To biopsy or not to biopsy?

Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy of Intraocular Mass-Like Lesions

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic performance of fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy for intraocular mass-like lesions and its contributing factors.

METHODS

Intraocular FNA cases were retrieved and reviewed along with histopathologic follow-ups, if available. The effects of rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE), repeated biopsy, and adjunct immunocytochemical studies on cytologic diagnoses were analyzed.

RESULTS

Of 72 FNA biopsies from 63 patients, nondiagnostic biopsy was seen in 17 cases (24%), whereas a definitive diagnosis was rendered in 39 cases (54%). The cytologic diagnoses correlated well with histopathologic follow-ups with a concordance rate of 61%. Almost all nondiagnostic biopsies (16/17, 94%) were seen in cases in which ROSE was not performed. Of the 7 patients in whom biopsy was repeated, a definitive diagnosis was rendered in 4 cases (57%). Immunocytochemistry was performed in the majority of cases with a malignant diagnosis, especially in metastatic tumors (75%).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data demonstrates that FNA is an effective tool for the diagnosis of intraocular tumors. ROSE, repeated biopsy, and adjunct immunocytochemistry can help reduce the nondiagnostic rate and/or enhance diagnosis of malignancy, further improving FNA diagnostic performance.

Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy in Uveal Melanoma: Technique, Complications, and Outcomes

PURPOSE

To report the technical aspects, complications, and outcomes concerning fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in uveal melanoma.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

METHODS

Patients with uveal melanoma who underwent transscleral or transvitreal FNAB at an ocular oncology center were retrospectively evaluated. FNAB was performed if the tumor was more than 5 mm in thickness. Array comparative genomic hybridization analysis was performed on biopsy samples with sufficient tissue. The main outcome measures were success (sample that gave a successful result for biomarker analysis) rate, complications, liver metastasis, and overall survival.

RESULTS

There were 217 (114 male, 52%) consecutive study patients with a mean age of 56.7 (16-84) years. The mean follow-up period was 31 (range 3.6-61.3) months. Mean tumor thickness was 8.4 (range 5-12) mm. The overall success rate of the procedure was 169 patients (77.9%). Thirty-one patients (14.3%) experienced intravitreal hemorrhage, of whom 9 (4.1%) required vitreal surgery. There was no case of endophthalmitis, orbital dissemination, local recurrence, or rhegmatogenous retinal detachment. Thirty-two patients (14.7%) developed metastasis during the study, of whom 20 (9.2%) died. Of the 169 successful samples, 53 patients (31%) were classified as low risk, 41 (24%) as intermediate risk, and 54 (32%) as high risk. Fifteen patients (9%) did not have any detectable chromosomal abnormality and 6 (4%) could not be classified.

CONCLUSION

FNAB is a relatively safe and successful technique that can be routinely used to obtain tissue for molecular genomic analysis; such analysis helps determine the diagnosis and prognosis in uveal melanoma.

[Value of transretinal tumor biopsy as diagnostic and predictive instrument]

Transretinal biopsy of intraocular tumors plays a decisive role as a diagnostic tool in ocular oncology. A biopsy is indicated to confirm a clinical diagnosis before treatment and allows identification of high risk melanomas of the uvea with a high potential of metastasis by molecular genetic evaluation of the specimen. This review will focus on the various biopsy techniques and indications for this method.

Fine needle aspiration biopsy of ophthalmic tumors

A majority of intraocular tumors can be diagnosed based on clinical examination and ocular imaging studies, which obviate the need for diagnostic ophthalmic fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB). Overall, diagnostic accuracy of ophthalmic FNAB is high but limited cellularity can compromise the diagnostic potential of ophthalmic aspirate samples. The role of ophthalmic FNAB is limited in retinal tumors. Orbital FNAB should be considered in the evaluation of lacrimal gland tumors, orbital metastasis, and lymphoproliferative lesions. Negative cytologic diagnosis of malignancy should not be considered unequivocal proof that an intraocular malignancy does not exist. With improved understanding of genetic prognostic factors of uveal melanoma, ophthalmic FNAB is gaining popularity for prognostic purposes in combination with eye conserving treatment of the primary tumor. In special clinical indications, ancillary studies such as immunohistochemistry and FISH can be performed on ophthalmic FNAB samples. Assistance of an experienced cytopathologist cannot be overemphasized.

Transretinal uveal melanoma biopsy with 25-gauge vitrectomy system

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficacy and the safety of uveal melanoma transretinal biopsy using 25-gauge vitrectomy system.

METHODS

At the patient's request of a tissue diagnosis, nine posterior uveal melanomas treated by proton-beam therapy were biopsied during the insertion of tantalium markers.

RESULTS

The diagnosis was uveal melanoma, confirmed in all cases using cytological (7 of 9) and histological analysis (2 of 9). Immunocytochemistry was performed on all samples (9 of 9). In eight of nine patients, minor postoperative vitreous haemorrhages were seen, which resolved in 1 day. No other ocular complications were noticed.

CONCLUSION

Uveal melanoma biopsy using 25-gauge vitrectomy system is a valuable procedure to confirm the diagnosis, with adequate sample and low ocular morbidity.

Diagnostic incisional biopsies in clinically indeterminate choroidal tumours

Most intraocular tumours are reliably diagnosed by a careful clinical examination combined with one or more non-invasive diagnostic techniques. However, in a small percentage of tumours, typically small and clinically amelanotic, the features are insufficiently distinct for a confident clinical diagnosis and tissue is required for diagnosis. We used a 23-G vitreous cutter to access the biopsy site in 43 patients with clinically indeterminate tumours. After retinotomy, an incisional choroidal biopsy yielded a specimen of ∼1 mm(3). Obtained tissue was routinely processed for light microscopy including an immunohistochemical panel of monoclonal antibodies. Adequate tissue for diagnosis was provided in 41/43 (95%) patients. The sensitivity and specificity to detect malignant disease were 0.97 and 1.00, respectively. The positive predictive value was 1.00. Complications included progression of pre-existing retinal detachment in 5/43 (12%) patients and transient rise in intraocular pressure to >40 mm Hg in 6/43 (14%) patients; 4 of these 6 patients had a pre-existing retinal detachment. No patient with a pre-operatively attached retina had a retinal detachment. We conclude that an incisional transretinal choroidal biopsy yields abundant material and may adequately confirm or exclude malignancy in patients with clinically indeterminate tumours. The complication rate can be minimised when patients with pre-existing retinal detachment are excluded from biopsy.

Minimally invasive anterior orbitotomy biopsy: finger's aspiration cutter technique (FACT)

PURPOSE

To evaluate aspiration cutter-assisted small-incision anterior orbitotomy.

METHODS

Three patients with orbital adnexal tumors underwent orbital biopsy through a 3-mm incision in the eyelid skin (n = 2) or conjunctival fornix (n = 1). Standard aspiration cutters were introduced into anterior and posterior orbital tumors utilizing a bimanual technique. Multiple passes were made into the tumor. Fresh specimens were analyzed for adequacy prior to the end of surgery. Cytopathology, histopathology, and immunohistochemical analysis were performed.

RESULTS

Aspiration cutter technique biopsies were diagnostic in 2 of 3 cases. Diagnoses were orbital lymphoma, metastatic endometrial adenocarcinoma, and metastatic prostate cancer. The 20-G aspiration cutter yielded the most tissue. No sutures were required for the small incisions.

CONCLUSIONS

Sutureless, aspiration cutter biopsy offered benefits commonly associated with fine needle aspiration biopsy, controlled aspiration, and enclosed mechanical cutting.

Anterior segment tumor biopsy using an aspiration cutter technique: clinical experience

PURPOSE

To report the results and complications of an aspiration cutter-assisted anterior segment tumor biopsy performed under viscoelastic.

DESIGN

Retrospective, consecutive, interventional case series.

METHODS

Fifty-five patients with anterior segment tumors underwent aspiration cutter-assisted biopsy at a single center. Fifty-six biopsies were performed, because 1 eye underwent biopsy twice. Indications for biopsy included: suspected anterior segment malignancy, patient's desire for pathologic confirmation before treatment, atypical tumor, and genetic tumor analysis. The main evaluated outcomes were the perioperative visual acuity, the biopsy technique, and related complications.

RESULTS

The initial sample comprised 55 consecutively biopsied patients, from which a minimum 1-month follow-up existed for 52 biopsy samples. The median total follow-up was 30.4 months (range, 1 to 190 months). The mean initial visual acuity was 20/50 before and 20/50 1 month after biopsy. No patient lost vision. Most cases were suspected iris melanoma (n = 39/56; 69.6%), followed by suspicious iris nevi (n = 4/56; 7.1%) and melanocytoma (n = 4/56; 7.1%). Seven (n = 7/52; 13.4%) wounds required a single 10-0 nylon suture to achieve negative Seidel test results at the corneal entry site. Postoperative surgical findings included transiently increased intraocular pressure (n = 6/52; 11.5%), 1 hyphema, 1 flare, and 1 persistent pupillary defect. All but the pupillary defect resolved within 4 weeks of the biopsy procedure. There were no secondary infections or cataracts.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that small-incision, aspiration cutter-assisted anterior segment biopsy seems to be a safe and effective procedure. No short- or long-term complications that would prevent its use were noted.