Altered voltage-dependence of slowly activating chloride-proton antiport by late endosomal ClC-6 explains distinct neurological disorders

Gain-of-function variants in CLCN7 cause hypopigmentation and lysosomal storage disease

Together with its β-subunit OSTM1, ClC-7 performs 2Cl-/H+ exchange across lysosomal membranes. Pathogenic variants in either gene cause lysosome-related pathologies, including osteopetrosis and lysosomal storage. CLCN7 variants can cause recessive or dominant disease. Different variants entail different sets of symptoms. Loss of ClC-7 causes osteopetrosis and mostly neuronal lysosomal storage. A recently reported de novo CLCN7 mutation (p.Tyr715Cys) causes widespread severe lysosome pathology (hypopigmentation, organomegaly, and delayed myelination and development, "HOD syndrome"), but no osteopetrosis. We now describe two additional HOD individuals with the previously described p.Tyr715Cys and a novel p.Lys285Thr mutation, respectively. Both mutations decreased ClC-7 inhibition by PI(3,5)P2 and affected residues lining its binding pocket, and shifted voltage-dependent gating to less positive potentials, an effect partially conferred to WT subunits in WT/mutant heteromers. This shift predicts augmented pH gradient-driven Cl- uptake into vesicles. Overexpressing either mutant induced large lysosome-related vacuoles. This effect depended on Cl-/H+-exchange, as shown using mutants carrying uncoupling mutations. Fibroblasts from the p.Y715C patient also displayed giant vacuoles. This was not observed with p.K285T fibroblasts probably due to residual PI(3,5)P2 sensitivity. The gain of function caused by the shifted voltage-dependence of either mutant likely is the main pathogenic factor. Loss of PI(3,5)P2 inhibition will further increase current amplitudes, but may not be a general feature of HOD. Overactivity of ClC-7 induces pathologically enlarged vacuoles in many tissues, which is distinct from lysosomal storage observed with the loss of ClC-7 function. Osteopetrosis results from a loss of ClC-7, but osteoclasts remain resilient to increased ClC-7 activity.

Mutations in CLCN6 as a Novel Genetic Cause of Neuronal Ceroid Lipofuscinosis

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to explore the pathogenesis of CLCN6-related disease and to assess whether its Cl-/H+-exchange activity is crucial for the biological role of ClC-6.

METHODS

We performed whole-exome sequencing on a girl with development delay, intractable epilepsy, behavioral abnormities, retinal dysfunction, progressive brain atrophy, suggestive of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses (NCLs). We generated and analyzed the first knock-in mouse model of a patient variant (p.E200A) and compared it with a Clcn6-/- mouse model. Additional functional tests were performed with heterologous expression of mutant ClC-6.

RESULTS

We identified a de novo heterozygous p.E200A variant in the proband. Expression of disease-causing ClC-6E200A or ClC-6Y553C mutants blocked autophagic flux and activated transcription factors EB (TFEB) and E3 (TFE3), leading to autophagic vesicle and cholesterol accumulation. Such alterations were absent with a transport-deficient ClC-6E267A mutant. Clcn6E200A/+ mice developed severe neurodegeneration with typical features of NCLs. Mutant ClC-6E200A, but not loss of ClC-6 in Clcn6-/- mice, increased lysosomal biogenesis by suppressing mTORC1-TFEB signaling, blocked autophagic flux through impairing lysosomal function, and increased apoptosis. Carbohydrate and lipid deposits accumulated in Clcn6E200A/+ brain, while only lipid storage was found in Clcn6-/- brain. Lysosome dysfunction, autophagy defects, and gliosis were early pathogenic events preceding neuron loss.

INTERPRETATION

CLCN6 is a novel genetic cause of NCLs, highlighting the importance of considering CLCN6 mutations in the diagnostic workup for molecularly undefined forms of NCLs. Uncoupling of Cl- transport from H+ countertransport in the E200A mutant has a dominant effect on the autophagic/lysosomal pathway. ANN NEUROL 2024.

Structural basis of pH-dependent activation in a CLC transporter

CLCs are dimeric chloride channels and anion/proton exchangers that regulate processes such as muscle contraction and endo-lysosome acidification. Common gating controls their activity; its closure simultaneously silences both protomers, and its opening allows them to independently transport ions. Mutations affecting common gating in human CLCs cause dominant genetic disorders. The structural rearrangements underlying common gating are unknown. Here, using single-particle cryo-electron microscopy, we show that the prototypical Escherichia coli CLC-ec1 undergoes large-scale rearrangements in activating conditions. The slow, pH-dependent remodeling of the dimer interface leads to the concerted opening of the intracellular H+ pathways and is required for transport. The more frequent formation of short water wires in the open H+ pathway enables Cl- pore openings. Mutations at disease-causing sites favor CLC-ec1 activation and accelerate common gate opening in the human CLC-7 exchanger. We suggest that the pH activation mechanism of CLC-ec1 is related to the common gating of CLC-7.

Distinct ClC-6 and ClC-7 Cl- sensitivities provide insight into ClC-7's role in lysosomal Cl- homeostasis

ClC-6 and ClC-7 are closely related, intracellular Cl- /H+ antiporters belonging to the CLC family of channels and transporters. They localize to acidic late endosomes and lysosomes and probably function in ionic homeostasis of these contiguous compartments. ClC-7 transport function requires association with the accessory protein Ostm1, whereas ClC-6 transport does not. To elucidate their roles in endo-lysosomes, we measured Cl- - and pH-dependences of over-expressed wild-type ClC-6 and ClC-7, as well as disease-associated mutants, using high-resolution recording protocols. Lowering extracellular Cl- (corresponding to luminal Cl- in endo-lysosomes) reduced ClC-6 currents, whereas it increased transport activity of ClC-7/Ostm1. Low extracellular Cl- activated ClC-7/Ostm 1 under acidic extracellular conditions, as well as under conditions of low intracellular chloride. Activation is conserved in ClC-7Y713C , a variant displaying disrupted PI(3,5)P2 inhibition. Detailed biophysical analysis of disease-associated ClC-6 and ClC-7 gain-of-function (GoF) variants, ClC-6Y553C and ClC-7Y713C , and the ClC-7Y577C and ClC-6Y781C correlates, identified additional functional nuances distinguishing ClC-6 and ClC-7. ClC-7Y577C recapitulated GoF produced by ClC-6Y553C . ClC-6Y781C displayed transport activation qualitatively similar to ClC-7Y713C , although current density did not differ from that of wild-type ClC-6. Finally, rClC-7R760Q , homologous to hClC-7R762Q , an osteopetrosis variant with fast gating kinetics, appeared indifferent to extracellular Cl- , identifying altered Cl- sensitivity as a plausible mechanism underlying disease. Collectively, the present studies underscore the distinct roles of ClC-6 and ClC-7 within the context of their respective localization to late endosomes and lysosomes. In particular, we suggest the atypical inhibition of ClC-7 by luminal Cl- serves to limit excessive intraluminal Cl- accumulation. KEY POINTS: ClC-6 and ClC-7 are late endosomal and lysosomal 2 Cl- /1 H+ exchangers, respectively. When targeted to the plasma membrane, both activate slowly at positive voltages. ClC-6 activity is decreased in low extracellular (i.e. luminal) chloride, whereas ClC-7 is activated by low luminal chloride, even at acidic pH. The functional gain-of-function phenotypes of the ClC-6 and ClC-7 disease mutations ClC-6Y553C and ClC-7Y715C are maintained when introduced in their respective homologues, ClC-7Y577C and ClC-6Y781C , with all mutations retaining chloride dependence of the respective wild type (WT). An osteopetrosis mutation of ClC-7 displaying fast gating kinetics (R762Q) was less sensitive to extracellular chloride compared to WT. The opposing substrate dependences of ClC-6 and ClC-7 Cl- / H+ exchangers point to non-overlapping physiological functions, leading us to propose that inhibition of ClC-7 by luminal chloride and protons serves to prevent osmotic stress imposed by hyper-accumulation of chloride.

Vesicular CLC chloride/proton exchangers in health and diseases

Chloride is one of the most abundant anions in the human body; it is implicated in several physiological processes such as the transmission of action potentials, transepithelial salt transport, maintenance of cellular homeostasis, regulation of osmotic pressure and intracellular pH, and synaptic transmission. The balance between the extracellular and intracellular chloride concentrations is controlled by the interplay of ion channels and transporters embedded in the cellular membranes. Vesicular members of the CLC chloride protein family (vCLCs) are chloride/proton exchangers expressed in the membrane of the intracellular organelles, where they control vesicular acidification and luminal chloride concentration. It is well known that mutations in CLCs cause bone, kidney, and lysosomal genetic diseases. However, the role of CLC exchangers in neurological disorders is only now emerging with the identification of pathogenic CLCN gene variants in patients with severe neuronal and intellectual dysfunctions. This review will provide an overview of the recent advances in understanding the role of the vesicular CLC chloride/proton exchangers in human pathophysiology.

Molecular basis of ClC-6 function and its impairment in human disease

ClC-6 is a late endosomal voltage-gated chloride-proton exchanger that is predominantly expressed in the nervous system. Mutated forms of ClC-6 are associated with severe neurological disease. However, the mechanistic role of ClC-6 in normal and pathological states remains largely unknown. Here, we present cryo-EM structures of ClC-6 that guided subsequent functional studies. Previously unrecognized ATP binding to cytosolic ClC-6 domains enhanced ion transport activity. Guided by a disease-causing mutation (p.Y553C), we identified an interaction network formed by Y553/F317/T520 as potential hotspot for disease-causing mutations. This was validated by the identification of a patient with a de novo pathogenic variant p.T520A. Extending these findings, we found contacts between intramembrane helices and connecting loops that modulate the voltage dependence of ClC-6 gating and constitute additional candidate regions for disease-associated gain-of-function mutations. Besides providing insights into the structure, function, and regulation of ClC-6, our work correctly predicts hotspots for CLCN6 mutations in neurodegenerative disorders.

The chloride antiporter CLCN7 is a modifier of lysosome dysfunction in FIG 4 and VAC14 mutants

The phosphatase FIG 4 and the scaffold protein VAC14 function in the biosynthesis of PI(3,5)P2, a signaling lipid that inhibits the lysosomal chloride transporter ClC-7. Loss-of-function mutations of FIG 4 and VAC14 reduce PI(3,5)P2 and result in lysosomal disorders characterized by accumulation of enlarged lysosomes and neurodegeneration. Similarly, a gain of function mutation of CLCN7 encoding ClC-7 also results in enlarged lysosomes. We therefore tested the ability of reduced CLCN7 expression to compensate for loss of FIG 4 or VAC14. Knock-out of CLCN7 corrected lysosomal swelling and partially corrected lysosomal hyperacidification in FIG 4 null cell cultures. Knockout of the related transporter CLCN6 (ClC-6) in FIG 4 null cells did not affect the lysosome phenotype. In the Fig 4 null mouse, reduction of ClC-7 by expression of the dominant negative CLCN7 variant p.Gly215Arg improved growth and neurological function and increased lifespan by 20%. These observations demonstrate a role for the CLCN7 chloride transporter in pathogenesis of FIG 4 and VAC14 disorders. Reduction of CLCN7 provides a new target for treatment of FIG 4 and VAC14 deficiencies that lack specific therapies, such as Charcot-Marie-Tooth Type 4J and Yunis-Varón syndrome.

Biophysical Aspects of Neurodegenerative and Neurodevelopmental Disorders Involving Endo-/Lysosomal CLC Cl-/H+ Antiporters

Endosomes and lysosomes are intracellular vesicular organelles with important roles in cell functions such as protein homeostasis, clearance of extracellular material, and autophagy. Endolysosomes are characterized by an acidic luminal pH that is critical for proper function. Five members of the gene family of voltage-gated ChLoride Channels (CLC proteins) are localized to endolysosomal membranes, carrying out anion/proton exchange activity and thereby regulating pH and chloride concentration. Mutations in these vesicular CLCs cause global developmental delay, intellectual disability, various psychiatric conditions, lysosomal storage diseases, and neurodegeneration, resulting in severe pathologies or even death. Currently, there is no cure for any of these diseases. Here, we review the various diseases in which these proteins are involved and discuss the peculiar biophysical properties of the WT transporter and how these properties are altered in specific neurodegenerative and neurodevelopmental disorders.

Functional and clinical studies reveal pathophysiological complexity of CLCN4-related neurodevelopmental condition

Missense and truncating variants in the X-chromosome-linked CLCN4 gene, resulting in reduced or complete loss-of-function (LOF) of the encoded chloride/proton exchanger ClC-4, were recently demonstrated to cause a neurocognitive phenotype in both males and females. Through international clinical matchmaking and interrogation of public variant databases we assembled a database of 90 rare CLCN4 missense variants in 90 families: 41 unique and 18 recurrent variants in 49 families. For 43 families, including 22 males and 33 females, we collated detailed clinical and segregation data. To confirm causality of variants and to obtain insight into disease mechanisms, we investigated the effect on electrophysiological properties of 59 of the variants in Xenopus oocytes using extended voltage and pH ranges. Detailed analyses revealed new pathophysiological mechanisms: 25% (15/59) of variants demonstrated LOF, characterized by a "shift" of the voltage-dependent activation to more positive voltages, and nine variants resulted in a toxic gain-of-function, associated with a disrupted gate allowing inward transport at negative voltages. Functional results were not always in line with in silico pathogenicity scores, highlighting the complexity of pathogenicity assessment for accurate genetic counselling. The complex neurocognitive and psychiatric manifestations of this condition, and hitherto under-recognized impacts on growth, gastrointestinal function, and motor control are discussed. Including published cases, we summarize features in 122 individuals from 67 families with CLCN4-related neurodevelopmental condition and suggest future research directions with the aim of improving the integrated care for individuals with this diagnosis.