Beta-adrenoceptor antagonists and human sperm motility

FDA-approved drugs that are spermatotoxic in animals and the utility of animal testing for human risk prediction

PURPOSE

This study reviews FDA-approved drugs that negatively impact spermatozoa in animals, as well as how these findings reflect on observations in human male gametes.

METHODS

The FDA drug warning labels included in the DailyMed database and the peer-reviewed literature in the PubMed database were searched for information to identify single-ingredient, FDA-approved prescription drugs with spermatotoxic effects.

RESULTS

A total of 235 unique, single-ingredient, FDA-approved drugs reported to be spermatotoxic in animals were identified in the drug labels. Forty-nine of these had documented negative effects on humans in either the drug label or literature, while 31 had no effect or a positive impact on human sperm. For the other 155 drugs that were spermatotoxic in animals, no human data was available.

CONCLUSION

The current animal models are not very effective for predicting human spermatotoxicity, and there is limited information available about the impact of many drugs on human spermatozoa. New approaches should be designed that more accurately reflect the findings in men, including more studies on human sperm in vitro and studies using other systems (ex vivo tissue culture, xenograft models, in silico studies, etc.). In addition, the present data is often incomplete or reported in a manner that prevents interpretation of their clinical relevance. Changes should be made to the requirements for pre-clinical testing, drug surveillance, and the warning labels of drugs to ensure that the potential risks to human fertility are clearly indicated.

Comparative effects of (+)-propranolol and nonoxynol-9 on human sperm motility in-vitro

Using the modified transmembrane migration method to measure sperm motility, it was shown that the surfactant nonoxynol-9 alone, was twice as potent as (+)-propranolol alone as a spermicidal agent. Addition of (+)-propranolol to nonoxynol-9 shifted the dose-response curve to the left of the curves for either component alone, and a surprising synergistic action was evident. These observations may form the basis for the development of a new advantageous topical contraceptive combination product.