Development of Multiwell-Plate Methods Using Pure Cultures of Methanogens To Identify New Inhibitors for Suppressing Ruminant Methane Emissions

Feed additives for methane mitigation: Recommendations for identification and selection of bioactive compounds to develop antimethanogenic feed additives

Despite the increasing interest in developing antimethanogenic additives to reduce enteric methane (CH4) emissions and the extensive research conducted over the last decades, the global livestock industry has a very limited number of antimethanogenic feed additives (AMFA) available that can deliver substantial reduction, and they have generally not reached the market yet. This work provides technical recommendations and guidelines for conducting tests intended to screen the potential to reduce, directly or indirectly, enteric CH4 of compounds before they can be further assessed in in vivo conditions. The steps involved in this work cover the discovery, isolation, and identification of compounds capable of affecting CH4 production by rumen microbes, followed by in vitro laboratory testing of potential candidates. The finding of new bioactive compounds as AMFA can be based on 2 approaches: empirical and mechanistic. The empirical approach involves obtaining and screening compounds present in databases and repositories that potentially possess the desired effect but have not yet been tested, screening natural sources of secondary compounds such as plants, fungi, and algae for their antimethanogenic effects, or examining compounds with antimethanogenic effect on microbes in other research domains outside the rumen. In contrast, the mechanistic approach is the theoretical process of discovery new bioactive compounds based on existing knowledge of a biological target or process. The in vitro methodologies reviewed include examining effects at the subcellular level, in single pure cultures of methanogens and examining in more complex mixed rumen microbial populations. Simple in vitro methodologies (subcellular assessments and batch culture) allow testing a large number of compounds, whereas more complex systems simulating the rumen microbial ecosystem can test a limited number of candidates but provide better insight about the antimethanogenic efficacy. This work collated the main advantages, limitations, and technical recommendations associated with each step and methodology use during the identification and screening of AMFA candidates.

High-throughput genetics enables identification of nutrient utilization and accessory energy metabolism genes in a model methanogen

Archaea are widespread in the environment and play fundamental roles in diverse ecosystems; however, characterization of their unique biology requires advanced tools. This is particularly challenging when characterizing gene function. Here, we generate randomly barcoded transposon libraries in the model methanogenic archaeon Methanococcus maripaludis and use high-throughput growth methods to conduct fitness assays (RB-TnSeq) across over 100 unique growth conditions. Using our approach, we identified new genes involved in nutrient utilization and response to oxidative stress. We identified novel genes for the usage of diverse nitrogen sources in M. maripaludis including a putative regulator of alanine deamination and molybdate transporters important for nitrogen fixation. Furthermore, leveraging the fitness data, we inferred that M. maripaludis can utilize additional nitrogen sources including ʟ-glutamine, ᴅ-glucuronamide, and adenosine. Under autotrophic growth conditions, we identified a gene encoding a domain of unknown function (DUF166) that is important for fitness and hypothesize that it has an accessory role in carbon dioxide assimilation. Finally, comparing fitness costs of oxygen versus sulfite stress, we identified a previously uncharacterized class of dissimilatory sulfite reductase-like proteins (Dsr-LP; group IIId) that is important during growth in the presence of sulfite. When overexpressed, Dsr-LP conferred sulfite resistance and enabled use of sulfite as the sole sulfur source. The high-throughput approach employed here allowed for generation of a large-scale data set that can be used as a resource to further understand gene function and metabolism in the archaeal domain.IMPORTANCEArchaea are widespread in the environment, yet basic aspects of their biology remain underexplored. To address this, we apply randomly barcoded transposon libraries (RB-TnSeq) to the model archaeon Methanococcus maripaludis. RB-TnSeq coupled with high-throughput growth assays across over 100 unique conditions identified roles for previously uncharacterized genes, including several encoding proteins with domains of unknown function (DUFs). We also expand on our understanding of carbon and nitrogen metabolism and characterize a group IIId dissimilatory sulfite reductase-like protein as a functional sulfite reductase. This data set encompasses a wide range of additional conditions including stress, nitrogen fixation, amino acid supplementation, and autotrophy, thus providing an extensive data set for the archaeal community to mine for characterizing additional genes of unknown function.

- Invited Review - The role of rumen microbiota in enteric methane mitigation for sustainable ruminant production

Ruminal methane production functions as the main sink for metabolic hydrogen generated through rumen fermentation and is recognized as a considerable source of greenhouse gas emissions. Methane production is a complex trait affected by dry matter intake, feed composition, rumen microbiota and their fermentation, lactation stage, host genetics, and environmental factors. Various mitigation approaches have been proposed. Because individual ruminants exhibit different methane conversion efficiencies, the microbial characteristics of low-methane-emitting animals can be essential for successful rumen manipulation and environment-friendly methane mitigation. Several bacterial species, including Sharpea, uncharacterized Succinivibrionaceae, and certain Prevotella phylotypes have been listed as key players in low-methane-emitting sheep and cows. The functional characteristics of the unclassified bacteria remain unclear, as they are yet to be cultured. Here, we review ruminal methane production and mitigation strategies, focusing on rumen fermentation and the functional role of rumen microbiota, and describe the phylogenetic and physiological characteristics of a novel Prevotella species recently isolated from low methane-emitting and high propionate-producing cows. This review may help to provide a better understanding of the ruminal digestion process and rumen function to identify holistic and environmentally friendly methane mitigation approaches for sustainable ruminant production.

Methanobrevibacter boviskoreani JH1T growth on alcohols allows development of a high throughput bioassay to detect methanogen inhibition

Rumen methanogenic archaea use by-products of fermentation to carry out methanogenesis for energy generation. A key fermentation by-product is hydrogen (H₂), which acts as the source of reducing potential for methane (CH₄) formation in hydrogenotrophic methanogens. The in vitro cultivation of hydrogenotrophic rumen methanogens requires pressurised H₂ which limits the ability to conduct high-throughput screening experiments with these organisms. The genome of the hydrogenotrophic methanogen Methanobrevibacter boviskoreani JH1^T harbors genes encoding an NADP-dependent alcohol dehydrogenase and a F₄₂₀-dependent NADP reductase, which may facilitate the transfer of reducing potential from ethanol to F₄₂₀ via NADP. The aim of this study was to explore the anaerobic culturing of JH1^T without pressurised H₂, using a variety of short chain alcohols. The results demonstrate that in the absence of H₂, JHI^T can use ethanol, 1-propanol, and 1-butanol but not methanol, as a source of reducing potential for methanogenesis. The ability to use ethanol to drive CH₄ formation in JH1^T makes it possible to develop a high throughput culture-based bioassay enabling screening of potential anti-methanogen compounds. The development of this resource will help researchers globally to accelerate the search for methane mitigation technologies for ruminant animals. Global emissions pathways that are consistent with the temperature goal of the Paris Agreement, rely on substantial reductions of agricultural greenhouse gasses, particularly from ruminant animals.

Competitive Reactions during Ethanol Chain Elongation Were Temporarily Suppressed by Increasing Hydrogen Partial Pressure through Methanogenesis Inhibition

Organic waste streams can be converted into high-value platform chemicals such as medium-chain carboxylic acids (MCCAs) using mixed microbial communities via chain elongation. However, the heterogeneity of waste streams and the use of complex microbial communities can lead to undesirable reactions, thus decreasing process efficiency. We explored suppressing excessive ethanol oxidation to acetate (EEO) by increasing the hydrogen partial pressure (PH2) through hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis inhibition by periodically adding 2-bromoethanesulfonate (2-BES) to an MCCA-producing bioreactor to reach 10 mM of 2-BES upon addition. The bioreactor was fed with pretreated food waste and brewery waste containing high concentrations of short-chain carboxylic acids and ethanol, respectively. While 2-BES addition initially reduced EEO, some methanogens (Methanobrevibacter spp.) persisted and resistant populations were selected over time. Besides changing the methanogenic community structure, adding 2-BES also changed the bacterial community structure due to its impact on PH2. While we demonstrated that PH2 could be manipulated using 2-BES to control EEO, methods that do not require the addition of a chemical inhibitor should be explored to maintain optimum PH2 for long-term suppression of EEO.

Synergistic Effects of 3-Nitrooxypropanol with Fumarate in the Regulation of Propionate Formation and Methanogenesis in Dairy Cows In Vitro

3-Nitrooxypropanol (3-NOP) is effective at reducing ruminal methane emissions in ruminants. But it also causes a drastic increase in hydrogen accumulation, resulting in feed energy waste. Fumarate is a key precursor for propionate formation and plays an important role in rumen hydrogen metabolism. Therefore, this study examined the effects of 3-NOP combined with fumarate on volatile fatty acids, methanogenesis, and microbial community structures in dairy cows in vitro. The in vitro culture experiment was performed using a 2-by-2 factorial design, two 3-NOP levels (0 or 2 mg/g dry matter [DM]) and two fumarate levels (0 or 100 mg/g DM), including 3 runs with 4 treatments, 4 replicates, and 4 blanks containing only the inoculum. Rumen fluid was collected from three lactating Holstein cows with permanent ruminal fistulas. The combination of 3-NOP and fumarate reduced methane emissions by 11.48% without affecting dry matter degradability. The propionate concentration increased and the acetate/propionate ratio decreased significantly. In terms of bacteria, the combination of 3-NOP and fumarate reduced the abundances of Ruminococcus and Lachnospiraceae_NK3A20_group and increased the abundances of Prevotella and Succiniclasticum. For archaea, the combination of 3-NOP and fumarate significantly increased the abundances of Methanobrevibacter_sp._AbM4, while the abundance of operational taxonomic unit 581 (OTU581) (belonging to an uncultured_rumen_methanogen_g__Methanobrevibacter strain) was significantly decreased. These results indicated that the combination of 3-NOP and fumarate could alleviate the accumulation of hydrogen and enhance the inhibition of methanogenesis compared with 3-NOP only in dairy cows. IMPORTANCE The global problem of climate change and the greenhouse effect has become increasingly severe, and the abatement of greenhouse gases has received great attention from the international community. Methane produced by ruminants during digestion not only aggravates the greenhouse effect but also causes a waste of feed energy. As a methane inhibitor, 3-nitrooxypropanol can effectively reduce methane emissions from ruminants. However, when it inhibits methane emissions, the emission of hydrogen increases sharply, resulting in the waste of feed resources. Fumarate is a propionic acid precursor that can promote the metabolism of hydrogen to propionic acid in animals. Therefore, we studied the effects of the combined addition of 3-nitrooxypropanol and fumarate on methanogenesis, rumen fermentation, and rumen flora. It is of great significance to inhibit methane emission from ruminants and slow down the greenhouse effect.

The Historical Development of Cultivation Techniques for Methanogens and Other Strict Anaerobes and Their Application in Modern Microbiology

The cultivation and investigation of strictly anaerobic microorganisms belong to the fields of anaerobic microbial physiology, microbiology, and biotechnology. Anaerobic cultivation methods differ from classic microbiological techniques in several aspects. The requirement for special instruments, which are designed to prevent the contact of the specimen with air/molecular oxygen by different means of manipulation, makes this field more challenging for general research compared to working with aerobic microorganisms. Anaerobic microbiological methods are required for many purposes, such as for the isolation and characterization of new species and their physiological examination, as well as for anaerobic biotechnological applications or medical indications. This review presents the historical development of methods for the cultivation of strictly anaerobic microorganisms focusing on methanogenic archaea, anaerobic cultivation methods that are still widely used today, novel methods for anaerobic cultivation, and almost forgotten, but still relevant, techniques.

Using genome comparisons of wild-type and resistant mutants of Methanococcus maripaludis to help understand mechanisms of resistance to methane inhibitors

Methane emissions from enteric fermentation in the ruminant digestive system generated by methanogenic archaea are a significant contributor to anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, methane produced as an end-product of enteric fermentation is an energy loss from digested feed. To control the methane emissions from ruminants, extensive research in the last decades has been focused on developing viable enteric methane mitigation practices, particularly, using methanogen-specific inhibitors. We report here the utilization of two known inhibitors of methanogenic archaea, neomycin and chloroform, together with a recently identified inhibitor, echinomycin, to produce resistant mutants of Methanococcus maripaludis S2 and S0001. Whole-genome sequencing at high coverage (> 100-fold) was performed subsequently to investigate the potential targets of these inhibitors at the genomic level. Upon analysis of the whole-genome sequencing data, we identified mutations in a number of genetic loci pointing to potential mechanisms of inhibitor action and their underlying mechanisms of resistance.

Occurrence and expression of genes encoding methyl-compound production in rumen bacteria

Background

Digestive processes in the rumen lead to the release of methyl-compounds, mainly methanol and methylamines, which are used by methyltrophic methanogens to form methane, an important agricultural greenhouse gas. Methylamines are produced from plant phosphatidylcholine degradation, by choline trimethylamine lyase, while methanol comes from demethoxylation of dietary pectins via pectin methylesterase activity. We have screened rumen metagenomic and metatranscriptomic datasets, metagenome assembled genomes, and the Hungate1000 genomes to identify organisms capable of producing methyl-compounds. We also describe the enrichment of pectin-degrading and methane-forming microbes from sheep rumen contents and the analysis of their genomes via metagenomic assembly.

Results

Screens of metagenomic data using the protein domains of choline trimethylamine lyase (CutC), and activator protein (CutD) found good matches only to Olsenella umbonata and to Caecibacter, while the Hungate1000 genomes and metagenome assembled genomes from the cattle rumen found bacteria within the phyla Actinobacteria, Firmicutes and Proteobacteria. The cutC and cutD genes clustered with genes that encode structural components of bacterial microcompartment proteins. Prevotella was the dominant genus encoding pectin methyl esterases, with smaller numbers of sequences identified from other fibre-degrading rumen bacteria. Some large pectin methyl esterases (> 2100 aa) were found to be encoded in Butyrivibrio genomes. The pectin-utilising, methane-producing consortium was composed of (i) a putative pectin-degrading bacterium (phylum Tenericutes, class Mollicutes), (ii) a galacturonate-using Sphaerochaeta sp. predicted to produce acetate, lactate, and ethanol, and (iii) a methylotrophic methanogen, Methanosphaera sp., with the ability to form methane via a primary ethanol-dependent, hydrogen-independent, methanogenesis pathway.

Conclusions

The main bacteria that produce methyl-compounds have been identified in ruminants. Their enzymatic activities can now be targeted with the aim of finding ways to reduce the supply of methyl-compound substrates to methanogens, and thereby limit methylotrophic methanogenesis in the rumen.

Use of Lactic Acid Bacteria to Reduce Methane Production in Ruminants, a Critical Review

Enteric fermentation in ruminants is the single largest anthropogenic source of agricultural methane and has a significant role in global warming. Consequently, innovative solutions to reduce methane emissions from livestock farming are required to ensure future sustainable food production. One possible approach is the use of lactic acid bacteria (LAB), Gram positive bacteria that produce lactic acid as a major end product of carbohydrate fermentation. LAB are natural inhabitants of the intestinal tract of mammals and are among the most important groups of microorganisms used in food fermentations. LAB can be readily isolated from ruminant animals and are currently used on-farm as direct-fed microbials (DFMs) and as silage inoculants. While it has been proposed that LAB can be used to reduce methane production in ruminant livestock, so far research has been limited, and convincing animal data to support the concept are lacking. This review has critically evaluated the current literature and provided a comprehensive analysis and summary of the potential use and mechanisms of LAB as a methane mitigation strategy. It is clear that although there are some promising results, more research is needed to identify whether the use of LAB can be an effective methane mitigation option for ruminant livestock.

Diverse hydrogen production and consumption pathways influence methane production in ruminants

Farmed ruminants are the largest source of anthropogenic methane emissions globally. The methanogenic archaea responsible for these emissions use molecular hydrogen (H₂), produced during bacterial and eukaryotic carbohydrate fermentation, as their primary energy source. In this work, we used comparative genomic, metatranscriptomic and co-culture-based approaches to gain a system-wide understanding of the organisms and pathways responsible for ruminal H₂ metabolism. Two-thirds of sequenced rumen bacterial and archaeal genomes encode enzymes that catalyse H₂ production or consumption, including 26 distinct hydrogenase subgroups. Metatranscriptomic analysis confirmed that these hydrogenases are differentially expressed in sheep rumen. Electron-bifurcating [FeFe]-hydrogenases from carbohydrate-fermenting Clostridia (e.g., Ruminococcus) accounted for half of all hydrogenase transcripts. Various H₂ uptake pathways were also expressed, including methanogenesis (Methanobrevibacter), fumarate and nitrite reduction (Selenomonas), and acetogenesis (Blautia). Whereas methanogenesis-related transcripts predominated in high methane yield sheep, alternative uptake pathways were significantly upregulated in low methane yield sheep. Complementing these findings, we observed significant differential expression and activity of the hydrogenases of the hydrogenogenic cellulose fermenter Ruminococcus albus and the hydrogenotrophic fumarate reducer Wolinella succinogenes in co-culture compared with pure culture. We conclude that H₂ metabolism is a more complex and widespread trait among rumen microorganisms than previously recognised. There is evidence that alternative hydrogenotrophs, including acetogenic and respiratory bacteria, can prosper in the rumen and effectively compete with methanogens for H₂. These findings may help to inform ongoing strategies to mitigate methane emissions by increasing flux through alternative H₂ uptake pathways, including through animal selection, dietary supplementation and methanogenesis inhibitors.

Development of a simultaneous bioreactor system for characterization of gas production kinetics of methanogenic archaea at high pressure

Cultivation of methanogens under high pressure offers a great opportunity in biotechnological processes, one of which is the improvement of the gas‐liquid transfer of substrate gases into the medium broth. This article describes a newly developed simultaneous bioreactor system consisting of four identical cultivation vessels suitable for investigation of microbial activity at pressures up to 50 bar and temperatures up to 145°C. Initial pressure studies at 10 and 50 bar of the autotrophic and hydrogenotrophic methanogens Methanothermobacter marburgensis, Methanobacterium palustre, and Methanobacterium thermaggregans were performed to evaluate the reproducibility of the system as well as to test the productivity of these strains. The strains were compared with respect to gas conversion (%), methane evolution rate (MER) (mmol L^‐1 h⁻¹), turnover rate (h⁻¹), and maximum conversion rate (k_min) (bar h⁻¹). A pressure drop that can be explained by the reaction stoichiometry showed that all tested strains were active under pressurized conditions. Our study sheds light on the production kinetics of methanogenic strains under high‐pressure conditions. In addition, the simultaneous bioreactor system is a suitable first step screening system for analyzing the substrate uptake and/or production kinetics of gas conversion and/or gas production processes for barophilic or barotolerant microbes.

Transplanting the pathway engineering toolbox to methanogens

Biological methanogenesis evolved early in Earth's history and was likely already a major process by 3.5 Ga. Modern methanogenesis is now a key process in virtually all anaerobic microbial communities, such as marine and lake sediments, wetland and rice soils, and human and cattle digestive tracts. Owing to their long evolution and extensive adaptations to various habitats, methanogens possess enormous metabolic and physiological diversity. Not only does this diversity offers unique opportunities for biotechnology applications, but also reveals their direct impact on the environment, agriculture, and human and animal health. These efforts are facilitated by an advanced genetic toolbox, emerging new molecular tools, and systems-level modelling for methanogens. Further developments and convergence of these technical advancements provide new opportunities for bioengineering methanogens.

Comparative Genomic Analysis of Members of the Genera Methanosphaera and Methanobrevibacter Reveals Distinct Clades with Specific Potential Metabolic Functions

Methanobrevibacter and Methanosphaera species represent some of the most prevalent methanogenic archaea in the gastrointestinal tract of animals and humans and play an important role in this environment. The aim of this study was to identify genomic features that are shared or specific for members of each genus with a special emphasis of the analysis on the assimilation of nitrogen and acetate and the utilization of methanol and ethanol for methanogenesis. Here, draft genome sequences of Methanobrevibacter thaueri strain DSM 11995^T, Methanobrevibacter woesei strain DSM 11979^T, and Methanosphaera cuniculi strain 4103^T are reported and compared to those of 16 other Methanobrevibacter and Methanosphaera genomes, including genomes of the 13 currently available types of strains of the two genera. The comparative genome analyses indicate that among other genes, the absence of molybdopterin cofactor biosynthesis is conserved in Methanosphaera species but reveals also that the three species share a core set of more than 300 genes that distinguishes the genus Methanosphaera from the genus Methanobrevibacter. Multilocus sequence analysis shows that the genus Methanobrevibacter can be subdivided into clades, potentially new genera, which may display characteristic specific metabolic features. These features include not only the potential ability of nitrogen fixation and acetate assimilation in a clade comprised of Methanobrevibacter species from the termite gut and Methanobrevibacter arboriphilus strains but also the potential capability to utilize ethanol and methanol in a clade comprising Methanobrevibacter wolinii strain DSM 11976^T, Mbb. sp. AbM4, and Mbb. boviskoreani strain DSM 25824^T.

A Flexible System for Cultivation of Methanococcus and Other Formate-Utilizing Methanogens

Many hydrogenotrophic methanogens use either H₂ or formate as the major electron donor to reduce CO₂ for methane production. The conventional cultivation of these organisms uses H₂ and CO₂ as the substrate with frequent replenishment of gas during growth. H₂ is explosive and requires an expensive gassing system to handle safely. Formate is as an ideal alternative substrate from the standpoints of both economy and safety but leads to large changes in the culture pH during growth. Here, we report that glycylglycine is an inexpensive and nontoxic buffer suitable for growth of Methanococcus maripaludis and Methanothermococcus okinawensis. This cultivation system is suitable for growth on liquid as well as solid medium in serum bottles. Moreover, it allows cultivation of liter scale cultures without expensive fermentation equipment. This formate cultivation system provides an inexpensive and flexible alternative for the growth of formate-utilizing, hydrogenotrophic methanogens.