PROTEIN COMPOSITION OF SPINACH CHLOROPLASTS AND THEIR PHOTOSYSTEM I AND PHOTOSYSTEM II SUBFRAGMENTS

Protein-pigments and the photosystem II reaction center: a glimpse into the history of research and reminiscences

This article provides a glimpse into the dawning of research on chlorophyll-protein complexes and a brief recollection of the path that led us to the identification of the photosystem II reaction center, i.e., the polypeptides that carry the site of primary charge separation in oxygenic photosynthesis. A preliminary version of the personal review on the latter topic has already appeared in this journal (Satoh Photosynth Res 76:233-240, 2003).

The chlorophyll-protein complexes of higher plant photosynthetic membranes or Just what green band is that?

Higher plant thylakoid membranes can be fractionated into a bewildering array of macrocomplexes, chlorophyll-protein complexes and chlorophyll-proteins with various deteregents and separations techniques. The chemical nature of each of these entities depends on the particular methods used to obtain them. This review summarizes the current status of the biochemical identification and characterization of individual chlorophyll-proteins and chlorophyll-protein complexes, and attempts to clarify the relationships among them.

Protein identification of purified particles isolated from spinach thylakoids by deoxycholate electrophoresis

Three thylakoid complexes were isolated by deoxycholate preparative electrophoresis. The protein composition of each fraction was analyzed by SDS analytical electrophoresis. No protein of the PS 1 enriched fraction (fraction 1) was found in the PS 2 enriched fraction (fraction 2) and inversely. The antenna complex (fraction 3) did not have any contamination by proteins of fraction 1 or fraction 2. Fraction 1 was mainly composed of the CP1, the reaction center complex of the PS1, and by low molecular weight proteins, previously found in other PS 1 preparations. Tentative assignments of these proteins are presented; among them are iron sulfur proteins. After analytical SDS electrophoresis of fraction 2, the reaction center complex was dissociated. Nevertheless three proteins of 50 kD, 42 kD and 35 kD were assigned to this complex. Fraction 2 contained also the three cytochromes of the thylakoid membranes: cyt f, cyt b6, cyt b559. Fraction 3 was exclusively composed of one protein pigment complex, CP2.

Membrane-surface electric properties of triton-fractionated spinach subchloroplast fragments

Surface charge density of subchloroplast fragments fractionated from spinach by Triton X-100 treatment was estimated from cation-induced quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence, with the premise that the fluorescence yield is dependent on the surface electric potential of the preparations. Application of the Gouy-Chapman theory of diffuse double layer to the subchloroplast preparations, or treating the surface of the preparations under electric charge regulation conditions yielded a result suggesting the Photosystem II reaction-center preparation (TSF-IIa) to be more negatively charged than the Photosystem I reaction-center preparation (TSF-I). Isoelectric points of the subchloroplast fragments were determined by measuring 90 degrees light scattering and more directly by gel isoelectric focusing. Isoelectric points of TSF-I and -IIa were estimated to be 4.8 and 4.0 from light-scattering experiments, and 4.5 and 4.1 from gel electrophoresis, respectively. The TSF-II preparation that contains both a light-harvesting complex and the reaction-center (core) complex showed a small cation-induced quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence. This fluorescence quenching may be ascribed mostly to the regulation of energy transfer in the preparation (Yamamoto, Y. and Ke, B. (1980) Biochim, Biophys. Acta 592, 296-302). Furthermore, the TSF-II preparation showed a broad and indefinite peak in light scattering in the pH range 3-8, suggesting that the complex probably carries a small amount of charge in this pH range. The physiological role of the membrane surface charge of the subchloroplast preparations in membrane structure and cation regulated processes in chloroplast is discussed.

Regulation of excitation energy distribution in photosystem-II fragments by magnesium ions

Fluorescence characteristics of Photosystem-II subchloroplasts (TSF-II and TSF-IIa) fractionated by Triton X-100 treatment were studied in relation to cation-induced regulation of excitation-energy distribution within subchloroplast fragments. Absorption spectra and fluorescence-emission spectra at 77 K showed that TSF-II contains the light-harvesting chlorophyll-protein complex in addition to the reaction-center complex, which is present alone in TSF-IIa. Mg2+ increased the ratio of F695nm to F685nm in the fluorescence-emission spectrum of TSF-II particles at 77 K, but had no effect on TSF-IIa particles. Mg2+ also induced a quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence at room temperature in TSF-II, an effect that was insensitive to the presence of DCMU. The DCMU-insensitive fluorescence quenching was not observed in the TSF-IIa preparation. These results suggest an existence of cation-induced regulation of excitation-energy transfer in TSF-II preparations. Presence of antenna chlorophyll molecules alone does not seem to be sufficient for observing energy-transfer regulation by cations in Photosystem-II preparations.

Contribution to the structural characterization of eucaryotic PSI reaction centre-I. Critical analysis of the polypeptidic composition of different P700 enriched fractions

In thylakoid membranes, several peptides of high MW† are present which may interfere with the study of CP1's components. Modifying Cleveland's technique [7] for limited proteolysis, we have characterized the polypeptides found in the 60 kD region. Some may result from incomplete washing of the CF1 while others come from the CP1; indeed, this chlorophyll protein complex, which has a higher MW (above 100 kD), very often undergoes a dissociation into smaller components of about 60 KD MW.Analysis of the protein content of different preparations commonly used to obtain PSI reaction centre enriched fractions has been performed. The α and β subunits of CF1 are among the main contaminants of most of these preparations. A further purification step is described which can be applied to all these preparations, but numerous peptides are still present in the active fractions. It is most unlikely that all these polypeptides are required for the primary photochemical event, and this emphasizes the necessity to find a new simple method to purify PSI reaction centres.

Sub-thylakoid fractions containing ribosomes

A sub-membrane fraction which contains a large portion of any thylakoid-bound ribosomes can be obtained when thylakoids are treated with the detergents Nonidet P-40, or Triton X-100. These 'pseudopolysome' fractions contain 50% of thylakoid-bound ribosomes, but less than 0.5% of thylakoid chlorophyll. Triton and Nonidet psuedopolysomes contain about 10%, and 3% of thylakoid protein, respectively. Pseudopolysomes, prepared from thylakoids with low levels of ribosomes, contain about the same proportion of thylakoid protein but proportionately less ribosomes. Pseudopolysomes contain thylakoid polypeptides in addition to chlorophyll, but lack a major membrane polypeptide of Mr 50 000. Pseudopolysome chlorophyll, and RNA band at the same buoyant density. However, they band at different densities after pseudopolysomes are treated with trypsin (a procedure which strips thylakoids of ribosomes). Pseudopolysome fractions from thylakoids with low levels of ribosomes have a lower density than the corresponding fractions from thylakoids with high levels of ribosomes. Ribosomes are released from thylakoids, and pseudopolysomes by the same treatments. Subunits are released with KCl and puromycin. Polysomes are released with trypsin. It was concluded the pseudopolysomes consist of ribosomes and a membrane fragment containing the sites to which ribosomes are bound.

Purification and characterization of 33 kilodalton protein of spinach chloroplasts

A protein was prepared from spinach chloroplasts in a highly purified form. The isoelectric point of the protein was 5.2. The apparent molecular weight was estimated to be 33 000 by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate and urea, and 34 000 by gel filtration column chromatography with Sephadex G-100. The protein was provisionally named '33 kilodalton protein' according to the molecular weight. The absorption spectrum of the protein did not show any absorption band in the visible region. No histidine was found in the amino acid analysis of the protein. The 33 kilodalton protein was released from the thylakoid membrane by EDTA-treatment and also by sonic oscillation. The protein was bound to System II particles, but not to System I particles.

Polypeptide composition of the purified photosystem II pigment-protein complex from spinach

The Photosystem II pigment-protein complex, the chlorophyll alpha-protein comprising the reaction center of Photosystem II, was prepared from EDTA-treated spinach chloroplasts by digitonin extraction, sucrose-gradient centrifugation, DEAE-cellulose column chromatography, and isoelectrofocussing on Ampholine. The dissociated pigment-protein complex exhibits two polypeptide subunits that migrate in SDS-polyacrylamide gel with electrophoretic mobilities corresponding to molecular weights of approximately 43,000 and 27,000. the chlorophyll was always found in the free pigment zone at the completion of the electrophoresis. Heat-treatment of the sample (100 degrees C, 90 s) for electrophoresis caused association of the two polypeptides into large aggregates. It is concluded that these two polypeptides, 43,000 and 27,000, are valid structural or functional components of Photosystem II pigment-protein complex.

Isoelectric points of spinach thylakoid membrane surfaces as determined by cross partition

The isoelectric points of unbroken chloroplast lamellae and various subchloroplast fractions, including a preparation of inside-out thylakoids, have been determined using aqueous two-phase systems containing dextran and charged polyethylene glycol. When the amounts of material in the top phase in a phase system with the positively charged trimethylamino polyethylene glycol are plotted against pH the curve intersects the corresponding curve obtained from phase systems with the negatively charged polyethylene glycol sulfonate. This cross-point can be correlated with the isoelectric point of the material. The cross-point for unbroken chloroplast lamellae was found to be around pH 4.7. Mechanical disintegration lowered the cross-point to around pH 4.4, probably because of exposure of new membrane surfaces. The disintegrated chloroplasts were fractionated by differential centrifugation to separate the grana and stroma lamellae. The stroma lamellae vesicles showed the same isoelectric point as the unbroken lamellae, while a cross-point at pH 4.3 was obtained for the grana-enriched fraction. For thylakoid membranes destacked under low salt conditions the cross-point was 0.3 pH unit lower than for membranes originating exclusively from the stroma lamellae. The most acidic crosspoint (pH 4.1) was observed for the fraction enriched in inside-out granathylakoids. It is suggested that the differences in isoelectric point between various subchloroplast fractions reflect a heterogeneous arrangement of surface charge along and across the thylakoid membrane.

Photosynthetic apparatus in chilling-sensitive plants : V. Changes in protein fractions of leaves and isolated chloroplasts following cod and dark storage and illumination of tomato leaves

Proteins of fresh, cold and dark-stored and illuminated tomato leaves were fractionated by SDS electrophoresis. The total soluble proteins extracted from fresh leaves were separated into 5 main fractions with MWs of 54,000, 45,000, 32,000, 23,000 and 14,000. The cold and dark storage of the leaves causes a marked reduction mainly in the fraction with MW of 45,000 which increased with the illumination of the cold and dark-storaged leaves. The polypeptides with MWs of 54,000 and 14,000 (probably large and small subunits of ribulose, bisphosphate carboxylase) were stable under these conditions. In contrast, the polypeptides with MWs of 54,000 and 14,000 are decreased following the storage of tomato leaves in the dark at room temperature. Chloroplast soluble proteins were seperated by SDS electrophoresis into fractions with MWs of 64,000, 54,000, 20,000 and 14,000. The same fractions in similar proportions were observed in soluble-chloroplast proteins from fresh as well as coold and dark-stored and illuminated leaves. No drastic changes in structural polypeptides were observed following cold and dark-storage and illumination of the leaves. The results indicated that the main protein fraction, which degradated following cold and dark storage of tomato leaves and synthetized during illumination, is the fraction of cytoplasmic protein which in SDS electrophoresis gives polypeptides of about 45,000 MW. The fractions of chloroplast proteins were stable under such conditions.

Polypeptide profiles of chlorophyll . protein complexes and thylakoid membranes of spinach chloroplasts

In addition to the major chlorophyll . protein complexes I and II, two minor chlorophyll proteins have been observed in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS))-polyacrylamide gels of spinach chloroplast membranes. These minor pigmented zones appeared to be derived from the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b . protein and from the reaction centre complex of Photosystem II. Data are presented on the polypeptide profiles of purified digitonin-subschloroplast particles, with special regard to the effect of solubilization temperature and extraction of lipids. The results are compared with the SDS-polypeptide pattern of spinach thylakoids obtained under exactly the same conditions with respect to electrophoresis technique, solubilization method and presence of lipid. In addition, the effects of temperature and lipid extraction on the distinct chlorophyll . protein complexes appearing in SDS gel electrophoretograms of chloroplast membranes were studied by slicing the chlorophyll-containing regions and subjecting them to a second run with or without heating or extraction with acetone. By supplementing these data with an examination of the polypeptide composition of cytochrome f and coupling factor, it has been possible to identify most of the major chloroplast membrane polypeptides.

Chloroplast membrane sidedness. Location of plastocyanin determined by chemical modifiers

Intact grana and stroma membranes (outer membrane absent) and detergent or sonication disrupted thylakoid membranes were treated with the hydrophilic covalent chemical modifiers [35S]diazonium benzene sulfonic acid ([35S]DABS) and [14C]glycine ethylester plus 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl)-carbodiimide metho-p-toluenesulfonate (CDIS). Plastocyanin was purified using column chromatography followed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and the incorporation of [35S]DABS and [14C]glycine ethylester into plastocyanin was determined by slicing the gels and counting the radioactivity in the plastocyanin band. Plastocyanin isolated from thylakoids disrupted prior to chemical modification binds two to four times as much of either modifier than the plastocyanin isolated from intact chloroplasts. This ratio is five to ten times lower than the ratio expected for a component buried behind the permeability barrier of a membrane. The data suggest that plastocyanin is partially exposed at the external surface of the thylakoid membrane rather than being completely buried in, or behind, the lipo-protein membrane.

The retention of photosynthetic activity by senescing chloroplasts of oat leaves

The retention of photosystems I and II and or RuDP carboxylase activity in chloroplasts isolated from the first leaves of Victory oat (Avena sativa L.) seedlings was followed as the chloroplasts senesced in darkness. Both photosystems (PS) I and II retained their full activity after 3 days at 1°C, while even after 7 days at 1°C around 80% of the activity was still present. After 3 days at 25°C, PS I lost only 20% and PS II 50% of the initial activity. Acid pH increased the rate of decay of both systems, PS II falling almost to zero after 3 days at pH 3.5 (at 25°C). The preparations were almost bacteria-free, and addition of antibiotics not only did not improve their stability, but accelerated the rates of loss of photosynthetic activity. This is held to indicate that the enzymes are undergoing some turnover even in isolated chloroplasts. If the leaves were allowed to senesce in the dark first and the chloroplasts then isolated, their photosynthetic activities had greatly decreased, showing that senescence is more rapid in situ than in isolation. Under these conditions PS I decayed more rapidly than PS II. Ribulosediphosphate carboxylase, as measured by CO2 fixation, declined more rapidly than the photosystems, though the addition of kinetin and indole-3-acetic acid somewhat decreased the rate of loss, at least for the first 24 h. When the intact (detached) leaves were held in the dark, the rate of oxygen evolution declined rapidly, but in monochromatic blue light (450 nm) at 25°C about 30% of the initial rate was retained after 72 h.

[Photosynthetic activity in the absence of CPl and CP2 pigmentary complexes (author's transl)]

Various photochemical activities were tested on chloroplasts of Zea mays that received 4 s of light every 4 h during the culture period. Photosystem I and Photosystem II were functioning, as well as the photosynthetic electron transport. These chloroplasts exhibited upon sodium dodecyl sulphate gel electrophoresis neither Complex 1 (Mr 70 000) generally associated with Photosystem I nor Complex 2 Mr 25 000) generally associated with Photosystem II. Chlorophyll is indeed attached to polypeptides of molecular weight 21 000 and 29 000. These results lead us to question the functional role of chloroplast protein-pigment complexes observed by sodium dodecyl sulphate gel electrophoresis.

Compositional characteristics of a chloroform/methanol soluble protein fraction from spinach chloroplast membranes

Extraction of an aqueous suspension of spinach chloroplast lamellae with a chloroform/methanol mixture leads to solubilization of about 1/3 of the total membrane protein. Amino acid analysis of the chloroform/methanol-soluble protein shows that this fraction is largely enriched in the hydrophobic residues proline, leucine, alanine and phenylalanine and considerably depleted in polar amino acids, namely lysine and arginine. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of the solubilized material reveals the presence of a variety of low molecular weight polypeptides (molecular weight less than or equal to 25 000), with more than 50% of the total fraction being contributed by a 25 000 dalton band. This band, which accounts for about 25% of the total chloroplast lamellar protein, has recently been identified as the main component of the light-harvesting chlorophyll-protein complex. The physiological role of most of the chloroform/methanol-soluble protein fraction is not known at present. From its chemical properties and apparent biological inertness, we propose that it plays mainly a structural role in situ, interacting with the lipid moiety of the chloroplast membrane. The material insoluble in the aqueous chloroform/methanol mixture is largely enriched in manganese, iron, cytochrome and water-soluble proteins, such as chloroplast coupling factor and ribulose diphosphate carboxylase.

Chlorophyll and peptide compositions in the two photosystems of marine green algae

The molar ratios of chlorophyll a to b in the thalli of marine green algae were between 1.5 and 2.2, being appreciably lower than the ratio between 2.8 and 3.4 found for the leaves of higher plants and the cells of fresh-water green algae. The ratio of chlorophylls to P-700 in these marine algae was also lower than that in higher plants. The a/b ratios in the pigment proteins of Photosystems 1 and 2 separated by polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis from sodium dodecyl sulfate-solubilized chloroplasts of four species of marine green algae, Bryopsis maxima, Cheatomorpha spiralis, Enteromorpha compressa and Ulva conglobata, were approximately 5 and 1, which are considerably smaller than the ratios, 7 and 2, respectively, found for the pigment proteins of the two photosystems of higher plants separated by the same technique. The chloroplasts of Bryopsis maxima and Cheatomorpha spiralis lacked two of the peptides associated with Photosystem II, which are present in the chloroplasts of Spinacia oleracea and Taraxacum officinale.

Separation of subchloroplast membrane particles by counter-current distribution

Counter-current distribution in an aqueous Dextran-polyethylene glycol two-phase system has been used to fractionate membrane fragments obtained by press treatment of Class II chloroplasts. By the counter-current distribution technique membrane particles are separated according to their surface properties such as charge and hydrophobicity. The fractions obtained were analysed with respect to photochemical activities, chlorophyll and P-700 contents. The Photosystem II enrichment after counter-current distribution was better than that obtained by differential centrifugation of the disrupted chloroplasts. However, the best separation of Photosystem I and II enriched particles could be achieved if differential centrifugation was combined with the counter-current distribution technique. Each centrifugal fraction could be further separated into Photosystems I and II enriched fractions since the Photosystem II particles preferred the dextran-rich bottom phase while the Photosystem I particles preferred the polyethylene glycol-rich top phase. By this procedure it was possible, without the use of detergents, to obtain vesicles which were more enriched in Photosystem II as compared to intact grana stacks. The partition behaviour of undisrupted Class II chloroplasts and the Photosystem I centrifugal fraction was the same. This similarity indicated that the membrane which is exposed to the surrounding polymers by the Class II chloroplasts is the Photosystem I rich membrane of the stroma lamellae.

Photophosphorylation and related properties of reaggregated vesicles from spinach photosystem I particles

The small Photosystem I particles prepared from spinach chloroplasts by the action of Triton X-100 (TSF 1 particles) reaggregate into membrane structures when they are incubated with soybean phospholipids and cholate and then subjected to a slow dialysis. The membranes so formed are vesicular in nature and show the capability of catalyzing phenazine methosulfate-mediated cyclic photophosphorylation at rates which are usually about 20% of those observed with chloroplasts, but higher rates have been obtained. When coupling factor is removed from the chloroplasts by treatment with EDTA, a requirement for coupling factor can be shown for the subsequent ATP formation. The uncouplers carbonylcyanide 3-chlorophenyl-hydrazone, valinomycin, Triton X-100 and NH+4 are effective with the reformed vesicles, which do not show the typical light-induced pH gradient observed with chloroplasts. Incubation of the TSF 1 particles with phospholipids alone allows for the formation of membrane vesicles, but such vesicles are only slightly active in ATP formation. In most properties investigated, the reformed membrane vesicles resemble the original chloroplast membrane so far as phenazine methosulfate-mediated cyclic photophosphorylation is concerned, which indicates a high degree of selectivity in the reaggregation process. The major difference between chloroplasts and the reformed vesicles is the failure of the latter to show a light-induced pH gradient.

Comparative studies on the polypeptide composition of chloroplast lamellae and lamellar fractions

The polypeptide composition of spinach chloroplast membranes and membrane fractions has been examined by the technique of sodium dodecylsulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Chloroplasts were fragmented into grana (Photosystem II enriched) and stroma lamellae (Photosystem I in character) by the French press technique. The grana lamellae were further fractionated by the use of digitonin into two fractions, one enriched in Photosystem II and the other enriched in Photosystem I. These membranes are composed of at least 15 polypeptides two of which, with approximate weights of 39 and 50 kdaltons, are observed only in granal fractions. Quantitatively the primarily Photosystem II fractions are enriched in polypeptides in the 30-23 kdalton range whereas the Photosystem I (or Photosystem I-enriched) fractions are enriched in polypeptides in the 60-54 kdalton region. The experiments reported show that contamination by soluble proteins or other membranes is negligible. The results indicate that subtle differences in composition account for the large differences in structure and function within the chloroplast membrane system.