A new algorithm for determining collimator angles that favor efficiency in MLC based IMRT delivery

Strategies to optimize stereotactic radiosurgery plans for brain tumors with volumetric-modulated arc therapy

Purpose

Prescription practice in SRS plans for brain tumors differs significantly for different modalities. In this retrospective study, the strategies to optimize SRS plans for brain tumors with volumetric arc therapy (VMAT) were presented.

Methods

Fifty clinically treated cases were stratified by the maximum target size into two groups (≥ 2 cm in 25 cases and <2 cm but ≥1 cm in 25 cases), which were optimized using traditional LINAC MLC‐based approaches with the average prescription isodose line (P‐IDL) of (91.4 ± 0.6)%. Four to five plans have been created for each case with variation of the P‐IDL from 65% to 90%. The optimization strategies to select an optimal P‐IDL, to use tuning structures within the target and beyond as well as to use NTO (normal tissue objectives), were applied to all new plans.

Results

The optimal P‐IDL was found to be around 75%. After applying the new optimization strategies with an average P‐IDL of 74.8%, the mean modified gradient index (mGI) and V12 were reduced by 25% and 35%, respectively for both groups. The Paddick conformity index (PCI) was averagely improved by 8%. The average homogeneity index (HI) and focal index (FI) were increased by 22% and 50%, respectively. The mGI was inversely proportional to the PTV volumes. The shape of the dose distribution in target was also changed from concave to convex. The comparison of PCI with historical data from other institutes and modalities shows that the plans in this study have the best conformity near the target.

Conclusions

With the new optimization strategies for VMAT SRS plan of brain tumor more conformal plans in both high and intermediate dose region (~50% of the PD) were created, in which the dose in the core of the target was notably increased while V12 and mGI were significantly decreased, and PCI was improved. The mGI was inversely proportional to the PTV volumes. The optimal P‐IDL is around 75%. The average PCI is the best in this study compared with the published historical data. These strategies are applicable to treatment planning for multiple brain and liver tumors where sparing the tissue peripheral to the target is critical.

Direct-aperture optimization applied to selection of beam orientations in intensity-modulated radiation therapy

Direct-aperture optimization (DAO) was applied to iterative beam-orientation selection in intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), so as to ensure a realistic segmental treatment plan at each iteration. Nested optimization engines dealt separately with gantry angles, couch angles, collimator angles, segment shapes, segment weights and wedge angles. Each optimization engine performed a random search with successively narrowing step sizes. For optimization of segment shapes, the filtered backprojection (FBP) method was first used to determine desired fluence, the fluence map was segmented, and then constrained direct-aperture optimization was used thereafter. Segment shapes were fully optimized when a beam angle was perturbed, and minimally re-optimized otherwise. The algorithm was compared with a previously reported method using FBP alone at each orientation iteration. An example case consisting of a cylindrical phantom with a hemi-annular planning target volume (PTV) showed that for three-field plans, the method performed better than when using FBP alone, but for five or more fields, neither method provided much benefit over equally spaced beams. For a prostate case, improved bladder sparing was achieved through the use of the new algorithm. A plan for partial scalp treatment showed slightly improved PTV coverage and lower irradiated volume of brain with the new method compared to FBP alone. It is concluded that, although the method is computationally intensive and not suitable for searching large unconstrained regions of beam space, it can be used effectively in conjunction with prior class solutions to provide individually optimized IMRT treatment plans.

Elongated beamlets: a simple technique for segment and MU reduction for sMLC IMRT delivery on accelerators utilizing 5 mm leaf widths

The focus of this work is to demonstrate the effects of using an elongated beamlet to achieve similar dose conformity as achieved with a square beamlet while reducing the number of segments and subsequent MU required. A series of 10 patients were planned for IMRT delivery to the prostate using minimum beamlet sizes of 5x5 mm2 (default scheme), 10x5 mm2 with the short axis parallel to the prostate-rectum interface (scheme 1), and 10x5 mm2 with the short axis perpendicular to the prostate-rectum interface (scheme 2). All other parameters between plans were left unchanged. Plans were appropriately normalized and evaluated for R65, R40, conformity index, total number of segments and MU. All plans were generated using the Corvus inverse planning system. The average number of segments in this study decreased by approximately 49% for both schemes 1 and 2. The subsequent number of MU required decreased by approximately 34.6%. The resultant modified modulation scaling factor (MSFmod) decreased by approximately 34.3%. Additionally, we found that each isodose distribution using scheme 2 would still meet our clinical acceptance criteria with no visible degradation in the dose distribution as compared with the default scheme. In conclusion, we have demonstrated that it is possible to achieve similar results as those obtained using a 5x5 mm2 beamlet with respect to target coverage and critical structure sparing by using strategically oriented elongated beamlets. This technique directly translates to a decreased MSF(mod) allowing for decreased leakage dose to the patient, a decreased risk of exceeding secondary shielding limits in pre-existing vaults, and shorter treatment times.