Loss of C-5 Sterol Desaturase Activity in Candida albicans: Azole Resistance or Merely Trailing Growth?

Precise genome editing underlines the distinct contributions of mutations in ERG11, ERG3, MRR1, and TAC1 genes to antifungal resistance in Candida parapsilosis

Candida parapsilosis has recently emerged as a major threat due to the worldwide emergence of fluconazole-resistant strains causing clonal outbreaks in hospitals and poses a therapeutic challenge due to the limited antifungal armamentarium. Here, we used precise genome editing using CRISPR-Cas9 to gain further insights into the contribution of mutations in ERG11, ERG3, MRR1, and TAC1 genes and the influence of allelic dosage to antifungal resistance in C. parapsilosis. Seven of the most common amino acid substitutions previously reported in fluconazole-resistant clinical isolates (including Y132F in ERG11) were engineered in two fluconazole-susceptible C. parapsilosis lineages (ATCC 22019 and STZ5). Each mutant was then challenged in vitro against a large array of antifungals, with a focus on azoles. Any possible change in virulence was also assessed in a Galleria mellonella model. We successfully generated a total of 19 different mutants, using CRISPR-Cas9. Except for R398I (ERG11), all remaining amino acid substitutions conferred reduced susceptibility to fluconazole. However, the impact on fluconazole in vitro susceptibility varied greatly according to the engineered mutation, the stronger impact being noted for G583R acting as a gain-of-function mutation in MRR1. Cross-resistance with newer azoles, non-medical azoles, but also non-azole antifungals such as flucytosine, was occasionally noted. Posaconazole and isavuconazole remained the most active in vitro. Except for G583R, no fitness cost was associated with the acquisition of fluconazole resistance. We highlight the distinct contributions of amino acid substitutions in ERG11, ERG3, MRR1, and TAC1 genes to antifungal resistance in C. parapsilosis.

Understanding fluconazole tolerance in Candida albicans: implications for effective treatment of candidiasis and combating invasive fungal infections

OBJECTIVES

Fluconazole (FLC) tolerant phenotypes in Candida species contribute to persistent candidemia and the emergence of FLC resistance. Therefore, making FLC fungicidal and eliminating FLC tolerance are important for treating invasive fungal diseases (IFDs) caused by Candida species. However, the mechanisms of FLC tolerance in Candida species remain to be fully explored.

METHODS

This review discusses the high incidence of FLC tolerance in Candida species and the importance of successfully clearing FLC tolerance in treating candidiasis. We further define and characterize FLC tolerance in C. albicans.

RESULTS

This review identifies global factors affecting FLC tolerance and suggest that FLC tolerance is a strategy of C. albicans response to FLC damage whose mechanism differs from FLC resistance.

CONCLUSIONS

This review highlights the significance of the cell membrane and cell wall integrity in FLC tolerance, guiding approaches to combat IFDs caused by Candida species..

A Small Molecule Inhibitor of Erg251 Makes Fluconazole Fungicidal by Inhibiting the Synthesis of the 14α-Methylsterols

Fluconazole (FLC) is widely used to prevent and treat invasive fungal infections. However, FLC is a fungistatic agent, allowing clinical FLC-susceptible isolates to tolerate FLC. Making FLC fungicidal in combination with adjuvants is a promising strategy to avoid FLC resistance and eliminate the persistence and recurrence of fungal infections. Here, we identify a new small molecule compound, CZ66, that can make FLC fungicidal. The mechanism of action of CZ66 is targeting the C-4 sterol methyl oxidase, encoded by the ERG251 gene, resulting in decreased content of sterols with the 14α-methyl group and ultimately eliminating FLC tolerance of Candida albicans. CZ66 most likely interacts with Erg251 through residues Glu195, Gly206, and Arg241. Establishing Erg251 as a synergistic lethal target protein of FLC should direct research to identify specific small molecule inhibitors of 14α-methylsterol synthesis and open the way to abolishing fungal FLC tolerance. IMPORTANCE Fluconazole (FLC) tolerance increases the frequency of acquired FLC resistance, and a high FLC tolerance level is associated with persistent candidemia. Multiple functional proteins, such as calcineurin, heat shock protein 90 (Hsp90), and ADP ribosylation factor, are essential for the survival of C. albicans exposed to FLC, but how these factors increase the fungicidal activity of FLC remains to be determined. In this study, we found that 14α-methylsterols replace ergosterol to allow C. albicans to survive FLC, but Erg251 inactivated by CZ66 results in loss of 14α-methylsterol synthesis and cell death of C. albicans treated with FLC. Establishing Erg251 as a synergistic lethal target protein of FLC should direct research to identify specific small molecule inhibitors of 14α-methylsterol synthesis and open the way to abolishing fungal FLC tolerance.

Rapid automated antifungal susceptibility testing system for yeasts based on growth characteristics

Fungal pathogens are a major threat to public health, as they are becoming increasingly common and resistant to treatment, with only four classes of antifungal medicines currently available and few candidates in the clinical development pipeline. Most fungal pathogens lack rapid and sensitive diagnostic techniques, and those that exist are not widely available or affordable. In this study, we introduce a novel automated antifungal susceptibility testing system, Droplet 48, which detects the fluorescence of microdilution wells in real time and fits growth characteristics using fluorescence intensity over time. We concluded that all reportable ranges of Droplet 48 were appropriate for clinical fungal isolates in China. Reproducibility within ±2 two-fold dilutions was 100%. Considering the Sensititre YeastOne Colorimetric Broth method as a comparator method, eight antifungal agents (fluconazole, itraconazole, voriconazole, caspofungin, micafungin, anidulafungin, amphotericin B, and 5-flucytosine) showed an essential agreement of >90%, except for posaconazole (86.62%). Category agreement of four antifungal agents (fluconazole, caspofungin, micafungin, and anidulafungin) was >90%, except for voriconazole (87.93% agreement). Two Candida albicans isolates and anidulafungin showed a major discrepancy (MD) (2.60%), and no other MD or very MD agents were found. Therefore, Droplet 48 can be considered as an optional method that is more automated and can obtain results and interpretations faster than previous methods. However, the optimization of the detection performance of posaconazole and voriconazole and promotion of Droplet 48 in clinical microbiology laboratories still require further research involving more clinical isolates in the future.

Functional Analysis of the C-5 Sterol Desaturase PcErg3 in the Sterol Auxotrophic Oomycete Pathogen Phytophthora capsici

Although sterols play an important role in most eukaryotes, some oomycetes, including Phytophthora spp., have lost the sterol synthesis pathway. Nevertheless, the ERG3 gene encoding C-5 sterol desaturase in the sterol synthesis pathway is still present in the genomes of Phytophthora spp. Phytophthora capsici, a destructive pathogen with a broad range of plant hosts, poses a significant threat to the production of agriculture. This study focused on the ERG3 gene in P. capsici (PcERG3) and explored its function in this pathogen. It showed that the PcERG3 gene could be expressed in all tested developmental stages of P. capsici, with sporangium and mycelium displaying higher expression levels. A potential substrate of Erg3 (stellasterol) was used to treat the P. capsici wild-type strain and a PcERG3Δ transformant, and their sterol profiles were determined by GC-MS. The wild-type strain could convert stellasterol into the down-stream product while the transformant could not, indicating that PcErg3 retains the C-5 sterol desaturase activity. By comparing the biological characteristics of different strains, it was found that PcERG3 is not important for the development of P. capsici. The pathogenicity of the PcERG3Δ transformants and the wild-type strain was comparable, suggesting that PcERG3 is not necessary for the interaction between P. capsici and its hosts. Further investigations revealed that the PcERG3Δ transformants and the wild-type strain displayed a similar level of tolerance to external adversities such as unsuitable temperatures, high osmotic pressures, and intemperate pH, signifying that PcERG3 is not essential for P. capsici to cope with these environmental stresses.

Titration of C-5 Sterol Desaturase Activity Reveals Its Relationship to Candida albicans Virulence and Antifungal Susceptibility Is Dependent upon Host Immune Status

The azole antifungals inhibit sterol 14α-demethylase (S14DM), which depletes cellular ergosterol and promotes synthesis of the dysfunctional lipid 14α-methylergosta-8,24(28)-dien-3β,6α-diol, ultimately arresting growth. Mutations that inactivate sterol Δ^5,6-desaturase (Erg3p), the enzyme that produces the sterol-diol upon S14DM inhibition, enhances Candida albicans growth in the presence of the azoles. However, erg3 null mutants are sensitive to some physiological stresses and can be less virulent than the wild type. These fitness defects may disfavor the selection of null mutants within patients. The objective of this study was to investigate the relationship between Erg3p activity, C. albicans pathogenicity, and the efficacy of azole therapy. An isogenic panel of strains was constructed that produce various levels of the ERG3 transcript. Analysis of the sterol composition confirmed a correspondingly wide range of Erg3p activity. Phenotypic analysis revealed that even moderate reductions in Erg3p activity are sufficient to greatly enhance C. albicans growth in the presence of fluconazole in vitro without impacting fitness. Moreover, even low levels of Erg3p activity are sufficient to support full virulence of C. albicans in the mouse model of disseminated infection. Finally, while the antifungal efficacy of fluconazole was similar for all strains in immunocompetent mice, there was an inverse correlation between Erg3p activity and the capacity of C. albicans to endure treatment in leukopenic mice. Collectively, these results establish that relative levels of Erg3p activity determine the antifungal efficacy of the azoles upon C. albicans and reveal the critical importance of host immunity in determining the clinical impact of this resistance mechanism. IMPORTANCE Mutations that completely inactivate Erg3p enable the prevalent human pathogen C. albicans to endure the azole antifungals in vitro. However, such null mutants are less frequently identified in azole-resistant clinical isolates than other resistance mechanisms, and previous studies have reported conflicting outcomes regarding antifungal resistance of these mutants in animal models of infection. The results of this study clearly establish a direct correlation between the level of Erg3p activity and the antifungal efficacy of fluconazole within a susceptible mammalian host. In addition, low levels of Erg3p activity are apparently more advantageous for C. albicans survival of azole therapy than complete loss of function. These findings suggest a more nuanced but more important role for Erg3p as a determinant of the clinical efficacy of the azole antifungals than previously appreciated. A revised model of the relationship between Erg3p activity, host immunity, and the antifungal susceptibility of C. albicans is proposed.

Species-Specific Differences in C-5 Sterol Desaturase Function Influence the Outcome of Azole Antifungal Exposure

The azole antifungals inhibit sterol 14α-demethylase (S14DM), leading to depletion of cellular ergosterol and the synthesis of an aberrant sterol diol that disrupts membrane function. In Candida albicans, sterol diol production is catalyzed by the C-5 sterol desaturase enzyme encoded by ERG3. Accordingly, mutations that inactivate ERG3 enable the fungus to grow in the presence of the azoles. The purpose of this study was to compare the propensities of C-5 sterol desaturases from different fungal pathogens to produce the toxic diol upon S14DM inhibition and thus contribute to antifungal efficacy. The coding sequences of ERG3 homologs from C. albicans (CaERG3), Candida glabrata (CgERG3), Candida auris (CaurERG3), Cryptococcus neoformans (CnERG3), Aspergillus fumigatus (AfERG3A-C) and Rhizopus delemar (RdERG3A/B) were expressed in a C. albicans erg3Δ/Δ mutant to facilitate comparative analysis. All but one of the Erg3p-like proteins (AfErg3C) at least partially restored C-5 sterol desaturase activity and to corresponding degrees rescued the stress and hyphal growth defects of the C. albicans erg3Δ/Δ mutant, confirming functional equivalence. Each C-5 desaturase enzyme conferred markedly different responses to fluconazole exposure in terms of the MIC and residual growth observed at supra-MICs. Upon fluconazole-mediated inhibition of S14DM, the strains expressing each homolog also produced various levels of 14α-methylergosta-8,24(28)-dien-3β,6α-diol. The RdErg3A and AfErg3A proteins are notable for low levels of sterol diol production and failing to confer appreciable azole sensitivity upon the C. albicans erg3Δ/Δ mutant. These findings suggest that species-specific properties of C-5 sterol desaturase may be an important determinant of intrinsic azole sensitivity.

Molecular and genetic basis of azole antifungal resistance in the opportunistic pathogenic fungus Candida albicans

Candida albicans is an opportunistic yeast and the major human fungal pathogen in the USA, as well as in many other regions of the world. Infections with C. albicans can range from superficial mucosal and dermatological infections to life-threatening infections of the bloodstream and vital organs. The azole antifungals remain an important mainstay treatment of candidiasis and therefore the investigation and understanding of the evolution, frequency and mechanisms of azole resistance are vital to improving treatment strategies against this organism. Here the organism C. albicans and the genetic changes and molecular bases underlying the currently known resistance mechanisms to the azole antifungal class are reviewed, including up-regulated expression of efflux pumps, changes in the expression and amino acid composition of the azole target Erg11 and alterations to the organism's typical sterol biosynthesis pathways. Additionally, we update what is known about activating mutations in the zinc cluster transcription factor (ZCF) genes regulating many of these resistance mechanisms and review azole import as a potential contributor to azole resistance. Lastly, investigations of azole tolerance in C. albicans and its implicated clinical significance are reviewed.

Molecular Mechanisms of Azole Resistance in Four Clinical Candida albicans Isolates

Azole resistance constitutes a serious clinical problem in the management of infections caused by Candida albicans. This study aimed to explore azole-resistant mechanisms in clinical C. albicans isolates collected in Jinan, Shandong, China. In total, 22 samples were collected and analyzed. Among these, four isolates (28A, 28D, 28I, and 28J) exhibited high level of pan-azole-resistance that was Hsp90 dependent. Gene sequencing revealed that the four Hsp90-dependent strains contained different ERG3 mutations that led to four novel amino acid substitutions (S265Y, N322D, N324S, and E355D) in Erg3. The role of these substitutions in azole resistance development was determined by constructing one copy of the mutated ERG3 from the 28A, 28D, and 28I strains into C. albicans CAI4, respectively. The minimum inhibitory concentration value of fluconazole (FLC) against C. albicans CAI4-ERG3^28I increased fourfold compared with the wild-type C. albicans strain, suggesting that the novel combination of substitutions S265Y, N322D, and N324S played an important role in mediating azole resistance in 28I. Besides, we identified several different mechanisms in other three isolates. Strains 28A and 28D displayed increased efflux ability and overexpression of MDR1. Strain 28J showed high level of ERG11 expression, but no mutation in its regulator Upc2 was observed. Our study revealed that multiple factors confer azole resistance in clinical C. albicans isolates and combination therapy should be conducted clinically.

Combining Colistin and Fluconazole Synergistically Increases Fungal Membrane Permeability and Antifungal Cidality

The increasing emergence of drug-resistant fungal pathogens, together with the limited number of available antifungal drugs, presents serious clinical challenges to treating systemic, life-threatening infections. Repurposing existing drugs to augment the antifungal activity of well-tolerated antifungals is a promising antifungal strategy with the potential to be implemented rapidly. Here, we explored the mechanism by which colistin, a positively charged lipopeptide antibiotic, enhances the antifungal activity of fluconazole, the most widely used orally available antifungal. In a range of susceptible and drug-resistant isolates and species, colistin was primarily effective at reducing fluconazole tolerance, a property of subpopulations of cells that grow slowly in the presence of a drug and may promote the emergence of persistent infections and resistance. Clinically relevant concentrations of colistin synergized with fluconazole, reducing fluconazole minimum inhibitory concentration 4-fold. Combining fluconazole and colistin also increased survival in a C. albicans Galleria mellonella infection, especially for a highly fluconazole-tolerant isolate. Mechanistically, colistin increased permeability to fluorescent antifungal azole probes and to intracellular dyes, accompanied by an increase in cell death that was dependent upon pharmacological or genetic inhibition of the ergosterol biosynthesis pathway. The positive charge of colistin is critical to its antifungal, and antibacterial, activity: colistin directly binds to several eukaryotic membrane lipids (i.e., l-α-phosphatidylinositol, l-α-phosphatidyl-l-serine, and l-α-phosphatidylethanolamine) that are enriched in the membranes of ergosterol-depleted cells. These results support the idea that colistin binds to fungal membrane lipids and permeabilizes fungal cells in a manner that depends upon the degree of ergosterol depletion.

Dihydrofolate Reductase Is a Valid Target for Antifungal Development in the Human Pathogen Candida albicans

The folate biosynthetic pathway is a promising and understudied source for novel antifungals. Even dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), a well-characterized and historically important drug target, has not been conclusively validated as an antifungal target. Here, we demonstrate that repression of DHFR inhibits growth of Candida albicans, a major human fungal pathogen. Methotrexate, an antifolate, also inhibits growth but through pH-dependent activity. In addition, we show that C. albicans has a limited ability to take up or utilize exogenous folates as only the addition of high concentrations of folinic acid restored growth in the presence of methotrexate. Finally, we show that repression of DHFR in a mouse model of infection was sufficient to eliminate host mortality. Our work conclusively establishes DHFR as a valid antifungal target in C. albicans.

While the folate biosynthetic pathway has provided a rich source of antibacterial, antiprotozoal, and anticancer therapies, it has not yet been exploited to develop uniquely antifungal agents. Although there have been attempts to develop fungal-specific inhibitors of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), the protein itself has not been unequivocally validated as essential for fungal growth or virulence. The purpose of this study was to establish dihydrofolate reductase as a valid antifungal target. Using a strain with doxycycline-repressible transcription of DFR1 (P_TETO-DFR1 strain), we were able to demonstrate that Dfr1p is essential for growth in vitro. Furthermore, nutritional supplements of most forms of folate are not sufficient to restore growth when Dfr1p expression is suppressed or when its activity is directly inhibited by methotrexate, indicating that Candida albicans has a limited capacity to acquire or utilize exogenous sources of folate. Finally, the P_TETO-DFR1 strain was rendered avirulent in a mouse model of disseminated candidiasis upon doxycycline treatment. Collectively, these results confirm the validity of targeting dihydrofolate reductase and, by inference, other enzymes in the folate biosynthetic pathway as a strategy to devise new and efficacious therapies to combat life-threatening invasive fungal infections.

IMPORTANCE The folate biosynthetic pathway is a promising and understudied source for novel antifungals. Even dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), a well-characterized and historically important drug target, has not been conclusively validated as an antifungal target. Here, we demonstrate that repression of DHFR inhibits growth of Candida albicans, a major human fungal pathogen. Methotrexate, an antifolate, also inhibits growth but through pH-dependent activity. In addition, we show that C. albicans has a limited ability to take up or utilize exogenous folates as only the addition of high concentrations of folinic acid restored growth in the presence of methotrexate. Finally, we show that repression of DHFR in a mouse model of infection was sufficient to eliminate host mortality. Our work conclusively establishes DHFR as a valid antifungal target in C. albicans.