Aerobic Hydrogen Production via Nitrogenase in Azotobacter vinelandii CA6

Debottlenecking the biological hydrogen production pathway of dark fermentation: insight into the impact of strain improvement

Confronted with the exhaustion of the earth’s fossil fuel reservoirs, bio-based process to produce renewable energy is receiving significant interest. Hydrogen is considered as an attractive energy carrier that can replace fossil fuels in the future mainly due to its high energy content, recyclability and environment-friendly nature. Biological hydrogen production from renewable biomass or waste materials by dark fermentation is a promising alternative to conventional routes since it is energy-saving and reduces environmental pollution. However, the current yield and evolution rate of fermentative hydrogen production are still low. Strain improvement of the microorganisms employed for hydrogen production is required to make the process competitive with traditional production methods. The present review summarizes recent progresses on the screening for highly efficient hydrogen-producing strains using various strategies. As the metabolic pathways for fermentative hydrogen production have been largely resolved, it is now possible to engineer the hydrogen-producing strains by rational design. The hydrogen yields and production rates by different genetically modified microorganisms are discussed. The key limitations and challenges faced in present studies are also proposed. We hope that this review can provide useful information for scientists in the field of fermentative hydrogen production.

Hydrogen can be generated by microorganisms.

Dark fermentation is efficient for biological hydrogen production.

Strain improvement is critical to enhancing hydrogen-producing ability.

AnfO controls fidelity of nitrogenase FeFe protein maturation by preventing misincorporation of FeV ‐cofactor

Azotobacter vinelandii produces three genetically distinct, but structurally and mechanistically similar nitrogenase isozymes designated as Mo‐dependent, V‐dependent, or Fe‐only based on the heterometal contained within their associated active site cofactors. These catalytic cofactors, which provide the site for N₂ binding and reduction, are, respectively, designated as FeMo‐cofactor, FeV‐cofactor, and FeFe‐cofactor. Fe‐only nitrogenase is a poor catalyst for N₂ fixation, when compared to the Mo‐dependent and V‐dependent nitrogenases and is only produced when neither Mo nor V is available. Under conditions favoring the production of Fe‐only nitrogenase a gene product designated AnfO preserves the fidelity of Fe‐only nitrogenase by preventing the misincorporation of FeV‐cofactor, which results in the accumulation of a hybrid enzyme that cannot reduce N₂. These results are interpreted to indicate that AnfO controls the fidelity of Fe‐only nitrogenase maturation during the physiological transition from conditions that favor V‐dependent nitrogenase utilization to Fe‐only nitrogenase utilization to support diazotrophic growth.

Metabolic Model of the Nitrogen-Fixing Obligate Aerobe Azotobacter vinelandii Predicts Its Adaptation to Oxygen Concentration and Metal Availability

There is considerable interest in promoting biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) as a mechanism to reduce the inputs of nitrogenous fertilizers in agriculture, but considerable fundamental knowledge gaps still need to be addressed. BNF is catalyzed by nitrogenase, which requires a large input of energy in the form of ATP and low potential electrons. Diazotrophs that respire aerobically have an advantage in meeting the ATP demands of BNF but face challenges in protecting nitrogenase from inactivation by oxygen. Here, we constructed a genome-scale metabolic model of the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii, which uses a complex respiratory protection mechanism to consume oxygen at a high rate to keep intracellular conditions microaerobic. Our model accurately predicts growth rate under high oxygen and substrate concentrations, consistent with a large electron flux directed to the respiratory protection mechanism. While a partially decoupled electron transport chain compensates for some of the energy imbalance under high-oxygen conditions, it does not account for all substrate intake, leading to increased maintenance rates. Interestingly, the respiratory protection mechanism is required for accurate predictions even when ammonia is supplemented during growth, suggesting that the respiratory protection mechanism might be a core principle of metabolism and not just used for nitrogenase protection. We have also shown that rearrangement of flux through the electron transport system allows A. vinelandii to adapt to different oxygen concentrations, metal availability, and genetic disruption, which cause an ammonia excretion phenotype. Accurately determining the energy balance in an aerobic nitrogen-fixing metabolic model is required for future engineering approaches.

Specificity of NifEN and VnfEN for the Assembly of Nitrogenase Active Site Cofactors in Azotobacter vinelandii

The nitrogen-fixing microbe Azotobacter vinelandii has the ability to produce three genetically distinct, but mechanistically similar, components that catalyze nitrogen fixation. For two of these components, the Mo-dependent and V-dependent components, their corresponding metal-containing active site cofactors, designated FeMo-cofactor and FeV-cofactor, respectively, are preformed on separate molecular scaffolds designated NifEN and VnfEN, respectively. From prior studies, and the present work, it is now established that neither of these scaffolds can replace the other with respect to their in vivo cofactor assembly functions. Namely, a strain inactivated for NifEN cannot produce active Mo-dependent nitrogenase nor can a strain inactivated for VnfEN produce an active V-dependent nitrogenase. It is therefore proposed that metal specificities for FeMo-cofactor and FeV-cofactor formation are supplied by their respective assembly scaffolds. In the case of the third, Fe-only component, its associated active site cofactor, designated FeFe-cofactor, requires neither the NifEN nor VnfEN assembly scaffold for its formation. Furthermore, there are no other genes present in A. vinelandii that encode proteins having primary structure similarity to either NifEN or VnfEN. It is therefore concluded that FeFe-cofactor assembly is completed within its cognate catalytic protein partner without the aid of an intermediate assembly site. IMPORTANCE Biological nitrogen fixation is a complex process involving the nitrogenases. The biosynthesis of an active nitrogenase involves a large number of genes and the coordinated function of their products. Understanding the details of the assembly and activation of the different nitrogen fixation components, in particular the simplest one known so far, the Fe-only nitrogenase, would contribute to the goal of transferring the necessary genetic elements of bacterial nitrogen fixation to cereal crops to endow them with the capacity for self-fertilization. In this work, we show that there is no need for a scaffold complex for the assembly of the FeFe-cofactor, which provides the active site for Fe-only nitrogenase. These results are in agreement with previously reported genetic reconstruction experiments using a non-nitrogen-fixing microbe. In aggregate, these findings provide a high degree of confidence that the Fe-only system represents the simplest and, therefore, most attractive target for mobilizing nitrogen fixation into plants.

Automated Laboratory Growth Assessment and Maintenance of Azotobacter vinelandii

Azotobacter vinelandii (A. vinelandii) is a commonly used model organism for the study of aerobic respiration, the bacterial production of several industrially relevant compounds, and, perhaps most significantly, the genetics and biochemistry of biological nitrogen fixation. Laboratory growth assessments of A. vinelandii are useful for evaluating the impact of environmental and genetic modifications on physiological properties, including diazotrophy. However, researchers typically rely on manual growth methods that are oftentimes laborious and inefficient. We present a protocol for the automated growth assessment of A. vinelandii on a microplate reader, particularly well-suited for studies of diazotrophic growth. We discuss common pitfalls and strategies for protocol optimization, and demonstrate the protocol's application toward growth evaluation of strains carrying modifications to nitrogen-fixation genes. © 2021 The Authors. Basic Protocol 1: Preparation of A. vinelandii plate cultures from frozen stock Basic Protocol 2: Preparation of A. vinelandii liquid precultures Basic Protocol 3: Automated growth rate experiment of A. vinelandii on a microplate reader.

Modeling of nitrogen fixation and polymer production in the heterotrophic diazotroph Azotobacter vinelandii DJ

Nitrogen fixation is an important metabolic process carried out by microorganisms, which converts molecular nitrogen into inorganic nitrogenous compounds such as ammonia (NH₃). These nitrogenous compounds are crucial for biogeochemical cycles and for the synthesis of essential biomolecules, i.e. nucleic acids, amino acids and proteins. Azotobacter vinelandii is a bacterial non-photosynthetic model organism to study aerobic nitrogen fixation (diazotrophy) and hydrogen production. Moreover, the diazotroph can produce biopolymers like alginate and polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) that have important industrial applications. However, many metabolic processes such as partitioning of carbon and nitrogen metabolism in A. vinelandii remain unknown to date.

Genome-scale metabolic models (M-models) represent reliable tools to unravel and optimize metabolic functions at genome-scale. M-models are mathematical representations that contain information about genes, reactions, metabolites and their associations. M-models can simulate optimal reaction fluxes under a wide variety of conditions using experimentally determined constraints. Here we report on the development of a M-model of the wild type bacterium A. vinelandii DJ (iDT1278) which consists of 2,003 metabolites, 2,469 reactions, and 1,278 genes. We validated the model using high-throughput phenotypic and physiological data, testing 180 carbon sources and 95 nitrogen sources. iDT1278 was able to achieve an accuracy of 89% and 91% for growth with carbon sources and nitrogen source, respectively. This comprehensive M-model will help to comprehend metabolic processes associated with nitrogen fixation, ammonium assimilation, and production of organic nitrogen in an environmentally important microorganism.

•

Genome-scale metabolic model of Azotobacter vinelandii DJ achives over 90% accuracy.

•

iDT1278 is the most comprehensive model to simulate diazotrophy.

•

Determining the most suitable culture conditions to produce polymers A. vinelandii.

•

Constraint-based modeling unravels links among nitrogen fixation and production of organic nitrogen.

Two-Stage Continuous Conversion of Carbon Monoxide to Ethylene by Whole Cells of Azotobacter vinelandii

Azotobacter vinelandii is an obligate aerobic diazotroph with a verified transient ability to reduce carbon monoxide to ethylene by its vanadium nitrogenase. In this study, we implemented an industrially relevant continuous two-stage stirred-tank system for in vivo biotransformation of a controlled supply of air enriched with 5% carbon monoxide to 302 μg ethylene g^-1 glucose consumed. To attain this value, the process required overcoming critical oxygen limitations during cell proliferation while simultaneously avoiding the A. vinelandii respiratory protection mechanism that negatively impacts in vivo nitrogenase activity. Additionally, process conditions allowed the demonstration of carbon monoxide's solubility as a reaction-limiting factor and a competitor with dinitrogen for the vanadium nitrogenase active site, implying that excess intracellular carbon monoxide could lead to a cessation of cell proliferation and ethylene formation as shown genetically using a new strain of A. vinelandii deficient in carbon monoxide dehydrogenase.IMPORTANCE Ethylene is an essential commodity feedstock used for the generation of a variety of consumer products, but its generation demands energy-intensive processes and is dependent on nonrenewable substrates. This work describes a continuous biological method for investigating the nitrogenase-mediated carbon monoxide reductive coupling involved in ethylene production using whole cells of Azotobacter vinelandii If eventually adopted by industry, this technology has the potential to significantly reduce the total energy input required and the ethylene recovery costs, as well as decreasing greenhouse gas emissions associated with current production strategies.

Aerobic nitrogen-fixing bacteria for hydrogen and ammonium production: current state and perspectives

Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) is accomplished through the action of the oxygen-sensitive enzyme nitrogenase. One unique caveat of this reaction is the inclusion of hydrogen gas (H₂) evolution as a requirement of the reaction mechanism. In the absence of nitrogen gas as a substrate, nitrogenase will reduce available protons to become a directional ATP-dependent hydrogenase. Aerobic nitrogen-fixing microbes are of particular interest, because these organisms have evolved to perform these reactions with oxygen-sensitive enzymes in an environment surrounded by oxygen. The ability to maintain a functioning nitrogenase in aerobic conditions facilitates the application of these organisms under conditions where most anaerobic nitrogen fixers are excluded. In recent years, questions related to the potential yields of the nitrogenase-derived products ammonium and H₂ have grown more approachable to experimentation based on efforts to construct increasingly more complicated strains of aerobic nitrogen fixers such as the obligate aerobe Azotobacter vinelandii. This mini-review provides perspectives of recent and historical efforts to understand and quantify the yields of ammonium and H₂ that can be obtained through the model aerobe A. vinelandii, and outstanding questions that remain to be answered to fully realize the potential of nitrogenase in these applications with model aerobic bacteria.

Interfacing nature's catalytic machinery with synthetic materials for semi-artificial photosynthesis

Semi-artificial photosynthetic systems aim to overcome the limitations of natural and artificial photosynthesis while providing an opportunity to investigate their respective functionality. The progress and studies of these hybrid systems is the focus of this forward-looking perspective. In this Review, we discuss how enzymes have been interfaced with synthetic materials and employed for semi-artificial fuel production. In parallel, we examine how more complex living cellular systems can be recruited for in vivo fuel and chemical production in an approach where inorganic nanostructures are hybridized with photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic microorganisms. Side-by-side comparisons reveal strengths and limitations of enzyme- and microorganism-based hybrid systems, and how lessons extracted from studying enzyme hybrids can be applied to investigations of microorganism-hybrid devices. We conclude by putting semi-artificial photosynthesis in the context of its own ambitions and discuss how it can help address the grand challenges facing artificial systems for the efficient generation of solar fuels and chemicals.

Efforts toward optimization of aerobic biohydrogen reveal details of secondary regulation of biological nitrogen fixation by nitrogenous compounds in Azotobacter vinelandii

Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) through the enzyme nitrogenase is performed by a unique class of organisms known as diazotrophs. One interesting facet of BNF is that it produces molecular hydrogen (H₂) as a requisite by-product. In the absence of N₂ substrate, or under conditions that limit access of N₂ to the enzyme through modifications of amino acids near the active site, nitrogenase activity can be redirected toward a role as a dedicated hydrogenase. In free-living diazotrophs, nitrogenases are tightly regulated to minimize BNF to meet only the growth requirements of the cell, and are often accompanied by uptake hydrogenases that oxidize the H₂ by-product to recover the electrons from this product. The wild-type strain of Azotobacter vinelandii performs all of the tasks described above to minimize losses of H₂ while also growing as an obligate aerobe. Individual alterations to A. vinelandii have been demonstrated that disrupt key aspects of the N₂ reduction cycle, thereby diverting resources and energy toward the production of H₂. In this work, we have combined three approaches to override the primary regulation of BNF and redirect metabolism to drive biological H₂ production by nitrogenase in A. vinelandii. The resulting H₂-producing strain was further utilized as a surrogate to study secondary, post-transcriptional regulation of BNF by several key nitrogen-containing metabolites. The improvement in yields of H₂ that were achieved through various combinations of these three approaches was compared and is presented along with the insights into inhibition of BNF by several nitrogen compounds that are common in various waste streams. The findings indicate that both ammonium and nitrite hinder BNF through this secondary inhibition, but urea and nitrate do not. These results provide essential details to inform future biosynthetic approaches to yield nitrogen products that do not inadvertently inhibit BNF.

Azotobacter vinelandii Nitrogenase Activity, Hydrogen Production, and Response to Oxygen Exposure

Azotobacter vinelandii selectively utilizes three types of nitrogenase (molybdenum, vanadium, and iron only) to fix N₂, with their expression regulated by the presence or absence of different metal cofactors in its environment. Each alternative nitrogenase isoenzyme is predicted to have different electron flux requirements based on in vitro measurements, with the molybdenum nitrogenase requiring the lowest flux and the iron-only nitrogenase requiring the highest. Here, prior characterized strains, derepressed in nitrogenase synthesis and also deficient in uptake hydrogenase, were further modified to generate new mutants lacking the ability to produce poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB). PHB is a storage polymer generated under oxygen-limiting conditions and can represent up to 70% of the cells' dry weight. The absence of such granules facilitated the study of relationships between catalytic biomass and product molar yields across different adaptive respiration conditions. The released hydrogen gas observed during growth, due to the inability of the mutants to recapture hydrogen, allowed for direct monitoring of in vivo nitrogenase activity for each isoenzyme. The data presented here show that increasing oxygen exposure limits equally the in vivo activities of all nitrogenase isoenzymes, while under comparative conditions, the Mo nitrogenase enzyme evolves more hydrogen per unit of biomass than the alternative isoenzymes.IMPORTANCEA. vinelandii has been a focus of intense research for over 100 years. It has been investigated for a variety of functions, including agricultural fertilization and hydrogen production. All of these endeavors are centered around A. vinelandii's ability to fix nitrogen aerobically using three nitrogenase isoenzymes. The majority of research up to this point has targeted in vitro measurements of the molybdenum nitrogenase, and robust data contrasting how oxygen impacts the in vivo activity of each nitrogenase isoenzyme are lacking. This article aims to provide in vivo nitrogenase activity data using a real-time evaluation of hydrogen gas released by derepressed nitrogenase mutants lacking an uptake hydrogenase and PHB accumulation.

Azotobacter vinelandii: the source of 100 years of discoveries and many more to come

Azotobacter vinelandii has been studied for over 100 years since its discovery as an aerobic nitrogen-fixing organism. This species has proved useful for the study of many different biological systems, including enzyme kinetics and the genetic code. It has been especially useful in working out the structures and mechanisms of different nitrogenase enzymes, how they can function in oxic environments and the interactions of nitrogen fixation with other aspects of metabolism. Interest in studying A. vinelandii has waned in recent decades, but this bacterium still possesses great potential for new discoveries in many fields and commercial applications. The species is of interest for research because of its genetic pliability and natural competence. Its features of particular interest to industry are its ability to produce multiple valuable polymers - bioplastic and alginate in particular; its nitrogen-fixing prowess, which could reduce the need for synthetic fertilizer in agriculture and industrial fermentations, via coculture; its production of potentially useful enzymes and metabolic pathways; and even its biofuel production abilities. This review summarizes the history and potential for future research using this versatile microbe.