A multicentre study investigating vital sign changes occurring in complicated and uncomplicated transfusions

Should adding pain, oxygen saturation and physical assessment to vital signs become the new standard of care for detecting blood transfusion reactions?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Clinicians sought to ascertain what frequency of vital signs best detects blood transfusion reactions. This review discusses early and delayed blood product transfusion reaction detection through the lens of scientific literature.

METHODS

A comprehensive appraisal of published literature was conducted using Integrative Research Review methodology through June 2022 not limited to English or research in Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Cochrane Library of Systematic Reviews, Medline and PubMed.

RESULTS

Full-text articles in the final sample included four articles discussing vital signs detecting blood transfusion reactions and four articles reporting the importance of adding physical assessments for early reaction detection. None of the studies provided evidence regarding how often vital signs should be monitored to detect transfusion reactions. No studies included identical screening components for detecting blood product transfusion reactions. Main themes emerged including variations in what was included in vital signs, importance of respiratory assessment, inclusion of physical assessment, nurse documentation and reporting compliance, and patient and family inclusion in transfusion reaction recognition.

CONCLUSION

Vital sign components varied across reviewed studies. Respiratory rate and pain were not always included in 'vital signs' to identify transfusion reactions. Only low-level data and no clinical trials loosely informing frequency of vital sign monitoring to transfusion reaction detection were found. Respiratory (to include oxygen saturation, lung sounds and respiratory rate) and pain assessment emerged as crucial to acute and delayed transfusion reaction recognition. The disconnect between 'vital signs' and the varied vital sign components reported to detect transfusion reactions in scientific literature requires further exploration.

Early recognition of possible transfusion reactions using an electronic automatic notification system for changes in vital signs in patients undergoing blood transfusions

BACKGROUND

The study was designed to evaluate the ability of a novel electronic automatic notification system (EANS) to detect significant changes in transfusion-associated vital signs (VSs) during transfusion and to determine whether the EANS improved acute transfusion reaction (ATR) detection rates and suspected ATR reporting rates.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

VSs were measured three times per unit or batch product transfused:-before, 15 minutes after commencement, and at the completion of the transfusion-and recorded on the EANS. Significant changes in VSs were defined as increased temperature (≥38°C or ≥1°C change in baseline temperature), 20 mm Hg or 20% increase or decrease in systolic blood pressure, or 20% increase in pulse rate. The 6-month periods preceding and after the introduction of the EANS were defined as "before" and "after." Data from these periods were used for comparison and evaluation.

RESULTS

During the after period, 945 notifications were reported from the EANS and 521 suspected ATR were detected. The suspected ATR reporting rates for the before and after were 0.29% (73/25 213) and 2.06% (521/25 304, P < .001) and the ATR detection rates before and after were 0.13% (33/25 213) and 0.49% (116/25 304, P < .001), respectively. Among 116 ATR cases, 49.1% could be detected only by significant changes in VSs.

CONCLUSION

The EANS was very effective in detecting ATRs that could have been overlooked by medical staff. Further data are needed to demonstrate the extent to which the introduction of an EANS may improve the safety of transfused patients.

Risk factors for hemolytic transfusion reactions resulting from ABO and minor red cell antigen incompatibility: From mislabeled samples to stem cell transplant and sickle cell disease

Advances in laboratory testing, pathogen reduction and donor qualification have dramatically reduced the risk of acquiring an infection from a blood transfusion. Despite this progress, the most feared complication of transfusion - a hemolytic reaction due to incompatibility between donor and recipient - remains, with essentially no recent progress in the prevention or recognition of this rare but frequently lethal complication. Herein, the role that compatibility testing and transfusion practice play in the occurrence of acute hemolysis are described, with a special emphasis on clinical scenarios confer an increased risk of a severe hemolytic reaction in response to red blood cell or platelet transfusion. In addition, the signs and symptoms of a severe hemolytic reaction are summarized, along with the initial approach to clinical management.

A retrospective cost analysis of the frequency and cost of transfusion premedications

BACKGROUND

Acetaminophen and diphenhydramine are routinely administered to prevent febrile non-hemolytic and allergic blood transfusion reactions despite multiple randomized controlled trials demonstrating that this practice lacks efficacy. As a result, patients are exposed to the adverse effects of these medications and their financial burdens with no expected benefit. The aim of this study was to quantify the frequency and cost of transfusion premedications in patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML).

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

This was a retrospective study of patients with AML admitted to Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) for induction chemotherapy between January 2008 and December 2016. Data were collected on the number of platelet and packed red blood cell (PRBC) transfusions each patient received during the initial inpatient encounter for AML, as well as on the administration of premedications prior to each transfusion.

RESULTS

During the 9-year study period, 948 AML patients received a total of 19,820 transfusions. Of these, 30% were preceded by oral diphenhydramine, 8% by intravenous diphenhydramine, and 39% by oral acetaminophen. The percentage of patients that received a transfusion preceded by a premedication increased over the study period (p = 0.03), as did the percentage of transfusions preceded by a premedication (p = 0.02). The total unadjusted cost of pre-transfusion medications to the institution during the study period was $50,309.77, or $52.67 per patient with AML. The cost of premedications per patient did not increase over the study period (p = .45).

CONCLUSIONS

Routine transfusion premedication administration is common in AML patients and not well-supported by available evidence.

Atypical Bacterial Growth within Units of Platelets Challenges Transfusion Medicine Dogma

Although transfusion-transmitted bacterial infection is relatively rare, mitigation of bacterial contamination of platelet units is arguably the top current transfusion-related safety concern. Several different technologies have been employed to detect or neutralize bacteria in platelet concentrates. However, studies of the efficacy of these systems have been hampered by problematic definitions of what represents a "true-positive" versus a "false-positive" culture result. In the current issue of the Journal of Clinical Microbiology (M. Cloutier, M.-È. Nolin, H. Daoud, A. Jacques, M. J. de Grandmont, É Ducas, G. Delage, and L. Thibault, J Clin Microbiol 56:e01105-18, 2018, https://doi.org/10.1128/JCM.01105-18), it was demonstrated that the growth of Bordetella holmesii is inhibited by the platelet storage environment, which may explain why the results of initial positive platelet cultures are not always confirmed by subsequent cultures later during the storage period. This important finding is at odds with the generally held belief within the field of transfusion medicine that initially positive platelet cultures that are not confirmed on repeat testing are instrumentation-based false positives. The clinical risk profile of organisms demonstrating storage-related low viability is worthy of further study.

Irradiation and prolonged storage of red cells are associated with increased adverse events

BACKGROUND

Red blood cell (RBC) transfusion is associated with the most transfusion-related adverse events (AE). Recent clinical studies showed no significant difference in transfusion-associated mortality between fresh and older RBCs. However, the impact of storage duration as well as irradiation on nonfatal yet much more common complications has not been fully investigated.

MATERIALS/METHODS

In this retrospective study of RBC transfusion-associated AEs, a total of 188,562 units of leucocyte-reduced RBCs were transfused in approximately 5·5 years. After excluding washed, deglycerolized, autologous or directed RBCs and RBCs transfused during a massive transfusion protocol, 149,052 units were analysed. Attributes of RBCs including storage time, collection method, CMV serological status and gamma irradiation, as well as the recipient's gender, were analysed. A total of 358 RBC transfusion AEs were categorized into allergic and non-allergic reactions and analysed.

RESULTS

Univariate and multivariate logistic analyses showed that irradiated RBCs were associated with a significantly increased frequency of non-allergic reactions (OR (95% CI): 1·89 (1·52, 2·35); P < 0·001). There was a significant association between the frequency of non-allergic reactions and the storage time of irradiated RBCs (OR (95% CI): 1·024 (1·001, 1·048); P = 0·042). In contrast, there was no association between the frequency of allergic reactions and the storage time of irradiated RBCs or between the age of non-irradiated RBCs and the frequency of non-allergic reactions.

CONCLUSIONS

Prolonged storage of irradiated RBCs was associated with a significant increase in non-allergic transfusion reactions. Overall, the irradiated RBCs appeared to cause more non-allergic reactions compared with non-irradiated RBCs.

Transfusion-associated hazards: A revisit of their presentation

As a therapy or a support to other therapies, despite being largely beneficial to patients in general, transfusion it is not devoid of some risks. In a moderate number of cases, patients may manifest adverse reactions, otherwise referred to as transfusion-associated hazards (TAHs). The latest French 2016 haemovigilance report indicates that 93% of TAHs are minor (grade 1), 5.5% are moderate (grade 2) and 1.6% are severe (grade 3), with only five deaths (grade 4) being attributed to transfusion with relative certainty (imputability of level [or grade] 1 to 3). Health-care providers need to be well aware of the benefits and potential risks (to best evaluate and discuss the benefit-risk ratio), how to prevent TAHs, the overall costs and the availability of alternative therapeutic options. In high-income countries, most blood establishments (BEs) and hospital blood banks (HBBs) have developed tools for reporting and analysing at least severe transfusion reactions. With nearly two decades of haemovigilance, transfusion reaction databases should be quite informative, though there are four main caveats that prevent it from being fully efficient: (ai) reporting is mainly declarative and is thus barely exhaustive even in countries where it is mandatory by law; (aii) it is often difficult to differentiate between the different complications related to transfusion, diseases, comorbidities and other types of therapies in patients suffering from debilitating conditions; (aiii) there is a lack of consistency in the definitions used to describe and report some transfusion reactions, their severity and their likelihood of being related to transfusion; and (aiv) it is difficult to assess the imputability of a particular BC given to a patient who has previously received many BCs over a relatively short period of time. When compiling all available information published so far, it appears that TAHs can be analysed using different approaches: (bi) their pathophysiological nature; (bii) their severity; (biii) the onset scheme; (biv) a quality assessment (preventable or non-preventable); (bv) their impact on ongoing therapy. Moreover, TAHs can be reported either in a non-integrative or in an integrative way; in the latter case, presentation may also differ when issued by a blood establishment or a treating ward. At some point, a recapitulative document would be useful to gain a better understanding of TAHs in order to decrease their occurrence and severity and allow decision makers to determine action plans: this is what this review attempts to make. This review attempts to merge the different aspects, with a focus on the hospital side, i.e., how the most frequent TAHs can be avoided or mitigated.