Abstract
The isolation and cultivation of the agent of Potomac horse fever, Ehrlichia risticii, by Holland, Ristic, et al., afforded Weisburg et al. an opportunity to examine its phylogeny. E. risticii is clearly related to the genus Rickettsia and not to chlamydiae. A reevaluation of the significance of phenotypic characteristics is thus required, since ehrlichiae, in some respects, resemble chlamydiae. For example, unlike rickettsiae, ehrlichiae and chlamydiae multiply in the phagosome of their host cells, but may not have the same mechanism of inhibition of phagosome-lyososome fusion. Rickettsiae, which multiply in the cytoplasm, may have a mechanism of survival in the phagosome similar to that of the ehrlichiae, but, in addition, utilize a phospholipase, which permits prompt escape from the phagosome. Rickettsiae, as most Gram negatives, multiply by binary fisson. Chlamydiae, on the other hand, undergo a cycle of development. Elementary bodies (EB) infect, but do not divide, while the reverse is true of reticulate bodies (RB). Ehrlichiae superficially resemble chlamydiae rather than rickettsiae, but ehrlichiae have not yet been submitted to the rigorous criteria of separation of EB and RB. Investigations in our laboratory of the metabolic activities of E. risticii and E. sennetsu link them to the rickettsiae and not to the chlamydiae. Ehrlichiae and rickettsiae, but not chlamydiae, derive some ATP from their catabolic activities. In conclusion, in further investigations of the monocytic ehrlichiae, it is safer to be guided by what we know of rickettsiae, than chlamydiae.
Collapse