Postoperative bleeding tendency as a risk factor inActinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans-associated periodontitis

A systematic review on the use of residual probing depth, bleeding on probing and furcation status following initial periodontal therapy to predict further attachment and tooth loss

BACKGROUND

Chronic periodontitis affects many adults. Initial cause related therapy (ICRT) is aimed at elimination of factors causing disease progression.

OBJECTIVES

To use a systematic review process of peer reviewed publications to assess the predictive value of residual probing depths (PD), bleeding on probing (BOP) and furcation involvement (FI) in determining further loss of attachment and tooth loss following ICRT.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

An electronic search of the Cochrane Oral Health Group specialized register, MEDLINE and EMBASE, was performed using specific search terms to identify studies assessing the predictive value of residual probing depths (PD), bleeding on probing (BOP) and furcation involvement (FI) in determining further loss of attachment and tooth loss following ICRT.

RESULTS

The searches resulted in 941 uniquely identified studies. Titles and abstracts were then independently screened by two reviewers (S.R. and G.R.P.) to identify publications that met specific inclusion criteria. The agreement between the reviewers was assessed and statistical analysis failed to demonstrate a difference between the two reviewers (kappa-value: 0.94, P = 0.003). Detailed review of 47 included publications resulted in acceptance of one publication which utilized data based on patient as unit of observation. This study included 16 subjects over 42 months demonstrating that residual probing depths are predictive of further disease progression whereas persisting bleeding on probing are not.

CONCLUSIONS

Data based on one study suggest that residual probing depths are predictive of further disease progression. The implications for carefully designed multicentre randomized clinical control trials are many.

A rapid DNA probe method for detection of Porphyromonas gingivalis and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans

BACKGROUND

The objective of the present study was to develop a rapid DNA probe method for the microbiological detection of periodontitis that can be used in dental clinics. By using the DNA probe, we also investigated the correlation between the occurrence of putative periodontopathic bacteria and clinical parameters.

METHODS

This rapid DNA probe method minimizes the use of a water bath for ordinary hybridization and washing in order to shorten the total reaction time. The detection process could be completed within 2 hours. In order to evaluate the clinical application of the DNA probe, subgingival plaque samples were taken from patients with periodontitis before initial therapy. After the therapy, the patients were microbiologically and clinically evaluated.

RESULTS

When the DNA probe method was compared with the culture method, the agreement was 88% for Porphyromonas gingivalis and 67% for Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans. A statistically significant association was found between the detection of P. gingivalis and probing depth, bleeding on probing (chi2 test: P <0.001, P <0.05). A significant association was also shown between the detection of A. actinomycetemcomitans and probing depth in patients aged 35 or older (chi2 test: P <0.001). The detection rate of A. actinomycetemcomitans was highest in teenagers. At shallow periodontal pocket sites (PD < or =3 mm) in teenagers, no P. gingivalis was found, while 22% of the sites harbored A. actinomycetemcomitans. After the therapy, the frequency of detection of P. gingivalis decreased significantly only in the clinically improved sites (chi2 test: P <0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The rapid DNA probe method appears promising as an efficient tool for rapid clinical detection of periodontopathic bacteria.

Longitudinal study of prognostic factors in established periodontitis patients

Numerous indicators for disease progression have been described in the last decade. The purpose of this study was to examine, longitudinally, a large battery of clinical, microbiological, and immunological indicators, to try to determine whether the presence of one or a combination of these parameters at baseline, would correlate positively with increased attachment and or bone loss (true prognostic factors). Following initial screening, 79 patients with established periodontitis were monitored longitudinally for one year. Whole mouth clinical measurements, plaque gingival and calculus indices, together with pocket depth and attachment level measurements, were repeated every three months. Full mouth radiographic survey, performed at baseline and 12 months, served to determine changes in crestal bone height using an image enhancement technique. Subgingival plaque samples were taken at baseline and every 3 months. Immunofluorescence assays were performed for the a battery of target microorganisms. Serum and GCF samples for IgG subclasses analysis were obtained at each visit and assayed using ELISA techniques. Likewise blood, samples were also drawn at each visit for a quantitative analysis of serum cotinine level. The overall mean attachment loss (AL) and bone loss (BL) were almost identical (0.159 mm and 0.164 mm, respectively). Individual patients variation was large (-0.733 to +1.004 mm). An overall 6.89% of sites were active; individual patients' means ranged from 0-28.9%. Mean pocket depth (PD) showed minimal change over the study period (-0.033 mm) thus suggesting that most if not all the AL was accompained by concomitant gingival recession. Smokers exhibited greater AL and radiographic BL compared to non-smokers. Likewise, patients' cotinine level showed direct correlation with outcomes of progressive periodontal breakdown. Past severity of periodontal involvement, as reflected in the patients baseline PD, AL and crestal bone height, showed good correlation with longitudinal changes in the periodontium. This correlation was higher for crestal BL as the outcome variable, while somewhat smaller for change in AL as the outcome variable. Bacteroides forsythus (Bf.), Prevotella intermedia (Pi.) and Porphyromonas gingivalis (Pg.) were frequently found in these patients. The presence of these microorganisms at baseline was associated with further disease progression. Subjects with mean baseline pocket depth equal or greater than 3.2 mm were at greater risk for future bone loss 1 year later (O.R. 2.97; C.I. 1.02-8.70). Smokers were at significantly greater risk for further attachment loss when compared to non-smokers (O.R. 5.41; C.I. 1.50-19.5). Subjects that harbored B. forsythus at baseline, were at seven times greater risk for increased pocket depth (O.R. 7.84; C.I.1.74-35.3). In conclusion, past periodontal destruction, smoking habits, Bf., Pg., & Pi. are prognostic factors for further periodontal breakdown. When designing clinical trials, or when evaluating epidemiological data, it is most important to balance for these factors. Also, treatment strategies should attempt to eliminate or modify these factors.

A longitudinal study of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans in army recruits

During recruiting examinations 201 recruits, 18-25 yr old, were examined for subgingival and extracrevicular Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans. The organism was isolated in 55 subjects, most often at low levels. Cluster analysis revealed 3 clusters with no (A, n = 86) or minor (B, n = 92) periodontal disease and low DMF-S, as well as established periodontitis, increased D + DF-S and high DMF-S (C, n = 22). When leaving the 12-months' service, 105 recruits were re-examined (54 cluster A, 41 cluster B, 9 cluster C subjects, 1 recruit who was not clustered). An increase of periodontal probing depth (PPD) of > or = 3 mm at 1 or more sites occurred in 33 subjects: 9 (17%) in cluster A, 16 (39%) in cluster B, 7 (78%) in cluster C and in the not-clustered recruit. Considerable variation in frequency distributions of PPD alterations was observed, therefore significant (p < 0.1) mean increase (1-sample t-test) and skew g1 (S-statistic) were additionally considered to define an "active" case. A total of 7 recruits (6.7%) met the criteria. Logistic regression analysis revealed a significant influence of self-reported smoking habits on activity status. Thus, heavy smokers (> 20 cigarettes/d) had a 14-fold higher risk (p = 0.030) for developing or progressing periodontitis compared to non- or light smokers (< 10 cigarettes/d). In particular, cluster B recruits appeared to have a lower risk (p = 0.11) for developing periodontitis than cluster C recruits (established periodontitis, high DMF-S). A. actinomycetemcomitans was isolated in 29 recruits (27.6%) at baseline and 30 recruits (28.6%) after 12 months. Presence of the organism was not a risk factor for periodontitis. However, in active subjects, significantly more samples were only A. actinomycetemcomitans-positive at re-examination compared to inactive recruits. It was concluded that smoking is a significant risk factor for periodontitis. Subjects with established periodontitis tend to deteriorate further. A. actinomycetemcomitans seems not to increase the risk for developing or progressing periodontitis in this age group. Longer studies involving larger populations are needed to confirm these observations.

Clinical indicators of probing attachment loss following initial periodontal treatment in advanced periodontitis patients

16 advanced periodontitis patients were subjected to initial periodontal treatment and monitored every 3rd month during 42 months. Clinical characteristics at baseline and during the 42-month maintenance period were investigated for their association with probing attachment loss over the 42-month period, both on a patient level and on a site level. On a patient level, averaged full-mouth plaque and bleeding on probing scores over the maintenance interval showed little association with probing attachment loss. Little association was also observed for % sites with depth > or = 6 mm at baseline. However, a notable relationship was seen for % sites > or = 6 mm at 3 months. This finding initiated a separation of the 16 subjects into 2 groups based upon % sites > or = 6 mm at 3 months (groups 'high' and 'low'). Site level analyses for these groups showed little association between frequent presence of plaque at the sites over the maintenance interval and probing attachment loss. Frequent bleeding on probing showed limited relationship with attachment loss for group 'low', but an appreciable association for group 'high'. The findings suggest that advanced periodontitis patients with multiple residual probing depths > or = 6 mm at re-evaluation run a greater risk of developing sites with additional attachment loss than patients with few such residual depths. For such higher risk patients, bleeding on probing at maintenance examinations may be a useful indicator of subsequent deterioration at a site level.

The correlated binomial model in the analysis of clinical diagnostic test parameters for recurrence of periodontitis

In the present study, recall data of 29 patients with advanced periodontitis were utilized to calculate diagnostic test parameters for bleeding scores or increased residual probing depth on increase of periodontal probing depth of > or = 2 mm after 2 years, comparing the simple binomial and correlated binomial model. 5.6% of sites were identified, where the periodontal probing depth increased 2 mm or more during 2 years of maintenance. Within-patient correlation coefficient of sites were found to be small, in general (p < 0.02), with the exceptions for predictive value of a positive test for frequent (> or = 3/4 times) bleeding on probing and residual probing depth of > or = 4 mm (p = 0.137 and p = 0.086, respectively), and specificity for no bleeding (p = 0.151). Point estimates of test parameters generally did not differ between simple binomial and correlated binomial model. The respective standard deviations were either over- or underestimated in the simple binomial model. It was concluded that the suggestion of a limited diagnostic value of bleeding scores or increased residual postoperative probing depth to predict recurrence of periodontitis cannot be rejected after application of a correlated binomial model.