Transcriptome responses of Lactococcus paracarnosus to different gas compositions and co-culture with Brochothrix thermosphacta

Lactococcus (Lc.) paracarnosus and the phylogenetically closely related Lc. carnosus species are common members of the microbiota in meat stored under modified atmosphere and at low temperature. The effect of these strains on meat spoilage is controversially discussed. While some strains are known to cause spoilage, others are being studied for their potential to suppress the growth of spoilage and pathogenic bacteria. In this study, Lc. paracarnosus DSM 111017T was selected based on a previous study for its ability to suppress the growth of meat spoilers, including Brochothrix thermosphacta. The mechanism by which this bioprotective strain inhibits competing bacteria and how it contributes to spoilage are not yet known. To answer these two questions, we investigated the effect of four different headspace gas mixtures (simulated air (21 % O2/79 % N2); HiOx-MAP (70 % O2/30 % CO2); nonOx-MAP (70 % N2/ 30 % CO2); simulated vacuum (100 % N2) and the presence of Brochothrix (B.) thermosphacta TMW 2.2101 on the growth and transcriptional response of Lc. paracarnosus DSM 111017T when cultured on a meat simulation agar surface at 4 °C. Analysis of genes specifically upregulated by the gas mixtures used revealed metabolic pathways that may lead to different levels of spoilage metabolites production. We propose that under elevated oxygen levels, Lc. paracarnosus preferentially converts pyruvate from glucose and glycerol to uncharged acetoin/diacetyl instead of lactate to counteract acid stress. Due to the potential production of a buttery off-flavour, the strain may not be suitable as a protective culture in meat packaged under high‑oxygen conditions. 70 % N2/ 30 % CO2, simulated vacuum- and the presence of Lc. paracarnosus inhibited the growth of B. thermosphacta TMW 2.2101. However, B. thermosphacta did not affect gene regulation of metabolic pathways in Lc. paracarnosus, and genes previously predicted to be involved in B. thermosphacta growth suppression were not regulated at the transcriptional level. In conclusion, the study indicates that the gas mixture used in packaging significantly affects the metabolism and spoilage potential of Lc. paracarnosus and its ability to inhibit B. thermosphacta growth.

Changes in extractive components and bacterial flora in live mussels Mytilus galloprovincialis during storage at different temperatures

To estimate the quality of mussels during storage, the mortality, succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) activity, extractive components, viable bacterial count (VBC), and bacterial flora of live mussels were investigated. The hierarchical cluster analysis, based on extractive components and VBC, taste active value (TAV), and equivalent umami concentration (EUC), suggested that metabolite composition, bacterial, and taste changing patterns of samples stored at 5 and 10°C differed from those stored at 0°C. The mortality of mussels stored at 5 and 10°C was lower than those at 0°C. The gills of live mussels stored at 0°C for more than 7 days exhibited significantly lower SDH activity than those stored at 5 and 10°C. There was no significant difference in EUC among the samples stored at different temperatures, but a significantly higher TAV of Ala and succinic acid was observed in live mussels after 12 days of storage at 5 and 10°C than in those stored at 0°C. Next-generation sequencing analysis showed that samples stored at 5 and 10°C lost bacterial diversity, and their bacterial flora changed compared to that before storage. Considering these results, the most suitable storage condition to maintain high quality for live mussels is 5°C for less than 7 days.

Microbial Profiling of Biltong Processing Using Culture-Dependent and Culture-Independent Microbiome Analysis

Biltong is a South African air-dried beef product that does not have a heat lethality step, but rather relies on marinade chemistry (low pH from vinegar, ~2% salt, spices/pepper) in combination with drying at ambient temperature and low humidity to achieve microbial reduction during processing. Culture-dependent and culture-independent microbiome methodologies were used to determine the changes in the microbial community at each step during biltong processing through 8 days of drying. Culture-dependent analysis was conducted using agar-based methods to recover viable bacteria from each step in the biltong process that were identified with 16S rRNA PCR, sequencing, and BLAST searching of the NCBI nucleotide database. DNA was extracted from samples taken from the laboratory meat processing environment, biltong marinade, and beef samples at three stages of processing (post-marinade, day 4, and day 8). In all, 87 samples collected from two biltong trials with beef obtained from each of three separate meat processors (n = six trials) were amplified, sequenced with Illumina HiSeq, and evaluated with bioinformatic analysis for a culture-independent approach. Both culture-dependent and independent methodologies show a more diverse population of bacteria present on the vacuum-packaged chilled raw beef that reduces in diversity during biltong processing. The main genera present after processing were identified as Latilactobacillus sp., Lactococcus sp., and Carnobacterium sp. The high prevalence of these organisms is consistent with extended cold-storage of vacuum-packaged beef (from packers, to wholesalers, to end users), growth of psychrotrophs at refrigeration temperatures (Latilactobacillus sp., Carnobacterium sp.), and survival during biltong processing (Latilactobacillus sakei). The presence of these organisms on raw beef and their growth during conditions of beef storage appears to 'front-load' the raw beef with non-pathogenic organisms that are present at high levels leading into biltong processing. As shown in our prior study on the use of surrogate organisms, L. sakei is resistant to the biltong process (i.e., 2-log reduction), whereas Carnobacterium sp. demonstrated a 5-log reduction in the process; the recovery of either psychrotroph after biltong processing may be dependent on which was more prevalent on the raw beef. This phenomenon of psychrotrophic bloom during refrigerated storage of raw beef may result in a natural microbial suppression of mesophilic foodborne pathogens that are further reduced during biltong processing and contributes to the safety of this type of air-dried beef.

Impact of Electrolyzed Water on the Microbial Spoilage Profile of Piedmontese Steak Tartare

A low initial contamination level of the meat surface is the sine qua non to extend the subsequent shelf life of ground beef for as long as possible. Therefore, the short- and long-term effects of a pregrinding treatment with electrolyzed water (EW) on the microbiological and physicochemical features of Piedmontese steak tartare were here assessed on site, by following two production runs through storage under vacuum packaging conditions at 4°C. The immersion of muscle meat in EW solution at 100 ppm of free active chlorine for 90 s produced an initial surface decontamination with no side effects or compositional modifications, except for an external color change that was subsequently masked by the grinding step. However, the initially measured decontamination was no longer detectable in ground beef, perhaps due to a quick recovery by bacteria during the grinding step from the transient oxidative stress induced by the EW. We observed different RNA-based metataxonomic profiles and metabolomic biomarkers (volatile organic compounds [VOCs], free amino acids [FAA], and biogenic amines [BA]) between production runs. Interestingly, the potentially active microbiota of the meat from each production run, investigated through operational taxonomic unit (OTU)-, oligotyping-, and amplicon sequence variant (ASV)-based bioinformatic pipelines, differed as soon as the early stages of storage, whereas microbial counts and biomarker dynamics were significantly distinguishable only after the expiration date. Higher diversity, richness, and abundance of Streptococcus organisms were identified as the main indicators of the faster spoilage observed in one of the two production runs, while Lactococcus piscium development was the main marker of shelf life end in both production runs. IMPORTANCE Treatment with EW prior to grinding did not result in an effective intervention to prolong the shelf life of Piedmontese steak tartare. Our RNA-based approach clearly highlighted a microbiota that changed markedly between production runs but little during the first shelf life stages. Under these conditions, an early metataxonomic profiling might provide the best prediction of the microbiological fate of each batch of the product.

Comparative genomics of Photobacterium species from terrestrial and marine habitats

Photobacterium (P.) is a genus widely studied in regards to its association with and ubiquitous presence in marine environments. However, certain species (P. phosphoreum, P. carnosum, P. iliopiscarium) have been recently described to colonize and spoil raw meats without a marine link. We have studied 27 strains from meat as well as 26 strains from marine environments in order to probe for intraspecies marine/terrestrial subpopulations and identify distinct genomic features acquired by environmental adaptation. We have conducted phylogenetic analysis (MLSA, ANI, fur, codon usage), search of plasmids (plasmidSPADES), phages (PHASTER), CRISPR-cas operons (CRISPR-finder) and secondary metabolites gene clusters (antiSMASH, BAGEL), in addition to a targeted gene search for specific pathways (e.g. TCA cycle, pentose phosphate, respiratory chain) and elements relevant for growth, adaptation and competition (substrate utilization, motility, bioluminescence, sodium and iron transport). P. carnosum appears as a conserved single clade, with one isolate from MAP fish clustering apart that doesn't, however, show distinct features that could indicate different adaptation. The species harbors genes for a wide carbon source utilization (glycogen/starch, maltose, pullulan, fucose) for colonization of diverse niches in its genome. P. phosphoreum is represented by two different clades on the phylogenetic analyses not correlating to their origin or distribution of other features analyzed that can be divided into two novel subspecies based on genome-wide values. A more diverse antimicrobial activity (sactipeptides, microcins), production of secondary metabolites (siderophores and arylpolyenes), stress response and adaptation (bioluminescence, sodium transporters, catalase, high affinity for oxygen cytochrome cbb3 oxidase, DMSO reductase and proton translocating NADH dehydrogenase) is predicted compared to the other species. P. iliopiscarium was divided into two clades based on source of isolation correlating with phylogeny and distribution of several traits. The species shows traits common to the other two species, similar carbon utilization/transport gene conservation as P. carnosum for the meat-isolated strains, and predicted utilization of marine-common DMSO and flagellar cluster for the sea-isolated strains. Results additionally suggest that photobacteria are highly prone to horizontal acquisition/loss of genetic material and genetic transduction, and that it might be a strategy for increasing the frequency of strain- or species-specific features that offers a growth/competition advantage.

An investigation into the anaerobic spoilage microbiota of beef carcass and rump steak cuts using high- throughput sequencing

The presence of anaerobic microflora on fresh beef carcass and rump steaks, which may contribute to meat spoilage, was explored in this study. A total of 120 carcass and 120 rump steak swabs were collected immediately after slaughtering and boning, respectively from five meat plants, anaerobically incubated and enriched at 4°C for 3 weeks. This was followed by DNA extraction and 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing using the Illumina MiSeq, with subsequent bioinformatics analysis. The enriched microbiota of the samples was classified and grouped into 149 operational taxonomic units (OTUs). The microbiota recovered from both sample types consisted mainly of Carnobacterium, with an average relative abundance of 28.4% and 32.8% in beef carcasses and beef rump steaks, respectively. This was followed by Streptococcus, Serratia, Lactococcus, Enterococcus, Escherichia-Shigella, Raoultella and Aeromonas ranging from 1.5 to 20% and 0.1 to 29.8% in enriched carcasses and rump steak swabs, respectively. Trichococcus, Bacteroides, Dysgomonas, Providencia, Paraclostridium and Proteus were also present ranging from 0 to 0.8% on carcass and 0 to 1.8% on rump steak swabs, respectively. Alpha and beta diversity measurements showed limited diversity between the two sample types, but some differences between samples from the beef plants investigated were evident. This study highlights the presence of potential spoilage bacteria, mainly anaerobic genera on and between carcass and rump steaks, as an indication of contamination on and between these samples.

Comparative Proteomics Reveals the Anaerobic Lifestyle of Meat-Spoiling Pseudomonas Species

The ability of certain Pseudomonas (P.) species to grow or persist in anoxic habitats by either denitrification, acetate fermentation, or arginine fermentation has been described in several studies as a special property. Previously, we had isolated strains belonging to the species P. lundensis, P. weihenstephanensis, and P. fragi from anoxic modified atmosphere packaged (MAP) minced beef and further proved their anaerobic growth in vitro on agar plates. This follow-up study investigated the anaerobic growth of two strains per respective species in situ on inoculated chicken breast filet under 100% N₂ modified atmosphere. We were able to prove anaerobic growth of all six strains on chicken breast filet with cell division rates of 0.2–0.8/day. Furthermore, we characterized the anaerobic metabolic lifestyle of these Pseudomonas strains by comparative proteomics, upon their cultivation in meat simulation media, which were constantly gassed with either air or 100% N₂ atmospheres. From these proteomic predictions, and respective complementation by physiological experiments, we conclude that the Pseudomonas strains P. fragi, P. weihenstephanensis, P. lundensis exhibit a similar anaerobic lifestyle and employ arginine fermentation via the arginine deiminase (ADI) pathway to grow anaerobically also on MAP meats. Furthermore, glucose fermentation to ethanol via the ED-pathway is predicted to enable long term survival but no true growth, while respiratory growth with nitrate as alternative electron acceptor or glucose fermentation to acetate could be excluded due to absence of essential genes. The citric acid cycle is partially bypassed by the glyoxylate shunt, functioning as the gluconeogenetic route without production of NADH₂ under carbon limiting conditions as e.g., in packaged meats. Triggered by an altered redox balance, we also detected upregulation of enzymes involved in protein folding as well as disulfide bonds isomerization under anoxic conditions as a counteracting mechanism to reduce protein misfolding. Hence, this study reveals the mechanisms enabling anaerobic grow and persistence of common meat-spoiling Pseudomonas species, and further complements the hitherto limited knowledge of the anaerobic lifestyle of Pseudomonas species in general.

Proof of concept: predicting the onset of meat spoilage by an integrated oxygen sensor spot in MAP packages

During storage of modified atmosphere packaged (MAP) meat, the initial microbiota grows to high cell numbers, resulting in perceptible spoilage after exceeding a specific threshold level. This study analyses, whether elevated oxygen consumption in the headspace of MA-packages would enable a prediction method for meat spoilage. We monitored the growth of single spoiling species inoculated on high-oxygen MAP beef and poultry, performed sensorial analysis and determined oxygen concentrations of the headspace via a non-invasive sensor spot technology. We detected microbial headspace oxygen consumption occurring prior to perceptible meat spoilage for certain species inoculated on beef steaks. However, headspace oxygen consumption and cell counts at the onset of spoilage were highly species-dependent, which resulted in a strong (Brochothrix thermosphacta) and moderate (Leuconostoc gelidum subspecies) decrease of the headspace oxygen content. No linear decrease of the headspace oxygen could be observed for Carnobacterium divergens and Carnobacterium maltaromaticum inoculated on poultry meat. We demonstrate the applicability of an incorporated oxygen sensor spot technology in MAP meat packages for detection of spoilage in individual packages prior to its perceptible onset. This enables individual package evaluation and sorting within retail, and consequently reduces meat disposal as waste.

Assessment of the potential use of MALDI-TOF MS for the identification of bacteria associated with chilled vacuum-packaged lamb meat

The focus of this study was to compare the effectiveness of MALDI-TOF MS and partial 16S rRNA gene sequencing for the identification of bacteria isolated from VP lamb meat stored chilled at 5 °C for 21 days, at the same time gaining insights into bacterial changes over time. The identity of bacterial isolates on non-selective and selective agars was determined by both methods and results compared. Results showed that total bacterial numbers increased over the 21 days (as expected) with Staphylococcus and Pseudomonas (day 0) being replaced by Carnobacterium, Brochothrix and members of the Enterobacteriaceae family by day 21. A high level of agreement (86-100%) for bacterial isolates' identity at genus level was observed between MALDI-TOF MS and partial 16S rRNA gene-based sequencing for isolates where identification was possible. With its cheaper cost and faster turnaround time, once optimized, MALDI-TOF MS could become a useful alternative to 16S rRNA gene-sequencing for the rapid identification of red meat bacterial isolates.

Effect of high levels of CO2 and O2 on membrane fatty acid profile and membrane physiology of meat spoilage bacteria

The membrane is the major protective barrier separating the cell from the environment and is thus important for bacteria to survive environmental stress. This study investigates changes in membrane lipid compositions and membrane physiology of meat spoiling bacteria in response to high CO2 (30%) and O2 (70%) concentrations, as commonly used for modified atmosphere packaging of meat. Therefore, the fatty acid profile as well as membrane fluidity, permeability and cell surface were determined and correlated to the genomic settings of five meat spoiling bacteria Brochothrix (B.) thermosphacta, Carnobacterium (C.) divergens, C. maltaromaticum, Leuconostoc (L.) gelidum subsp. gelidum and L. gelidum subsp. gasicomitatum cultivated under different gas atmospheres. We identified different genomic potentials for fatty acid adaptations, which were in accordance with actual measured changes in the fatty acid composition for each species in response to CO2 and/or O2, e.g., an increase in saturated, iso and cyclopropane fatty acids. Even though fatty acid changes were species-specific, the general physiological responses were similar, comprising a decreased membrane permeability and fluidity. Thus, we concluded that meat spoiling bacteria facilitate a change in membrane fatty acids upon exposure to O2 and CO2, what leads to alteration of membrane fluidity and permeability. The observed adaptations might contribute to the resistance of meat spoilers against detrimental effects of the gases O2 and CO2 and thus help to explain their ability to grow under different modified atmospheres. Furthermore, this study provides fundamental knowledge regarding the impact of fatty acid changes on important membrane properties of bacteria.

Development of a rapid detection method for Photobacterium spp. using Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP)

While the abundance of photobacteria has previously been exclusively associated with marine environments and spoilage of seafood, several recent studies have demonstrated their status as pervasive constituents of the microbiota on packaged meats. Since their ubiquitous nature has been revealed, detection of their presence on meat, their entry route into meat processing environments and prevention of their growth is a novel emerging challenge for the food industry. In this study, we have developed a highly sensitive and specific loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for the detection of relevant species of photobacteria on foods, and tested its efficacy on meats. The gene encoding trimethylamine-N-oxide reductase (torA) was chosen as the target for this assay. Designed primers based on the gene sequence proved their specificity by testing 67 isolates of 5 species of photobacteria (positive) as well as 63 strains of 16 species of other common meat spoilers (negative). The optimized assay takes 2 h including sample preparation and has a detection limit of only 10-11 copies (50 fg/reaction) of the average Photobacterium (P.) genome per reaction. Its applicability could be successfully demonstrated on naturally and artificially contaminated chicken, beef and pork samples and evaluated by comparison with a culture-dependent approach using selective media and MALDI-TOF MS for identification. The developed LAMP assay revealed presence of photobacteria on one naturally contaminated chicken sample stored at 4 °C long before (3 days) confirmation by the culture-dependent approach. This study demonstrates that the developed LAMP assay represents a reliable and sensitive method for rapid detection of photobacteria on meats. However, its specificity would allow the applicability of the methodology to be extended to other foods, e.g. fish and seafood where presence of photobacteria is directly linked to their shelf life. The method has no requirement for specialized equipment or specially trained personal allowing an easy implementation within the quality control of the food industry. Considering the lot-to-lot variations observed on meats regarding the presence of photobacteria and the impracticality of implementing quantitative methods within the routine control, the LAMP method can simplify and reduce the workload for detection of photobacteria on high sample numbers. Consequently, producers can identify batches/plants that need more stringent control, and are provided with a tool to determine the entry route of photobacteria into the processing and distribution chain of raw meats.

Lactococcus carnosus sp. nov. and Lactococcus paracarnosus sp. nov., two novel species isolated from modified-atmosphere packaged beef steaks

As part of a study investigating the spoilage microbiome of modified-atmosphere packaged beef from Germany, four novel strains of lactic acid bacteria were isolated and subsequently taxonomically characterized by a polyphasic approach, which revealed that they could not be assigned to known species. The isolates were Gram-staining-positive, coccoid, facultatively anaerobic, non-motile, catalase-negative and oxidase-negative. Morphological, physiological and phylogenetic analysis revealed a distinct lineage within the genus Lactococcus , with Lactococcus piscium and Lactococcus plantarum as closest relatives. Results indicated that they represented two different novel species with two strains, (TMW 2.1612T/TMW 2.1613 and TMW 2.1615T/TMW 2.1614), respectively. The two strains of both novel species shared identical 16S rRNA gene sequences but a MLSA allowed their intraspecies differentiation. The 16S rRNA gene sequences of TMW 2.1612T and TMW 2.1615T had a similarity of 99.85 % to each other and a similarity of 99.85 and 99.78 % the most closely related type strain of Lactococcus piscium , respectively. However, the ANIb value between the respective type strains TMW 2.1612T and TMW 2.1615T, and the type strain of Lactococcus piscium was only 94.3 and 92.0 %, respectively, and 92.9 % between TMW 2.1612T and TMW 2.1615T. The in silico DDH estimate value between the respective type strain TMW 2.1612T and TMW 2.1615T and the most closely related type strain of Lactococcus piscium was only 59.9 and 48.9 %, respectively, and 51.1 % between TMW 2.1612T and TMW 2.1615T. Peptidoglycan type of strain TMW 2.1612T is Lys–Thr–Ala and major fatty acids are summed feature 8 and C16 : 0. Peptidoglycan type of strain TMW 2.1615T is Lys–Ala and major fatty acids are C16 : 0, C19 : 0cyclo ω8c and summed feature 8. On the basis of polyphasic evidence, the meat isolates represent two novel species of the genus Lactococcus , for which the names Lactococcus carnosus sp. nov and Lactococcus paracarnosus sp. nov are proposed. The designated respective type strains are TMW 2.1612T (=DSM 111016T =CECT 30115T) and TWM 2.1615T (=DSM 111017T =CECT 30116T).

Evaluation of storage methods of beef by microbiological and chemical indicators

Meat and meat products are a major part of a person's ration. However, due to their high nutritional value, they are a favorable environment for the development of microorganisms and require refrigerated storage. The purpose of this work was to evaluate the storage methods for refrigerated and frozen beef by microbiological and chemical parameters and to suggest criteria for evaluating beef by the content of psychrotrophic microorganisms. It was found out that the storage of beef meat with an initial mesophilic bacterial content of about 4.88 log CFU.cm-2 of surface and psychrotrophic bacteria 3.79 log CFU.cm-2 at temperature 0 °C is only possible for 8 days, further, the microbiological indices exceed the acceptable standards. Investigation of the dynamics of microflora reproduction during the storage of beef in the frozen state at temperature -2 to -3 °C for 20 days established a decrease in 1.3 times the number of mesophilic bacteria in 10 days of storage. At the same time, the number of psychrotrophic microorganisms during this storage time was increased in 4.5 times, and 20 days in 7.9 times and amounted to 5.3 log CFU.cm-2 of surface area. This indicates that the storage of meat in the frozen state inhibits or completely stops the development of mesophilic microorganisms for 20 days. It was found out that storing of beef in the cooled state at a temperature of 0 ±0.5 °C for more than eight days is impractical, as its biochemical indices are worsening and signs of spoilage are appearing. At the same time, storing of beef in the frozen state at a temperature of -2 to -3 °C for 20 days does not cause such significant biochemical changes as in beef stored in the cooled state at a temperature of 0 ±0.5 °C for 16 days. Therefore, we have experimentally substantiated the quantitative indicators of the content of psychrotrophic microorganisms on the surface of beef intended for storage in a cooled or frozen state. The proposed microbiological criteria will improve the safety of beef.

Developing a Commercial Antimicrobial Active Packaging System of Ground Beef Based on "Tsipouro" Alcoholic Distillate

The present study aimed to develop a commercial active packaging system of ground beef, by exploiting the antimicrobial and antioxidant properties of a traditional Greek alcoholic distillate called “tsipouro”. Commercial packages (500 g) were used and 40 mL of “tsipouro” was added in absorbent pads placed underneath the ground beef, while 10 mL was also mounted under the packaging film, facing the headspace. Samples were packaged in 80% O₂: 20% CO₂ and stored at 0, 4, 8, and 12 °C. Total Viable Counts, pseudomonads, Brochothrix thermosphacta, lactic acid bacteria, yeasts-moulds, pH, colour (L*, a*, b*), odour (buttery and acidic), and ethanol migration to ground beef (SPME/GC-FID) were determined. Moreover, mathematical models (square root and Arrhenius) describing the effect of temperature on determinant indicators of spoilage and quality deterioration like growth of dominant microorganisms and red colour reduction were developed and validated under non-isothermal conditions. B. thermosphacta dominated the microbial association of ground beef, while LAB were second in dominance, revealing a high growth potential at all assays. a* value (redness) was gradually decreased in controls, while samples treated with “tsipouro” showed more stable red colour during storage. Although ethanol was organoleptically detectable, especially at low storage temperatures (0–4 °C), it was rather perceived as a pleasant cool odour. Prediction by both models for microbial growth as well as those of Arrhenius model for reduction of a* value showed good agreement with the observations under non-isothermal storage. Overall, our study showed that the developed antimicrobial active packaging of ground beef based on “tsipouro”, combined with high oxygen MAP lead to an almost 2-fold shelf-life extension compared with controls during storage at chill and abuse temperatures.

Analysis of Microbiota Structure and Potential Functions Influencing Spoilage of Fresh Beef Meat

Beef is one of the most consumed food worldwide, and it is prone to spoilage by bacteria. This risk could be caused by resident microbiota and their alterations in fresh beef meat during processing. However, scarce information is available regarding potential spoilage factors due to resident microbiota in fresh beef meat. In this study, we analyzed the microbiota composition and their predicted functions on fresh beef meat. A total of 120 beef meat samples (60 fresh ground and 60 non-ground beef samples) were collected from three different sites in South Korea on different months, and the microbiota were analyzed by the MiSeq system. Our results showed that although the microbiota in beef meat were varied among sampling site and months, the dominant phyla were the same with shared core bacteria. Notably, psychrotrophic genera, related to spoilage, were detected in all samples, and their prevalence increased significantly in July. These genera could inhibit the growth of other microbes with using glucose by fermentation. The results of this study extend our understanding of initial microbiota in fresh beef meat and potential functions influencing spoilage and can be useful to develop the preventive measures to reduce the spoilage of beef meat products.

Metatranscriptomic analysis of modified atmosphere packaged poultry meat enables prediction of Brochothrix thermosphacta and Carnobacterium divergens in situ metabolism

In this study, in situ-expressed metabolic routes of Brochothrix (B.) thermosphacta and Carnobacterium (C.) divergens were evaluated based on a metatranscriptomic dataset from bacteria growing on MAP chicken meat (O₂/CO₂; N₂/CO₂). Both species exhibited no (C. divergens) or minor transcription regulation (B. thermosphacta) within their main metabolic routes in response to different atmospheres. Both employ pathways related to glucose and ribose. Gluconeogenesis from lipid-borne glycerol is active in the progressing lack of carbohydrates. Pyruvate fates in both species comprise lactate, ethanol, acetate, CO₂, formate, C4-compounds and H₂O₂ (only B. thermosphacta). Both species express genes for a minimal aerobic respiratory chain, but do not possess the genetic setting for a functional citric acid cycle. While products of carbohydrate and glycerol metabolism display mild to medium sensorial off-characteristics, predicted end products of their amino acid metabolism comprise, e.g., isobutyrate and isovalerate (B. thermosphacta) or cadaverine and tyramine (C. divergens) as potent spoilage compounds.

Comparative Proteomics of Meat Spoilage Bacteria Predicts Drivers for Their Coexistence on Modified Atmosphere Packaged Meat

Besides intrinsic and extrinsic factors such as antagonism for organic substrates or temperature, the storage atmosphere of meat has a high influence on the development of its initial microbiota. Specific modified atmospheres (MAs) selectively suppress growth of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria, thus reshaping the initial microbiota. As some microorganisms are more tolerant to MA, they overgrow competitors and produce metabolites that cause rejection of the product. In order to elucidate responses to different MA by means of metabolic adaptation and competition for organic substrates on meat, the typical representative meat spoilage bacteria Brochothrix (B.) thermosphacta TMW2.2101 and four lactic acid bacteria Carnobacterium (C.) divergens TMW2.1577, C. maltaromaticum TMW2.1581, Leuconostoc (L.) gelidum subsp. gelidum TMW2.1618 and L. gelidum subsp. gasicomitatum TMW2.1619 were chosen. Bacteria were grown in sterile glass bottles filled with a meat simulation medium, which was aerated constantly with either air, 100%_N₂, 30%_CO₂/70%_O₂ or 30%_CO₂/70%_N₂. Growth of bacteria during incubation at 25°C and stirring at 120 rpm was monitored over 48 h and a label-free quantitative mass spectrometric approach was employed to determine changes within the bacterial proteomes in response to oxygen and carbon dioxide. Both Leuconostoc subsp. were intrinsically tolerant to MA, exhibiting no proteomic regulation of enzymes, whereas the other species provide a set of metabolic adaptation mechanism, enabling higher resistance to the detrimental effects of MA. Those mechanisms comprise: enhanced oxidative stress reduction, adjustment of the pyruvate metabolism and catabolic oxygen consumption in response to oxygen and intracellular pH homeostasis, maintenance of osmotic balance and alteration of the fatty acid composition in response to carbon dioxide. We further evaluated the potential of industrial used MA to inhibit specific bacterial spoilage. No bacterial inhibition is predicted for 30%_CO₂/70%_O₂ for the analyzed species, whereas 30%_CO₂/70%_N₂ predictively inhibits C. divergens TMW21577 and B. thermosphacta TMW2.2101. Furthermore, species-specific metabolic pathways enabling different and preferential carbon source utilization were identified, which enable non-competitive coexistence of respective bacteria on meat, resulting in synergistic spoilage. In conclusion, this study gives mechanistically explanations of their acknowledged status as typical spoilage organisms on MAP meats.

Quantitative Oxygen Consumption and Respiratory Activity of Meat Spoiling Bacteria Upon High Oxygen Modified Atmosphere

High oxygen modified atmosphere packaging is a commonly applied method to prolong the minimum shelf life of fresh (red) meats. Upon spoilage, changes of the initial oxygen concentration and microbiome composition can be observed. Thus, we classified the typical representative meat spoiling bacteria Brochothrix (B.) thermosphacta TMW2.2101 and the four lactic acid bacteria (LAB) Carnobacterium (C.) divergens TMW2.1577, C. maltaromaticum TMW2.1581, Leuconostoc (L.) gelidum subsp. gelidum TMW2.1618, and L. gelidum subsp. gasicomitatum TMW2.1619 along their oxygen consuming capacity, which can indicate the timeline of microbiome and sensorial changes. All bacteria were grown in a model system employing gas tight glass bottles containing meat simulation media and under modified atmosphere (70% O2 and 30% CO2). Oxygen concentrations of media and headspaces were monitored over time and the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) was calculated for all species. All bacteria were able to consume dissolved oxygen, with B. thermosphacta TMW2.2101 exhibiting a 31-times higher OUR per single cell in 60 h. Furthermore, all strains showed significant growth enhancement in the presence of heme indicating respiratory activity. Comparative genomic and physiological analyses predict the activity of a respiratory chain for all species upon high oxygen atmosphere. An additional cytochrome aa3 oxidase is suggested to be responsible for the increased OUR of B. thermosphacta TMW2.2101. Furthermore, B. thermosphacta TMW2.2101 revealed highest oxidative stress tolerance compared to the other bacteria, facilitating a higher respiratory activity. Coupling of respiration and fermentation via regeneration of NADH can be a competitive advantage for meat spoiling bacteria resulting in a higher cell count and possibly accelerated spoilage. The exhibited highest capacity for oxygen consumption of B. thermosphacta compared to LAB in vitro also suggests a higher contribution of this bacterium to the change in the atmosphere upon spoilage of MAP meats in situ.

Relevant Aspects of Clostridium estertheticum as a Specific Spoilage Organism of Vacuum-Packed Meat

Clostridium estertheticum is a psychrotolerant, gram-positive, motile, anaerobic, spore-forming, rod-shaped bacteria that causes blown pack spoilage (BPS). Spoilage occurs in vacuum-packed meat without temperature abuse. Having been reported in the last 30 years in several countries, BPS by Cl. estertheticum is a major issue around the world and presents a huge economic impact on the meat industry. Despite being an important spoilage microorganism, studies on Cl. estertheticum are challenged by numerous aspects. These include, lack or poor growth in laboratory media, long culturing periods, and unpredictable isolation on the media. These factors hamper the detection of Cl. estertheticum before occurrence of BPS, which further undermines efforts to prevent the occurrence of BPS. Nevertheless, considerable developments have taken place with regard to culture-independent methods. Although information on Cl. estertheticum is available, it is limited and remains highly fragmented. Therefore, this review collates the available information and discusses relevant aspects of Cl. estertheticum as a specific spoilage organism of BPS in vacuum-packed meat.

An adapted isolation procedure reveals Photobacterium spp. as common spoilers on modified atmosphere packaged meats

The genus Photobacterium comprises species of marine bacteria, commonly found in open-ocean and deep-sea environments. Some species (e.g. Photobacterium phosphoreum) are associated with fish spoilage. Recently, culture-independent studies have drawn attention to the presence of photobacteria on meat. This study employed a comparative isolation approach of Photobacterium spp. and aimed to develop an adapted isolation procedure for recovery from food samples, as demonstrated for different meats: Marine broth is used for resuspending and dilution of food samples, followed by aerobic cultivation on marine broth agar supplemented with meat extract and vancomycin at 15°C for 72 h. Identification of spoilage-associated microbiota was carried out via Matrix Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Time of Flight Mass Spectrometry using a database supplemented with additional mass spectrometry profiles of Photobacterium spp. This study provides evidence for the common abundance of multiple Photobacterium species in relevant quantities on various modified atmosphere packaged meats. Photobacterium carnosum was predominant on beef and chicken, while Photobacterium iliopiscarium represented the major species on pork and Photobacterium phosphoreum on salmon, respectively.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

This study demonstrates highly frequent isolation of multiple photobacteria (Photobacterium carnosum, Photobacterium phosphoreum, and Photobacterium iliopiscarium) from different modified-atmosphere packaged spoiled and unspoiled meats using an adapted isolation procedure. The abundance of photobacteria in high numbers provides evidence for the hitherto neglected importance and relevance of Photobacterium spp. to meat spoilage.