Spatial characteristics of the oscillatory potentials of the electroretinogram

Compartmental Differences in Macular Retinal Ganglion Cell Function

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to investigate local differences of macular retinal ganglion cell (RGC) function by means of the steady-state pattern electroretinogram (SS-PERG).

Methods

SS-PERGs were recorded in healthy subjects (n = 43) in response to gratings (1.6 c/deg, 15.63 reversals/s, and 98% contrast) presented on an LED display (800 cd/m², 12.5 degrees eccentricity at 30 cm viewing distance) partitioned in triangular sectors (inferior [I]; nasal [N]; superior [S]; and temporal [T]) or concentric regions (central [C] and annulus [A]). For each partition, response amplitude (nV), amplitude adaptation (% change over recording time), phase/latency (deg/ms), and oscillatory potentials (OPs) amplitude (root mean square [RMS] nV) were measured. Data were analyzed with Generalized Estimating Equation (GEE) statistics.

Results

Amplitude differed (P < 0.001) between sectors (I: 254 nV; N: 328 nV; S: 275 nV; T: 264 nV; and N>T, I) as well as concentrically (C: 684 nV; A: 323 nV; and C>A). Latency did not differ between sectors (range = 53–54 ms, P = 0.45) or concentrically (range = 51–51 ms, P = 0.7). Adaptation did not differ (P = 0.66) concentrically (C: −19% and A: −22%) but differed (P = 0.004) between sectors (I: +25% and S: −29%). The OP amplitude did not differ (P = 0.5) between sectors (range = 63–73 nV) as well as concentrically (range = 82–90 nV, P = 0.3).

Conclusions

Amplitude profiles paralleled RGC densities from histological studies. Adaptation profile suggested greater autoregulatory challenge in the inferior retina. Latency profile may reflect axonal conduction time to the optic nerve head assuming a direct relationship between axon length and its size/velocity. Location-independent OPs may reflect preganglionic activity.

Translational Relevance

Normal macular RGC function displays local differences that may be related to local vulnerability in optic nerve disorders.

Retino-cortical stimulus frequency-dependent gamma coupling: evidence and functional implications of oscillatory potentials

Long‐range gamma band EEG oscillations mediate information transmission between distant brain regions. Gamma band‐based coupling may not be restricted to cortex‐to‐cortex communication but may include extracortical parts of the visual system. The retinogram and visual event‐related evoked potentials exhibit time‐locked, forward propagating oscillations that are candidates of gamma oscillatory coupling between the retina and the visual cortex. In this study, we tested if this gamma coupling is present as indicated by the coherence of gamma‐range (70–200 Hz) oscillatory potentials (OPs) recorded simultaneously from the retina and the primary visual cortex in freely moving, adult rats. We found significant retino‐cortical OP coherence in a wide range of stimulus duration (0.01–1000 msec), stimulus intensity (800–5000 mcd/mm²), interstimulus interval (10–400 msec), and stimulus frequency (0.25–25 Hz). However, at low stimulus frequencies, the OPs were time‐locked, flickering light at 25 Hz entrained continuous OP coherence (steady‐state response, SSR). Our results suggest that the retina and the visual cortex exhibit oscillatory coupling at high‐gamma frequency with precise time locking and synchronization of information transfer from the retina to the visual cortex, similar to cortico‐cortical gamma coupling. The temporal fusion of retino‐cortical gamma coherence at stimulus rates of theater movies may explain the mechanism of the visual illusion of continuity. How visual perception depends on early transformations of ascending sensory information is incompletely understood. By simultaneous measurement of flash‐evoked potentials in the retina and the visual cortex in awake, freely moving rats, we demonstrate for the first time that time‐locked gamma oscillatory potentials exhibit stable retino‐cortical synchrony across a wide range of stimulus parameters and that the temporal continuity of coherence changes with stimulus frequency according to the expected change in the visual illusion of continuity.

Oscillatory potentials in the retina: what do they reveal

This chapter is an overview of current knowledge on the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the retina. The first section describes the characteristics of the OPs. The basic, adaptational, pharmacological and developmental characteristics of the OPs are different from the a- and b-waves, the major components of the electroretinogram (ERG). The OPs are most easily recorded in mesopic adaptational conditions and reflect rapid changes of adaptation. They represent photopic and scotopic processes, probably an interaction between cone and rod activity in the retina. The OPs are sensitive to disruption of inhibitory (dopamine, GABA-, and glycine-mediated) neuronal pathways and are not selectively affected by excitatory amino acids. The earlier OPs are associated with the on-components and the late OPs with the off-components in response to a brief stimulus of light. The postnatal appearance of the first oscillatory activity is preceded by the a- and b-waves. The earlier OPs appear postnatally prior to, and mature differently from, the later ones. The second section deals with present views on the origin of the OPs. These views are developed from experimental studies with the vertebrate retina including the primate retina and clinical studies. Findings favor the conclusion that the OPs reflect neuronal synaptic activity in inhibitory feedback pathways initiated by the amacrines in the inner retina. The bipolar (or the interplexiform) cells are the probable generators of the OPs. Dopaminergic neurons, probably amacrines (or interplexiform cells), are involved in the generation of the OPs. The earlier OPs are generated in neurons related to the on-pathway of the retina and the later ones to the off-channel system. Peptidergic neurons may be indirectly involved as modulators. The individual OPs seem to represent the activation of several retinal generators. The earlier OPs are more dependent on an intact rod function and the later ones on an intact cone system. Thus, the OPs are good indicators of neuronal adaptive mechanisms in the retina and are probably the only post-synaptic neuronal components that can be recorded in the ERG except when structured stimuli are used. The last section describes the usefulness of the oscillatory response as an instrument to study the postnatal development of neuronal adaptation of the retina. In this section clinical examples of of the sensitivity of the OPs for revealing early disturbance in neuronal function in different retinal diseases such as pediatric, vascular and degenerative retinopathies are also given.

Electrical responses from diabetic retina

Diabetic retinopathy has long been considered to be a retinal manifestation of systemic diabetic angiopathy. Indeed, it is therapeutically true. However, the prolongation of OP peak latency in diabetic eyes without any angiographic evidence of angiopathy leads us to presume that certain neuronal disorders occur early in diabetic eyes. Even though we cannot neglect the possibility that the prolongation of the OP peak latency may derive from undetectable retinal hypoperfusion, it is still far from conventional diabetic angiopathy. Rather, the status should be properly termed "intraretinal diabetic neuropathy" in that the neurones are the disturbed cells to cause visual dysfunction. Thereafter, the OP amplitude diminishes as retinopathy advances, probably depending on the degree of retinal circulatory disturbance. Marked diminution of the OP amplitude predicts rapid progression and poor prognosis of retinopathy. Diabetic retinal pigment epitheliopathy as manifested by one of our non-photic EOG responses is another kind of early ocular involvement of diabetes. Because its mechanisms are not yet known, so far we have not succeeded in correlating it to any kind of subjective visual index. Routine fundus inspection or fluorescent fundus angiography is incapable of detecting the compromised neural retina and/or retinal pigment epithelial integrity and thus the electrophysiology of vision has the edge in ophthalmology.

Effect of kainic acid and NMDA on the pattern electroretinogram, the scotopic threshold response, the oscillatory potentials and the electroretinogram in the urethane anaesthetized cat

Kainic acid (KA, 12.5-100 nmol) or N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA 25-250 nmol) was injected into the vitreous of one eye of urethane anaesthetized cats. Pattern electroretinograms (PERGs) were recorded to transient contrast reversing bars. Scotopic luminance electroretinograms (ERGs) were recorded to blue flashes. All doses of KA reduced the oscillatory potentials (OPs), PERG and focal ERG (FERG). At 50 nmol KA, the b-wave and scoptic threshold response (STR) were normal. At 100 nmol KA, the STR was absent and the b-wave reduced by over 50%. OPs and STRs were reduced in all NMDA injected eyes. NMDA at 25 nmol enhanced the FERG, PERG, and b-wave and high doses (above 150 nmol) reduced them. Light microscopic examination of retinas showed 25 nmol KA only damaged dendrites of ganglion cells. NMDA damage was slight with < 200 nmol. These data show that the cat PERG has a proximal component which is very sensitive to low doses of KA; the PERG and FERG are very similar; the STR and PERG are generated by different structures and that the OPs and the FERG and PERG are all generated close to the ganglion cell layer, proximal to the STR.

Retinal oscillatory potential abnormalities in patients with chronic renal failure, before and after dialytic treatment

Nineteen patients with chronic renal failure were studied, oscillatory potentials (OPs) being recorded shortly before and after dialytic treatment. Mean values of either onset latency (O1 latency) and duration of the complex (O1-N4 inter-peak latency) were found to be significantly longer in patients than in controls (p < 0.001). Most of the patients (12) showed a pathological prolongation of latency (> 2.5 SD). Amplitude changes also affected OPs, but earlier components were reduced to a lesser degree than the later ones, as shown by statistical analysis. Moreover, seven patients showed an almost complete loss of O3 and O4 peaks. Latency changes may be transiently reversed by dialysis, suggesting a functional impairment of the retinal response; the loss of later components is a more persistent abnormality probably related with a structural damage.

Temporal relationship between ERG components and geniculate unit activity in rabbit

The purpose of this study was to examine if there is an ERG component (alpha-wave, b-wave, oscillatory potentials) which can be used to account for the intraretinal processing time. To address this issue, ERGs and LGN unit responses were recorded simultaneously from anesthetized and paralyzed rabbits. A gradual decrease in the intensity of the light stimulus yields a progressive increase in the latency of the LGN unit response. A similar, highly correlated (r = 0.91 +/- 013), latency shift was also noted for one oscillatory potential (OP2). In comparison, correlation coefficients of r = 0.63 +/- 0.27 and r = 0.70 +/- 0.29 were obtained for the alpha- and b-wave respectively. Furthermore, in 77.6% of the cells examined, OP2 preceded LGN unit activity while the b-wave preceded LGN activity in only 17.8% of the cases. Our results suggest that, of all the retinal potentials considered, the peak time of OP2 better reflects the primary visual processes and the intraretinal time taken for visual processing.

Spatial summation and visual adaptation in the inner part of the frog retina

The spatial summation of the proximal negative response (PNR) of frog retina was analyzed during different states of adaptation induced by repetitive light stimulation with either 15 sec or 1 min interstimulus interval. The spatial summation area of the PNR was found to be wider during relatively more dark adapted conditions compared to relatively more light adapted ones. This finding indicates that lateral mechanisms in the inner network of the retina seem to be activated by adapting stimuli. Secondly, the results suggest that the activity of the amacrines, as reflected by the PNR, may initiate the series of neuronal events which underlie the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the electroretinogram (ERG).

Spatial properties of the oscillatory potentials of the frog electroretinogram in relation to state of adaptation

The spatial characteristics of the oscillatory potentials (OPs) and the a- and b-waves of the frog electroretinogram (ERG) were studied during different states of adaptation induced by repetitive light stimulus given at 1 min or 15 sec interval. The spatial integration area of the OPs was found to be reduced during relatively more light-adapted conditions compared to relatively more dark-adapted ones. No major adaptive effect on the spatial summation area of the a- and b-waves observed. The results indicate that the spatial changes of the OPs observed may be signalled by the amacrine cells which would thus be indirectly involved in the generation of the OPs. The spatial properties of the OPs differed from that of the a- and b-waves suggesting that the OPs have a different origin to that of the a- and b-waves. Finally, the present data indicate a clear and sensitive spatial organization in the frog ERG.