Medical management of esophageal perforation secondary to esophageal foreign bodies in 5 dogs

Complications associated with and outcome of surgical intervention for treatment of esophageal foreign bodies in dogs

OBJECTIVE

To identify complications associated with and short- and long-term outcomes of surgical intervention for treatment of esophageal foreign bodies (EFBs) in dogs.

ANIMALS

63 client-owned dogs.

PROCEDURES

Patient records from 9 veterinary hospitals were reviewed to identify dogs that underwent surgery for removal of an EFB or treatment or an associated esophageal perforation between 2007 and 2019. Long-term follow-up data were obtained via a client questionnaire.

RESULTS

54 of the 63 (85.7%) dogs underwent surgery after an unsuccessful minimally invasive procedure or subsequent evidence of esophageal perforation was identified. Esophageal perforation was present at the time of surgery in 42 (66.7%) dogs. Most dogs underwent a left intercostal thoracotomy (37/63 [58.7%]). Intraoperative complications occurred in 18 (28.6%) dogs, and 28 (50%) dogs had a postoperative complication. Postoperative complications were minor in 14 of the 28 (50%) dogs. Dehiscence of the esophagotomy occurred in 3 dogs. Forty-seven (74.6%) dogs survived to discharge. Presence of esophageal perforation preoperatively, undergoing a thoracotomy, and whether a gastrostomy tube was placed were significantly associated with not surviving to discharge. Follow-up information was available for 38 of 47 dogs (80.9%; mean follow-up time, 46.5 months). Infrequent vomiting or regurgitation was reported by 5 of 20 (25%) owners, with 1 dog receiving medication.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Results suggested that surgical management of EFBs can be associated with a high success rate. Surgery should be considered when an EFB cannot be removed safely with minimally invasive methods or esophageal perforation is present.

Digital Image Analysis has an Additive Beneficial Role to Conventional Cytology in Diagnosing the Nature of Biliary Ducts Stricture

BACKGROUND & AIM

Conventional cytological evaluation (CCE) fails to identify nature indeterminate biliary duct stricture (IBDS) in many cases. Digital image analysis (DIA) has the ability to identify and analyze the DNA content of cells. This study assesses the role of DIA in recognizing the nature of IBDS compared to CCE.

METHODS

A prospective observational study was conducted at the Al-Rajhi University Hospital. Fifty patients with IBDS, based on abdominal imaging, were subjected to endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) and brush sampling. These samples were evaluated with CCE and DIA. Follow-up for at least 9 months and cost-analysis had also been done.

RESULTS

Based on the final diagnosis, 32 (64.0%) patients had malignant stricture, and 39 (78.0%) had distal stricture. DIA had 84.40% (95% CI; 67.20-94.70) sensitivity and 94.40% (95% CI; 72.70-99.90) specificity in identifying nature of IBDS, whereas CCE had 19.0% (95% CI; 7.20-36.40) sensitivity and 89.0% (95% CI; 65.30-98.60) specificity. Combination of both modalities had 84.40% (95% CI; 67.20-94.70) sensitivity and 83.30% (95% CI; 58.60-96.40) specificity in identification nature of IBDS. Based on CCE alone, only 6/32 (18.80%) of malignant stricture were diagnosed, and 26/32 (81.20%) were missed. However, DIA alone was able to diagnose 27/32 (84.40%) of malignant stricture, and only 5 cases were missed. Both procedures had detection rate of malignant stricture as DIA alone. Benign stricture was correctly diagnosed in 16/18 (88.80%), 17/18 (94.40%), and 15/18 (83.30%) using CCE alone, DIA alone, and both procedures together, respectively. Cost per detection additional one malignant stricture using DIA required 99.4$.

CONCLUSION

DIA is substantially better than CCE in diagnosing the nature of IBDS but at an increase cost and thus suggests its application in a wider role in clinical practice.

CLINICAL TRIAL NUMBER

NCT04112030.

The value of DNA image cytometry combined with brush routine cytology in diagnosing indeterminate biliary strictures: A large sample size retrospective study

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Brush cytology is widely applied to diagnosis indeterminate biliary stricture but suffer from low sensitivity. Changes in DNA content are a character of malignant cell and can be detected by DNA image cytometry (DNA-ICM). The study aimed to estimate the value of routine cytology (RC), DNA-ICM, and their combination in diagnosing indeterminate biliary strictures.

METHODS

A total of 362 patients who underwent both RC and DNA-ICM tests were analysed. Their results were retrospectively applied to final diagnoses. Diagnostic values were compared among RC, DNA-ICM, and their combination based on the location of strictures.

RESULTS

The DNA-ICM and combination of two methods had higher diagnostic accuracy than RC in all strictures (63.3% vs 42.3%, P < 0.001, 64.36% vs 42.3%, P < 0.001) and in distal strictures (65.36% vs 42.81%, P < 0.001, 66.01% vs 42.81%, P < 0.001). But in proximal strictures, DNA-ICM showed no superior (51.8% vs 42.81%, P = 0.184). Combination of two methods was not fully significant superior to RC in proximal strictures (55.36% vs 39.29%, P = 0.089). After classification of "suspicious for malignancy" as positive for malignancy, the diagnostic accuracy of DNA-ICM was still higher than that of RC in all strictures (63.3% vs 51.9%, P = 0.002) and in distal strictures (65.36% vs 52.29%, P = 0.001). Combination of two methods was no superior to DNA-ICM alone (64.36% vs 63.3%, P = 0.757). The utilization of DNA-ICM was more accurate in distal strictures than in proximal strictures (65.36% vs 51.8%, P = 0.017).

CONCLUSION

DNA-ICM is an objective and effective addition tool with RC, especially in distal strictures. The combination of DNA-ICM and RC showed no superior to DNA-ICM alone but could improve diagnostic accuracy to RC in proximal strictures although not fully significant.