A review of diagnostic tests for qualitative and quantitative tear film deficiency in dogs

Development and validation of a method to generate phenol red thread tests

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to develop and validate a method to generate phenol red thread tests (PRTT) due to the lack of availability of commercial PRTT.

METHODS

White cotton thread was dyed with phenol red (pH indicator) for 48 h, dried, cut, and sterilized. To validate its wicking ability, the thread was inserted into solutions of varying pH, flanking the pH of healthy tears, for different time intervals. To assess its diagnostic utility, PRTTs were performed in vivo on wildtype and a murine model of evaporative dry eye, acyl-coA: wax alcohol acyltransferase 2 knockout (Awat2 KO) mice.

RESULTS

Two batches of PRTT were produced that had a similar appearance and function to the commercial product. In vitro testing revealed no significant differences in the wicking kinetics at any time point across the pH solutions for batch 1 and only one difference for batch 2 (pH 7.4 vs 7.8 at 5 s, P = 0.029). When comparing both batches, similar wicking kinetics were found with only two significant differences identified (pH 7.6 at 40 s and pH 7.8 at 35 s, P < 0.01). In vivo, our PRTT yielded similar measurements to the commercial PRTT in wildtype and Awat2 KO mice and detected a significant increase in aqueous tear volume in the Awat2 KO mice (commercial: P = 0.015, our PRTT: P = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

Our method provides a reproducible diagnostic test that performs similarly to its commercial counterpart in a relevant dry eye model indicating that it can serve as a valid and reliable replacement.

Investigation of ocular surface parameters in dogs with different cephalic conformations using veterinary ocular surface analyzer (OSA-VET)

OBJECTIVE

To compare ocular surface parameters in dogs with different cephalic conformations and evaluate correlations among tests.

ANIMALS STUDIED

Sixty-eight privately owned dogs.

PROCEDURES

The study categorized canine eyes into three groups based on the craniofacial ratio (CFR): brachycephaly (≤0.52), mesocephaly (>0.52 to <0.67), and dolichocephaly (≥0.67). All eyes were examined using an ocular surface analyzer (OSA-VET) to determine lipid layer thickness (LLT) of the tear film, tear meniscus height (TMH), non-invasive tear breakup time (NIBUT), and meibomian gland loss rate of the lower eyelids (MGLRL). Schirmer tear test 1 (STT-1) and tear film breakup time (TBUT) were also performed. Statistical analyses involved one-way ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis H test, post hoc Holm-Sidak test, and Pearson correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

While STT-1 showed no significant difference among dog groups, brachycephalic dogs had significantly lower values in TBUT, NIBUT, and LLT, and a higher TMH, compared to mesocephalic and dolichocephalic dogs. Additionally, brachycephalic dogs exhibited a significantly higher MGLRL than dolichocephalic dogs. Correlations among tests were generally weak to moderate (r < .6) except for a strong correlation between CFR and LLT (r = .641, p < .001), and between TBUT and NIBUT (r = .899, p < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Brachycephalic morphology predisposes dogs to a significantly thinner lipid layer and diminished tear film stability, likely due to factors such as impaired meibomian gland function and increased ocular exposure compared to other cephalic conformations, thereby increasing their risk of keratoconjunctivitis sicca (KCS). OSA-VET shows a valuable tool to provide more comprehensive and precise diagnosis for canine ocular surface disorders.

Schirmer tear test-1 with open or closed eyelids: An evaluation in brachycephalic and nonbrachycephalic dogs

PURPOSE

Assess aqueous tear production when measured with the dogs' eyelids open or closed.

METHODS

Thirty healthy dogs (15 Shih Tzus, 15 Labrador retrievers) were recruited. With the order of testing randomized for each dog, two sessions (separated by 30 min) of STT-1 testing were performed with the dogs' eyelids closed or open. Schirmer strip wetness (every 10 s for 60 s) and number of time(s) the strip dislodged during testing were recorded in each eye. Preferred STT-1 method was surveyed via a global Listserv of the veterinary ophthalmology community.

RESULTS

STT-1 values were significantly higher in closed versus open eyes in Shih Tzus (18.6 ± 2.7 mm/min vs. 16.3 ± 2.5 mm/min; p = .002) and Labrador retrievers (21.6 ± 2.9 mm/min vs. 17.8 ± 3.2 mm/min, p < .001), findings that were also significant at times <60 s for either breed (p ≤ .004). Schirmer strips dislodged from six dogs with open eyelids and no dogs with closed eyelids. Maximal STT-1 difference with closed versus open eyelids was 13 mm/min in Labrador retrievers and 7 mm/min in Shih Tzus. Survey results from 275 veterinarians showed STT-1 performed with "closed eyelids" (38.5%), "open eyelids" (26.9%), or "never paid attention, sometimes closed, sometimes open" (34.6%).

CONCLUSIONS

Eyelids status (closed or open) during STT-1 testing had a significant impact on aqueous tear secretion in brachycephalic and nonbrachycephalic dogs, highlighting the importance of consistency when repeating STT-1 in a canine patient. STT-1 differences are likely due to sustained reflex tearing throughout the test duration when the dogs' eyelids are closed.

The Shih Tzu eye: Ophthalmic findings of 1000 eyes

PURPOSE

To evaluate the frequency of ophthalmic disorders in Shih Tzus.

ANIMALS

Five hundred client-owned Shih Tzu dogs (1000 eyes).

PROCEDURES

Medical records of 500 Shih Tzu dogs were reviewed and ophthalmic examination data were collected and analyzed.

RESULTS

In total, out of 1000 eyes, 964 (96.4%; OD: 480 eyes, OS: 484 eyes) had at least one ophthalmic abnormality, and only 36 eyes (3.6%; OD: 20 eyes, OS: 16 eyes) were diagnosed as normal. A total of 1375 individual ophthalmic abnormalities were observed in 964 diseased eyes. Fifty-nine different unique diagnoses were made in the study population, and only three conditions [medial canthal entropion (10.4% of eyes; bilateral in 10.2% of dogs), caruncular trichiasis (21.1% of eyes; bilateral in 20.2% of dogs), and reduced tear film breakup time (17.6% of eyes; bilateral in 17.4% of dogs)] affected 49.1% of the eyes.

CONCLUSION AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Findings suggested that the most prevalent disorders for the Shih Tzus were hairy caruncle, reduced TBUT, medial canthal entropion, keratoconjunctivitis sicca, pigmentary keratitis, lagophthalmos, and mature cataract.

Tear clearance rate in dogs: Measurement using anterior segment optical coherence tomography

OBJECTIVE

The tear clearance rate (TCR), determined using anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) images, and its correlation with ocular surface parameters, including blink rate, Schirmer tear test-1 (STT-1) and tear film breakup time (TFBUT), were evaluated.

ANIMALS STUDIED

Left eyes of 20 client-owned dogs with no ocular disease symptoms.

PROCEDURES

The tear meniscus height (TMH) was evaluated using AS-OCT images before the instillation of 5 μL saline (TMHbase ), immediately post-instillation (TMH0 ), 30-s post-instillation (TMH0.5 ) and at 1 min intervals for 5 min post-instillation (TMH1 , TMH2 , TMH3 , TMH4 and TMH5 ). The TCR was calculated using the formula [(TMH0  - TMH0.5 )/TMH0 ]×100 (%). The eyes were classified into two groups with the median: 'High TMHbase ' (n = 10) and 'Low TMHbase ' (n = 10). Eyes with STT-1 values ≥15 mm/min and TFBUT ≥ 12 s were assigned to the 'Satisfied' subgroup, whereas eyes not satisfying these criteria were assigned to the 'Not satisfied' subgroup.

RESULTS

TMH0 was higher than TMH0.5 (p = 0.02), wherein TMH0.5 to TMH5 did not differ significantly. The TCR and blink rate were negatively correlated (p = 0.02). The 'Not satisfied' subgroup in the low TMHbase group had a lower TCR (p = 0.02) and higher blink rate (p = 0.04) than the 'Satisfied' subgroup.

CONCLUSIONS

TCR can be evaluated using AS-OCT in dogs. Eyes with a lower TCR blink more frequently. TMH merits studying to understand ocular surface health.

Randomized comparison of in vivo performance of TearLab® and I-PEN® osmometry in normal dogs

OBJECTIVE

To compare tear film (TF) osmolarity measured using TearLab® and I-PEN® osmometers in the same dogs without any ocular surface disease.

ANIMAL STUDIED

Fifty-two dogs (98 eyes) of different breeds were evaluated.

PROCEDURES

Tear film (TF) osmolarity was evaluated at 2-min intervals. The test was randomly determined, and single measurements were performed using each osmometer. Subsequently, complete ophthalmologic examinations were performed based on Schirmer tear test-1 (STT-1) analysis, tear film breakup time (TFBUT), and slit-lamp biomicroscopy. For each osmometer, the mean ± standard deviation of the TF osmolarity was calculated, and a paired Student's t-test was used to compare the values obtained. Pearson correlation analysis was performed to assess the association between osmolarity and other values such as STT-1, TFBUT, and age.

RESULTS

Tear film osmolarity determined using TearLab® (340.42 ± 15.87 mOsm/L) and I-PEN® (321.58 ± 17.39 mOsm/L) were significantly different (p < .001). However, statistical significance could not be confirmed between osmolarity and other values, such as STT-1, TFBUT, and age.

CONCLUSIONS

In dogs, the TF osmolarity values obtained using TearLab® tend to be higher than those obtained using I-PEN®, contrary to that observed in humans. These findings can serve as a reference for establishing normal values for each osmometer for clinical use in measuring TF osmolarity in dogs.