SPECTRAL FORMS AND ORIENTATION OF BACTERIOCHLOROPHYLLS c AND α IN CHLOROSOMES OF THE GREEN PHOTOSYNTHETIC BACTERIUM Chloroflexus aurantiacus

Probing size variations of molecular aggregates inside chlorosomes using single-object spectroscopy

We theoretically investigate the possibility to use single-object spectroscopy to probe size variations of the bacteriochlorophyll aggregates inside chlorosomes. Chlorosomes are the light-harvesting organelles of green sulfur and non-sulfur bacteria. They are known to be the most efficient light-harvesting systems in nature. Key to this efficiency is the organization of bacteriochlorophyll molecules in large self-assembled aggregates that define the secondary structure inside the chlorosomes. Many studies have been reported to elucidate the morphology of these aggregates and the molecular packing inside them. It is widely believed that tubular aggregates play an important role. Because the size (radius and length) of these aggregates affects the optical and excitation energy transport properties, it is of interest to be able to probe these quantities inside chlorosomes. We show that a combination of single-chlorosome linear polarization resolved spectroscopy and single-chlorosome circular dichroism spectroscopy may be used to access the typical size of the tubular aggregates within a chlorosome and, thus, probe possible variations between individual chlorosomes that may result, for instance, from different stages in growth or different growth conditions.

Limitations of Linear Dichroism Spectroscopy for Elucidating Structural Issues of Light-Harvesting Aggregates in Chlorosomes

Linear dichroism (LD) spectroscopy is a widely used technique for studying the mutual orientation of the transition-dipole moments of the electronically excited states of molecular aggregates. Often the method is applied to aggregates where detailed information about the geometrical arrangement of the monomers is lacking. However, for complex molecular assemblies where the monomers are assembled hierarchically in tiers of supramolecular structural elements, the method cannot extract well-founded information about the monomer arrangement. Here we discuss this difficulty on the example of chlorosomes, which are the light-harvesting aggregates of photosynthetic green-(non) sulfur bacteria. Chlorosomes consist of hundreds of thousands of bacteriochlorophyll molecules that self-assemble into secondary structural elements of curved lamellar or cylindrical morphology. We exploit data from polarization-resolved fluorescence-excitation spectroscopy performed on single chlorosomes for reconstructing the corresponding LD spectra. This reveals that LD spectroscopy is not suited for benchmarking structural models in particular for complex hierarchically organized molecular supramolecular assemblies.

CsmA Protein is Associated with BChl a in the Baseplate Subantenna of Chlorosomes of the Photosynthetic Green Filamentous Bacterium Oscillochloris trichoides belonging to the Family Oscillochloridaceae

The baseplate subantenna in chlorosomes of green anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria, belonging to the families Chloroflexaceae and Chlorobiaceae, is known to represent a complex of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a with the ~6 kDa CsmA proteins. Earlier, we showed the existence of a similar BChl a subantenna in chlorosomes of the photosynthetic green bacterium Oscillochloris trichoides, member of Oscillochloridaceae, the third family of green photosynthetic bacteria. However, this BChl a subantenna was not visually identified in absorption spectra of isolated Osc. trichoides chlorosomes in contrast to those of Chloroflexaceae and Chlorobiaceae. In this work, using room and low-temperature absorbance and fluorescence spectroscopy and sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis of alkaline-treated and untreated chlorosomes of Osc. trichoides, we showed that the baseplate BChl a subantenna does exist in Oscillochloridaceae chlorosomes as a complex of BChl a with the 5.7 kDa CsmA protein. The present results support the idea that the baseplate subantenna, representing a complex of BChl a with a ~6 kDa CsmA protein, is a universal interface between the BChl c subantenna of chlorosomes and the nearest light-harvesting BChl a subantenna in all three known families of green anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria.

The chlorosome: a prototype for efficient light harvesting in photosynthesis

Three phyla of bacteria include phototrophs that contain unique antenna systems, chlorosomes, as the principal light-harvesting apparatus. Chlorosomes are the largest known supramolecular antenna systems and contain hundreds of thousands of BChl c/d/e molecules enclosed by a single membrane leaflet and a baseplate. The BChl pigments are organized via self-assembly and do not require proteins to provide a scaffold for efficient light harvesting. Their excitation energy flows via a small protein, CsmA embedded in the baseplate to the photosynthetic reaction centres. Chlorosomes allow for photosynthesis at very low light intensities by ultra-rapid transfer of excitations to reaction centres and enable organisms with chlorosomes to live at extraordinarily low light intensities under which no other phototrophic organisms can grow. This article reviews several aspects of chlorosomes: the supramolecular and molecular organizations and the light-harvesting and spectroscopic properties. In addition, it provides some novel information about the organization of the baseplate.

Anisotropic distribution of emitting transition dipoles in chlorosome from Chlorobium tepidum: fluorescence polarization anisotropy study of single chlorosomes

The polarization anisotropy of fluorescence spectra from single chlorosomes isolated from a green sulfur bacterium, Chlorobium (Cb.) tepidum, was observed at 13 K. As the polarizer was rotated, the intensities of the fluorescence bands of both bacteriochlorophyll (BChl)-c self-aggregates and BChl-a in baseplate proteins showed clear oscillations. From the oscillation, the values of the degree of polarization (DP) and the phase shift (PS) between the BChl-c and BChl-a bands were determined for each single chlorosome. The DP versus PS plot for Cb. tepidum chlorosomes showed linear correlations between the PS and the DP values for both BChl-c and BChl-a fluorescence bands. This tendency could be explained from a simulation assuming a random orientation of chlorosomes and a triaxial orientation distribution of emitting transition dipoles within a single chlorosome. The intensity ratios among the X-/Y-/Z-principal transition dipoles were estimated to be 0.3/0.5/1 and 1/0.6/0.1 for the BChl-c and BChl-a fluorescence bands, respectively. Here, the X-, Y-, and Z-axes are perpendicular, parallel to the cytoplasmic membrane, and parallel to the chlorosome long axis, respectively. A theoretical calculation based on the exciton theory was conducted to reproduce the observed triaxial orientation distribution of emitting transition dipoles. The simulation revealed that a deformation introduced to the circular cross section of the rod-shaped BChl-c self-aggregates could qualitatively reproduce results of this study.

Investigation on chlorosomal antenna geometries: tube, lamella and spiral-type self-aggregates

Molecular mechanics calculations and exciton theory have been used to study pigment organization in chlorosomes of green bacteria. Single and double rod, multiple concentric rod, lamella, and Archimedean spiral macrostructures of bacteriochlorophyll c molecules were created and their spectral properties evaluated. The effects of length, width, diameter, and curvature of the macrostructures as well as orientations of monomeric transition dipole moment vectors on the spectral properties of the aggregates were studied. Calculated absorption, linear dichroism, and polarization dependent fluorescence-excitation spectra of the studied long macrostructures were practically identical, but circular dichroism spectra turned out to be very sensitive to geometry and monomeric transition dipole moment orientations of the aggregates. The simulations for long multiple rod and spiral-type macrostructures, observed in recent high-resolution electron microscopy images (Oostergetel et al., FEBS Lett 581:5435-5439, 2007) gave shapes of circular dichroism spectra observed experimentally for chlorosomes. It was shown that the ratio of total circular dichroism intensity to integrated absorption of the Q(y) transition is a good measure of degree of tubular structures in the chlorosomes. Calculations suggest that the broad Q(y) line width of chlorosomes of sulfur bacteria could be due to (1) different orientations of the transition moment vectors in multi-walled rod structures or (2) a variety of Bchl-aggregate structures in the chlorosomes.

Hexanol-induced order-disorder transitions in lamellar self-assembling aggregates of bacteriochlorophyll c in Chlorobium tepidum chlorosomes

Chlorosomes are light-harvesting complexes of green photosynthetic bacteria. Chlorosomes contain bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) c, d, or e aggregates that exhibit strong excitonic coupling. The short-range order, which is responsible for the coupling, has been proposed to be augmented by pigment arrangement into undulated lamellar structures with spacing between 2 and 3 nm. Treatment of chlorosomes with hexanol reversibly converts the aggregated chlorosome chlorophylls into a form with spectral properties very similar to that of the monomer. Although this transition has been extensively studied, the structural basis remains unclear due to variability in the obtained morphologies. Here we investigated hexanol-induced structural changes in the lamellar organization of BChl c in chlorosomes from Chlorobium tepidum by a combination of X-ray scattering, electron cryomicroscopy, and optical spectroscopy. At a low hexanol/pigment ratio, the lamellae persisted in the presence of hexanol while the short-range order and exciton interactions between chlorin rings were effectively eliminated, producing a monomer-like absorption. The result suggested that hexanol hydroxyls solvated the chlorin rings while the aliphatic tail partitioned into the hydrophobic part of the lamellar structure. This partitioning extended the chlorosome along its long axis. Further increase of the hexanol/pigment ratio produced round pigment-hexanol droplets, which lost all lamellar order. After hexanol removal the spectral properties were restored. In the samples treated under the high hexanol/pigment ratio, lamellae reassembled in small domains after hexanol removal while the shape and long-range order were irreversibly lost. Thus, all the interactions required for establishing the short-range order by self-assembly are provided by BChl c molecules alone. However, the long-range order and overall shape are imposed by an external structure, e.g., the proteinaceous chlorosome baseplate.

The 17-propionate function of (bacterio)chlorophylls: biological implication of their long esterifying chains in photosynthetic systems

Molecular structures of (bacterio)chlorophylls [= (B)Chls] in photosynthetic apparatus are surveyed, and a diversity of the ester groups of the 17-propionate substituent is particularly focused on in this review. In oxygenic photosynthetic species including green plants and algae, the ester of Chl molecules is limited to a phytyl group. Geranylgeranyl and farnesyl groups in addition to phytyl are observed in (B)Chl molecules inside photosynthetic proteins of anoxygenic bacteria. In main light-harvesting antennas of green bacteria (chlorosomes), a greater variety of ester groups including long straight chains are used in the composite BChl molecules. This diversity is ascribable to the fact that chlorosomal BChls self-aggregate to form a core part of chlorosomes without any specific interaction of oligopeptides. Biological significance of the long chains is discussed in photosynthetic apparatus, especially in chlorosomes.

Polarized Fluorescence of Aggregated Bacteriochlorophyll c and Baseplate Bacteriochlorophyll a in Single Chlorosomes Isolated from Chloroflexus aurantiacus

The polarization anisotropy of fluorescence from single chlorosomes isolated from a green filamentous bacterium, Chloroflexus aurantiacus, was measured using a confocal laser microscope at 13 K. Each single chlorosome that is floating in a frozen solvent exhibited strong polarization anisotropy of fluorescence. We calculated the degrees of fluorescence polarization for 51 floating single chlorosomes. The value ranged from 0.1 to 0.76 for the BChl-c aggregate in the core chlorosomes and from 0 to 0.4 for the energy acceptor BChl-a in the baseplate protein in the outer membrane. The shifts in polarization angles between the two emission bands were distributed over all the possible values with a sharp peak around 90 degrees , suggesting the perpendicular orientation between the transition dipoles of the fluorescence emission from the BChl-c aggregate and that from BChl-a. A simulation assuming a random orientation of chlorosomes reproduced the experimental results exactly. The analysis further indicated the appreciable contribution of the transition dipole of BChl-c that has an orientation perpendicular to the major polarization axis in each chlorosome. Small values of the degrees of polarization implied the BChl-a transition dipole to be somewhat tilted with respect to the normal of the cytoplasmic membrane to which chlorosomes are attached. These conclusions can be obtained only by observing the fluorescence of single chlorosomes.

Self-aggregation of synthetic zinc chlorophyll derivatives possessing multi-perfluoroalkyl chains in perfluorinated solvents

Zinc 3(1)-hydroxy-13(1)-oxo-chlorins possessing two, three, four and six perfluorooctyl chains were synthesized from naturally occurring chlorophyll-a. Only the synthetic zinc chlorin possessing six perfluorooctyl chains was directly dissolved in perfluorinated solvents due to its high fluorine content in molecular weight (over 50%). In this solution, visible absorption spectra gave a red-shifted Q(y) band at 723 nm (compared to 648 nm in THF) and showed the formation of well-ordered self-aggregates. No monomeric form was observed in the solution from any fluorescence emission spectra from visible absorption spectra. In the aggregate solution, no precipitation occurred during either standing for a long period or heating at 70 degrees C. This showed that the supramolecular structure was stabilized by F-F interactions on its surface among the perfluorooctyl chains on the 17-position and perfluorinated solvents. The core part of the supramolecular structure was constructed by a special intramolecular bond of Zn ... O3(2)-H ... O=C13(1), which was confirmed from resonance Raman spectral analysis.

Characterization of Chlorobium tepidum chlorosomes: a calculation of bacteriochlorophyll c per chlorosome and oligomer modeling

The bacteriochlorophyll (Bchl) c content and organization was determined for Chlorobium (Cb.) tepidum chlorosomes, the light-harvesting complexes from green photosynthetic bacteria, using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and atomic force microscopy. Single-chlorosome fluorescence data was analyzed in terms of the correlation of the fluorescence intensity with time. Using this technique, known as fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, chlorosomes were shown to have a hydrodynamic radius (Rh) of 25 +/- 3.2 nm. This technique was also used to determine the concentration of chlorosomes in a sample, and pigment extraction and quantitation was used to determine the molar concentration of Bchl c present. From these data, a number of approximately 215,000 +/- 80,000 Bchl c per chlorosome was determined. Homogeneity of the sample was further characterized by dynamic light scattering, giving a single population of particles with a hydrodynamic radius of 26.8 +/- 3.7 nm in the sample. Tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (TMAFM) was used to determine the x,y,z dimensions of chlorosomes present in the sample. The results of the TMAFM studies indicated that the average chlorosome dimensions for Cb. tepidum was 174 +/- 8.3 x 91.4 +/- 7.7 x 10.9 +/- 2.71 nm and an overall average volume 90,800 nm(3) for the chlorosomes was determined. The data collected from these experiments as well as a model for Bchl c aggregate dimensions was used to determine possible arrangements of Bchl c oligomers in the chlorosomes. The results obtained in this study have significant implications on chlorosome structure and architecture, and will allow a more thorough investigation of the energetics of photosynthetic light harvesting in green bacteria.

Pure and scrambled self-aggregates prepared with zinc analogues of bacteriochlorophylls c and d

Zinc analogues of bacteriochlorophylls c and d self-assembled in aqueous media with phospholipids. A methanol solution of zinc chlorin and alpha-lecithin was put in a cellulose tube and the inner methanol solvent was gradually replaced with water by dialysis to form the self-assembled oligomers. Visible absorption spectra of the aqueous solution showed that zinc chlorins formed J-aggregates within the hydrophobic core of alpha-lecithin assemblies and that the supramolecular structure of the aggregates depended upon the stereochemistry at the 3(1)-position and the alkyl substituents at the 8-, 12-, and 17(4)-positions of the zinc chlorin. When the aqueous aggregates were prepared with a mixture of 3(1)-epimers and/or 8-, 12-, or 17(4)-homologues of zinc 3(1)-hydroxy-13(1)-oxochlorins, the structurally distinct components coaggregated to make scrambled oligomers. However, during the dialysis, zinc 3(1)-hydroxy- and 7(1)-hydroxy-13(1)-oxochlorins slowly individually aggregated to give two structurally different oligomer units in the cellulose tube. In contrast, if the two zinc chlorin components rapidly self-assembled in an aqueous medium, these components coaggregated to form scrambled oligomers. The present study shows that both the molecular structure of the pigments and the speed of the oligomerization determine the molecular arrangement in chlorosome-type self-assembled oligomers.

A refined model of the chlorosomal antennae of the green bacterium Chlorobium tepidum from proton chemical shift constraints obtained with high-field 2-D and 3-D MAS NMR dipolar correlation spectroscopy

Heteronuclear 2-D and 3-D magic-angle spinning NMR dipolar correlation spectroscopy was applied to determine solid-state (1)H shifts for aggregated bacteriochlorophyll c (BChl c) in uniformly (13)C-enriched light harvesting chlorosomes of the green photosynthetic bacterium Chlorobium tepidum. A complete assignment of 29 different observable resonances of the 61 protons of the aggregated BChl c in the intact chlorosomes is obtained. Aggregation shifts relative to monomeric BChl c in solution are detected for protons attached to rings I, II, and III/V and to their side chains. The 2(1)-H(3), 3(2)-H(3), and 3(1)-H resonances are shifted upfield by -2.2, -1, and -3.3 ppm, respectively, relative to monomeric BChl c in solution. Although the resonances are inhomogeneously broadened and reveal considerable global structural heterogeneity, the 5-CH and the 7-Me responses are doubled, which provides evidence for the existence of at least two relatively well-defined structurally different arrangements. Ab initio quantum chemical modeling studies were performed to refine a model for the self-assembled BChl c with two different types of BChl stacks. The BChl in the stacks can adopt either anti- or syn-configuration of the coordinative bond, where anti and syn designate the relative orientation of the Mg-OH bond relative to the direction of the 17-17(1) bond. The analogy between aggregation shifts for BChl c in the chlorosome and for self-assembled chlorophyll a/H(2)O is explored, and a bilayer model for the tubular supra-structure of sheets of BChl c is proposed, from a homology modeling approach.

Supramolecular structure of self-assembled synthetic zinc-13(1)-oxo-chlorins possessing a primary, secondary or tertiary alcoholic 3(1)-hydroxyl group: visible spectroscopic and molecular modeling studies

Zinc-chlorin 3 (see Fig. 2 in text) possessing a tertiary 3(1)-hydroxyl group and a 13-keto group was synthesized as a model for the antenna chlorophylls of green bacteria. Self-aggregation of 3 in nonpolar organic media was examined and compared to 1 and 2 possessing a primary and secondary 3(1)-hydroxyl group, respectively. Zinc-chlorin 3 self-aggregated in 1 vol% CH2Cl2-hexane to form oligomers and showed a red-shifted Qy maximum at 704 nm compared to the monomer (648 nm in CH2Cl2). This red-shift is larger than that of 2S (648-->697 nm) and comparable to that of 2R (648-->705 nm), but smaller than that of 1 (648-->740 nm), indicating that while a single 3(1)-methyl group (prim-OH-->sec-OH) suppressed close and/or higher aggregation, the additional 3(1)-methyl group (sec-OH-->tert-OH) did not further suppress aggregation. The relative stability of the aggregates was in the order 1 > 2R-3 > 2S as determined by visible spectral analyses. Molecular modeling calculations on dodecamers of zinc-chlorins 1, 2R and 3 gave similar well-ordered energy-minimized structures, while 1 stacked more tightly than 2R and 3. In contrast, 2S gave a relatively disordered (twisted) structure. The calculated dodecameric structures could explain the visible spectral data of 1-3 in nonpolar organic media.

The effects of epimerization at the 3(1)-position of bacteriochlorophylls c on their aggregation in chlorosomes of green sulfur bacteria. Control of the ratio of 3(1) epimers by light intensity

R- and S-epimerization at the 3(1) position of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) c and the formation of rod-like aggregates in chlorosomes of green sulfur bacteria were markedly affected in Chlorobium (Cb.) tepidum and Cb. limicola by cultivation under various light intensities (photon fluence rate). The stronger the light, the higher the ratio of the S-epimer to the R-epimer for each homolog of BChl c in the bacteria. S[P,E] BChl cF and S[I,E] BChl cF were found to be the major S-epimers in Cb. tepidum and Cb. limicola, respectively. R[P,E] BChl cF decreased markedly compared to R[E,E] BChl cF in Cb. tepidum, whereas no observable change in the ratio of R[P,E]/R[E,E] was detected for Cb. limicola. With increase in light intensity the Qy absorption maximum of the bacteria shifted to shorter wavelengths. In vitro spectroscopic studies of the aggregates showed a marked difference in the formation of aggregates from R- and S-epimers of BChl c; the S-epimers formed aggregates much more slowly than did the R-epimers. These results suggest that the ratio of the epimers of BChl c might significantly affect the aggregation of BChl in the chlorosome. We propose different roles for the R- and S-epimers in chlorosomes of Cb. limicola and Cb. tepidum.

Fast energy transfer between BChl d and BChl c in chlorosomes of the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium limicola

We have studied energy transfer in chlorosomes of Chlorobium limicola UdG6040 containing a mixture of about 50% bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) c and BChl d each. BChl d-depleted chlorosomes were obtained by acid treatment. The energy transfer between the different pigment pools was studied using both steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy at room temperature and low temperature. The steady-state emission of the intact chlorosome originated mainly from BChl c, as judged by comparison of fluorescence emission spectra of intact and BChl d-depleted chlorosomes. This indicated that efficient energy transfer from BChl d to BChl c takes place. At room temperature BChl c/d to BChl a excitation energy transfer (EET) was characterized by two components of 27 and 74 ps. At low temperature we could also observe EET from BChl d to BChl c with a time constant of approximately 4 ps. Kinetic modeling of the low temperature data indicated heterogeneous fluorescence kinetics and suggested the presence of an additional BChl c pool, E790, which is more or less decoupled from the baseplate BChl a. This E790 pool is either a low-lying exciton state of BChl c which acts as a trap at low temperature or alternatively represents the red edge of a broad inhomogeneous absorption band of BChl c. We present a refined model for the organization of the spatially separated pigment pools in chlorosomes of Cb. limicola UdG6040 in which BChl d is situated distal and BChl c proximal with respect to the baseplate.

The influence of the presence of lipid on the aggregation of 8,12-diethyl farnesyl bacteriochlorophyll c located in adsorbed layers and monolayers

The photoacoustic spectra and time-resolved delayed luminescence spectra in the microsecond time range were measured for layers of 8,12-diethyl farnesyl bacteriochlorophyll c adsorbed on quartz supports by solvent evaporation and as Langmuir-Blodgett monolayers. Both types of model system were also investigated with the addition of lipid. The data showed a very strong influence of lipid addition on pigment aggregation. In samples with synthetic and natural lipid addition, the pigments were found to be predominantly in the monomeric and dimeric states, whereas in the same type of sample without lipid, the pigments were aggregated to a higher degree. The influence of the presence of lipid on the aggregation of bacteriochlorophyll c in monolayers and adsorbed layers may also suggest that the contact of various pigment molecules with the lipids surrounding the chlorosome may influence the formation of various pigment aggregates in vivo. The synthetic lipid L-alpha-phosphatidylcholine dipalmitoyl and the natural lipid L-alpha-phosphatidylcholine type IVS from soy beans were used. In the latter case, only adsorbed layers were investigated. Our interpretation is preliminary as only one 8,12-diethyl farnesyl bacteriochlorophyll c homologue was present in our systems.