Reply from David P. Burns, Eric F. Lucking and Ken D. O'Halloran: Auxiliary compensation for diaphragm dysfunction in dystrophic disease

Loss of compensation afforded by accessory muscles of breathing leads to respiratory system compromise in the mdx mouse model of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Despite profound diaphragm weakness, peak inspiratory pressure-generating capacity is preserved in young mdx mice revealing adequate compensation by extra-diaphragmatic muscles of breathing in early dystrophic disease. We hypothesised that loss of compensation gives rise to respiratory system compromise in advanced dystrophic disease. Studies were performed in male wild-type (n = 196) and dystrophin-deficient mdx mice (n = 188) at 1, 4, 8, 12 and 16 months of age. In anaesthetised mice, inspiratory pressure and obligatory and accessory respiratory EMG activities were recorded during baseline and sustained tracheal occlusion for up to 30-40 s to evoke peak system activation to task failure. Obligatory inspiratory EMG activities were lower in mdx mice across the ventilatory range to peak activity, emerging in early dystrophic disease. Early compensation protecting peak inspiratory pressure-generating capacity in mdx mice, which appears to relate to transforming growth factor-β1-dependent fibrotic remodelling of the diaphragm and preserved accessory muscle function, was lost at 12 and 16 months of age. Denervation and surgical lesion of muscles of breathing in 4-month-old mice revealed a greater dependency on diaphragm for peak inspiratory performance in wild-type mice, whereas mdx mice were heavily dependent upon accessory muscles (including abdominal muscles) for peak performance. Accessory EMG activities were generally preserved or enhanced in young mdx mice, but peak EMG activities were lower than wild-type by 12 months of age. In general, ventilation was reasonably well protected in mdx mice until 16 months of age. Despite the early emergence of impairments in the principal obligatory muscles of breathing, peak inspiratory performance is compensated in early dystrophic disease due to diaphragm remodelling and facilitated contribution by accessory muscles of breathing. Loss of compensation afforded by accessory muscles underpins the emergence of respiratory system morbidity in advanced dystrophic disease. KEY POINTS: Despite diaphragm weakness, peak inspiratory performance is preserved in young dystrophin-deficient mdx mice revealing adequate compensation by extra-diaphragmatic muscles. Peak obligatory muscle (diaphragm, external intercostal, and parasternal intercostal) EMG activities are lower in mdx mice, emerging early in dystrophic disease, before the temporal decline in peak performance. Peak EMG activities of some accessory muscles are lower, whereas others are preserved. There is greater recruitment of the trapezius muscle in mdx mice during peak system activation. In phrenicotomised mice with confirmed diaphragm paralysis, there is a greater contribution made by extra-diaphragmatic muscles to peak inspiratory pressure in mdx compared with wild-type mice. Surgical lesion of accessory (including abdominal) muscles adversely affects peak pressure generation in mdx mice. Diaphragm remodelling leading to stiffening provides a mechanical advantage to peak pressure generation via the facilitated action of extra-diaphragmatic muscles in early dystrophic disease. Peak accessory EMG activities are lower in 12-month-old mdx compared to wild-type mice. Peak inspiratory pressure declines in mdx mice with advanced disease. We conclude that compensation afforded by accessory muscles of breathing declines in advanced dystrophic disease precipitating the emergence of respiratory system dysfunction.

N-acetylcysteine Decreases Fibrosis and Increases Force-Generating Capacity of mdx Diaphragm

Respiratory muscle weakness occurs due to dystrophin deficiency in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). The mdx mouse model of DMD shows evidence of impaired respiratory muscle performance with attendant inflammation and oxidative stress. We examined the effects of N-acetylcysteine (NAC) supplementation on respiratory system performance in mdx mice. Eight-week-old male wild type (n = 10) and mdx (n = 20) mice were studied; a subset of mdx (n = 10) received 1% NAC in the drinking water for 14 days. We assessed breathing, diaphragm, and external intercostal electromyogram (EMG) activities and inspiratory pressure during ventilatory and non-ventilatory behaviours. Diaphragm muscle structure and function, cytokine concentrations, glutathione status, and mRNA expression were determined. Diaphragm force-generating capacity was impaired in mdx compared with wild type. Diaphragm muscle remodelling was observed in mdx, characterized by increased muscle fibrosis, immune cell infiltration, and central myonucleation. NAC supplementation rescued mdx diaphragm function. Collagen content and immune cell infiltration were decreased in mdx + NAC compared with mdx diaphragms. The cytokines IL-1β, IL-6 and KC/GRO were increased in mdx plasma and diaphragm compared with wild type; NAC decreased systemic IL-1β and KC/GRO concentrations in mdx mice. We reveal that NAC treatment improved mdx diaphragm force-generating capacity associated with beneficial anti-inflammatory and anti-fibrotic effects. These data support the potential use of NAC as an adjunctive therapy in human dystrophinopathies.