Innovations and stepwise evolution of CBFs/DREB1s and their regulatory networks in angiosperms

Functional Divergence in Orthologous Transcription Factors: Insights from AtCBF2/3/1 and OsDREB1C

Despite traditional beliefs of orthologous genes maintaining similar functions across species, growing evidence points to their potential for functional divergence. C-repeat binding factors/dehydration-responsive element binding protein 1s (CBFs/DREB1s) are critical in cold acclimation, with their overexpression enhancing stress tolerance but often constraining plant growth. In contrast, a recent study unveiled a distinctive role of rice OsDREB1C in elevating nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), photosynthesis, and grain yield, implying functional divergence within the CBF/DREB1 orthologs across species. Here, we delve into divergent molecular mechanisms of OsDREB1C and AtCBF2/3/1 by exploring their evolutionary trajectories across rice and Arabidopsis genomes, regulatomes, and transcriptomes. Evolutionary scrutiny shows discrete clades for OsDREB1C and AtCBF2/3/1, with the Poaceae-specific DREB1C clade mediated by a transposon event. Genome-wide binding profiles highlight OsDREB1C's preference for GCCGAC compared to AtCBF2/3/1's preference for A/GCCGAC, a distinction determined by R12 in the OsDREB1C AP2/ERF domain. Cross-species multiomic analyses reveal shared gene orthogroups (OGs) and underscore numerous specific OGs uniquely bound and regulated by OsDREB1C, implicated in NUE, photosynthesis, and early flowering, or by AtCBF2/3/1, engaged in hormone and stress responses. This divergence arises from gene gains/losses (∼16.7% to 25.6%) and expression reprogramming (∼62.3% to 66.2%) of OsDREB1C- and AtCBF2/3/1-regulated OGs during the extensive evolution following the rice-Arabidopsis split. Our findings illustrate the regulatory evolution of OsDREB1C and AtCBF2/3/1 at a genomic scale, providing insights on the functional divergence of orthologous transcription factors following gene duplications across species.

Convergent and/or parallel evolution of RNA-binding proteins in angiosperms after polyploidization

Increasing studies suggest that the biased retention of stress-related transcription factors (TFs) after whole-genome duplications (WGDs) could rewire gene transcriptional networks, facilitating plant adaptation to challenging environments. However, the role of posttranscriptional factors (e.g. RNA-binding proteins, RBPs) following WGDs has been largely ignored. Uncovering thousands of RBPs in 21 representative angiosperm species, we integrate genomic, transcriptomic, regulatomic, and paleotemperature datasets to unravel their evolutionary trajectories and roles in adapting to challenging environments. We reveal functional enrichments of RBP genes in stress responses and identify their convergent retention across diverse angiosperms from independent WGDs, coinciding with global cooling periods. Numerous RBP duplicates derived from WGDs are then identified as cold-induced. A significant overlap of 29 orthogroups between WGD-derived and cold-induced RBP genes across diverse angiosperms highlights a correlation between WGD and cold stress. Notably, we unveil an orthogroup (Glycine-rich RNA-binding Proteins 7/8, GRP7/8) and relevant TF duplicates (CCA1/LHY, RVE4/8, CBF2/4, etc.), co-retained in different angiosperms post-WGDs. Finally, we illustrate their roles in rewiring circadian and cold-regulatory networks at both transcriptional and posttranscriptional levels during global cooling. Altogether, we underline the adaptive evolution of RBPs in angiosperms after WGDs during global cooling, improving our understanding of plants surviving periods of environmental turmoil.

Ancient Duplication and Lineage-Specific Transposition Determine Evolutionary Trajectory of ERF Subfamily across Angiosperms

AP2/ERF transcription factor family plays an important role in plant development and stress responses. Previous studies have shed light on the evolutionary trajectory of the AP2 and DREB subfamilies. However, knowledge about the evolutionary history of the ERF subfamily in angiosperms still remains limited. In this study, we performed a comprehensive analysis of the ERF subfamily from 107 representative angiosperm species by combining phylogenomic and synteny network approaches. We observed that the expansion of the ERF subfamily was driven not only by whole-genome duplication (WGD) but also by tandem duplication (TD) and transposition duplication events. We also found multiple transposition events in Poaceae, Brassicaceae, Poales, Brassicales, and Commelinids. These events may have had notable impacts on copy number variation and subsequent functional divergence of the ERF subfamily. Moreover, we observed a number of ancient tandem duplications occurred in the ERF subfamily across angiosperms, e.g., in Subgroup IX, IXb originated from ancient tandem duplication events within IXa. These findings together provide novel insights into the evolution of this important transcription factor family.

Genomic evidence for climate-linked diversity loss and increased vulnerability of wild barley spanning 28 years of climate warming

The information on how plant populations respond genetically to climate warming is scarce. Here, landscape genomic and machine learning approaches were integrated to assess genetic response of 10 wild barley (Hordeum vulgare ssp. spontaneum; WB) populations in the past and future, using whole genomic sequencing (WGS) data. The WB populations were sampled in 1980 and again in 2008. Phylogeny of accessions was roughly in conformity with sampling sites, which accompanied by admixture/introgressions. The 28-y climate warming resulted in decreased genetic diversity, increased selection pressure, and an increase in deleterious single nucleotide polymorphism (dSNP) numbers, heterozygous deleterious and total deleterious burdens for WB. Genome-environment associations identified some candidate genes belonging to peroxidase family (HORVU2Hr1G057450, HORVU4Hr1G052060 and HORVU4Hr1G057210) and heat shock protein 70 family (HORVU2Hr1G112630). The gene HORVU2Hr1G120170 identified by selective sweep analysis was under strong selection during the climate warming of the 28-y, and its derived haplotypes were fixed by WB when faced with the 28-y increasingly severe environment. Temperature variables were found to be more important than precipitation variables in influencing genomic variation, with an eco-physiological index gdd5 (growing degree-days at the baseline threshold temperature of 5 °C) being the most important determinant. Gradient forest modelling revealed higher predicted genomic vulnerability in Sede Boqer under future climate scenarios at 2041-2070 and 2071-2100. Additionally, estimates of effective population size (Ne) tracing back to 250 years indicated a forward decline in all populations over time. Our assessment about past genetic response and future vulnerability of WB under climate warming is crucial for informing conservation efforts for wild cereals and rational use strategies.

Genome-Wide Analysis of C-Repeat Binding Factor Gene Family in Capsicum baccatum and Functional Exploration in Low-Temperature Response

Capsicum baccatum is a close relative of edible chili peppers (Capsicum annuum) with high economic value. The CBF gene family plays an important role in plant stress resistance physiology. We detected a total of five CBF genes in the C. baccatum genome-wide sequencing data. These genes were scattered irregularly across four chromosomes. The genes were categorized into three groupings according to their evolutionary relationships, with genes in the same category showing comparable principles for motif composition. The 2000 bp upstream of CbCBF contains many resistance-responsive elements, hormone-responsive elements, and transcription factor binding sites. These findings emphasize the crucial functions of these genes in responding to challenging conditions and physiological regulation. Analysis of tissue-specific expression revealed that CbCBF3 exhibited the greatest level of expression among all tissues. Under conditions of low-temperature stress, all CbCBF genes exhibited different levels of responsiveness, with CbCBF3 showing a considerable up-regulation after 0.25 h of cold stress, indicating a high sensitivity to low-temperature response. The importance of the CbCBF3 gene in the cold response of C. baccatum was confirmed by the use of virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) technology, as well as the prediction of its protein interaction network. To summarize, this study conducts a thorough bioinformatics investigation of the CbCBF gene family, showcases the practicality of employing VIGS technology in C. baccatum, and confirms the significance of the CbCBF3 gene in response to low temperatures. These findings provide significant references for future research on the adaptation of C. baccatum to low temperatures.

Differences in alternative splicing and their potential underlying factors between animals and plants

BACKGROUND

Alternative splicing (AS), a posttranscriptional process, contributes to the complexity of transcripts from a limited number of genes in a genome, and AS is considered a great source of genetic and phenotypic diversity in eukaryotes. In animals, AS is tightly regulated during the processes of cell growth and differentiation, and its dysregulation is involved in many diseases, including cancers. Likewise, in plants, AS occurs in all stages of plant growth and development, and it seems to play important roles in the rapid reprogramming of genes in response to environmental stressors. To date, the prevalence and functional roles of AS have been extensively reviewed in animals and plants. However, AS differences between animals and plants, especially their underlying molecular mechanisms and impact factors, are anecdotal and rarely reviewed.

AIM OF REVIEW

This review aims to broaden our understanding of AS roles in a variety of biological processes and provide insights into the underlying mechanisms and impact factors likely leading to AS differences between animals and plants.

KEY SCIENTIFIC CONCEPTS OF REVIEW

We briefly summarize the roles of AS regulation in physiological and biochemical activities in animals and plants. Then, we underline the differences in the process of AS between plants and animals and especially analyze the potential impact factors, such as gene exon/intron architecture, 5'/3' untranslated regions (UTRs), spliceosome components, chromatin dynamics and transcription speeds, splicing factors [serine/arginine-rich (SR) proteins and heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins (hnRNPs)], noncoding RNAs, and environmental stimuli, which might lead to the differences. Moreover, we compare the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD)-mediated turnover of the transcripts with a premature termination codon (PTC) in animals and plants. Finally, we summarize the current AS knowledge published in animals versus plants and discuss the potential development of disease therapies and superior crops in the future.

Orthogroup and phylotranscriptomic analyses identify transcription factors involved in the plant cold response: A case study of Arabidopsis BBX29

C-repeat binding factors (CBFs) are well-known transcription factors (TFs) that regulate plant cold acclimation. RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) data from diverse plant species provide opportunities to identify other TFs involved in the cold response. However, this task is challenging because gene gain and loss has led to an intertwined community of co-orthologs and in-paralogs between and within species. Using orthogroup (closely related homologs) analysis, we identified 10,549 orthogroups in five representative eudicots. A phylotranscriptomic analysis of cold-treated seedlings from eudicots identified 35 high-confidence conserved cold-responsive transcription factor orthogroups (CoCoFos). These 35 CoCoFos included the well-known cold-responsive regulators CBFs, HSFC1, ZAT6/10, and CZF1 among others. We used Arabidopsis BBX29 for experimental validation. Expression and genetic analyses showed that cold-induction of BBX29 is CBF- and abscisic acid-independent, and BBX29 is a negative regulator of cold tolerance. Integrative RNA-seq and Cleavage Under Targets and Tagmentation followed by sequencing analyses revealed that BBX29 represses a set of cold-induced TFs (ZAT12, PRR9, RVE1, MYB96, etc.). Altogether, our analysis yielded a library of eudicot CoCoFos and demonstrated that BBX29 is a negative regulator of cold tolerance in Arabidopsis.

Combined genomic and transcriptomic analysis reveals the contribution of tandem duplication genes to low-temperature adaptation in perennial ryegrass

Perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) is an agronomically important cool-season grass species that is widely used as forage for ruminant animal production and cultivated in temperate regions for the establishment of lawns. However, the underlying genetic mechanism of the response of L. perenne to low temperature is still unclear. In the present study, we performed a comprehensive study and identified 3,770 tandem duplication genes (TDGs) in L. perenne, and evolutionary analysis revealed that L. perenne might have undergone a duplication event approximately 7.69 Mya. GO and KEGG pathway functional analyses revealed that these TDGs were mainly enriched in photosynthesis, hormone-mediated signaling pathways and responses to various stresses, suggesting that TDGs contribute to the environmental adaptability of L. perenne. In addition, the expression profile analysis revealed that the expression levels of TDGs were highly conserved and significantly lower than those of all genes in different tissues, while the frequency of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) from TDGs was much higher than that of DEGs from all genes in response to low-temperature stress. Finally, in-depth analysis of the important and expanded gene family indicated that the members of the ELIP subfamily could rapidly respond to low temperature and persistently maintain higher expression levels during all low temperature stress time points, suggesting that ELIPs most likely mediate low temperature responses and help to facilitate adaptation to low temperature in L. perenne. Our results provide evidence for the genetic underpinning of low-temperature adaptation and valuable resources for practical application and genetic improvement for stress resistance in L. perenne.

Genome-Wide Identification and Expression Profiles of C-Repeat Binding Factor Transcription Factors in Betula platyphylla under Abiotic Stress

CBF (C-repeat binding factor) transcription factor subfamily belongs to AP2/ERF (Apetala 2/ethylene-responsive factor) transcription factor family, known for playing a vital role in plant abiotic stress response. Although some CBF transcription factors have been identified in several species, such as Arabidopsis, tobacco, tomato and poplar, research of CBF focus mainly on model plant Arabidopsis and have not been reported in Betula platyphylla yet. In this study, a total of 20 BpCBF subfamily members were identified. The conserved domains, physicochemical properties, exon-intron gene structure and the structure of conserved protein motifs of BpCBFs were analyzed via bioinformatic tools. The collinearity analysis of CBF genes was performed between Betula platyphylla and Arabidopsis thaliana, Betula platyphylla, and Populus trichocarpa. The cis-acting elements in the promoter region of BpCBFs were identified, which were mainly environmental stress-related and hormone-related element components. In this case, the expression patterns of the 20 BpCBFs upon ABA or salt treatment were investigated. Most of these transcription factors were responsive to ABA or salt stress in different plant tissues. The up-regulation trend upon cold treatment of the six cold-responsive genes validated by qRT-PCR was consistent with the result of RNA-seq. BpCBF7 showed transcription activating activity. This study sheds light on the responses of BpCBFs to abiotic stress and provides a reference for further study of CBF transcription factors in woody plants.

A phylotranscriptomic dataset of angiosperm species under cold stress

Angiosperms are one of the most diverse and abundant plant groups that are widely distributed on Earth, from tropical to temperate and polar zones. The wide distribution of angiosperms may be attributed to the evolution of sophisticated mechanisms of environmental adaptability, including cold tolerance. Since the development of high-throughput sequencing, transcriptome has been widely utilized to gain insights into the molecular mechanisms of plants in response to cold stress. However, previous studies generally focused on single or two species, and comparative transcriptome analyses for multispecies responding to cold stress were limited. In this study, we selected 11 representative angiosperm species, performed phylotranscriptome experiments at four time points before and after cold stress, and presented a profile of cold-induced transcriptome changes in angiosperms. Our multispecies cold-responsive RNA-seq datasets provide valuable references for exploring conserved and evolutionary mechanisms of angiosperms in adaptation to cold stress.

The DREB transcription factor, a biomacromolecule, responds to abiotic stress by regulating the expression of stress-related genes

Abiotic stress is a crucial factor that affects plant survival and growth and even leads to plant death in severe cases. Transcription factors can enhance the ability of plants to fight against various stresses by controlling the expression of downstream genes. The dehydration response element binding protein (DREB) is the most extensive subfamily of AP2/ERF transcription factors involved in abiotic stress. However, insufficient research on the signal network of DREB transcription factors has limited plant growth and reproduction. Furthermore, field planting of DREB transcription factors and their roles under multiple stress also require extensive research. Previous reports on DREB transcription factors have focused on the regulation of DREB expression and its roles in plant abiotic stress. In recent years, there has been new progress in DREB transcription factors. Here, the structure and classification, evolution and regulation, role in abiotic stress, and application in crops of DREB transcription factors were reviewed. And this paper highlighted the evolution of DREB1/CBF, as well as the regulation of DREB transcription factors under the participation of plant hormone signals and the roles of subgroups in abiotic stress. In the future, it will lay a solid foundation for further study of DREB transcription factors and pave the way for the cultivation of resistant plants.

Integrative multi-omics analysis of three early diverged rosid species reveals an ancient hierarchical cold-responsive regulatory network

Elucidating regulators, including transcription factors (TFs) and RNA-binding proteins (RBPs), underlying gene transcriptional and post-transcriptional co-regulatory network is key to understand plant cold responses. Previous studies were mainly conducted on single species, and whether the regulators are conserved across different species remains elusive. Here, we selected three species that diverged at the early evolution of rosids (~99-113 million years ago), performed cold-responsive phylotranscriptome experiments, and integrated chromatin immunoprecipitation- and DNA affinity purification-sequencing (ChIP/DAP-seq) analysis to explore cold-responsive regulators and their regulatory networks. First, we detected over 10,000 cold-induced differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and alternative splicing genes (DASGs) in each species. Among the DEGs, a set of TFs and RBPs were conserved in rosid cold response. Compared to TFs, RBPs displayed a delayed cold-responsive pattern, implying a hierarchical regulation of DEGs and DASGs. By integrating DEGs and DASGs, we identified 259 overlapping DE-DASG orthogroups (closely-related homologs) that were cold-regulated at both transcriptional and post-transcriptional levels in all three studied species. Notably, pathway analysis on each of the DEGs, DASGs, and DE-DASGs in the three species showed a common enrichment connected to the circadian rhythm. Evidently, 226 cold-responsive genes were directly targeted by at least two circadian rhythm components (CCA1, LHY, RV4, RVE7, and RVE8). Finally, we revealed an ancient hierarchy of cold-responsive regulatory networks at transcriptional and post-transcriptional levels launched by circadian components in rosids. Altogether, this study sheds light on conserved regulators underlying cold-responsive regulatory networks across rosid species, despite a long evolutionary history after their divergence.

Progress and Prospects of the Molecular Basis of Soybean Cold Tolerance

Cold stress is a major factor influencing the geographical distribution of soybean growth and causes immense losses in productivity. Understanding the molecular mechanisms that the soybean has undergone to survive cold temperatures will have immense value in improving soybean cold tolerance. This review focuses on the molecular mechanisms involved in soybean response to cold. We summarized the recent studies on soybean cold-tolerant quantitative trait loci (QTLs), transcription factors, associated cold-regulated (COR) genes, and the regulatory pathways in response to cold stress. Cold-tolerant QTLs were found to be overlapped with the genomic region of maturity loci of E1, E3, E4, pubescence color locus of T, stem growth habit gene locus of Dt1, and leaf shape locus of Ln, indicating that pleiotropic loci may control multiple traits, including cold tolerance. The C-repeat responsive element binding factors (CBFs) are evolutionarily conserved across species. The expression of most GmDREB1s was upregulated by cold stress and overexpression of GmDREB1B;1 in soybean protoplast, and transgenic Arabidopsis plants can increase the expression of genes with the DRE core motif in their promoter regions under cold stress. Other soybean cold-responsive regulators, such as GmMYBJ1, GmNEK1, GmZF1, GmbZIP, GmTCF1a, SCOF-1 and so on, enhance cold tolerance by regulating the expression of COR genes in transgenic Arabidopsis. CBF-dependent and CBF-independent pathways are cross-talking and work together to activate cold stress gene expression. Even though it requires further dissection for precise understanding, the function of soybean cold-responsive transcription factors and associated COR genes studied in Arabidopsis shed light on the molecular mechanism of cold responses in soybeans and other crops. Furthermore, the findings may also provide practical applications for breeding cold-tolerant soybean varieties in high-latitude and high-altitude regions.