Response : Attenuated HIV Vaccine: Caveats

Clonal Expansion of Human Immunodeficiency Virus-Infected Cells and Human Immunodeficiency Virus Persistence During Antiretroviral Therapy

The latent HIV-1 reservoir in blood decays very slowly, even during prolonged suppression of viral replication by antiretroviral therapy (ART). Mechanisms for reservoir persistence include replenishment through low-level viral replication, longevity and homeostatic proliferation of memory T cells, and most recently appreciated, clonal expansion of HIV-infected cells. Clonally expanded cells make up a large and increasing fraction of the residual infected cell population on ART, and insertion of HIV proviruses into certain host cellular genes has been associated with this proliferation. That the vast majority of proviruses are defective clouds our assessment of the degree to which clonally expanded cells harbor infectious viruses, and thus the extent to which they contribute to reservoirs relevant to curing infection. This review summarizes past studies that have defined our current understanding and the gaps in our knowledge of the mechanisms by which proviral integration and clonal expansion sustain the HIV reservoir.

Live attenuated AIDS viruses as vaccines: promise or peril?

Live attenuated viruses can provide vaccine protection against various viral illnesses. A number of live attenuated strains of the simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) or related lentiviruses have been evaluated in primate models as vaccine candidates against AIDS. Impressive efficacy was observed for some viruses, most notably SIV strains with deletions in the nef-gene. Sterilizing immunity was seen against homologous and heterologous virus challenge, against cell-free and cell-associated challenge, against intravenous and mucosal challenge, and against challenge as early as 3 weeks and as late as 2.25 years after just one immunization. However, these promising efficacy results are overshadowed by safety problems, such as reversion of the vaccine strain to a pathogenic virus encoding full-length nef or residual virulence of multiply deleted vaccine strains. Strategies aimed at decreasing the replicative capacity of nef-deleted vaccine strains to increase the safety profile have significantly curtailed vaccine efficacy. Nevertheless, studies of live attenuated vaccine strains should proceed and should focus on determining the correlates of vaccine protection and the molecular determinants for virulence and attenuation.

Resistance of neonatal monkeys to live attenuated vaccine strains of simian immunodeficiency virus

A major safety concern of using live-attenuated vaccine strategies against AIDS is the potential exposure of neonates or fetuses to vaccine virus from the mother. Here we report that high viral loads and disease were observed in only 2 of 18 neonatal monkeys infected with gene-deleted vaccine strains of simian immunodeficiency virus. Pathogenicity was restricted to neonates born to unvaccinated mothers, that is, lacking maternal immunity, and that received extremely high doses of vaccine virus orally. No in utero transmission of vaccine virus was observed in four neonates born to mothers vaccinated during the second trimester. Our results suggest that the live attenuated vaccine approach should remain a viable option for preventing HIV infection and disease in high-risk human populations.