Tadpole Antibodies against Frog Hemoglobin and Their Effect on Development

Amphibians as a model to study the role of immune cell heterogeneity in host and mycobacterial interactions

Mycobacterial infections represent major concerns for aquatic and terrestrial vertebrates including humans. Although our current knowledge is mostly restricted to Mycobacterium tuberculosis and mammalian host interactions, increasing evidence suggests common features in endo- and ectothermic animals infected with non-tuberculous mycobacteria (NTMs) like those described for M. tuberculosis. Importantly, most of the pathogenic and non-pathogenic NTMs detected in amphibians from wild, farmed, and research facilities represent, in addition to the potential economic loss, a rising concern for human health. Upon mycobacterial infection in mammals, the protective immune responses involving the innate and adaptive immune systems are highly complex and therefore not fully understood. This complexity results from the versatility and resilience of mycobacteria to hostile conditions as well as from the immune cell heterogeneity arising from the distinct developmental origins according with the concept of layered immunity. Similar to the differing responses of neonates versus adults during tuberculosis development, the pathogenesis and inflammatory responses are stage-specific in Xenopus laevis during infection by the NTM M. marinum. That is, both in human fetal and neonatal development and in tadpole development, responses are characterized by hypo-responsiveness and a lower capacity to contain mycobacterial infections. Similar to a mammalian fetus and neonates, T cells and myeloid cells in Xenopus tadpoles and axolotls are different from the adult immune cells. Fetal and amphibian larval T cells, which are characterized by a lower T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire diversity, are biased toward regulatory function, and they have distinct progenitor origins from those of the adult immune cells. Some early developing T cells and likely macrophage subpopulations are conserved in adult anurans and mammals, and therefore, they likely play an important role in the host-pathogen interactions from early stages of development to adulthood. Thus, we propose the use of developing amphibians, which have the advantage of being free-living early in their development, as an alternative and complementary model to study the role of immune cell heterogeneity in host-mycobacteria interactions.

Changes in the immune system during metamorphosis of Xenopus

Profound immunological changes occur as tadpoles metamorphose into adult amphibians. These include the expression of a different antibody repertoire, a lessening of skin graft tolerance, the appearance on leukocytes of class I MHC antigens. Here Martin Flajnik and his colleagues review what is known of these changes in Xenopus and speculate on how they may occur.

Assessment of virally vectored autoimmunity as a biocontrol strategy for cane toads

Background

The cane toad, Bufo (Chaunus) marinus, is one of the most notorious vertebrate pests introduced into Australia over the last 200 years and, so far, efforts to identify a naturally occurring B. marinus-specific pathogen for use as a biological control agent have been unsuccessful. We explored an alternative approach that entailed genetically modifying a pathogen with broad host specificity so that it no longer caused disease, but carried a gene to disrupt the cane toad life cycle in a species specific manner.

Methodology/Principal Findings

The adult beta globin gene was selected as the model gene for proof of concept of autoimmunity as a biocontrol method for cane toads. A previous report showed injection of bullfrog tadpoles with adult beta globin resulted in an alteration in the form of beta globin expressed in metamorphs as well as reduced survival. In B. marinus we established for the first time that the switch from tadpole to adult globin exists. The effect of injecting B. marinus tadpoles with purified recombinant adult globin protein was then assessed using behavioural (swim speed in tadpoles and jump length in metamorphs), developmental (time to metamorphosis, weight and length at various developmental stages, protein profile of adult globin) and genetic (adult globin mRNA levels) measures. However, we were unable to detect any differences between treated and control animals. Further, globin delivery using Bohle iridovirus, an Australian ranavirus isolate belonging to the Iridovirus family, did not reduce the survival of metamorphs or alter the form of beta globin expressed in metamorphs.

Conclusions/Significance

While we were able to show for the first time that the switch from tadpole to adult globin does occur in B. marinus, we were not able to induce autoimmunity and disrupt metamorphosis. The short development time of B. marinus tadpoles may preclude this approach.

Genes induced during the early developmental stages of the Cane Toad, Bufo (Chaunus) marinus

Metamorphosis, a critical stage in the development of toads and frogs, involves rapid levels of morphological change. In the current study, we have used microarray analysis to identify shifts in gene expression between tadpole and toadlet stages of the cane toad, Bufo (Chaunus) marinus. Here, we report on nine genes that show the greatest induction during metamorphosis; the gut-associated gastrokine and trefoil factor, blood components haemoglobins alpha/beta, apolipoprotein and serum albumin, a nasal gene olfactomedin, a lens gene gamma-crystallin, and a novel gene with low homology to frog harderin. We present both temporal and spatial expression patterns of these genes identified in developing and adult cane toads. This study extends our knowledge of the molecular basis of toad metamorphosis, and not only offers insights to the genes induced during the general remodelling that occurs but also reveals possible targets for control and manipulation of amphibian pest species, for example, the cane toad in Australia.

Exploring lymphocyte differentiation pathways

Highlights in a 4-decade exploration of lymphocyte differentiation begin with comparative studies in birds and mammals leading to recognition of the separate T- and B-cell differentiation pathways and their cooperative interaction. The global effects of aborting IgM B-cell development with anti-mu antibodies indicated that B cells can undergo immunoglobulin isotype switching. A search for the mammalian bursa equivalent that began with an extended excursion through the gut-associated lymphoepithelial tissues ultimately led to the hematopoietic tissue origin of mammalian B cells. The identification of the precursors of B cells in hematopoietic tissues provided an expanded view of the life history of B cells. A recurring theme in this essay is the interplay between understanding normal lymphocyte differentiation and the defects that underlie immunodeficiency diseases and lymphoid malignancies.

Apoptosis in the thymus of developing Xenopus laevis

Metamorphosis in Xenopus laevis is a time when thyroxine and glucocorticoid levels rise, dramatic morphological and physiological changes take place, and tolerance is established to newly expressed adult antigens. In vitro exposure of thymocytes tested at different metamorphic stages, to the T-cell lectin, phytohemagglutinin (PHA), stimulates increased apoptosis, but incubation with the synthetic glucocorticoid, dexamethasone (DEX), fails in this regard. Altered-self antigenicity, following trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS) treatment, increases apoptosis only in the late stages of metamorphosis. Developmentally blocked metamorphosing larvae demonstrate low thymic apoptotic rates that are also unaffected by in vitro exposure to DEX or by in vivo exposure to thyroxine, but are increased by PHA and in some individuals by TNBS. When released from blockade, their thymic apoptotic rates rise as progress through metamorphosis is renewed. Larval thymic apoptosis is glucocorticocoid- and thyroxine insensitive, but is lectin and altered-self antigen activated, particularly during postclimax stages.

The development of inducer and effector immune suppressor cell function in Xenopus laevis, the South African clawed toad: the effect of metamorphosis

Thymic capacity to induce suppression of antibody production by immunized Xenopus laevis toadlet spleen fragments was tested in co-cultures for different developmental stages (Nieuwkoop, P.D. and J. Faber: Normal Table of Xenopus laevis (Daudin) (North Holland, Amsterdam) 1967). While thymuses of stages 52-54 (premetamorphosis) induced suppression, those of stages 58-62 (metamorphosis) did not. This capacity returned in metamorphic climax (stages 63-65). Tests of lectin-induced suppressor function in spleens of different developmental stages exposed the same pattern of compromised activity during metamorphosis. To test whether larval thymuses could effect suppression, rather than just induce it, antigen-activated thymuses from the different stages were co-cultured with immunized toadlet spleen fragments which had been suppressor-depleted by cyclophosphamide. Only thymuses from premetamorphic larvae suppressed. Thus, when thymic capacity to induce suppression returned in metamorphic climax, it was adult-like: it lacked effector suppressor cells.

Active suppression of the allogeneic histocompatibility reactions during the metamorphosis of the clawed toad Xenopus

Metamorphosis is a privileged period for the induction of tolerance to allografts. Transfer of lymphocytes from metamorphosing Xenopus into isogenic adults prevented the rejection of a skin graft differing from the adult host by minor histocompatibility antigens. This implies that active suppression is involved at one step of the induction of tolerance to the self-antigens that differentiate at the time of metamorphosis. The reciprocal experiments of preventing tolerance induction by transfer of normal adult cells into metamorphosing animals failed. However, passive transfer of anti-graft immunity in tolerant animals was partially observed, provided that a transfer of primed cells was done simultaneously with the challenging graft. Thus, memory cells are not as sensitive to the suppression as are the cells that respond in a first set reaction.

Ontogeny of immunity in amphibians: changes in antibody repertoires and appearance of adult major histocompatibility antigens in Xenopus

Larval Xenopus anti-2,4-dinitrophenyl antibodies of the low-molecular weight type can be analyzed by isoelectric focusing (IEF). Within a clone of genetically identical animals, tadpoles make antibodies whose IEF spectrotypes are shared by most of the individuals. Adults of the same clone also make antibodies of identical spectrotype, but the adult pattern can be very different from the larval one, although both responses are heterogeneous. The larval spectrotypes that one cannot see in a primary adult response can be found if the adult has been primed during larval life and boosted after metamorphosis. The heterogeneity of the response is somewhat lower in tadpoles (up to 12 antibody IEF bands) than in adults (up to 20 antibody IEF bands). The change in the repertoire occurs during metamorphosis at the time of the appearance of two major histocompatibility complex antigens. One, a lymphocyte antigen, appears 10-15 days before the end of metamorphosis, the other, present on red cells (and presumably also on lymphocytes), appears 1.5 month after the end of metamorphosis, as determined by immunofluorescence analysis. During the same period, the syngeneic mixed leukocyte reaction switches from a larval anti-adult to an adult anti-larval reaction.