A prospective study comparing PlasmaKnife with bipolar dissection tonsillectomy: a preliminary communication of an emerging technology

Comparison of post-tonsillectomy pain with two different types of bipolar forceps: low temperature quantum molecular resonance device versus high temperature conventional electrocautery

CONCLUSION

The low temperature device did not show any advantages over the conventional high temperature electrocautery in terms of the postoperative pain, operation time, and complications in pediatric tonsillectomy.

OBJECTIVE

To compare post-tonsillectomy pain following the use of two different instruments with the same bipolar forceps techniques: low temperature quantum molecular resonance (QMR) device versus conventional high temperature electrocautery.

METHODS

Pediatric patients admitted from July 2008 through January 2009 were included. The participants underwent bilateral tonsillectomy; one side by the QMR device and the other by the bipolar electrocautery. The sides for each instrument were counterbalanced by the order of presentation. The postoperative pain was measured using the faces pain rating scale.

RESULTS

In all, 33 patients with a mean age of 7.6 years were enrolled. The postoperative pain, operation time, and complications in 33 sides dissected by the electrocautery and 33 sides by the QMR device were compared. The average operation times with each device were not statistically different. The mean ratings of the perception of pain related to each instrument were not different on operation day and postoperative day 1, day 4, and day 7 (p = 0.133, 0.057, 0.625, and 1.0, respectively). There was no postoperative complication in any of the patients.

A prospective multi-centre randomised controlled trial comparing PlasmaKnife with bipolar dissection tonsillectomy: evaluating an emerging technology

OBJECTIVE

To clinically evaluate and compare the PlasmaKnife to bipolar electrocautery in paediatric tonsillectomy.

METHODS

A prospective, multi-centred, double-blinded randomised controlled trial, conducted in central London teaching hospitals. The participants were 100 patients aged 2-16 years with recurrent tonsillitis or obstructive adenotonsillar hypertrophy awaiting a tonsillectomy were recruited in to the study. The primary outcome measures were throat, ear and swallowing pain scores over two weeks. Secondary outcome measures were return to normal diet, return to normal activity, analgesic requirements, operation time and intra-operative blood loss.

RESULTS

Surgical dissection was similar between the two groups with minimal blood loss and comparable overall operative times. We found that PlasmaKnife tonsillectomy caused more throat pain at 24 h (p=0.02). There was a tendency for a higher proportion in the bipolar dissection group to return to a normal diet, at day 3 (p=0.05) and at day 7 (p=0.04). The bipolar dissection returned to normal activities in a larger proportion than the PlasmaKnife group at day 3 (p=0.02) and at day 7 (p=0.01). There is some evidence of an association between use of analgesia at day 14 and method of tonsillectomy (p=0.03); the PlasmaKnife group tended to use less analgesia. During the study, four secondary bleeds occurred in the PlasmaKnife group and one in the bipolar dissection group, and all were managed conservatively.

CONCLUSION

Our study has found no significant advantage to PlasmaKnife over bipolar diathermy tonsillectomy. However, this preliminary study finds PlasmaKnife to be an interesting instrument and may warrant a larger randomised study to evaluate the potential advantages.