Characterizing the marker-dye correction for Gafchromic(®) EBT2 film: a comparison of three analysis methods

Eigencolor radiochromic film dosimetry

PURPOSE

The goal of this work is to propose a new multichannel method correcting for systematic thickness disturbances and to evaluate its precision in relevant radiation dosimetry applications.

METHODS

The eigencolor ratio technique is introduced and theoretically developed to provide a method correcting for thickness disturbances. The method is applied to EBT3 Gafchromic^TM film irradiated with cobalt-60 and 6 MV photon beams and digitized with an Epson 10000XL photo scanner. Dose profiles and output factors of different field sizes are measured and analyzed. Variance analysis of the previous method of Bouchard et al. ["On the characterization and uncertainty analysis of radiochromic film dosimetry" Med Phys. 2009;36:1931-1946] is adapted to the new approach. Uncertainties are predicted for relevant applications.

RESULTS

Results show that systematic disturbances attributed to thickness variations are efficiently corrected. The method is shown efficient to identify and correct for dark spots which cause systematic errors in single-channel distributions. Applications of the method in the context of relative dosimetry yields standard uncertainties ranging between 0.8% and 1.9%, depending on the region of interest (ROI) size and the film irradiation. Variance analysis predicts that uncertainty levels between 0.3% and 0.6% are achievable with repeated measurements. Uncertainties are found to vary with absorbed dose and ROI size.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed multichannel method is efficient for accurate dosimetry, reaching uncertainty levels comparable to previous publications with EBT film. The method is also promising for applications beyond clinical QA, such as machine characterization and other advanced dosimetry applications.

Calibration of the EBT3 Gafchromic Film Using HNN Deep Learning

To achieve a dose distribution conformal to the target volume while sparing normal tissues, intensity modulation with steep dose gradient is used for treatment planning. To successfully deliver such treatment, high spatial and dosimetric accuracy are crucial and need to be verified. With high 2D dosimetry resolution and a self-development property, the Ashland Inc. product EBT3 Gafchromic film is a widely used quality assurance tool designed especially for this. However, the film should be recalibrated each quarter due to the “aging effect,” and calibration uncertainties always exist between individual films even in the same lot. Recently, artificial neural networks (ANN) are applied to many fields. If a physicist can collect the calibration data, it could be accumulated to be a substantial ANN data input used for film calibration. We therefore use the Keras functional Application Program Interface to build a hierarchical neural network (HNN), with the inputs of net optical densities, pixel values, and inverse transmittances to reveal the delivered dose and train the neural network with deep learning. For comparison, the film dose calculated using red-channel net optical density with power function fitting was performed and taken as a conventional method. The results show that the percentage error of the film dose using the HNN method is less than 4% for the aging effect verification test and less than 4.5% for the intralot variation test; in contrast, the conventional method could yield errors higher than 10% and 7%, respectively. This HNN method to calibrate the EBT film could be further improved by adding training data or adjusting the HNN structure. The model could help physicists spend less calibration time and reduce film usage.

Comparison of three film analysis softwares using EBT2 and EBT3 films in radiotherapy

Introduction The purpose of the study was to compare the results of gamma value based film analysis according to the used type of self-developer film and software product. Material and methods The films were irradiated with different treatment techniques such as 3D conformal and intensity modulated radiotherapy with static and rotational delivery. Stereotactic plans with conformal and intensity modulated arc techniques, using coplanar and non-coplanar beam setup were also evaluated. The data of irradiated film were compared with the planned planar dose distribution exported from the treatment planning system. Three film analysis software programs were evaluated: PTW Mephysto (PTW), FilmQA Pro (FQP) and radiohromic.com(RC). Both EBT2 and EBT3 types of films were examined. The comparisons of dose distributions were performed with gamma analysis using 10% cut-off level. Results The results of the gamma analysis for larger fields were between 78.3% and 98.3%, 75.7% and 100%, 80.2% and 98.8% with PTW, FQP and RC, respectively. The results of evaluation in case of stereotactic measurements were 76.8%-99.2% for PTW, 95.7%-100% for FQP and 91.2%-99.9% for RC. Conclusions All the three software programs are suitable for calibrating and evaluating films, performing gamma analysis, and can be used for patient specific quality assurance measurements. There is no direct connection between gamma passing rate and absolute accuracy or software quality, it is just a feature of the software. The interpretation of own results has to be defined on an institutional level according to given workflow and preliminary results.

Calibration of Gafchromic EBT Film Using the Microtek ScanMaker 9800XL Plus Flatbed Scanner with a Modified One Red-Channel after Three-Channel Method

Purpose:

Using the Microtek ScanMaker 9800XL Plus (9800XL⁺) flatbed scanner, a method is presented to accurately calibrate EBT film, which cannot be calibrated simply using a general three-channel method because of the nonhomogeneous scanning.

Materials and Methods:

Through the percentage-depth-dose method, 6-MV photon beams with two different monitor units were delivered to eight EBT2 films, each of which was tightly sandwiched in a 30-cm cubic polystyrene phantom and positioned parallel to the central axis of the beam. Before and after irradiation, all films were scanned using the Microtek 9800XL⁺ scanner and the pixel values (PVs) were measured along the central axis of the beam on the film and fitted to the corresponding depth doses. Before calibration, the irradiated film image was first modified using a template matrix, which was generated using the prescanned background images. Then, a modified one red-channel after three-channel method was used to calibrate the film.

Results:

Without a template matrix, the three-channel method cannot be used because the PVs do not correspond to a rational fitting form. Using the proposed method, the difference between the fitted dose and the delivered dose is <2%. The green channel, and not the red, is found to have the largest dynamic range.

Conclusion:

The proposed technique allows the use of the three-channel method to calibrate film using a Microtek 9800XL⁺ scanner.

Biological characterization of a novel in vitro cell irradiator

To evaluate the overall robustness of a novel cellular irradiator we performed a series of well-characterized, dose-responsive assays to assess the consequences of DNA damage. We used a previously described novel irradiation system and a traditional ¹³⁷Cs source to irradiate a cell line. The generation of reactive oxygen species was assessed using chloromethyl-H₂DCFDA dye, the induction of DNA DSBs was observed using the comet assay, and the initiation of DNA break repair was assessed through γH2AX image cytometry. A high correlation between physical absorbed dose and biologic dose was seen for the production of intracellular reactive oxygen species, physical DNA double strand breaks, and modulation of the cellular double stand break pathway. The results compared favorably to irradiation with a traditional ¹³⁷Cs source. The rapid, straightforward tests described form a reasonable approach for biologic characterization of novel irradiators. These additional testing metrics go beyond standard physics testing such as Monte Carlo simulation and thermo-luminescent dosimeter evaluation to confirm that a novel irradiator can produce the desired dose effects in vitro. Further, assessment of these biological metrics confirms that the physical handling of the cells during the irradiation process results in biologic effects that scale appropriately with dose.

The combination of the error correction methods of GAFCHROMIC EBT3 film

Purpose

The aim of this study was to combine a set of methods for use of radiochromic film dosimetry, including calibration, correction for lateral effects and a proposed triple-channel analysis. These methods can be applied to GAFCHROMIC EBT3 film dosimetry for radiation field analysis and verification of IMRT plans.

Methods

A single-film exposure was used to achieve dose calibration, and the accuracy was verified based on comparisons with the square-field calibration method. Before performing the dose analysis, the lateral effects on pixel values were corrected. The position dependence of the lateral effect was fitted by a parabolic function, and the curvature factors of different dose levels were obtained using a quadratic formula. After lateral effect correction, a triple-channel analysis was used to reduce disturbances and convert scanned images from films into dose maps. The dose profiles of open fields were measured using EBT3 films and compared with the data obtained using an ionization chamber. Eighteen IMRT plans with different field sizes were measured and verified with EBT3 films, applying our methods, and compared to TPS dose maps, to check correct implementation of film dosimetry proposed here.

Results

The uncertainty of lateral effects can be reduced to ±1 cGy. Compared with the results of Micke A et al., the residual disturbances of the proposed triple-channel method at 48, 176 and 415 cGy are 5.3%, 20.9% and 31.4% smaller, respectively. Compared with the ionization chamber results, the difference in the off-axis ratio and percentage depth dose are within 1% and 2%, respectively. For the application of IMRT verification, there were no difference between two triple-channel methods. Compared with only corrected by triple-channel method, the IMRT results of the combined method (include lateral effect correction and our present triple-channel method) show a 2% improvement for large IMRT fields with the criteria 3%/3 mm.

Calibration of EBT2 film using a red-channel PDD method in combination with a modified three-channel technique

PURPOSE

Ashland Inc. EBT2 and EBT3 films are widely used in quality assurance for radiation therapy; however, there remains a relatively high degree of uncertainty [B. Hartmann, M. Martisikova, and O. Jakel, "Homogeneity of Gafchromic EBT2 film," Med. Phys. 37, 1753-1756 (2010)]. Micke et al. (2011) recently improved the spatial homogeneity using all color channels of a flatbed scanner; however, van Hoof et al. (2012) pointed out that the corrected nonuniformity still requires further investigation for larger fields. To reduce the calibration errors and the uncertainty, the authors propose a new red-channel percentage-depth-dose method in combination with a modified three-channel technique.

METHODS

For the ease of comparison, the EBT2 film image used in the authors' previous study (2012) was reanalyzed using different approaches. Photon beams of 6-MV were delivered to two different films at two different beam on times, resulting in the absorption doses of ranging from approximately 30 to 300 cGy at the vertical midline of the film, which was set to be coincident with the central axis of the beam. The film was tightly sandwiched in a 30(3)-cm(3) polystyrene phantom, and the pixel values for red, green, and blue channels were extracted from 234 points on the central axis of the beam and compared with the corresponding depth doses. The film was first calibrated using the multichannel method proposed by Micke et al. (2010), accounting for nonuniformities in the scanner. After eliminating the scanner and dose-independent nonuniformities, the film was recalibrated via the dose-dependent optical density of the red channel and fitted to a power function. This calibration was verified via comparisons of the dose profiles extracted from the films, where three were exposed to a 60° physical wedge field and three were exposed to composite fields, and all of which were measured in a water phantom. A correction for optical attenuation was implemented, and treatment plans of intensity modulated radiation therapy and volumetric modulated arc therapy were evaluated.

RESULTS

The method described here demonstrated improved accuracy with reduced uncertainty. The relative error compared with the measurements of a water phantom was less than 1%, and the overall calibration uncertainty was less than 2%. Verification tests revealed that the results were close to those of the authors' previous study, and all differences were within 3%, except those with a high-dose gradient. The gamma pass rates (2%/2 mm) of the treatment plan evaluated using the method described here were greater than 99%, and no obvious stripe patterns were observed in the dose-difference maps.

CONCLUSIONS

Spatial homogeneity was significantly improved via the calibration method described here. This technique is both convenient and time-efficient because it does not require cutting the film, and only two exposures are necessary.

Radiochromic film calibration for low-energy seed brachytherapy dose measurement

PURPOSE

Radiochromic film dosimetry is typically performed for high energy photons and moderate doses characterizing external beam radiotherapy (XRT). The purpose of this study was to investigate the accuracy of previously established film calibration procedures used in XRT when applied to low-energy, seed-based brachytherapy at higher doses, and to determine necessary modifications to achieve similar accuracy in absolute dose measurements.

METHODS

Gafchromic EBT3 film was used to measure radiation doses upwards of 35 Gy from 75 kVp, 200 kVp, 6 MV, and (∼28 keV) I-125 photon sources. For the latter irradiations a custom phantom was built to hold a single I-125 seed. Film pieces were scanned with an Epson 10000XL flatbed scanner and the resulting 48-bit RGB TIFF images were analyzed using both FilmQA Pro software andMATLAB. Calibration curves relating dose and optical density via a rational functional form for all three color channels at each irradiation energy were determined with and without the inclusion of uncertainties in the measured optical densities and dose values. The accuracy of calibration curve variations obtained using piecewise fitting, a reduced film measurement area for I-125 irradiation, and a reduced number of dose levels was also investigated. The energy dependence of the film lot used was also analyzed by calculating normalized optical density values.

RESULTS

Slight differences were found in the resulting calibration curves for the various fitting methods used. The accuracy of the calibration curves was found to improve at low doses and worsen at high doses when including uncertainties in optical densities and doses, which may better represent the variability that could be seen in film optical density measurements. When exposing the films to doses > 8 Gy, two-segment piecewise fitting was found to be necessary to achieve similar accuracies in absolute dose measurements as when using smaller dose ranges. When reducing the film measurement area for the I-125 irradiations, the accuracy of the calibration curve was degraded due to the presence of localized film heterogeneities. No degradation in the calibration curves was found when reducing the number of calibration points down to only 4, but with piecewise fitting, 6 calibration points as well as a blank film are required. Variations due to photon energy in film optical density of up to 3% were found above doses of 2 Gy.

CONCLUSIONS

A modified procedure for performing EBT3 film calibration was established for use with low-energy brachytherapy seeds and high dose exposures. The energy dependence between 6 MV and I-125 photons is significant such that film calibrations should be done with an appropriately low-energy source when performing low-energy brachytherapy dose measurements. Two-segment piecewise fitting with the inclusion of errors in measured optical density as well as dose was found to result in the most accurate calibration curves. Above doses of 1 Gy, absolute dose measurements can be made with an accuracy of 1.6% for 6 MV beams and 5.7% for I-125 seed exposures if using the I-125 source for calibration, or 2.3% if using the 75 kVp photon beam for calibration.

Dosimetry for 131Cs and 125I seeds in solid water phantom using radiochromic EBT film

PURPOSE

To measure the 2D dose distributions with submillimeter resolution for (131)Cs (model CS-1 Rev2) and (125)I (model 6711) seeds in a Solid Water phantom using radiochromic EBT film for radial distances from 0.06cm to 5cm. To determine the TG-43 dosimetry parameters in water by applying Solid Water to liquid water correction factors generated from Monte Carlo simulations.

METHODS

Each film piece was positioned horizontally above and in close contact with a (131)Cs or (125)I seed oriented horizontally in a machined groove at the center of a Solid Water phantom, one film at a time. A total of 74 and 50 films were exposed to the (131)Cs and (125)I seeds, respectively. Different film sizes were utilized to gather data in different distance ranges. The exposure time varied according to the seed air-kerma strength and film size in order to deliver doses in the range covered by the film calibration curve. Small films were exposed for shorter times to assess the near field, while larger films were exposed for longer times in order to assess the far field. For calibration, films were exposed to either 40kV (M40) or 50kV (M50) x-rays in air at 100.0cm SSD with doses ranging from 0.2Gy to 40Gy. All experimental, calibration and background films were scanned at a 0.02cmpixel resolution using a CCD camera-based microdensitometer with a green light source. Data acquisition and scanner uniformity correction were achieved with Microd3 software. Data analysis was performed using ImageJ, FV, IDL and Excel software packages. 2D dose distributions were based on the calibration curve established for 50kV x-rays. The Solid Water to liquid water medium correction was calculated using the MCNP5 Monte Carlo code. Subsequently, the TG-43 dosimetry parameters in liquid water medium were determined.

RESULTS

Values for the dose-rate constants using EBT film were 1.069±0.036 and 0.923±0.031cGyU(-1)h(-1) for (131)Cs and (125)I seed, respectively. The corresponding values determined using the Monte Carlo method were 1.053±0.014 and 0.924±0.016cGyU(-1)h(-1) for (131)Cs and (125)I seed, respectively. The radial dose functions obtained with EBT film measurements and Monte Carlo simulations were plotted for radial distances up to 5cm, and agreed within the uncertainty of the two methods. The 2D anisotropy functions obtained with both methods also agreed within their uncertainties.

CONCLUSION

EBT film dosimetry in a Solid Water phantom is a viable method for measuring (131)Cs (model CS-1 Rev2) and (125)I (model 6711) brachytherapy seed dose distributions with submillimeter resolution. With the Solid Water to liquid water correction factors generated from Monte Carlo simulations, the measured TG-43 dosimetry parameters in liquid water for these two seed models were found to be in good agreement with those in the literature.

A novel high-throughput irradiator for in vitro radiation sensitivity bioassays

This paper describes the development and characterization of a fully automated in vitro cell irradiator using an electronic brachytherapy source to perform radiation sensitivity bioassays. This novel irradiator allows complex variable dose and dose rate schemes to be delivered to multiple wells of 96-well culture plates used in standard biological assays. The Xoft Axxent® eBx™ was chosen as the x-ray source due to its ability to vary tube current up to 300 µA for a 50 kVp spectrum using clinical surface applicators. Translation of the multiwell plate across the fixed radiation field is achieved using a precision motor driven computer controlled positioning system. A series of measurements was performed to characterize dosimetric performance of the system. Measurements have shown that the radiation output measured with an end window ionization chamber is stable between operating currents of 50-300 µA. In addition, radiochromic film was used to characterize the field flatness and symmetry. The average field flatness in the in-plane and cross-plane direction was 2.9 ± 1.0% and 4.0 ± 1.7%, respectively. The average symmetry in the in-plane and cross-plane direction was 1.8 ± 0.9% and 1.6 ± 0.5%, respectively. The optimal focal spot resolution at the cellular plane was determined by measuring sequential irradiations on radiochromic film for three different well spacing schemes. It was determined that the current system can irradiate every other well with negligible impact on the radiation field characteristics. Finally, a performance comparison between this system and a common cabinet irradiator is presented.

Dosimetric characterization and output verification for conical brachytherapy surface applicators. Part I. Electronic brachytherapy source

PURPOSE

Historically, treatment of malignant surface lesions has been achieved with linear accelerator based electron beams or superficial x-ray beams. Recent developments in the field of brachytherapy now allow for the treatment of surface lesions with specialized conical applicators placed directly on the lesion. Applicators are available for use with high dose rate (HDR)(192)Ir sources, as well as electronic brachytherapy sources. Part I of this paper will discuss the applicators used with electronic brachytherapy sources; Part II will discuss those used with HDR (192)Ir sources. Although the use of these applicators has gained in popularity, the dosimetric characteristics including depth dose and surface dose distributions have not been independently verified. Additionally, there is no recognized method of output verification for quality assurance procedures with applicators like these. Existing dosimetry protocols available from the AAPM bookend the cross-over characteristics of a traditional brachytherapy source (as described by Task Group 43) being implemented as a low-energy superficial x-ray beam (as described by Task Group 61) as observed with the surface applicators of interest.

METHODS

This work aims to create a cohesive method of output verification that can be used to determine the dose at the treatment surface as part of a quality assurance/commissioning process for surface applicators used with HDR electronic brachytherapy sources (Part I) and(192)Ir sources (Part II). Air-kerma rate measurements for the electronic brachytherapy sources were completed with an Attix Free-Air Chamber, as well as several models of small-volume ionization chambers to obtain an air-kerma rate at the treatment surface for each applicator. Correction factors were calculated using MCNP5 and EGSnrc Monte Carlo codes in order to determine an applicator-specific absorbed dose to water at the treatment surface from the measured air-kerma rate. Additionally, relative dose measurements of the surface dose distributions and characteristic depth dose curves were completed in-phantom.

RESULTS

Theoretical dose distributions and depth dose curves were generated for each applicator and agreed well with the measured values. A method of output verification was created that allows users to determine the applicator-specific dose to water at the treatment surface based on a measured air-kerma rate.

CONCLUSIONS

The novel output verification methods described in this work will reduce uncertainties in dose delivery for treatments with these kinds of surface applicators, ultimately improving patient care.

Total skin electron therapy in the lying-on-the-floor position using a customized flattening filter to eliminate field junctions

A total skin electron (TSE) floor technique is presented for treating patients who are unable to safely stand for extended durations. A customized flattening filter is used to eliminate the need for field junctioning, improve field uniformity, and reduce setup time. The flattening filter is constructed from copper and polycarbonate, fits into the linac's accessory slot, and is optimized to extend the useful height and width of the beam such that no field junctions are needed during treatment. A TSE floor with flattening filter (TSE FF) treatment course consisted of six patient positions: three supine and three prone. For all treatment fields, electron beam energy was 6 MeV; collimator settings were an x of 30 cm, y of 40 cm, and θcoll of 0°; and a 0.4 cm thick polycarbonate spoiler was positioned in front of the patient. Percent depth dose (PDD) and photon contamination for the TSE FF technique were compared with our standard technique, which is similar to the Stanford technique. Beam profiles were measured using radiochromic film, and dose uniformity was verified using an anthropomorphic radiological phantom. The TSE FF technique met field uniformity requirements specified by the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Task Group 30. TSE FF R80 ranges from 4 to 4.8 mm. TSE FF photon contamination was ~ 3%. Anthropomorphic radiological phantom verification demonstrated that dose to the entire skin surface was expected to be within about ±15% of the prescription dose, except for the perineum, scalp vertex, top of shoulder, and soles of the feet. The TSE floor technique presented herein eliminates field junctioning, is suitable for patients who cannot safely stand during treatment, and provides comparable quality and uniformity to the Stanford technique.

Accuracy and sensitivity of four-dimensional dose calculation to systematic motion variability in stereotatic body radiotherapy (SBRT) for lung cancer

The dynamic movement of radiation beam in real-time tumor tracking may cause overdosing to critical organs surrounding the target. The primary objective of this study was to verify the accuracy of the 4D planning module incorporated in CyberKnife treatment planning system. The secondary objective was to evaluate the error that may occur in the case of a systematic change of motion pattern. Measurements were made using a rigid thorax phantom. Target motion was simulated with two waveforms (sin and cos4) of different amplitude and frequency. Inversely optimized dose distributions were calculated in the CyberKnife treatment planning system using the 4D Monte Carlo dose calculation algorithm. Each plan was delivered to the phantom assuming (1) reproducible target motion,and (2) systematic change of target motion pattern. The accuracy of 4D dose calculation algorithm was assessed using GAFCHROMIC EBT2 films based on 5%/3 mm γ criteria. Treatment plans were considered acceptable if the percentage of pixels passing the 5%/3 mm γ criteria was greater than 90%. The mean percentages of pixels passing were 95% for the target and 91% for the static off-target structure, respectively, with reproducible target motion. When systematic changes of the motion pattern were introduced during treatment delivery, the mean percentages of pixels passing decreased significantly in the off-target films (48%; p &lt; 0.05), but did not change significantly in the target films (92%; p = 0.324) compared to results of reproducible target motion. These results suggest that the accuracy of 4D dose calculation, particularly in off-target stationary structure, is strongly tied to the reproducibility of target motion and that the solutions of 4D planning do not reflect the clinical nature of nonreproducible target motion generally.