Noise aliasing in interline-video-based fluoroscopy systems

Understanding Image Resolution and Quality in Videofluoroscopy

Current best practice recommendations for videofluoroscopic swallowing studies (VFSS) suggest that fluoroscopy should be performed either on a continuous setting or at 30 pulses per second (pps). Image capture should likewise be set to maximum resolution (i.e., 30 frames per second [fps]). In this article, we discuss choices in technical settings that may result in the output of fewer than 30 unique images per second or result in image distortions. We also describe a test that can be used to confirm image capture quality and rate using an analog metronome. Clinicians and researchers need to be aware of these issues and the limitations they bring to videofluoroscopy review and analysis.

A spatio-temporal detective quantum efficiency and its application to fluoroscopic systems

PURPOSE

Fluoroscopic x-ray imaging systems are used extensively in spatio-temporal detection tasks and require a spatio-temporal description of system performance. No accepted metric exists that describes spatio-temporal fluoroscopic performance. The detective quantum efficiency (DQE) is a metric widely used in radiography to quantify system performance and as a surrogate measure of patient "dose efficiency". It has been applied previously to fluoroscopic systems with the introduction of a temporal correction factor. However, the use of a temporally-corrected DQE does not provide system temporal information and it is only valid under specific conditions, many of which are not likely to be satisfied by suboptimal systems. The authors propose a spatio-temporal DQE that describes performance in both space and time and is applicable to all spatio-temporal quantum-based imaging systems.

METHODS

The authors define a spatio-temporal DQE (two spatial-frequency axes and one temporal-frequency axis) in terms of a small-signal spatio-temporal modulation transfer function (MTF) and spatio-temporal noise power spectrum (NPS). Measurements were made on an x-ray image intensifier-based bench-top system using continuous fluoroscopy with an RQA-5 beam at 3.9 microR/frame and hardened 50 kVp beam (0.8 mm Cu filtration added) at 1.9 microR/frame.

RESULTS

A zero-frequency DQE value of 0.64 was measured under both conditions. Nonideal performance was noted at both larger spatial and temporal frequencies; DQE values decreased by approximately 50% at the cutoff temporal frequency of 15 Hz.

CONCLUSIONS

The spatio-temporal DQE enables measurements of decreased temporal system performance at larger temporal frequencies analogous to previous measurements of decreased (spatial) performance. This marks the first time that system performance and dose efficiency in both space and time have been measured on a fluoroscopic system using DQE and is the first step toward the generalized use of DQE on clinical fluoroscopic systems.

A small-signal approach to temporal modulation transfer functions with exposure-rate dependence and its application to fluoroscopic detective quantum efficiency

The detective quantum efficiency (DQE) is a metric widely used in radiography to quantify system performance and as a surrogate measure of patient "dose efficiency." It has been applied previously to fluoroscopic systems with the introduction of a temporal correction factor. Calculation of this correction factor relies on measurements of the temporal modulation transfer function (MTF). However, the temporal MTF is often exposure-rate dependent, violating a necessary Fourier linearity requirement. The authors show that a Fourier analysis is appropriate for fluoroscopic systems if a "small-signal" approach is used. Using a semitransparent edge, a lag-corrected DQE is described and measured for an x-ray image intensifier-based fluoroscopic system under continuous (non-pulsed) exposure conditions. It was found that results were equivalent for both rising and falling-edge profiles independent of edge attenuation when effective attenuation was in the range of 0.1-0.6. This suggests that this range is appropriate for measuring the small-signal temporal MTF. In general, lag was greatest at low exposure rates. It was also found that results obtained using a falling-edge profile with a radiopaque edge were equivalent to the small-signal results for the test system. If this result is found to be true generally, it removes the need for the small-signal approach. Lag-corrected DQE values were validated by comparison with radiographic DQE values obtained using very long exposures under the same conditions. Lag was observed to inflate DQE measurements by up to 50% when ignored.

A moving slanted-edge method to measure the temporal modulation transfer function of fluoroscopic systems

Lag in fluoroscopic systems introduces a frame-averaging effect that reduces measurements of image noise and incorrectly inflates measurements of the detective quantum efficiency (DQE). A correction can be implemented based on measurements of the temporal modulation transfer function (MTF). We introduce a method of measuring the temporal MTF under fluoroscopic conditions using a moving slanted edge, a generalization of the slanted-edge method used to measure the (spatial) MTF, providing the temporal MTF of the entire imaging system. The method uses a single x-ray exposure, constant edge velocity, and assumes spatial and temporal blurring are separable. The method was validated on a laboratory x-ray image intensifier (XRII) system by comparison with direct measurements of the XRII optical response, showing excellent agreement over the entire frequency range tested (+/- 100 Hz). With proper access to linearized data and continuous fluoroscopy, this method can be implemented in a clinical setting on both XRII and flat-panel detectors. It is shown that the temporal MTF of the CsI-based validation system is a function of exposure rate. The rising-edge response showed more lag than the falling edge, and the temporal MTF decreased with decreasing exposure rate. It is suggested that a small-signal approach, in which the range of exposure rates is restricted to a linear range by using a semitransparent moving edge, would be appropriate for measuring the DQE of these systems.