5, 30, and 65% MVC. Visual feedback was provided (6-8 s) and then removed (6-8 s). After removal of drift (< 0.5 Hz) from the force, the standard deviation (SD) and coefficient of variation (CV) of force were calculated from vision and no-vision data.

RESULTS

Maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) force was 19% lower for elbow flexors and 37% lower for knee extensors in elderly adults than in young adults. Overall, the CV of force was 27% greater in the vision condition compared with the no-vision condition. The CV of force for vision was greater for elderly adults than for young adults at the 2.5% MVC target force and lower at 30 and 65% MVC. For the 2.5% MVC target force, the decline in CV of force from vision to no vision was greater for elderly adults than for young adults. At 30 and 65% MVC, the decline was significant but similar for young and elderly adults. For elbow flexors, the change in power from vision to no vision was greater for 0- to 4-Hz (reduced power) and 8- to 12-Hz (increased power) frequencies for elderly adults compared with young adults.

CONCLUSION

Visuomotor correction contributed to force fluctuations in large proximal muscles. The contribution was greater for healthy elderly adults at low forces. Visuomotor processes thus contributed to the age-related increase in force fluctuations.

Is the human masticatory system devoid of recurrent inhibition?

The aim of the present study was to investigate the existence or otherwise of a functional recurrent inhibitory system (Renshaw cell system) in the motoneurons that innervate human masticatory muscles. In a previous study, L: -acetylcarnitine (L: -Ac), a substance known to potentiate recurrent inhibition in humans was found to alter, in a specific way, the discharge variability, and the synchronous activity of motor units depending on the presence or absence of recurrent inhibition in the corresponding motoneuron pool. Using a similar paradigm, we have recorded the tonic discharge activity of motor unit pairs from the masseter muscle during voluntary isometric contraction while subjects were undergoing continuous intravenous saline (SAL, NaCl 0.9%) perfusion. Following a brief baseline-recording period, the subjects were given a test injection of either L: -Ac or isotonic saline (SAL) in a double blind manner. The variability, synchronization, and coherence between the motor unit discharges were analysed during three successive periods: pre-injection, during injection, and post-injection, each lasting 2-3 min. Neither L: -Ac nor SAL injection induced a significant change in the inter-spike interval (ISI) or the coefficient of variation of the ISIs in the motor units tested. There were also no significant changes in the pattern of synchronous activity or in the coherence, which reflects the common frequency content of the unit discharges. Reminiscent of what had been observed previously with motoneurons without recurrent inhibition in the Abductor Digitorum Minimi muscle, the lack of effects of L: -Ac injection on the firing behaviour of masseter motoneurons may suggest that classical Renshaw cell inhibition is lacking in this motoneuron pool.

Effects produced in human arm and forearm motoneurones after electrical stimulation of ulnar and median nerves at wrist level

Effects of electrical stimulation of ulnar and median nerves at wrist level were investigated in post-stimulus time histograms (PSTHs) of single motor units from both flexors and extensors in human arm and forearm. Stimulation of ulnar nerve produced late (mean extra time-after monosynaptic group Ia excitation-10.7 +/- 0.1 ms) high-threshold (>1.2 x motor threshold, MT) excitation, which was not reproduced by purely cutaneous stimulation, in all the investigated motor nuclei except in Extensor Carpi Radialis. Stimulation of median nerve, and of the skin of fingers II and III (at palmar side level), produced short latency inhibition (mean extra time 3.8 +/- 0.3 ms), which was most often truncated or followed by late excitation (mean extra time 11.8 +/- 0.3 ms); both effects were of low threshold (0.8 x MT). Short latency inhibition was very strong, and late excitation was rare and weak in almost all the investigated motor units except in those supplying flexors in forearm, in which the main effect was the late facilitation (stronger than in other motoneurones). Since extra time was not more than 13 ms, it is suggested that the late effects may be mediated through spinal pathways, at least during their 3-5 first ms. Based on the electrophysiological results and on the anatomical characteristics of ulnar and median nerves, it is assumed that ulnar-induced late high-threshold peak in PSTHs might reflect group II excitation in spinal motoneurones, and median-induced modifications in motor unit discharge, mainly cutaneous control of motoneurone discharge. Since the central delay of median-induced inhibition is longer the more caudal the motoneurone, inhibitory propriospinal-like interneurones are supposed to mediate cutaneous inhibitory control from hand upon muscles in arm and forearm. Potential roles of proprioceptive and cutaneous control from hand to more proximal musculature, provided by ulnar and median nerve, respectively, during precise hand movements are discussed.

Recurrence quantification analysis of surface EMG detects changes in motor unit synchronization induced by recurrent inhibition

The systemic injection of L-Acetylcarnitine (L-Ac) induces a reversible increase in recurrent inhibition. In addition, L-Ac potentiation of recurrent inhibition has been found to increase the synchronous activity of single motor units, as detected by traditional linear analysis in the time domain. This result has been recently confirmed using a nonlinear method based on the analysis of embedded determinism (%DET) extracted from the surface EMG. The present study aimed at testing the general applicability of RQA methodology, as a viable tool for assessing motor unit synchronization, by extending the analysis of surface EMG, as revealed by changes in %DET induced by L-Ac, to many upper and lower limb muscles and to muscles that are not easily studied by needle electrodes, such as the orbicularis oculi. Subjects performed brief periods of tonic contractions, alternated to periods of rests to avoid muscle fatigue. Pharmacological enhancement of recurrent inhibition was obtained by a short-lasting intravenous injection of L-Ac. Control experiments were performed replacing L-Ac injection with saline injection. The average %DET showed a significant increase during L-Ac injection in the deltoid, biceps brachii, extensor carpi radialis, while no effect was observed in the opponens pollicis and abductor digiti minimi for the upper limb muscles. Similarly, the average %DET showed a significant increase during L-Ac injection in the quadriceps, soleus, and tibialis anterior, while no effect was observed in the abductor hallucis for the lower limb muscles. RQA of orbicularis oculi muscle activity showed no increase in %DET during L-Ac injection in analogy to what found in the intrinsic muscles of the hand and foot, known to be devoid of recurrent inhibition. The presence or absence of drug-induced increase in motor unit synchronization agrees with the known distribution of recurrent inhibition in the various motor nuclei. The overall significance of these findings is the potential application of RQA methodology as a reliable and independent tool for generally assessing motor unit synchronization from surface EMG under strictly controlled experimental condition.

The amplitude of force variability is correlated in the knee extensor and elbow flexor muscles

The purpose of this study was to determine motor output variability for different muscles in the same individuals. Ten young (21.7 +/- 3.4 years) and ten elderly (72.1 +/- 3.9 years) men underwent assessment of maximal isometric (MVC) and dynamic (1-RM) strength, and performed constant-force (2-50% MVC), constant-load (5-50% 1-RM load), and unloaded postural contractions as steadily as possible with the first dorsal interosseus (FDI), elbow flexors (EF), and knee extensors (KE). The coefficient of variation (CV) of force for isometric contractions and the standard deviation (SD) of acceleration for concentric, eccentric, and postural contractions were calculated. The 1-RM load, the CV of force for four of five isometric target forces, and the SD of acceleration during postural contractions were correlated between the EF and KE muscles. MVC force, 1-RM load, and SD of acceleration during postural contractions were not correlated between the FDI/EF or FDI/KE. The CV of force was correlated between the FDI/EF and FDI/KE for two of five isometric target forces. The SD of acceleration during concentric and eccentric contractions was not correlated between muscles. The normalized fluctuations during isometric contractions were greater for the FDI compared with the EF and KE. Elderly adults displayed greater fluctuations only for the FDI during low-force isometric and postural contractions. The dominant frequency of fluctuations was similar for the EF and KE muscles. The correlated fluctuations for the EF and KE muscles, within subjects, suggests that the two motor neuron pools transform the various neural inputs similarly.

Mediation of late excitation from human hand muscles via parallel group II spinal and group I transcortical pathways

This study addresses the question of the origin of the long-latency responses evoked in flexors in the forearm by afferents from human hand muscles. The effects of electrical stimuli to the ulnar nerve at wrist level were assessed in healthy subjects using post-stimulus time histograms for flexor digitorum superficialis and flexor carpi radialis (FCR) single motor units (eight subjects) and the modulation of the ongoing rectified FCR EMG (19 subjects). Ulnar stimulation evoked four successive peaks of heteronymous excitation that were not produced by purely cutaneous stimuli: a monosynaptic Ia excitation, a second group I excitation attributable to a propriospinally mediated effect, and two late peaks. The first long-latency excitation occurred 8-13 ms after monosynaptic latency and had a high-threshold (1.2-1.5 x motor threshold). When the conditioning stimulation was applied at a more distal site and when the ulnar nerve was cooled, the latency of this late excitation increased more than the latency of monosynaptic Ia excitation. This late response was not evoked in the contralateral FCR of one patient with bilateral corticospinal projections to FCR motoneurones. Finally, oral tizanidine suppressed the long-latency high-threshold excitation but not the early low-threshold group I responses. These results suggest that the late high-threshold response is mediated through a spinal pathway fed by muscle spindle group II afferents. The second long-latency excitation, less frequently observed (but probably underestimated), occurred 16-18 ms after monosynaptic latency, had a low threshold indicating a group I effect, and was not suppressed by tizanidine. It is suggested that this latest excitation involves a transcortical pathway.

A central back-coupling hypothesis on the organization of motor synergies: a physical metaphor and a neural model

We offer a hypothesis on the organization of multi-effector motor synergies and illustrate it with the task of force production with a set of fingers. A physical metaphor, a leaking bucket, is analyzed to demonstrate that an inanimate structure can show apparent error compensation among its elements. A neural model is developed using tunable back-coupling loops as means of assuring error compensation in a task-specific way. The model demonstrates non-trivial features of multi-finger interaction such as delayed emergence of force stabilizing synergies and simultaneous stabilization of the total force and total moment produced by the fingers. The hypothesis suggests that neurophysiological structures involving short-latency feedback may play a central role in the formation of motor synergies.

Proprioceptive reflexes in patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy

Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (RSD) is a syndrome that frequently follows an injury and is characterized by sensory, autonomic and motor features of the affected extremities. One of the more common motor features of RSD is tonic dystonia, which is caused by impairment of inhibitory interneuronal spinal circuits. In this study the circuits that modulate the gain of proprioceptive reflexes of the shoulder musculature are quantitatively assessed in 19 RSD patients, 9 of whom presented with dystonia. The proprioceptive reflexes are quantified by applying two types of force disturbances: (1) disturbances with a fixed low frequency and a variable bandwidth and (2) disturbances with a small bandwidth around a prescribed centre frequency. Compared to controls, patients have lower reflex gains for velocity feedback in response to the disturbances around a prescribed centre frequency. Additionally, patients with dystonia lack the ability to generate negative reflex gains for position feedback, for these same disturbances. Proprioceptive reflexes to the disturbances with a fixed low frequency and variable bandwidth present no difference between patients and controls. Although dystonia in the RSD patients was limited to the distal musculature, the results suggest involvement of interneuronal circuits that mediate postsynaptic inhibition of the motoneurons of the proximal musculature.

Recurrent inhibition of wrist extensor motoneurones: a single unit study on a deafferented patient

In order to document the effects of recurrent inhibition on the firing times of human alpha-motoneurones during natural motor behaviour, a case study was performed on a deafferented patient. The fact that this subject had completely lost the large-diameter sensory afferents provided us with a unique opportunity of selectively stimulating the motor axons in the nerves. The tonic activity of single motor units (n = 21) was recorded in the extensor carpi radialis muscles while applying randomly timed antidromic electrical stimuli to the radial nerve. The peristimulus time histogram analysis showed the presence of biphasic inhibitory effects, including an early, short-lasting component followed by a longer-lasting component occurring 20-40 ms later. The interspike interval (ISI) during which the stimulation occurred was generally lengthened as compared to the previous ISIs. The stimulation was most effective when delivered early (20-30 ms) after a spike. It was also effective, although less so, when delivered at the end of the ISI (70-100 ms after a spike). The lengthening effect sometimes extended over one or two of the subsequent ISIs. The lengthening effect of the motor axon stimulation was followed by an excitatory-like effect, which took the form of a shortening that affected up to five ISIs after the stimulation. The biphasic inhibitory effects and the subsequent facilitatory effects are discussed in terms of the dual nature of the synaptic processes involved in the recurrent inhibitory network, the postactivation facilitation/depression processes and the mutual inhibition occurring between Renshaw cells.

Effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation on the H reflex and F wave in the hand muscles

OBJECTIVE

In 14 healthy subjects, we studied the effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on the excitability of spinal motoneurons in the abductor pollicis brevis muscle (ABP), by testing the F wave and H reflex.

METHODS

TMS pulses were delivered with the subjects at rest and at various motor threshold (Mth) intensities. Electrical stimuli were delivered to the median nerve at the wrist at two different intensities. High-intensity pulse was used to evoke an F wave and low-intensity paired pulse to evoke an H reflex in the ABP muscle. The effects of TMS were studied using a conditioning-test paradigm. The tests F wave and H reflex were conditioned by TMS (120% Mth) at various interstimulus intervals (ISIs) (30-100ms) and intensities (90-200% Mth).

RESULTS

At 30ms but not at ISIs from 40 to 100ms, conditioning TMS (120% Mth) significantly increased the F-wave area. At the 30ms ISI, conditioning TMS at 120% Mth intensity significantly increased the F-wave area whereas higher intensities (140-180% Mth) did not. At 200% Mth intensity, the F-wave area decreased significantly. At 30 and 40ms ISIs, conditioning TMS at 120% Mth significantly reduced the H-reflex area. At 50-100ms ISIs, the H-reflex area almost matched the control value. At the 30ms ISI, conditioning TMS at >or=100% Mth intensity significantly decreased the H-reflex area.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, our findings suggest that the distinct changes in the TMS-conditioned F wave and H reflex reflect changing excitability in the motoneuronal populations activated by the cortical input.

Pharmacologically induced enhancement of recurrent inhibition in humans: effects on motoneurone discharge patterns

The aim of the present study was to investigate the effects of spinal recurrent inhibition on human motoneurone discharge patterns. The tonic discharge activity of motor unit pairs was recorded in the extensor carpi radialis (ECR) and abductor digiti minimi (ADM) muscles during voluntary isometric contraction. While undergoing continuous intravenous saline (NaCl 0.9 %) perfusion, the subjects were given a short lasting injection of L-acetylcarnitine (L-Ac), which has been found to potentiate recurrent inhibition in humans. The variability, synchronization and coherence of the motor unit discharges were analysed during four successive test periods (lasting 2-3 min each). A significant decrease in the inter-spike interval (ISI) coefficient of variation was observed in the discharge patterns of the motor units tested in the ECR and not in the ADM, which were not accompanied by any consistent changes in the mean ISIs of the motor unit activity in either muscle. The L-Ac injection also led to a significant increase in the synchronization in half of the motor unit pairs tested in the ECR muscle (n = 29), whereas no consistent changes were observed with the ADM motor units (n = 25). However, coherence analysis failed to reveal any consistent differences in the incidence of significant values of coherence spectrum between the pre-injection and injection periods among the motor unit pairs tested with either saline or L-Ac injections, in either the ECR or ADM muscles. The contrasting effects on the variability and the synchronization of the motor unit discharges observed with ECR motoneurones known to undergo recurrent inhibition and with ADM motoneurones known to lack recurrent inhibition suggest that the drug may have specific effects which are mediated by an enhancement of the Renshaw cell activity. The decrease in the ISI variability is in line with the hypothesis that recurrent inhibition may contribute along with the post-spike after-hyperpolarization to limiting the influence of the synaptic noise on the firing times of steadily discharging motoneurones. The present data, which suggest that recurrent inhibition plays a synchronizing rather than a desynchronizing role, are in keeping with the fact that the Renshaw cells may provide an important source of common inhibitory inputs.

Effect of chemically activated fine muscle afferents on spinal recurrent inhibition in humans

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that 'metabolites released during fatiguing muscle contractions excite group III-IV muscle nociceptive afferents, inhibiting homonymous motoneurones via Renshaw cells,' by recording changes in recurrent inhibition of soleus motoneurones when high-threshold, small-diameter afferents (group III-IV fibres) from the same muscle were tonically activated.

METHODS

Experiments were performed in 7 healthy subjects at rest and during weak isometric voluntary contraction of the soleus muscle. Muscle nociceptive afferents were activated by local standardized injection of levo-ascorbic acid. Renshaw cells were orthodromically activated by a conditioning H reflex and the resulting recurrent inhibition of the soleus motoneurones was assessed by a subsequent test H reflex. An additional H reflex of the same size as the test reflex was used to assess motoneurone excitability.

RESULTS

At rest, muscle nociceptive stimulation produced transient facilitation of both test H and reference H reflexes. Under weak voluntary contraction, muscle nociceptive stimulation produced long-lasting extra-inhibition and extra-facilitation of the test reflex and reference reflex respectively, the time course of which closely resembled that of the subjective muscle pain curve.

CONCLUSIONS

Discharge of putative group III-IV muscle afferents facilitated homonymous recurrent inhibition. The filtering property of recurrent inhibition may contribute to limit motoneurone activity during muscle pain and/or adapt motoneurone firing rate to the modified contractile properties of motor units as muscle fatigue developed.

Neural control of rhythmic human arm movement: phase dependence and task modulation of hoffmann reflexes in forearm muscles

Although we move our arms rhythmically during walking, running, and swimming, we know little about the neural control of such movements. Our working hypothesis is that neural mechanisms controlling rhythmic movements are similar in the human lumbar and cervical spinal cord. Thus reflex modulation during rhythmic arm movement should be similar to that seen during leg movement. Our main experimental hypotheses were that the amplitude of H-reflexes in the forearm muscles would be modulated during arm movement (i.e., phase-dependent) and would be inhibited during cycling compared with static contraction (i.e., task-dependent). Furthermore, to determine the locus of any modulation, we tested the effect that active and passive movement of the ipsilateral (relative to stimulated arm) and contralateral arm had on H-reflex amplitude. Subjects performed rhythmic arm cycling on a custom-made hydraulic ergometer in which the two arms could be constrained to move together (180 degrees out of phase) or could rotate independently. Position of the stimulated limb in the movement cycle is described with respect to the clock face. H-reflexes were evoked at 12, 3, 6, and 9 o'clock positions during static contraction as well as during rhythmic arm movements. Reflex amplitudes were compared between tasks at equal M wave amplitudes and similar levels of electromyographic (EMG) activity in the target muscle. Surface EMG recordings were obtained bilaterally from flexor carpi radialis as well as from other muscles controlling the wrist, elbow, and shoulder. Compared with reflexes evoked during static contractions, movement of the stimulated limb attenuated H-reflexes by 50.8% (P < 0.005), 65.3% (P < 0.001), and 52.6% (P < 0.001) for bilateral, active ipsilateral, and passive ipsilateral movements, respectively. In contrast, movement of the contralateral limb did not significantly alter H-reflex amplitude. H-reflexes were also modulated by limb position (P < 0.005). Thus task- and phase-dependent modulation were observed in the arm as previously demonstrated in the leg. The data support the hypothesis that neural mechanisms regulating reflex pathways in the moving limb are similar in the human upper and lower limbs. However, the inhibition of H-reflex amplitude induced by contralateral leg movement is absent in the arms. This may reflect the greater extent to which the arms can be used independently.

A cumulative sum test for a peri-stimulus time histogram using the Monte Carlo method

We have established a cumulative sum (CUSUM) test for a peri-stimulus time histogram (PSTH) for the case where a conditioning stimulus is delivered at a fixed interval after previous discharge of a motor unit. (We refer to this kind of PSTH as an 'arranged PSTH'). Expectations of the firing probability after the conditioning stimulus vary among the bins in this arranged PSTH, while the expectations among the bins are all the same in the original PSTH; thus, we could not apply conventional tests for statistical analysis. We, therefore, propose a novel CUSUM test that uses the Monte Carlo method. With this method, the range of the statistical scattering noise on a CUSUM is computationally found by simulating the statistical process in order to calculate the confidence interval. We verified this CUSUM test using both simulated and actual experiments. This paper presents the procedure for performing this new method, along with an example of its application.

Statistical test for peri-stimulus time histograms in assessing motor neuron activity

The peri-stimulus time histogram is a valuable tool for evaluating neural connections in humans. To detect the degree to which a conditioning stimulus to a sensory nerve modulates motor neuron activity, a histogram of motor unit spike intervals after a conditioning stimulus is measured. This histogram allows the effect of the conditioning stimulus to be visualised. By comparison with a reference histogram of motor unit spike intervals after a sham stimulus, the noise caused by spontaneous firing sway can be removed. However, no valid statistical test has yet been developed to separate the physiological effect from the spontaneous sway and statistical noise. A computational method has been proposed to detect modulation caused by a conditioning stimulus. To clarify the effect of a conditioning stimulus, this new method used reference histograms to calculate a confidence interval. A simulated experiment demonstrated that about 2000 re-samplings were sufficient to estimate a confidence interval for a histogram with 1 ms bin width constructed from 300 triggers. Testing of the experimental data, measured from the tibialis anterior muscles during the elicitation of the excitatory spinal reflex, confirmed that significant peaks were produced at 30, 34, 35 and 38ms after the conditioning stimulus. These correspond appropriately to the delay of the spinal reflex.

Common drive in motor units of a synergistic muscle pair

The interaction among the motor units of the extensor carpi radialis longus (ECRL) and the extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) muscles in man was studied during wrist extensions in which the two muscles acted as synergists. Intramuscular recordings were obtained using special quadrifilar needle electrodes. Isometric wrist extensions at 20-30% of the maximal effort were studied. The electromyographic (EMG) signals were decomposed into the individual motor-unit action potential trains comprising the signal. The interaction among motor units were characterized by the estimated time-varying mean firing rate and the cross-correlation between the time-varying mean firing rates of pairs of motor units. Pairs of motor units within each muscle as well as pairs of motor units across the muscles were considered. In-phase common fluctuations, termed common drive, were observed in the mean firing rates of motor units within each muscle, consistent with earlier work on other muscles. Common fluctuations were also observed between the firing rates of ECU and ECRL motor units albeit with a variable phase shift. The existence of common drive across synergistic muscles was interpreted as implying that the CNS considers the muscles as a functional unit when they act as synergists.

Motor control of low-threshold motor units in the human trapezius muscle

The firing pattern of low-threshold motor units was examined in the human trapezius and first dorsal interosseous (FDI) muscles during slowly augmenting, low-amplitude contractions that were intended to mimic contractile activity in postural muscles. The motor unit activity was detected with a special needle electrode and was analyzed with the assistance of computer algorithms. The surface electromyographic (EMG) signal was recorded. Its root-mean-square (RMS) value was calculated and presented to the subject who used it to regulate the muscle force level. In the trapezius, there was minimal, if any, firing rate modulation of early recruited motor units during slow contractions (< or =1% EMG(max)/s), and later recruited motor units consistently presented higher peak firing rates. As the force rate of the contraction increased (3% EMG(max)/s), the firing rates of the motor units in the trapezius approached an orderly hierarchical pattern with the earliest recruited motor units having the greatest firing rate. In contrast, and as reported previously, the firing rates of all motor units in the FDI always presented the previously reported hierarchical "onion-skin" pattern. We conclude that the low-threshold motor units in the postural trapezius muscle, that is the motor units that are most often called on to activate the muscle in postural activities, have different control features in slow and fast contractions. More detailed analysis revealed that, in the low force-rate contractions of the trapezius, recruitment of new motor units inhibited the firing rate of active motor units, providing an explanation for the depressed firing rate of the low-threshold motor units. We speculate that Renshaw cell inhibition contributes to the observed deviation of the low-threshold motor units from the hierarchical onion-skin pattern.

Bilateral painful hand-moving fingers: electrophysiological assessment of the central nervous system oscillator

We describe a 35-year-old woman who presented with the syndrome of painful hand-moving fingers on the right side. Eight months later, she developed similar finger movements and hand discomfort on the left side. She had a history of hand trauma and recurrent shoulder dislocation on the right side. Kinesiologic electromyography suggested a common central oscillator for finger movements in both hands. Electrophysiological assessment of spinal alpha motor neuron excitability, reciprocal inhibition, and Renshaw cell inhibition failed to show any abnormalities. Somatosensory evoked potential test showed marked attenuation of N20 potential recorded from the left somatosensory cortex; paired transcortical magnetic stimulation of the left motor cortex suggested failure of cortical facilitation. The data suggest that the central oscillator responsible for finger movements is located above the spinal cord level in this patient.

Blink reflexes and the silent period in tetanus

Abnormalities of the silent period (SP) and blink reflexes occur in diseases that interfere with inhibitory pathways, such as tetanus and stiff-person syndrome (SPS). The SP is abnormal in tetanus but not in SPS. Studies of the blink reflex in tetanus are limited. In this report, a patient with generalized tetanus is described. The masseteric-and mixed-nerve SP was absent or truncated. In contrast to SPS, blink reflex studies revealed no bilateral R1 component, and a discrete R3 was only present ipsilateral to right supraorbital stimulation. This reflects the distinct inhibitory pathways underlying these disorders.

Distribution of presynaptic inhibition on type-identified motoneurones in the extensor carpi radialis pool in man

The question was addressed as to whether the magnitude of Ia presynaptic inhibition might depend on the type of motor unit activated during voluntary contraction in the wrist extensor muscles. For this purpose, we investigated the effects of applying electrical stimulation to the median nerve on the responses of 25 identified motor units to radial nerve stimulation delivered 20 ms after a conditioning stimulation. The reflex responses of the motor units yielded peaks in the post-stimulus time histograms with latencies compatible with monosynaptic activation. Although median nerve stimulation did not affect the motoneurone net excitatory drive assessed from the mean duration of the inter-spike interval, it led to a decrease in the contents of the first two 0.25 ms bins of the peak. This decrease may be consistent with the Ia presynaptic inhibition known to occur under these stimulation conditions. In the trials in which the median nerve was being stimulated, the finding that the response probability of the motor units, even in their monosynaptic components, tended to increase as their force threshold and their macro-potential area increased and as their twitch contraction time decreased suggests that the median nerve stimulation may have altered the efficiency with which the Ia inputs recruited the motoneurones in the pool. These effects were consistently observed in seven pairs of motor units each consisting of one slow and one fast contracting motor unit which were simultaneously tested, which suggests that the magnitude of the Ia presynaptic inhibition may depend on the type of motor unit tested rather than on the motoneurone pool excitatory drive. The present data suggest for the first time that in humans, the Ia presynaptic inhibition may show an upward gradient working from fast to slow contracting motor units which is able to compensate for the downward gradient in monosynaptic reflex excitation from 'slow' to 'fast' motor units. From a functional point of view, a weaker Ia presynaptic inhibition acting on the fast contracting motor units may contribute to improving the proprioceptive assistance to the wrist myotatic unit when the contraction force has to be increased.

Effects of aging on motor-unit control properties

It was hypothesized that the age-related alterations in the morphological properties of a motor unit would be accompanied by modifications in the control aspects of the motor unit, as either an adaptive or compensatory mechanism to preserve smooth force production. In specific, the objective of the study was to investigate the age-related alterations in the concurrent firing behavior of multiple motor units in the first dorsal interosseous (FDI) muscle in isometric contractions at 20 and 50% of the subject's voluntary contraction level. Analysis of the data collected from 10 young (24-37 yr of age) and 10 elderly (65-88 yr of age) subjects led to three novel observations regarding the firing behavior of aged motor units. 1) Among elderly subjects, there is a decrease in the common fluctuations that are observed among the firing rates of motor units in the young. 2) The relationship observed between the firing rate and recruitment threshold of young subjects is disturbed in the elderly. Although in young subjects, at any point in a given submaximal contraction, earlier recruited motor units have higher firing rates than later-recruited units; in aged subjects this dependency of firing rate on recruitment rank is compromised. 3) The progressive decrease observed in the firing rates of concurrently active motor units in constant-force contractions in the young is not seen in the aged. In addition to these original findings, this study provided support for earlier reports of 1) decreased average firing rates probably reflecting the slowing of the muscle, 2) a shift in recruitment thresholds toward lower force levels in line with the shift toward type I fibers, and 3) multiphasic action potential shapes indicative of the reinnervation process that takes place during aging. Taken as a whole, these findings indicate significant age-related modifications in the control properties of human motor units.

Quadriceps muscle strength, contractile properties, and motor unit firing rates in young and old men

Changes with age in the voluntary static and dynamic strength of the quadriceps muscle group have been well characterized, and the importance of the muscle group for locomotion and independent living have been highlighted in both normal human aging and in clinical studies. Surprisingly few studies of this muscle group have described age-related changes in voluntary activation ability using twitch interpolation and changes in stimulated contractile properties, and none have assessed the influence of old age on motor unit firing rates. We compared in 13 young (mean age 26 years) and 12 old (mean age 80 years) men the voluntary isometric strength, stimulated contractile properties, and average steady state motor unit firing rates in the quadriceps muscle. Maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) force and twitch tension were approximately 50% lower in the old men, but contractile speed was only approximately 10% slower than in the young men. There was no difference in the ability of either group to activate the quadriceps to a high degree (94-96%). At all isometric force levels tested (10%, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% MVC), there were no differences in mean motor unit firing rates. In both groups, the range of firing rates was similar and not large ( approximately 8 Hz at 10% MVC and 26 Hz at MVC). Thus, the substantial age-related weakness in this muscle does not seem to be related to changes in neural drive.

Single motor unit activity in relation to pulsatile motor output in human finger movements

1. Forty-six single motor units in the common finger extensor, superficial finger flexor, and first dorsal interosseus muscles were recorded with intramuscular wire electrodes while subjects made voluntary flexion and extension finger movements at a single metacarpo-phalangeal joint. 2. Motor unit firing was analysed in relation to the 8-10 Hz discontinuities which previously have been shown to characterize these movements. Statistical time- and frequency-domain analyses of the activity of individual motor units in relation to the discontinuities showed that when the muscle was the agonist, all motor units in the common finger extensor muscle, and all units except one in the flexor muscles exhibited significant frequency modulation of their discharge in close temporal association with the joint acceleration. On the other hand, motor unit firing rate was not related to the frequency of the discontinuities. When the muscle recorded from was the antagonist, 21 of the 25 active units exhibited a similar frequency modulation. 3. When angular movement velocity was increased from 4 to 25 deg s-1, the strength of motor unit frequency modulation increased. Peak coherence between motor unit activity and acceleration increased by 74 %, on average, in the common finger extensor units. 4. The findings rule out a tentative mechanism attributing the discontinuities to newly recruited motor units firing at circa 8-10 Hz. Instead, a coherent 8-10 Hz input to the agonist and antagonist motoneurone pools is implied.

Recurrent inhibition in humans

Methods have been developed to investigate recurrent inhibition (RI) in humans. A conditioning reflex discharge is used to evoke in motoneurones (MNs) supplying homonymous and synergistic muscles, an inhibition the characteristics of which are consistent with RI: it appears and increases with the conditioning motor discharge, has a short latency and a long duration, and is enhanced by an agonist of acetylcholine. As in the cat, homonymous RI exists in all explored motor nuclei of the limbs except those of the digits and the pattern of distribution of heteronymous RI closely matches that of monosynaptic Ia excitation. However, striking inter-species differences exist concerning the distribution of heteronymous RI since it is much more widely extended in the human lower limb than in the cat hindlimb, whereas it is more restricted in the upper limb than in the cat forelimb. Changes in transmission in the recurrent pathway have been investigated during various voluntary or postural contractions involving different (homonymous, synergistic, antagonistic) muscles and it has been found that the activation of Renshaw cells (RCs) by the voluntary motor discharge via recurrent collaterals was powerfully controlled by descending tracts: for example, during homonymous contraction, RI evoked by a given conditioning reflex discharge is much smaller during strong than during weak contraction, which suggests that the descending control of RCs might contribute to the regulation of muscle force. The finding that RC inhibition is more marked during phasic than during tonic contraction of similar force of the homonymous muscle is discussed in relation with the projections of RCs to Ia interneurones mediating reciprocal inhibition. Only in patients with progressive paraparesis is there evidence for decreased RI at rest which may contribute to the exaggeration of the passively-induced stretch reflex underlying spasticity. However, despite the seemingly normal RI at rest in most patients, the control of RCs during voluntary movements is disturbed in these patients, which probably contributes to their motor disability.

Mechanisms underlying spinal motor neuron excitability during the cutaneous silent period in humans

The transient suppression of muscle contraction during the cutaneous silent period (CSP) could be produced either through postsynaptic inhibition of motoneurons or through presynaptic inhibition of the excitatory inputs to motoneurons that sustain voluntary contraction. We sought to delineate the mechanisms underlying the CSP in hand muscles by measuring changes in H-reflexes and motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) produced by transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) during the CSP in 10 healthy volunteers. H-reflexes and MEPs both measure the excitability of the motoneuron pool and activate similar subpopulations of motoneurons through different pathways. Inhibition of H-reflexes and MEPs of similar size was maximal at the midpoint of the CSP and gradually returned to baseline. The similar time course of recovery suggests that the H-reflex and MEP are affected by inhibition at a common site, most likely postsynaptic inhibition of the motoneurons.

Organization of recurrent inhibition and facilitation in motor nuclei innervating ankle muscles of the cat

The distribution of recurrent inhibition and facilitation to motor nuclei of muscles that act at the cat ankle joint was compared with the locomotor activity and mechanical action of those muscles described in published studies. Emphasis was placed on motor nuclei whose muscles have a principal action about the abduction-adduction axis and the pretibial flexors: tibialis posterior (TP), peroneus longus (PerL), peroneus brevis (PerB), the anterior part of tibialis anterior (TA) and extensor digitorum longus (EDL). Most intracellular recordings in spinalized, unanesthetized decerebrate cats showed only inhibitory or excitatory responses to antidromic stimulation of peripheral nerves, but mixed effects were also seen. Recurrent effects among motor nuclei of ankle abductors and adductors were not distributed uniformly. TP motoneurons received recurrent inhibition from most other nuclei active in stance and stimulation of the TP nerve inhibited these motor nuclei. Although PerB motoneurons are also active during stance, they received primarily facilitation from most motor nuclei. PerL received mixtures of inhibition and facilitation from all sources. Stimulation of the nerves to PerL, PerB, and peroneus tertius (PerT) produced weak recurrent inhibition and facilitation, even in homonymous motoneurons and motoneurons of Ia synergists. The ankle flexors TA and EDL displayed different patterns of recurrent inhibition and facilitation. TA motoneurons received prominent homonymous inhibition and inhibition from semitendinosus (St). EDL, whose activity profile differs from TA and which also acts at the digits, did not receive strong recurrent inhibition from either TA or St, nor did stimulation of the EDL nerve produce much inhibition. The distribution of recurrent inhibition and facilitation is correlated with the pattern of locomotor activity, but with exceptions that suggest an influence of mechanical action, particularly in the antagonistic interactions between TP and PerB. The extended pattern of recurrent inhibition, the reduction or absence of inhibition produced by motor nuclei with individualized functions or digit function and the prevalence of facilitation suggest that the recurrent Renshaw system is organized into inhibitory and disinhibitory projections that participate in the control of sets of motor nuclei engaged in rhythmic and stereotyped movements.

A method for potentiating Renshaw cell activity in humans

Owing to the introduction of a special electrophysiological method [3] it has been possible to study spinal recurrent inhibition in humans. The method, however, is indirect and, being based on an H reflex technique, can only be tested in motor nuclei from which a large monosynaptic response can be obtained. We have developed a complementary method by which pharmacological stimulation of Renshaw cells is obtained [6]. It exploits the central cholinergic properties of L-acetylcarnitine [18], a substance which most likely acts potentiating the synaptic drive of the motoneurone collaterals [7], known to be the main source of excitation of Renshaw cells [15,20]. The use of L-acetylcarnitine has allowed to establish the validity of the original methodology [6] and to confirm the presence of recurrent inhibition, tested either by the H reflex technique [11-13] or, if not possible, by the PSTH technique and/or rectified averaged EMG analysis [1,4], in many limb motor nuclei. Thus, it can be expected that L-acetylcarnitine may be used as an independent means for identifying changes in motoneuronal activity related or attributed to the influence of Renshaw cells.

Silent period in upper limb muscles after noxious cutaneous stimulation in man

We studied the effect of electrical stimulation of the C5-C8 dermatomes on voluntary electromyographic activity (EMG) recorded from the ipsilateral first dorsal interosseus (FDI), abductor digiti minimi, flexor and extensor carpi, triceps brachii, biceps brachii, and orbicularis oculi muscles of healthy humans. Finger stimulation (C6-C8) produced an EMG inhibition (silent period, SP), which progressively decreased in duration from distal to proximal muscles; in the biceps it induced a slight facilitation and in the orbicularis oculi muscle, it had no effect. Stimulation of the C5 dermatome induced no response in either distal or proximal muscles. Only high-intensity stimuli evoked clear silent periods. The threshold for evoking an SP was almost double that required for sensory action potentials, 3.25 times the sensory threshold, and decidedly above the pain threshold. An indirect estimation of the conduction velocity of SP afferent fibres placed them in the A-delta group of myelinated fibres. In double-shock experiments, used to study the recovery cycle of the SP in the FDI muscle after finger stimulation, neither low- nor high-intensity conditioning stimuli delivered 100-500 ms before the test stimulus changed test SPs. Experiments designed to evaluate motoneuronal excitability showed that in relaxed FDI muscle, finger stimulation markedly reduced the F wave at the 50 ms time interval, the time when the SP normally occurs. Our findings demonstrate that the activation of A-delta afferents from the fingers inhibits the C7-T1 motoneurons postsynaptically, through an oligosynaptic spinal circuit. We propose that the strong inhibitory effect exerted by noxious cutaneous stimuli on all distal muscles may contribute to a defence action which is specific for the human upper limb.

Firing rate modulation of human motor units in different muscles during isometric contraction with various forces

To examine the factors affecting the control of human motor units, rate coding strategies of the motor units were investigated in upper limb and intrinsic hand muscles during voluntary isometric contraction of steady force levels up to 80% of maximal voluntary contraction. Numerous spike trains from single motor units were recorded from the m. first dorsal interosseous (FDI) and the m. biceps brachii (BB) of eight human subjects by means of tungsten micro-electrodes, and the mean firing rate (MFR) was calculated for each subject and inter-individual comparisons made. The MFRs of the FDI were larger than that of the BB at the higher force level, and substantial differences were not found between these muscles at the lower force level. The slope of the linear regression line of MFRs vs. exerted forces for the FDI was more than twice that for the BB. Therefore, isometric force control of the FDI depends more on the rate coding strategy. The difference in rate coding between the FDI and BB motor units may be determined by factors other than muscle fiber composition, because both muscles are known to possess a similar composition of fiber types. Possible mechanisms underlying these characteristics of rate coding strategy are considered in this report.

Distribution of Ia effects onto human hand muscle motoneurones as revealed using an H reflex technique

1. The possibility of eliciting H reflexes in relaxed hand muscles using a collision between the orthodromic impulses generated by magnetic cortical stimulation and the antidromic motor volley due to a supramaximal (SM) peripheral nerve stimulus was investigated in seven subjects. 2. Magnetic stimuli, applied through a circular coil (outer diameter, 13 cm) centred at the vertex, evoking EMG responses of 3-5 mV amplitude in the relaxed abductor digit minimi (ADM) muscle, and SM test stimuli to the ulnar nerve at the wrist producing a direct maximal motor response (Mmax) in the ADM muscle, were given either alone or combined. 3. In all subjects, combined cortical and SM ulnar stimulation produced a response after the Mmax with the latency of an H reflex evoked by the ulnar stimulus. This response occurred only within interstimulus intervals (1-20 ms) compatible with collision in the motor axons. The response behaved like an H reflex being time-locked to the SM ulnar stimulus, facilitated by voluntary activation of ADM muscle, depressed by vibration (4 s, 100 Hz) of ADM tendon and by a submotor-threshold ulnar nerve stimulus applied 50 and 80 ms before the combined stimulation, respectively. 4. In some subjects, it was also possible to distinguish an earlier response preceding the H reflex by 3 ms. Evidence is given that this response is probably of cortical origin. 5. Varying the intensity of magnetic stimulation resulted in a non-linear relationship between the H reflex size and the size of the cortical response. When the latter was between 5-25% of Mmax, H reflexes were small (2.5-7.5% of Mmax); with cortical responses between 25-50% of Mmax, there was a steep increase in H reflex amplitude (10-30% of Mmax). We suggest that this behaviour is due to an uneven distribution of Ia effects within the motoneurone pool.