In vitro mechanical properties of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon in horses in relation to age

Desmitis of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon in the forelimb: A retrospective case study of 91 horses

BACKGROUND

Desmitis of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon (ALDDFT) is a commonly reported injury. Despite the commonality of this injury, the literature is limited to small case series, with the reported success following treatment varying from 18% to 75%.

OBJECTIVES

To identify the prognosis and factors associated with a return to work following ALDDFT injury.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

METHODS

Medical records of horses from four equine hospitals (January 2000 and December 2018) with a diagnosis of desmitis of ALDDFT were reviewed. Data retrieved included case detail, use, history, lameness treatment and follow-up. Success was defined as returning to work. Backward stepwise logistic regression was used to identify variables significantly associated with return to work.

RESULTS

Ninety-one horses were included. The mean age was 13.5 years (standard deviation 4.9 years). Thirty-four percent (28/91) of horses were sound at the initial presentation. Sixty-eight percent (62/91) of horses were managed using controlled exercise alone, 28% (29/91) were treated with intra-lesional injection, therapeutic ultrasound, extracorporeal shockwave therapy or desmectomy of the ALDDFT and 3% (3/91) were euthanased without treatment. Sixty-four percent (54/85) of horses returned to work. Horses that were lame at follow-up were less likely to return to work (odds ratio [OR] 107.93, 95% confidence interval [CI] 20.06-580.61, p < 0.001) than those that returned to soundness. Identification of adhesions on ultrasonography was also associated with having reduced odds for return to work when compared to horses without adhesions (OR 0.10, 95% CI 0.01-0.76, p = 0.03).

MAIN LIMITATIONS

Retrospective nature of the study, the potential of selection bias with regards to follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Sixty-four percent (54/85) of horses returned to work following injury of the ALDDFT. Persistence of lameness and adhesion formation were significantly associated with a poor outcome.

Mechanical properties of animal ligaments: a review and comparative study for the identification of the most suitable human ligament surrogates

The interest in the properties of animal soft tissues is often related to the desire to find an animal model to replace human counterparts due to the unsteady availability of human tissues for experimental purposes. Once the most appropriate animal model is identified, it is possible to carry out ex-vivo and in-vivo studies for the repair of ligamentous tissues and performance testing of replacement and support healing devices. This work aims to present a systematic review of the mechanical properties of ligaments reported in the scientific literature by considering different anatomical regions in humans and several animal species. This study was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) method. Moreover, considering the lack of a standard protocol for preconditioning of tissues, this aspect is also addressed. Ninety-six studies were selected for the systematic review and analysed. The mechanical properties of different animal species are reported and summarised in tables. Only results from studies reporting the strain rate parameter were considered for comparison with human ligaments, as they were deemed more reliable. Elastic modulus, ultimate tensile stress, and ultimate strain properties are graphically reported identifying the range of values for each animal species and to facilitate comparison between values reported in the scientific literature in animal and human ligaments. Useful similarities between the mechanical properties of swine, cow, and rat and human ligaments have been found.

An equine tendon model for studying intra-tendinous shear in tendons that have more than one muscle contribution

Human Achilles tendon is composed of three smaller sub-tendons and exhibits non-uniform internal displacements, which decline with age and after injury, suggesting a potential role in the development of tendinopathies. Studying internal sliding behaviour is therefore important but difficult in human Achilles tendon. Here we propose the equine deep digital flexor tendon (DDFT) and its accessory ligament (AL) as a model to understand the sliding mechanism. The AL-DDFT has a comparable sub-bundle structure, is subjected to high and frequent asymmetric loads and is a natural site of injury similar to human Achilles tendons. Equine AL-DDFT were collected and underwent whole tendon level (n=7) and fascicle level (n=7) quasi-static mechanical testing. Whole tendon level testing was performed by sequentially loading through the proximal AL and subsequently through the proximal DDFT and recording regional strain in the free structures and joined DDFT and AL. Fascicle level testing was performed with focus on the inter-sub-bundle matrix between the two structures at the junction. Our results demonstrate a significant difference in the regional strain between the joined DDFT and AL and a greater transmission of force from the AL to the DDFT than vice versa. These results can be partially explained by the mechanical properties and geometry of the two structures and by differences in the properties of the interfascicular matrices. In conclusion, this tendon model successfully demonstrates that high displacement discrepancy occurs between the two structures and can be used as an easy-access model for studying intra-tendinous shear mechanics at the sub-tendon level. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Our study provides a naturally occurring and easily accessible equine model to study the complex behaviour of sub-tendons within the human Achilles tendon, which is likely to play a critical role in the pathogenesis of tendon disease. Our results demonstrate that the difference in material stiffness between the equine AL and DDFT stems largely from differences in the inter-fascicular matrix and furthermore that differences in strain are maintained in distal parts of the tightly joined structure. Furthermore, our results suggest that distribution of load between sub-structures is highly dependent on the morphological relationship between them; a finding that has important implications for understanding Achilles tendon mechanical behaviour, injury mechanisms and rehabilitation.

Revolving doors of tendinopathy: definition, pathogenesis and treatment

The ultimate cure for the tendon pathology continues to elude current science. Despite great steps in technology, the causation and treatment is still not clear. The number of different theories and treatment modalities in the literature may confuse clinicians and patients. In this paper we outline the definitions, evolution of pathogenesis and treatment for tendinopathy. By highlighting these, the aim of this paper is to guide the practitioner in counselling and treating their patients.

Age-related differences in trunk intrinsic stiffness

Age-related differences in trunk intrinsic stiffness, as an important potential contributor to spinal stability, were investigated here because of: (1) the role of spinal instability in low back pain (LBP) development; (2) the increasing prevalence of LBP with age, and (3) the increasing population of older people in the workforce. Sixty individuals aged 20-70 years, in five equal-size age groups, completed a series of displacement-controlled perturbation tests in an upright standing posture while holding four different levels of trunk extension efforts. In addition to examining any age-related difference in trunk intrinsic stiffness, the current design assessed the effects of gender, level of effort, and any differences in lower back neuromuscular patterns on trunk intrinsic stiffness. No significant differences in trunk intrinsic stiffness were found between the age groups. However, stiffness was significantly larger among males and increased with the level of extension effort. No influences of differences in neuromuscular pattern were observed. Since the passive contribution of trunk tissues in the upright standing posture is minimal, our values of estimated trunk intrinsic stiffness primarily represent the volitional contribution of the lower back musculoskeletal system to spinal stability. Therefore, it seems unlikely that the alterations in volitional behavior of the lower back musculature, caused by aging (e.g., as reflected in reduced strength), diminish their contributions to the spinal stability.

Evaluation of the material properties of the subsynovial connective tissue in carpal tunnel syndrome

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine the material properties of the normal carpal tunnel subsynovial connective tissue in response to shear stress.

METHODS

The shear modulus and maximum shear strength were measured with a custom-made micro-tester in 10 specimens of subsynovial connective tissue from 10 wrists in eight patients with idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome and in 10 specimens from five fresh frozen cadavers without a history of carpal tunnel syndrome.

FINDINGS

The mean shear modulus was 22.8 (SD 15.4)kPa for the patient group and 2.7 (SD 1.8)kPa for the control group. The mean maximum shear strength was 54.6 (SD 20.3)kPa for the patient group and 23.3 (SD 10.7)kPa for the control group. The values for the patient group were significantly higher than the control group (P<0.05).

INTERPRETATION

The material properties of subsynovial connective tissue are altered in patients with idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome. The impact, if any, of these altered properties on carpal tunnel syndrome remains to be elucidated.

Two clinical manifestations of desmopathy of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon in the hindlimb of 23 horses

REASONS FOR PERFORMING STUDY

Desmopathy of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon (ALDDFT) in the hindlimb is an unusual cause of lameness in horses, and reports of the condition are sparse.

OBJECTIVES

To describe the clinical and ultrasonographic findings, therapy and outcome of 23 horses treated for desmopathy of the ALDDFT in the hindlimb.

METHODS

Records of 23 horses with ultrasonographic evidence of desmopathy of the ALDDFT in one or both hindlimbs from 3 referral centres were reviewed retrospectively. Age, breed, sex, duration and nature of clinical signs, results of clinical and lameness examinations, treatment and outcome were recorded.

RESULTS

In 13 horses (Group A), there was an acute onset of unilateral lameness. Ten horses (Group B) had an insidious or sudden onset of postural abnormality. There were 10 cobs, 5 British native-breed ponies and 8 horses of various larger breeds. Twenty horses were used for general purposes, and mean age was 12 years. Enlargement of the ALDDFT in the affected hindlimb(s) was identified in all horses. In 44% of horses, ultrasonographic abnormalities were localised to part of the ALDDFT. Treatment included box-rest and controlled exercise, and 10 horses were subjected to desmotomy or desmectomy of the ALDDFT. Seventy-three percent of horses in Group A returned to full function, while 90% of those in Group B remained lame.

CONCLUSIONS

Two distinct clinical conditions are associated with the ALDDFT of the hindlimb. Traumatically induced injury resulting in acute onset lameness appears to have a favourable prognosis, with most horses returning to previous work. However, postural changes, once present, are irreversible and indicate a poor prognosis.

POTENTIAL RELEVANCE

Desmopathy of the ALDDFT should be recognised as a potential cause of hindlimb lameness and this study provides clinical and prognostic information. Knuckling and/or semiflexion of the metatarsophalangeal joint may accompany the condition; therefore, if a horse is presented with a flexural deformity of this joint, desmopathy of the ALDDFT should be considered as a primary differential diagnosis.

Determination of passive mechanical properties of the superficial and deep digital flexor muscle-ligament-tendon complexes in the forelimbs of horses

OBJECTIVE

To determine the relative contributions of the muscles, tendons, and accessory ligaments to the passive force-length properties of the superficial (SDF) and deep digital flexor (DDF) myotendinous complexes.

SAMPLE POPULATION

8 cadaveric forelimbs from 6 adult Thoroughbreds.

PROCEDURE

In vitro, limb configurations during slack position and myotendinous lengths during subsequent axial loading of forelimbs were recorded before and after transection of accessory ligaments. Expressions were derived to describe the force-length behavior of each muscle, tendon, and accessory ligament-tendon unit; linear stiffness was computed for these components. The elastic modulus was established for the SDF and DDF tendons. RESULTS; Linear stiffness was 2.80 +/- 0.38 kN/cm for the SDF muscle, 3.47 +/- 0.66 kN/cm for the DDF muscle, 2.73 +/- 0.18 kN/cm for the SDF tendon, 3.22 +/- 0.20 kN/cm for the DDF tendon, 6.46 +/- 0.85 kN/cm for the SDF accessory ligament, 1.93 +/- 0.11 kN/cm for the SDF accessory ligament-tendon unit, and 2.47 +/- 0.11 kN/cm for the DDF accessory ligament-tendon unit. The elastic modulus for the SDF and DDF tendons was 920 +/- 77 and 843 +/- 56 MPa, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Both the muscle-tendon and ligament-tendon portions of SDF and DDF myotendinous complexes had important roles in supporting the forelimb of horses. Although muscle tension can be enhanced by elbow joint flexion and active contraction, the accessory ligaments transmitted more force to the distal tendons than did the muscles under the conditions tested.

Oblique scaling: an algorithm to correct for a non-perpendicular camera view in tendon strain measurements

Image distortion due to a non-perpendicular camera view introduces serious errors in tendon and ligament strain measurements when data are recorded using a single camera. These errors can be corrected with the oblique scaling algorithm using two pairs of scaling markers attached to the tendon surface. Computer simulations show that application of this algorithm reduces errors over 100 times to less than 0.06%. The method is relatively insensitive to measurement errors in the scaling marker distance but sensitive to the accuracy of alignment of the scaling markers. It can be concluded that the oblique scaling algorithm eliminates the influences of a non-perpendicular camera view in single-camera tendon and ligament strain measurements.

Acquired flexural deformity of the metacarpophalangeal joint in five horses associated with tendonous damage in the palmar metacarpus

Five cases of acquired flexural deformity of the metacarpophalangeal joint (MCPJ) in older horses and ponies were studied. The mean age of affected horses was 14-8 years. Four deformities developed following desmitis of the accessory ligament of the deep digital flexor tendon (ALDDFT) and superficial digital flexor tendon (SDFT) and one following tendonitis of the SDFT alone. All cases were markedly lame and demonstrated variable degrees of flexural deformity. Ultrasonographic examination was performed on all cases which revealed extensive adhesion formation between the ALDDFT and SDFT and reduced cross-sectional area of the deep digital flexor tendon in each case. A variety of treatments were unsuccessfully employed to treat this condition. The prognosis for acquired flexural deformity of the MCPJ in old horses following tendonous damage in the palmar metacarpus is likely to be poor.

Comparison of collagen fibril populations in the superficial digital flexor tendons of exercised and nonexercised thoroughbreds

This study was undertaken to test the hypothesis that collagen fibrils, the submicroscopic units of strength in tendon, would hypertrophy in response to a specific defined training programme. Fibril diameters were measured in central and peripheral regions of superficial digital flexor tendon (SDFT) samples from five 18-month-old horses which underwent a subsequent 18 month training programme and 6 age- and sex-matched controls. Central region fibrils from the trained horses had a mass-average diameter (MAD) of 105.3 nm, which was significantly lower (P < 0.01) than that of 131.7 nm for the same region in the control horses. This reduction in fibril diameter in the region of tendon which is predisposed to injury was interpreted as evidence of microtrauma, as it implies the region is weakened by the training regimen. Repeated episodes of microtrauma may accumulate and eventually result in degenerative lesions and clinical tendonitis.

Age-related differences in collagen crimp patterns in the superficial digital flexor tendon core region of untrained horses

OBJECTIVE

To measure collagen fibril crimp angles and lengths as well as collagen fibril mass-average diameters in central and peripheral regions of the superficial digital flexor tendon of wild horses, to ascertain any age-related changes in either region in the absence of imposed galloping exercise.

DESIGN

Measurements from a random cull of wild horses.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Superficial digital flexor tendon samples were taken from 23 wild horses ranging in age from two to ten years.

PROCEDURE

Horses were divided into 'young' (< 5 years, n = 10), 'middle-aged' (5 to < 10 years, n = 9) and 'old' groups (10+ years, n = 4) and the mean crimp angle, mean crimp length and collagen fibril mass-average diameter calculated for the central region, and for the peripheral region of each group. Differences between groups and regions were analysed using two-tailed t tests.

RESULTS

The crimp angle for the central region was found to decrease with age, so that in old horses it was smaller than that for the tendon periphery (P, 0.05). The crimp angle for the latter region did not alter significantly with age. Crimp period lengths and collagen fibril mass-average diameters did not show significant changes with age in either region.

CONCLUSIONS

Reduction of the crimp angle in the core of the superficial digital flexor tendon occurs normally with age, as tendons of older animals would have undergone a higher number of loading cycles. It is possible that athletic training increases the frequency and/or the magnitude of high loading cycles experienced by the tendon, and may accelerate and worsen the normal load-related ageing process in the superficial digital flexor tendons of young performance horses, particularly in the central regions where lesions usually occur.