Artificial pollen walls simulated by the tandem processes of phase separation and self-assembly in vitro

Mechanisms of pollen wall development in Lysimachia vulgaris

Exine, this complex sporopollenin-containing and highly variable among taxa envelope of the male gametophyte, consists of two layers, ectexine and endexine. We traced in detail the pollen wall development in Lysimachia vulgaris (Primulaceae), with emphasis on driving forces and critical ontogenetic time. By observation on the sequence of the emergent patterns and by analysis of their substructure with TEM, we intended to clarify the obvious and not-obvious ways of exine construction and to find out the common features in pattern development in other representatives in living nature. The ectexine and endexine ontogeny follows the main stages observed in many other species: first, the appearance of microspore plasma membrane invaginations with isotropic contents within, changed later to anisotropic state; then successive appearance of spherical, rod-like, and lamellate units in the periplasmic space. The lamellate endexine appears unusually early in the exine development. All these elements and their aggregations are manifestation of well-known physical phenomena: phase separation and micellar self-assembly. A consideration of similar surface patterns in very remote taxa suggests the participation in their development of some general nature phenomena as the lows of space-filling operations.

Pollen wall development in Impatiens glandulifera: exine substructure and underlying mechanisms

The aim of this study was to investigate in detail the pollen wall ontogeny in Impatiens glandulifera, with emphasis on the substructure and the underlying mechanisms of development. Sporopollenin-containing pollen wall, the exine, consists of two parts, ectexine and endexine. By determining the sequence of developing substructures with TEM, we have in mind to understand in which way the exine substructure is connected with function. We have shown earlier that physical processes of self-assembly and phase separation are universally involved in ectexine development; currently, we try to clear up whether these processes participate in endexine development. The data received were compared with those on other species. The ectexine ontogeny of I. glandulifera followed the main stages observed in many other species, including the late tetrad stage named "Golden gates". It turned out that the same physico-chemical processes act in endexine development, especially expressed in aperture sites. Another peculiar phenomenon observed in exine development was the recurrency of micellar sequence at near-aperture and aperture sites where the periplasmic space is widened. It should be noted that, in the whole, the developmental substructures observed during the tetrad and early post-tetrad period are similar in species with columellate exines. Evidently, these basic physical processes proceed, reiterating again and again in different species, resulting in an enormous variety of exine structures on the base of a relatively modest number of genes. Granular and alveolar exines emerge on the base of the same basic processes but are arrested at spherical and cylindrical micelle mesophases correspondingly.

ZmMS1/ZmLBD30-orchestrated transcriptional regulatory networks precisely control pollen exine development

Because of its significance for plant male fertility and, hence, direct impact on crop yield, pollen exine development has inspired decades of scientific inquiry. However, the molecular mechanism underlying exine formation and thickness remains elusive. In this study, we identified that a previously unrecognized repressor, ZmMS1/ZmLBD30, controls proper pollen exine development in maize. Using an ms1 mutant with aberrantly thickened exine, we cloned a male-sterility gene, ZmMs1, which encodes a tapetum-specific lateral organ boundary domain transcription factor, ZmLBD30. We showed that ZmMs1/ZmLBD30 is initially turned on by a transcriptional activation cascade of ZmbHLH51-ZmMYB84-ZmMS7, and then it serves as a repressor to shut down this cascade via feedback repression to ensure timely tapetal degeneration and proper level of exine. This activation-feedback repression loop regulating male fertility is conserved in maize and sorghum, and similar regulatory mechanism may also exist in other flowering plants such as rice and Arabidopsis. Collectively, these findings reveal a novel regulatory mechanism of pollen exine development by which a long-sought master repressor of upstream activators prevents excessive exine formation.

Ontogenesis in miniature. Pollen wall development in Campanula rapunculoides

MAIN CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest a reconsideration of pollen wall ontogeny process, entailing examination of physical factors, which enable a new understanding of exine developmental processes as self-formation. The pollen wall, the most complex cell wall in plants, is especially interesting as a model of ontogeny in miniature. By a detailed study of each developmental stage of Campanula rapunculoides pollen wall, we aimed to understand the establishment of complex pollen walls and the underlying developmental mechanisms. Other aim was to compare our current observations with studies in other species to reveal the common principles. We also tried to analyse the reasons for commonalities in ontogenies of exines in remote species. TEM, SEM, comparative methods were used in this study. The sequence of events leading to exine emergence from early tetrad stage to maturity is as follows: the appearance of spherical micelles in the periplasmic space and de-mixing of the mixture in periplasm (condensed and depleted layers); appearance of plasma membrane invaginations and columns of spherical micelles inside condensed layer; appearance of rod-like units, pro-tectum and thin foot layer; the appearance of spiral substructure of procolumellae and of dendritic outgrowths on the tops of procolumellae, of vast depleted zone in aperture sites; formation of the endexine lamellae on the base of laminate micelles; gradual twisting of dendritic outgrowths (macromolecule chains) into clubs on the tops of columellae and into spines; final sporopollenin accumulation. Our observations are consistent with the sequence of self-assembling micellar mesophases. Complex organisation of the exine is established through processes of self-assembly operating together with another physical process-phase separation. After genomic determination of the exine building substances, purely physical processes which are not under direct genomic control play an important role after genomic control of constructive substances. The comparison of the underlying mechanisms of exine development in remote species occurred to be general and similar to crystallisation. Our ontogenetic experience has shown the commonality of pollen wall ontogenies in remote species.

Genome-Scale Analysis of the Grapevine KCS Genes Reveals Its Potential Role in Male Sterility

Very long-chain fatty acid (VLCFA) synthesis in plants, is primarily rate-limited by the enzyme 3-ketoacyl CoA synthase (KCS), which also controls the rate and carbon chain length of VLCFA synthesis. Disruption of VLCFA during pollen development, may affect the pollen wall formation and ultimately lead to male sterility. Our study identified 24 grapevine KCS (VvKCS) genes and provided new names based on their relative chromosome distribution. Based on sequence alignment and phylogenetic investigation, these genes were grouped into seven subgroups, members of the same subgroup having similar motif structures. Synteny analysis of VvKCS genes, showed that the segmental duplication events played an important role in expanding this gene family. Expression profiles obtained from the transcriptome data showed different expression patterns of VvKCS genes in different tissues. Comparison of transcriptome and RT-qPCR data of the male sterile grape ‘Y−14’ and its fertile parent ‘Shine Muscat’, revealed that 10 VvKCS genes were significantly differentially expressed at the meiosis stage, which is a critical period of pollen wall formation. Further, joint analysis by weighted gene co-expression network analysis (WGCNA) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG), revealed that five of these VvKCS (VvKCS6/15/19/20/24) genes were involved in the fatty acid elongation pathway, which may ultimately affect the structural integrity of the pollen wall in ‘Y−14’. This systematic analysis provided a foundation for further functional characterization of VvKCS genes, with the aim of grapevine precision breeding improvement.

Pollen wall and tapetal development in Cymbalaria muralis: the role of physical processes, evidenced by in vitro modelling

Our aim was to unravel the underlying mechanisms of pollen wall development in Cymbalaria muralis. By determining the sequence of developing substructures with TEM, we intended to compare it with that of other taxa and clarify whether physical processes of self-assembly and phase separation were involved. In parallel, we tried to simulate in vitro the substructures observed in Cymbalaria muralis exine development, using colloidal mixtures, to determine whether purely physical self-assembly processes could replicate them. Exine ontogeny followed the main stages observed in many other species and was initiated by phase separation, resulting in heterogeneity of the homogeneous contents of the periplasmic space around the microspore which is filled with genome-determined substances. At every stage, phase separation and self-assembly come into force, gradually driving the substances through the sequence of mesophases: spherical micelles, columns of spherical micelles, cylindrical micelles arranged in a layer, laminate micelles. The final two of these mesophases define the structure of the columellate ectexine and lamellate endexine respectively. Structures obtained in vitro from colloidal mixtures simulated the developing exine structures. Striking columella-like surface of some abnormal tapetal cells and lamella-like structures in the anther medium confirm the conclusion that pattern generation is a feature of colloidal materials, after genomic control on material contents. Simulation experiments show the high pattern-generating capacity of colloidal interactions.

Loss of THIN EXINE2 disrupts multiple processes in the mechanism of pollen exine formation

Exine, the sporopollenin-based outer layer of the pollen wall, forms through an unusual mechanism involving interactions between two anther cell types: developing pollen and tapetum. How sporopollenin precursors and other components required for exine formation are delivered from tapetum to pollen and assemble on the pollen surface is still largely unclear. Here, we characterized an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) mutant, thin exine2 (tex2), which develops pollen with abnormally thin exine. The TEX2 gene (also known as REPRESSOR OF CYTOKININ DEFICIENCY1 (ROCK1)) encodes a putative nucleotide-sugar transporter localized to the endoplasmic reticulum. Tapetal expression of TEX2 is sufficient for proper exine development. Loss of TEX2 leads to the formation of abnormal primexine, lack of primary exine elements, and subsequent failure of sporopollenin to correctly assemble into exine structures. Using immunohistochemistry, we investigated the carbohydrate composition of the tex2 primexine and found it accumulates increased amounts of arabinogalactans. Tapetum in tex2 accumulates prominent metabolic inclusions which depend on the sporopollenin polyketide biosynthesis and transport and likely correspond to a sporopollenin-like material. Even though such inclusions have not been previously reported, we show mutations in one of the known sporopollenin biosynthesis genes, LAP5/PKSB, but not in its paralog LAP6/PKSA, also lead to accumulation of similar inclusions, suggesting separate roles for the two paralogs. Finally, we show tex2 tapetal inclusions, as well as synthetic lethality in the double mutants of TEX2 and other exine genes, could be used as reporters when investigating genetic relationships between genes involved in exine formation.

Pollen wall development in Hydrangea bretschneiderii Dippel. (Hydrangeaceae): advanced interpretation through physical input, with in vitro experimental verification

We aimed to unravel the underlying mechanisms of pollen wall development in Hydrangea bretschneiderii. For this, we tested our hypothesis that distinct physical processes, phase separation and micellar self-assembly, underpinned exine development by taking the substances, determined by the genome, through several phase transitions. We traced each developmental stage with TEM; then, we obtained in vitro simulations corresponding to those stages. The main steps of exine ontogeny observed in the microspore periplasmic space were initiated with phase separation, resulting in the conversion of homogeneous contents to heterogeneous two-layered state of the material. After each step of phase, separation self-assembly picked up the initiative and took the substances through the sequence of micellar mesophases which were the base for all the exine structures. These mesophases are as follows: spherical micelles, transforming first into columns, and then to cylindrical micelles which turn to columellae after initial sporopollenin accumulation. The tectum appeared along the interface of the phase separated material. After the tetrad disintegration and the next phase separation, laminate mesophase appeared being the base for the endexine lamellae. Then, a new step of phase separation at aperture sites brought the appearance of a granular endexine layer; the latter became intermixed finally with lamellae. This gives, together with experimental simulation, strong evidence that the genome "shifts a part of work" on exine formation onto physical processes, and the latter are an inherent mechanism of evolution.

Pollen wall patterns as a model for biological self-assembly

We are still far from being able to predict organisms' shapes purely from their genetic codes. While it is imperative to identify which encoded macromolecules contribute to a phenotype, determining how macromolecules self-assemble independently of the genetic code may be equally crucial for understanding shape development. Pollen grains are typically single-celled microgametophytes that have decorated walls of various shapes and patterns. The accumulation of morphological data and a comprehensive understanding of the wall development makes this system ripe for mathematical and physical modeling. Therefore, pollen walls are an excellent system for identifying both the genetic products and the physical processes that result in a huge diversity of extracellular morphologies. In this piece, I highlight the current understanding of pollen wall biology relevant for quantification studies and enumerate the modellable aspects of pollen wall patterning and specific approaches that one may take to elucidate how pollen grains build their beautifully patterned walls.

The Role of Cutinsomes in Plant Cuticle Formation

The cuticle commonly appears as a continuous lipophilic layer located at the outer epidermal cell walls of land plants. Cutin and waxes are its main components. Two methods for cutin synthesis are considered in plants. One that is based on enzymatic biosynthesis, in which cutin synthase (CUS) is involved, is well-known and commonly accepted. The other assumes the participation of specific nanostructures, cutinsomes, which are formed in physicochemical self-assembly processes from cutin precursors without enzyme involvement. Cutinsomes are formed in ground cytoplasm or, in some species, in specific cytoplasmic domains, lipotubuloid metabolons (LMs), and are most probably translocated via microtubules toward the cuticle-covered cell wall. Cutinsomes may additionally serve as platforms transporting cuticular enzymes. Presumably, cutinsomes enrich the cuticle in branched and cross-linked esterified polyhydroxy fatty acid oligomers, while CUS1 can provide both linear chains and branching cutin oligomers. These two systems of cuticle formation seem to co-operate on the surface of aboveground organs, as well as in the embryo and seed coat epidermis. This review focuses on the role that cutinsomes play in cuticle biosynthesis in S. lycopersicum, O. umbellatum and A. thaliana, which have been studied so far; however, these nanoparticles may be commonly involved in this process in different plants.

Lipid Metabolism: Critical Roles in Male Fertility and Other Aspects of Reproductive Development in Plants

Fatty acids and their derivatives are essential building blocks for anther cuticle and pollen wall formation. Disruption of lipid metabolism during anther and pollen development often leads to genic male sterility (GMS). To date, many lipid metabolism-related GMS genes that are involved in the formation of anther cuticle, pollen wall, and subcellular organelle membranes in anther wall layers have been identified and characterized. In this review, we summarize recent progress on characterizing lipid metabolism-related genes and their roles in male fertility and other aspects of reproductive development in plants. On the basis of cloned GMS genes controlling biosynthesis and transport of anther cutin, wax, sporopollenin, and tryphine in Arabidopsis, rice, and maize as well as other plant species, updated lipid metabolic networks underlying anther cuticle development and pollen wall formation were proposed. Through bioinformatics analysis of anther RNA-sequencing datasets from three maize inbred lines (Oh43, W23, and B73), a total of 125 novel lipid metabolism-related genes putatively involved in male fertility in maize were deduced. More, we discuss the pathways regulating lipid metabolism-related GMS genes at the transcriptional and post-transcriptional levels. Finally, we highlight recent findings on lipid metabolism-related genes and their roles in other aspects of plant reproductive development. A comprehensive understanding of lipid metabolism, genes involved, and their roles in plant reproductive development will facilitate the application of lipid metabolism-related genes in gene editing, haploid and callus induction, molecular breeding and hybrid seed production in crops.

Cutin and suberin: assembly and origins of specialized lipidic cell wall scaffolds

Cutin and suberin are hydrophobic lipid biopolyester components of the cell walls of specialized plant tissue and cell-types, where they facilitate adaptation to terrestrial habitats. Many steps in their biosynthetic pathways have been characterized, but the basis of their spatial deposition and precursor trafficking is not well understood. Members of the GDSL lipase/esterase family catalyze cutin polymerization, and candidate proteins have been proposed to mediate interactions between cutin or suberin and other wall components. Comparative genomic studies of charophyte algae and early diverging land plants, combined with knowledge of the biosynthesis, trafficking and assembly mechanisms, suggests an origin for the capacity to secrete waxes, as well as aliphatic and phenolic compounds before the first colonization of true terrestrial habitats.