The contemporary design of endovascular aneurysm stent-graft materials: PTFE versus polyester

Endovascular aneurysm repair of the abdominal aorta (EVAR) and of the thoracic aorta (TEVAR) have revolutionised therapeutic strategies in the management of aortic pathology, and endovascular repair is now an established and attractive alternative to open surgical repair (OSR) due to its superior short-term safety profile. However, opinions are divided regarding its long-term cost-effectiveness, which is reflected in the controversial NICE guidelines on abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair published in 2018, which advised against EVAR for elective aortic repair due to high secondary intervention rates and resultant associated costs. There is no doubt that OSR continues to have a valuable role to play in aortic repair, but it is not universally applicable, especially in older and sicker patients. Therefore, we should not dismiss EVAR and TEVAR without examining the reasons for long-term failure, and the most obvious starting point is stent graft material properties. Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and polyester are the two most common stent-graft materials; however, there has been no objective comparison of PTFE and polyester stent-graft post-procedural outcomes in EVAR and TEVAR, or even OSR. This lack of definitive data on different stent-graft materials and their configuration necessitates a comprehensive review to elucidate the post-procedural outcome in terms of endograft failure, cardiovascular events, and aortic-related mortality and morbidity.

Evaluation and verification of patient-specific modelling of type B aortic dissection

Quantitative assessment of the complex hemodynamic environment in type B aortic dissection (TBAD) through computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations can provide detailed insights into the disease and its progression. As imaging and computational technologies have advanced, methodologies have been developed to increase the accuracy and physiological relevance of CFD simulations. This study presents a patient-specific workflow to simulate blood flow in TBAD, utilising the maximum amount of in vivo data available in the form of CT images, 4D-flow MRI and invasive Doppler-wire pressure measurements, to implement the recommended current best practice methodologies in terms of patient-specific geometry and boundary conditions. The study aimed to evaluate and verify this workflow through detailed qualitative and quantitative comparisons of the CFD and in vivo data. Based on data acquired from five TBAD patients, a range of essential model inputs was obtained, including inlet flow waveforms and 3-element Windkessel model parameters, which can be utilised in further studies where in vivo flow data is not available. Local and global analysis showed good consistency between CFD results and 4D-MRI data, with the maximum velocity in the primary entry tear differing by up to 0.3 m/s, and 80% of the analysed regions achieving moderate or strong correlations between the predicted and in vivo velocities. CFD predicted pressures were generally well matched to the Doppler-wire measurements, with some deviation in peak systolic values. Overall, this study presents a validated comprehensive workflow with extensive data for CFD simulation of TBAD.

Influence of shape-memory stent grafts on local aortic compliance

The effect of repair techniques on the biomechanics of the aorta is poorly understood, resulting in significant levels of postoperative complications for patients worldwide. This study presents a computational analysis of the influence of Nitinol-based devices on the biomechanical performance of a healthy patient-specific human aorta. Simulations reveal that Nitinol stent-grafts stretch the artery wall so that collagen is stretched to a straightened high-stiffness configuration. The high-compliance regime (HCR) associated with low diastolic lumen pressure is eliminated, and the artery operates in a low-compliance regime (LCR) throughout the entire cardiac cycle. The slope of the lumen pressure–area curve for the LCR post-implantation is almost identical to that of the native vessel during systole. This negligible change from the native LCR slope occurs because the stent-graft increases its diameter from the crimped configuration during deployment so that it reaches a low-stiffness unloading plateau. The effective radial stiffness of the implant along this unloading plateau is negligible compared to the stiffness of the artery wall. Provided the Nitinol device unloads sufficiently during deployment to the unloading plateau, the degree of oversizing has a negligible effect on the pressure–area response of the vessel, as each device exerts approximately the same radial force, the slope of which is negligible compared to the LCR slope of the native artery. We show that 10% oversizing based on the observed diastolic diameter in the mid descending thoracic aorta results in a complete loss of contact between the device and the wall during systole, which could lead to an endoleak and stent migration. 20% oversizing reaches the Dacron enforced area limit (DEAL) during the pulse pressure and results in an effective zero-compliance in the later portion of systole.

Development of an FEA framework for analysis of subject-specific aortic compliance based on 4D flow MRI

This paper presents a subject-specific in-silico framework in which we uncover the relationship between the spatially varying constituents of the aorta and the non-linear compliance of the vessel during the cardiac cycle uncovered through our MRI investigations. A microstructurally motivated constitutive model is developed, and simulations reveal that internal vessel contractility, due to pre-stretched elastin and actively generated smooth muscle cell stress, must be incorporated, along with collagen strain stiffening, in order to accurately predict the non-linear pressure-area relationship observed in-vivo. Modelling of elastin and smooth muscle cell contractility allows for the identification of the reference vessel configuration at zero-lumen pressure, in addition to accurately predicting high- and low-compliance regimes under a physiological range of pressures. This modelling approach is also shown to capture the key features of elastin digestion and SMC activation experiments. The volume fractions of the constituent components of the aortic material model were computed so that the in-silico pressure-area curves accurately predict the corresponding MRI data at each location. Simulations reveal that collagen and smooth muscle volume fractions increase distally, while elastin volume fraction decreases distally, consistent with reported histological data. Furthermore, the strain at which collagen transitions from low to high stiffness is lower in the abdominal aorta, again supporting the histological finding that collagen waviness is lower distally. The analyses presented in this paper provide new insights into the heterogeneous structure-function relationship that underlies aortic biomechanics. Furthermore, this subject-specific MRI/FEA methodology provides a foundation for personalised in-silico clinical analysis and tailored aortic device development. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This study provides a significant advance in in-silico medicine by capturing the structure/function relationship of the subject-specific human aorta presented in our previous MRI analyses. A physiologically based aortic constitutive model is developed, and simulations reveal that internal vessel contractility must be incorporated, along with collagen strain stiffening, to accurately predict the in-vivo non-linear pressure-area relationship. Furthermore, this is the first subject-specific model to predict spatial variation in the volume fractions of aortic wall constituents. Previous studies perform phenomenological hyperelastic curve fits to medical imaging data and ignore the prestress contribution of elastin, collagen, and SMCs and the associated zero-pressure reference state of the vessel. This novel MRI/FEA framework can be used as an in-silico diagnostic tool for the early stage detection of aortic pathologies.