More than meets the eye: The impact of imposter syndrome on feedback receptivity

Identity influences on medical students' orientation to feedback during third year clinical rotations

Medical students' feedback orientation (their attitudes about and preferences for feedback from preceptors) may change over the course of the third year of medical school and is likely influenced by identity-related factors. This study proposed that both how students view themselves personally (i.e., impostor syndrome) and how they view themselves in relation to the group (i.e., identification with the profession) are identity factors related to related to feedback orientation during clinical rotations. 177 third-year medical students enrolled in a four-phase longitudinal survey study beginning at the start of clinical rotations and continuing every twelve weeks of the academic year thereafter. Feedback orientation was conceptualized and measured as comprising aspects of utility (i.e., feedback is valuable and useful), sensitivity (i.e., feeling intimidated or threatened by corrective feedback), confidentiality (i.e., public/private context of feedback), and retention (i.e., feedback remembered). Results indicated that these aspects of feedback orientation did not significantly change during the third year. Instead, impostor syndrome was at least marginally, significantly associated with all aspects of feedback orientation across phases. Group identity was associated with feedback utility and retention, and female-identifying students reported significantly greater feedback confidentiality and feedback retention. Interventions may be needed to improve medical students' attitudes about feedback, particularly for those who experience impostor syndrome. Fostering group cohesion among medical students may influence how well students remember feedback and find it useful.

The prevalence of imposter syndrome and associated factors in Chinese medical students and residents: A single-center pilot study

PURPOSE

Here we aimed to define the prevalence of imposter syndrome (IS) and identify associated characteristics in Chinese medical students and residents enrolled at Peking Union Medical College Hospital (PUMCH).

METHODS

This was a single-center, cross-sectional study of medical students and residents enrolled at PUMCH conducted in September and October 2022. Participants were recruited to complete a 37-question survey on demographics, a Chinese version of the Clance Imposter Phenomenon Scale (CIPS), and self-assessments of anxiety, depression, burnout, sleep quality, challenges of clinical learning, and time allocation. IS prevalence and its associated factors were analyzed.

RESULTS

One hundred and forty-eight medical students and 89 residents completed the survey. IS was significant or severe in 62.8% of medical students and 57.2% of residents. Students enrolled in the eight-year program had significantly higher CIPS scores than those enrolled in the 4 + 4 program (66.4 vs. 60.7, p = .005). There were no gender differences in IS prevalence and severity. Participants with severe IS had significantly higher self-rated anxiety, depression, insomnia, and burnout than participants with mild/moderate IS. Participants significantly challenged by clinical learning had significantly higher CIPS scores.

CONCLUSIONS

IS is both prevalent and severe in Chinese medical students and residents. Classroom learning, an eight-year program, and being challenged by clinical learning are potentially associated with IS.

Supportive learning environments, impression management and 'strategic imposterism': A word of caution

Learning environments are critical to individual growth and expression. While high stakes environments can drive self‐doubt and imposterism, the authors warn that overly comfortable environments may encourage ‘strategic imposterism.’

Investigating feedback orientation in medical learners

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Feedback processes in health professions education (HPE) are not always successful. While recommendations to improve feedback provision dominate the literature, studying specific learner attributes that impact feedback uptake may also improve feedback processes. Feedback orientation is a concept from management science involving four dimensions of learner attributes and attitudes that impact their feedback uptake: utility, accountability, social awareness, and feedback self-efficacy. Feedback orientation may represent a valuable concept in HPE. We aimed to understand medical learners' feedback orientation at different stages in their development.

METHODS

We used the Feedback Orientation Scale, a 20-item survey instrument, for a cross-sectional analysis of feedback orientation in medical students and Internal Medicine residents at one large academic center. We performed descriptive statistics and analysis of variance for data analysis.

RESULTS

We found the same factors (dimensions) to feedback orientation in our population as in management science. Overall feedback orientation scores were high and were largely consistent across trainee levels. Utility was the domain that was highest across learners, whereas feedback self-efficacy was lowest.

CONCLUSIONS

Feedback orientation represents a useful concept to explore medical learners' attitudes toward feedback's role in their development. The four domains can help guide further nuanced feedback research and application.[Box: see text].

Survey Highlighting Impostor Phenomenon (SHIP): Evaluating the Prevalence of Impostor Phenomenon Among Physicians in a Military Treatment Facility

OBJECTIVES

Impostor Phenomenon (IP) describes feelings of distrust in one's own capabilities or accomplishments. This experience exists across many professional settings, affecting men and women across diverse backgrounds. IP has not been studied within a military health system. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of IP among physicians at a military hospital.

METHODS

An online survey was constructed incorporating the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale (CIPS) and demographic data. All physicians at the institution received the survey link via email and the survey remained open for 1 month for completion. Multivariable analysis was performed to identify significant differences among groups as well as characteristics associated with IP. Exploratory factor analysis was used to examine the factor structure of the CIPS.

RESULTS

The response rate was 25% (94/376). Forty-one respondents (44.1%) had CIPS scores ranging between 41 and 60, classifying the respondent as having moderate IP experiences. Differences in scores were noted for age and years of experience (both P < .01). No differences were noted based on gender, self-reported race/ethnicity, or surgical versus nonsurgical specialty. Active-duty respondents had a mean IP score of 62 (SD  =  16) and civilian respondents had a mean IP score of 49 (SD  =  12, P < .01).

CONCLUSION

With nearly half (46.3%) of respondents reporting frequent or intense IP experiences, this study underscores the pervasiveness of the issue and indicates concordance with previously published data. IP is not limited to certain subgroups or gender identity but rather is a common issue which may negatively affect a physician's well-being.

Confidence-competence alignment and the role of self-confidence in medical education: A conceptual review

CONTEXT

There have been significant advances in competency-based medical education (CBME) within health professions education. While most of the efforts have focused on competency, less attention has been paid to the role of confidence as a factor in preparing for practice. This paper seeks to address this deficit by exploring the role of confidence and the calibration of confidence with regard to competence.

METHODS

This paper presents a conceptual review of confidence and the calibration of confidence in different medical education contexts. Building from an initial literature review, the authors engaged in iterative discussions exploring divergent and convergent perspectives, which were then supplemented with targeted literature reviews. Finally, a stakeholder consultation was conducted to situate and validate the provisional findings.

RESULTS

A series of axioms were developed to guide perceptions and responses to different states of confidence in health professionals: (a) confidence can shape how we act and is optimised when it closely corresponds to reality; (b) self-confidence is task-specific, but also inextricably influenced by the individual self-conceptualisation, the surrounding system and society; (c) confidence is shaped by many external factors and the context of the situation; (d) confidence must be considered in conjunction with competence and (e) the confidence-competence ratio (CCR) changes over time. It is important to track learners' CCRs and work with them to maintain balance.

CONCLUSION

Confidence is expressed in different ways and is shaped by a variety of modifiers. While CBME primarily focuses on competency, proportional confidence is an integral component in ensuring safe and professional practice. As such, it is important to consider both confidence and competence, as well as their relationship in CBME. The CCR can serve as a key construct in developing mindful and capable health professionals. Future research should evaluate strategies for assessing CCR, identify best practices for teaching confidence and guiding self-calibration of CCR and explore the role of CCR in continuing professional development for individuals and teams.