Systematic review: role of health promotion in vascular dementia

Exploring what progress is being made in the development of health promotion material for vascular dementia: A systematic review of the evidence

A systematic review conducted by Price and Keady (Journal of Nursing and Healthcare of Chronic Illness, 2, 88 and 2010) demonstrated that there was a dearth of health-promoting literature available for people diagnosed with vascular dementia. The correlation between health behavior and the onset of cardiovascular change that can lead to vascular dementia had demonstrated a need for health education and health-promoting information to be made accessible to vulnerable populations to ameliorate the risk of cognitive decline because of cardiovascular disease. Dementia is a progressive and life-limiting condition and with limited treatment options and a lack of progress in identifying a way to delay onset or even cure the condition. Focus must be targeted towards risk reduction strategies that serve to reduce onset and decline and limit the global burden on not only the individual with the condition and their carers but also to the health and social care economy. To identify the progress that has been made in developing health-promoting literature and patient education guidance since 2010 a systematic literature review was undertaken. Using thematic analysis, CINAHL, MEDLINE, and psych INFO databases were accessed and following PRISMA guidelines an inclusion and exclusion criteria was developed in order to locate peer-reviewed articles. Titles and abstracts were reviewed to identify a match with key terms, and from 133 screened abstracts eight studies met the inclusion requirements. From the eight studies, thematic analysis was implemented to identify shared understanding of experiences relating to health promotion in vascular dementia. The methodology for the study was replicated from the authors' previous systematic review in 2010. Five key themes were identified in the literature (Healthy heart healthy brain; Risk factors; Risk reduction/modification; Interventions; Absence of targeted health promotion). From what little evidence was available to review the thematic analysis has demonstrated developments in knowledge into the link between the onset of cognitive impairment and vascular dementia because of compromised cardiovascular health. Modifying health behavior has become essential in ameliorating the risk of vascular cognitive decline. With these developments the synthesis of the literature demonstrates that even with these insights there continues to be a lack of targeted material that individuals can access to understand the link between cardiovascular health and cognitive decline. It is recognized that maximizing cardiovascular health has the potential to lessen the risk of vascular cognitive impairment and vascular dementia developing and progressing yet targeted health promoting material remains lacking. With the developments in understanding the causal links between poor cardiovascular health, vascular cognitive impairment, and vascular dementia progress now needs to be made in developing targeted health promotion material for individuals to access to share this knowledge to reduce the potential onset and subsequent burden of dementia.

Introducing the bio-psycho-social-physical model of dementia through a collective case study design

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES

To provide evidence for the development of a physical domain attached to the well-known bio-psycho-social model of dementia. The objectives were to develop a set of international case studies that followed a trajectory approach, from prevention to end-of-life care.

BACKGROUND

In the UK the bio-psycho-social model has informed the shape of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence and the Social Care Institute for Excellence 'dementia' guideline. However, limited attention has been paid to outlining and describing a physical domain of dementia, a discrepancy that informed the rationale for this study.

DESIGN

A collective case study design was used to address the research aim and objectives.

METHODS

Case studies from along the trajectory of dementia were provided by an international team of contributors from an inter-disciplinary background comprising nursing (general and mental health), social work and social science.

RESULTS

The team's synthesis and analysis of the six case studies generated five repeating themes with each theme becoming components of a 'physical' domain of dementia. The five identified physical components were: (1) physical well-being, (2) physical health and examination, (3) physical care, (4) physical treatment and (5) physical environment.

CONCLUSIONS

The development of a bio-psycho-social-physical model of dementia presents a holistic and culturally sensitive approach to understanding the experience of living with dementia, and to providing care and support in a variety of situations and contexts.

RELEVANCE TO CLINICAL PRACTICE

The physical domain of dementia has particular relevance to nursing and nursing practice, such as providing physical care at the end-of-life. The interplay between the biological-psychological-social-physical domains of dementia and the trajectory of dementia could form the basis of clinical decision-making and practice.

Neighbourhoods and dementia in the health and social care context: a realist review of the literature and implications for UK policy development

The National Dementia Strategy in England has performed an essential role in transforming health and social care services and improving the commissioning architecture. However, to date, little attention has been paid to understanding the ways in which the outdoor and built environment impacts and intersects with the lives of people with dementia and their carers. One way of better understanding the outdoor and built environment is through a focus on the ‘neighbourhood’ as this is an area of public policy where attempts are being made across disciplines to unpack its meanings, significance and identity. This paper adopts a realist review method to detail the key findings and messages from the body of work that links the experience of living with dementia to the neighbourhood. Our findings from this review are assimilated and defined/presented under three headings, namely: outdoor spaces, built environment, and everyday technologies. These headings and our definitions are not discrete properties and there is some overlap in content. We found no research that sets out to enquire about how people with dementia might define their neighbourhood or that explores everyday neighbourhood practices for those living with the condition. Emerging concepts such as citizenship and, in the UK, the Coalition Government advancement of the ‘Big Society’, promote a vision of civic responsibilities and networked, dementia-capable communities, but evaluation of such initiatives are virtually absent from the literature. The review did uncover some interesting and innovative research methods that extend neighbourhood working, such as the ‘walking interview’. In order to develop a neighbourhood model for dementia, future research should examine the relationship and interaction between the neighbourhood as a social space and as a physical space alongside the active role of people with dementia as ‘place-makers’.