Heartbeat optical coherence elastography: corneal biomechanics in vivo

Dynamic evaluation of corneal cross-linking and osmotic diffusion effects using optical coherence elastography

Dynamic deformation events induced by osmosis or photochemical stiffening substantially influence geometrical and mechanical assessments in post-mortem corneas, therefore need to be carefully monitored in experimental settings. In this study, we employed optical coherence elastography (OCE) to quantify dynamic deformation processes at high resolution in freshly enucleated porcine corneas. Osmotic effects were studied by immerging n = 9 eyes in preservation media of three different tonicities. Dynamic processes underlying corneal cross-linking (CXL) were studied by subjecting n = 6 eyes to standard Dresden treatment, while three control groups were used. The entire procedures were performed under an OCE setup during up to 80 min, acquiring a volumetric scan every 20 s. Changes in OCE-derived axial deformations were incrementally calculated between consecutive scans. Preservation conditions had a strong influence on the observed strain patterns, which were consistent with the tonicity of the medium (swelling in hypotonic, deswelling in hypertonic environment). In the CXL group, we observed deswelling of the anterior stroma 10 min after starting the UV irradiation, which was not observed in any control group (p = 0.007). The presented results proved OCE to be a valuable technique to quantify subtle dynamic biomechanical alterations in the cornea resulting from CXL and preservation solutions.

In-vivo characterization of scleral rigidity in myopic eyes using fundus-pulsation optical coherence elastography

The sclera plays an important role in the structural integrity of the eye. However, as myopia progresses, the elongation of the eyeball exerts stretching forces on the posterior sclera, which typically happens in conjunction with scleral remodeling that causes rigidity loss. These biomechanical alterations can cause localized eyeball deformation and vision impairment. Therefore, monitoring scleral rigidity is clinically important for the management and risk assessment of myopia. In this study, we propose fundus pulsation optical coherence elastography (FP-OCE) to characterize posterior scleral rigidity in living humans. This methodology is based on a choroidal pulsation model, where the scleral rigidity is inversely associated with the choroidal max strain obtained through phase-sensitive optical coherence tomography (PhS-OCT) measurement of choroidal deformation and thickness. Using FP-OCE, we conducted a pilot clinical study to explore the relationship between choroidal strain and myopia severity. The results revealed a significant increase in choroidal max strain in pathologic myopia, indicating a critical threshold beyond which scleral rigidity decreases significantly. Our findings offer a potential new method for monitoring myopia progression and evaluating therapies that alter scleral mechanical properties.

Optical coherence elastography measures the biomechanical properties of the ex vivo porcine cornea after LASIK

Significance

The biomechanical impact of refractive surgery has long been an area of investigation. Changes to the cornea structure cause alterations to its mechanical integrity, but few studies have examined its specific mechanical impact.

Aim

To quantify how the biomechanical properties of the cornea are altered by laser assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) using optical coherence elastography (OCE) in ex vivo porcine corneas.

Approach

Three OCE techniques, wave-based air-coupled ultrasound (ACUS) OCE, heartbeat (Hb) OCE, and compression OCE were used to measure the mechanical properties of paired porcine corneas, where one eye of the pair was left untreated, and the fellow eye underwent LASIK. Changes in stiffness as a function of intraocular pressure (IOP) before and after LASIK were measured using each technique.

Results

ACUS-OCE showed that corneal stiffness changed as a function of IOP for both the untreated and the treated groups. The elastic wave speed after LASIK was lower than before LASIK. Hb-OCE and compression OCE showed regional changes in corneal strain after LASIK, where the absolute strain difference between the cornea anterior and posterior increased after LASIK.

Conclusions

The results of this study suggest that LASIK may soften the cornea and that these changes are largely localized to the region where the surgery was performed.

Optomechanical assessment of photorefractive corneal cross-linking via optical coherence elastography

Purpose: Corneal cross-linking (CXL) has recently been used with promising results to positively affect corneal refractive power in the treatment of hyperopia and mild myopia. However, understanding and predicting the optomechanical changes induced by this procedure are challenging. Methods: We applied ambient pressure modulation based optical coherence elastography (OCE) to quantify the refractive and mechanical effects of patterned CXL and their relationship to energy delivered during the treatment on porcine corneas. Three different patterned treatments were performed, designed according to Zernike polynomial functions (circle, astigmatism, coma). In addition, three different irradiation protocols were analyzed: standard Dresden CXL (fluence of 5.4 J/cm2), accelerated CXL (fluence of 5.4 J/cm2), and high-fluence CXL (fluence of 16.2 J/cm2). The axial strain distribution in the stroma induced by ocular inflation (Δp = 30 mmHg) was quantified, maps of the anterior sagittal curvature were constructed and cylindrical refraction was assessed. Results: Thirty minutes after CXL, there was a statistically significant increase in axial strain amplitude (p < 0.050) and a reduction in sagittal curvature (p < 0.050) in the regions treated with all irradiation patterns compared to the non-irradiated ones. Thirty-6 hours later, the non-irradiated regions showed compressive strains, while the axial strain in the CXL-treated regions was close to zero, and the reduction in sagittal curvature observed 30 minutes after the treatment was maintained. The Dresden CXL and accelerated CXL produced comparable amounts of stiffening and refractive changes (p = 0.856), while high-fluence CXL produced the strongest response in terms of axial strain (6.9‰ ± 1.9‰) and refractive correction (3.4 ± 0.9 D). Tripling the energy administered during CXL resulted in a 2.4-fold increase in the resulting refractive correction. Conclusion: OCE showed that refractive changes and alterations in corneal biomechanics are directly related. A patient-specific selection of both, the administered UV fluence and the irradiation pattern during CXL is promising to allow customized photorefractive corrections in the future.

Recent advances in optical elastography and emerging opportunities in the basic sciences and translational medicine [Invited]

Optical elastography offers a rich body of imaging capabilities that can serve as a bridge between organ-level medical elastography and single-molecule biophysics. We review the methodologies and recent developments in optical coherence elastography, Brillouin microscopy, optical microrheology, and photoacoustic elastography. With an outlook toward maximizing the basic science and translational clinical impact of optical elastography technologies, we discuss potential ways that these techniques can integrate not only with each other, but also with supporting technologies and capabilities in other biomedical fields. By embracing cross-modality and cross-disciplinary interactions with these parallel fields, optical elastography can greatly increase its potential to drive new discoveries in the biomedical sciences as well as the development of novel biomechanics-based clinical diagnostics and therapeutics.

Co-axial acoustic-based optical coherence vibrometry probe for the quantification of resonance frequency modes in ocular tissue

We present a co-axial acoustic-based optical coherence vibrometry probe (CoA-OCV) for vibro-acoustic resonance quantification in biological tissues. Sample vibrations were stimulated via a loudspeaker, and pre-compensation was used to calibrate the acoustic spectrum. Sample vibrations were measured via phase-sensitive swept-source optical coherence tomography (OCT). Resonance frequencies of corneal phantoms were measured at varying intraocular pressures (IOP), and dependencies on Young´s Modulus (E), phantom thickness and IOP were observed. Cycling IOP revealed hysteresis. For E = 0.3 MPa, resonance frequencies increased with IOP at a rate of 3.9, 3.7 and 3.5 Hz/mmHg for varied thicknesses and 1.7, 2.5 and 2.8 Hz/mmHg for E = 0.16 MPa. Resonance frequencies increased with thickness at a rate of 0.25 Hz/µm for E = 0.3 MPa, and 0.40 Hz/µm for E = 0.16 MPa. E showed the most predominant impact in the shift of the resonance frequencies. Full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the resonance modes increased with increasing thickness and decreased with increasing E. Only thickness and E contributed to the variance of FWHM. In rabbit corneas, resonance frequencies of 360-460 Hz were observed. The results of the current study demonstrate the feasibility of CoA-OCV for use in future OCT-V studies.

Multiple Optical Elastography Techniques Reveal the Regulation of Corneal Stiffness by Collagen XII

Purpose

Collagen XII plays a role in regulating the structure and mechanical properties of the cornea. In this work, several optical elastography techniques were used to investigate the effect of collagen XII deficiency on the stiffness of the murine cornea.

Methods

A three-prong optical elastography approach was used to investigate the mechanical properties of the cornea. Brillouin microscopy, air-coupled ultrasonic optical coherence elastography (OCE) and heartbeat OCE were used to assess the mechanical properties of wild type (WT) and collagen XII-deficient (Col12a1-/-) murine corneas. The Brillouin frequency shift, elastic wave speed, and compressive strain were all measured as a function of intraocular pressure (IOP).

Results

All three optical elastography modalities measured a significantly decreased stiffness in the Col12a1-/- compared to the WT (P < 0.01 for all three modalities). The optical coherence elastography techniques showed that mean stiffness increased as a function of IOP; however, Brillouin microscopy showed no discernable trend in Brillouin frequency shift as a function of IOP.

Conclusions

Our approach suggests that the absence of collagen XII significantly softens the cornea. Although both optical coherence elastography techniques showed an expected increase in corneal stiffness as a function of IOP, Brillouin microscopy did not show such a relationship, suggesting that the Brillouin longitudinal modulus may not be affected by changes in IOP. Future work will focus on multimodal biomechanical models, evaluating the effects of other collagen types on corneal stiffness, and in vivo measurements.

High-frequency ultrasound detects biomechanical weakening in keratoconus with lower stiffness at higher grade

In vivo biomechanical characterization of the cornea remains a challenge. We have developed a high-frequency ultrasound elastography method, the ocular pulse elastography (OPE), to measure corneal axial displacement (CAD) induced by the ocular pulse. Here we compared CAD and a stiffness index derived from CAD between keratoconus patients and normal controls. We also explored the trend of these parameters with keratoconus grade. Twenty normal subjects and twenty keratoconus patients were recruited in this study. Corneal topography, tomography, intraocular pressure (IOP) and ocular pulse amplitude (OPA) were obtained in each measured eye. The cornea’s heartbeat-induced cyclic axial displacements were measured by high-frequency (50 MHz) ultrasound. A corneal stiffness index (CSI) was derived from CAD normalized against OPA. CAD and CSI were compared between normal and keratoconus groups, and across keratoconus grades. Keratoconus corneas had significantly greater CAD and lower CSI than normal controls (p’s<0.01). Both parameters correlated strongly with grade, in which CAD increased significantly (p = 0.002) and CSI decreased significantly (p = 0.011) with grade. These results suggested a biomechanical weakening in keratoconus which worsens at higher disease severity. This study also demonstrated the ability of high-frequency ultrasound elastography to provide a safe, quick, and accurate evaluation of the cornea’s biomechanical condition in vivo. The OPE-measured biomechanical metrics, when integrated with existing diagnostic criteria, may aid the decision-making in the early and definitive diagnosis and staging of keratoconus.

Multimodal Heartbeat and Compression Optical Coherence Elastography for Mapping Corneal Biomechanics

The biomechanical properties of the cornea have a profound influence on the health, structural integrity, and function of the eye. Understanding these properties may be critical for diagnosis and identifying disease pathogenesis. This work demonstrates how two different elastography techniques can be combined for a multimodal approach to measuring corneal biomechanical properties. Heartbeat optical coherence elastography (Hb-OCE) and compression OCE were performed simultaneously to measure the stiffness of the cornea in an in vivo rabbit model. Measurements were further performed after collagen crosslinking to demonstrate how the combined technique can be used to measure changes in corneal stiffness and map mechanical contrast. The results of this work further suggest that measurements from Hb-OCE and compression OCE are comparable, meaning that Hb-OCE and compression OCE may be used interchangeably despite distinct differences in both techniques.

Analysis of strain estimation methods in phase-sensitive compression optical coherence elastography

In compression optical coherence elastography (OCE), deformation is quantified as the local strain at each pixel in the OCT field-of-view. A range of strain estimation methods have been demonstrated, yet it is unclear which method provides the best performance. Here, we analyze the two most prevalent strain estimation methods used in phase-sensitive compression OCE, i.e., weighted least squares (WLS) and the vector method. We introduce a framework to compare strain imaging metrics, incorporating strain sensitivity, strain signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), strain resolution, and strain accuracy. In addition, we propose a new phase unwrapping algorithm in OCE, fast phase unwrapping (FPU), and combine it with WLS, termed WLS_FPU. Using the framework, we compare this new strain estimation method with both a current implementation of WLS that incorporates weighted phase unwrapping (WPU), termed WLS_WPU, and the vector method. Our analysis reveals that the three methods provide similar strain sensitivity, strain SNR, and strain resolution, but that WLS_FPU extends the dynamic range of accurate, measurable local strain, e.g., measuring a strain of 2.5 mɛ with ∼4% error, that is ×11 and ×15 smaller than the error measured using WLS_WPU and the vector method, respectively. We also demonstrate, for the first time, the capability to detect sub-resolution contrast in compression OCE, i.e., changes in strain occurring within the strain axial resolution, and how this contrast varies between the different strain estimation methods. Lastly, we compare the performance of the three strain estimation methods on mouse skeletal muscle and human breast tissue and demonstrate that WLS_FPU avoids strain imaging artifacts resulting from phase unwrapping errors in WLS_WPU and provides improved contrast over the other two methods.

Introduction to optical coherence elastography: tutorial

Optical coherence elastography (OCE) has seen rapid growth since its introduction in 1998. The past few decades have seen tremendous advancements in the development of OCE technology and a wide range of applications, including the first clinical applications. This tutorial introduces the basics of solid mechanics, which form the foundation of all elastography methods. We then describe how OCE measurements of tissue motion can be used to quantify tissue biomechanical parameters. We also detail various types of excitation methods, imaging systems, acquisition schemes, and data processing algorithms and how various parameters associated with each step of OCE imaging can affect the final quantitation of biomechanical properties. Finally, we discuss the future of OCE, its potential, and the next steps required for OCE to become an established medical imaging technology.

Pulsatile tissue deformation dynamics of the murine retina and choroid mapped by 4D optical coherence tomography

Irregular ocular pulsatility and altered mechanical tissue properties are associated with some of the most sight-threatening eye diseases. Here we present 4D optical coherence tomography (OCT) for the quantitative assessment and depth-resolved mapping of pulsatile dynamics in the murine retina and choroid. Through a pixel-wise analysis of phase changes of the complex OCT signal, we reveal spatiotemporal displacement characteristics across repeated frame acquisitions. We demonstrate in vivo fundus elastography (FUEL) imaging in wildtype mouse retinas and in a mouse model of retinal neovascularization and uncover subtle structural deformations related to ocular pulsation. Our data in mouse eyes hold promise for a powerful retinal elastography technique that may enable a new paradigm of OCT-based measurements and image contrast.

Temporal phase evolution OCT for measurement of tissue deformation in the human retina in-vivo

We demonstrate the use of temporal phase evolution (TPE-) OCT methods to evaluate retinal tissue deformation in-vivo over time periods of several seconds. A custom built spectral domain (SD)-OCT system with an integrated retinal tracker, ensuring stable imaging with sub-speckle precision, was used for imaging. TPE-OCT measures and images phase differences between an initial reference B-scan and each of the subsequent B-scans of the evaluated temporal sequence. In order to demonstrate the precision and repeatability of the measurements, retinal nerve fiber (RNF) tissue deformations induced by retinal vessels pulsating with the heartbeat were analyzed in several healthy subjects. We show TPE maps (M-scans of phase evolution as a function of position along B-scan trace vs. time) of wrapped phase data and corresponding deformation maps in selected regions of the RNF layer (RNFL) over the course of several cardiac cycles. A reproducible phase pattern is seen at each heartbeat cycle for all imaged volunteers. RNF tissue deformations near arteries and veins up to ∼ 1.6 µm were obtained with an average precision for a single pixel of about 30 nm. Differences of motion induced by arteries and veins are also investigated.

Enhanced medical diagnosis for dOCTors: a perspective of optical coherence tomography

SIGNIFICANCE

After three decades, more than 75,000 publications, tens of companies being involved in its commercialization, and a global market perspective of about USD 1.5 billion in 2023, optical coherence tomography (OCT) has become one of the fastest successfully translated imaging techniques with substantial clinical and economic impacts and acceptance.

AIM

Our perspective focuses on disruptive forward-looking innovations and key technologies to further boost OCT performance and therefore enable significantly enhanced medical diagnosis.

APPROACH

A comprehensive review of state-of-the-art accomplishments in OCT has been performed.

RESULTS

The most disruptive future OCT innovations include imaging resolution and speed (single-beam raster scanning versus parallelization) improvement, new implementations for dual modality or even multimodality systems, and using endogenous or exogenous contrast in these hybrid OCT systems targeting molecular and metabolic imaging. Aside from OCT angiography, no other functional or contrast enhancing OCT extension has accomplished comparable clinical and commercial impacts. Some more recently developed extensions, e.g., optical coherence elastography, dynamic contrast OCT, optoretinography, and artificial intelligence enhanced OCT are also considered with high potential for the future. In addition, OCT miniaturization for portable, compact, handheld, and/or cost-effective capsule-based OCT applications, home-OCT, and self-OCT systems based on micro-optic assemblies or photonic integrated circuits will revolutionize new applications and availability in the near future. Finally, clinical translation of OCT including medical device regulatory challenges will continue to be absolutely essential.

CONCLUSIONS

With its exquisite non-invasive, micrometer resolution depth sectioning capability, OCT has especially revolutionized ophthalmic diagnosis and hence is the fastest adopted imaging technology in the history of ophthalmology. Nonetheless, OCT has not been completely exploited and has substantial growth potential-in academics as well as in industry. This applies not only to the ophthalmic application field, but also especially to the original motivation of OCT to enable optical biopsy, i.e., the in situ imaging of tissue microstructure with a resolution approaching that of histology but without the need for tissue excision.

Compressional Optical Coherence Elastography of the Cornea

Assessing the biomechanical properties of the cornea is crucial for detecting the onset and progression of eye diseases. In this work, we demonstrate the application of compression-based optical coherence elastography (OCE) to measure the biomechanical properties of the cornea under various conditions, including validation in an in situ rabbit model and a demonstration of feasibility for in vivo measurements. Our results show a stark increase in the stiffness of the corneas as IOP was increased. Moreover, UV-A/riboflavin corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL) also dramatically increased the stiffness of the corneas. The results were consistent across 4 different scenarios (whole CXL in situ, partial CXL in situ, whole CXL in vivo, and partial CXL in vivo), emphasizing the reliability of compression OCE to measure corneal biomechanical properties and its potential for clinical applications.