Functional Differences in the Blooming Phytoplankton Heterosigma akashiwo and Prorocentrum donghaiense Revealed by Comparative Metaproteomics

Critical steps in an environmental metaproteomics workflow

Environmental metaproteomics is a rapidly advancing field that provides insights into the structure, dynamics, and metabolic activity of microbial communities. As the field is still maturing, it lacks consistent workflows, making it challenging for non-expert researchers to navigate. This review aims to introduce the workflow of environmental metaproteomics. It outlines the standard practices for sample collection, processing, and analysis, and offers strategies to overcome the unique challenges presented by common environmental matrices such as soil, freshwater, marine environments, biofilms, sludge, and symbionts. The review also highlights the bottlenecks in data analysis that are specific to metaproteomics samples and provides suggestions for researchers to obtain high-quality datasets. It includes recent benchmarking studies and descriptions of software packages specifically built for metaproteomics analysis. The article is written without assuming the reader's familiarity with single-organism proteomic workflows, making it accessible to those new to proteomics or mass spectrometry in general. This primer for environmental metaproteomics aims to improve accessibility to this exciting technology and empower researchers to tackle challenging and ambitious research questions. While it is primarily a resource for those new to the field, it should also be useful for established researchers looking to streamline or troubleshoot their metaproteomics experiments.

Electrophysiological techniques in marine microalgae study: A new perspective for harmful algal bloom (HAB) research

Electrophysiological techniques, by measuring bioelectrical signals and ion channel activities in tissues and cells, are now widely utilized to study ion channel-related physiological functions and their underlying mechanisms. Electrophysiological techniques have been extensively employed in the investigation of animals, plants, and microorganisms; however, their application in marine algae lags behind that in other organisms. In this paper, we present an overview of current electrophysiological techniques applicable to algae while reviewing the historical usage of such techniques in this field. Furthermore, we explore the potential specific applications of electrophysiological technology in harmful algal bloom (HAB) research. The application prospects in the studies of stress tolerance, competitive advantage, nutrient absorption, toxin synthesis and secretion by HAB microalgae are discussed and anticipated herein with the aim of providing novel perspectives on HAB investigations.

Membrane lipid remodeling and autophagy to cope with phosphorus deficiency in the dinoflagellate Prorocentrum shikokuense

Dinoflagellates, which are responsible for more than 80% of harmful algal blooms in coastal waters, are competitive in low-phosphate environments. However, the specific acclimated phosphorus strategies to adapt to phosphorus deficiency in dinoflagellates, particularly through intracellular phosphorus metabolism, remain largely unknown. Comprehensive physiological, biochemical, and transcriptomic analyses were conducted to investigate intracellular phosphorus modulation in a model dinoflagellate, Prorocentrum shikokuense, with a specific focus on membrane lipid remodeling and autophagy in response to phosphorus deficiency. Under phosphorus deficiency, P. shikokuense exhibited a preference to spare phospholipids with nonphospholipids. The major phospholipid classes of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine decreased in content, whereas the betaine lipid class of diacylglyceryl carboxyhydroxymethylcholine increased in content. Furthermore, under phosphorus deficiency, P. shikokuense induced autophagy as a mechanism to conserve and recycle cellular phosphorus resources. The present study highlights the effective modulation of intracellular phosphorus in P. shikokuense through membrane phospholipid remodeling and autophagy and contributes to a comprehensive understanding of the acclimation strategies to low-phosphorus conditions in dinoflagellates.

Efficient modulation of cellular phosphorus components in response to phosphorus deficiency in the dinoflagellate Karenia mikimotoi

IMPORTANCE

Dinoflagellates are the most common phytoplankton group and account for more than 75% of harmful algal blooms in coastal waters. In recent decades, dinoflagellates seem to prevail in phosphate-depleted waters. However, the underlying acclimation mechanisms and competitive strategies of dinoflagellates in response to phosphorus deficiency are poorly understood, especially in terms of intracellular phosphorus modulation and recycling. Here, we focused on the response of intracellular phosphorus metabolism to phosphorus deficiency in the model dinoflagellate Karenia mikimotoi. Our work reveals the strong capability of K. mikimotoi to efficiently regulate intracellular phosphorus resources, particularly through membrane phospholipid remodeling and miRNA regulation of energy metabolism. Our research improved the understanding of intracellular phosphorus metabolism in marine phytoplankton and underscored the advantageous strategies of dinoflagellates in the efficient modulation of internal phosphorus resources to maintain active physiological activity and growth under unsuitable phosphorus conditions, which help them outcompete other species in coastal phosphate-depleted environments.

The molecular mechanisms and environmental effects of modified clay control algal blooms in aquacultural water

Modified clay (MC) technology is an effective method for controlling harmful algal blooms (HABs). Based on field experience, a bloom does not continue after treatment with MC, even though the residual HAB biomass accounts for 20-30% of the initial biomass. Laboratory studies using unialgal cultures have found that MC could inhibit the growth of the residual algal cells to prevent HABs. Nevertheless, the phytoplankton in field waters is diverse. Therefore, unclassified complex mechanisms may exist. To illustrate the molecular mechanisms through which MC controls HABs in the field and verify the previous laboratory findings, a series of experiments and bioinformatics analyses were conducted using bloom waters from aquacultural ponds. The results showed that a 72.29% removal efficiency of algal biomass could effectively control blooms. The metatranscriptomic results revealed that the number of downregulated genes (131,546) was greater than that of upregulated genes (24,318) at 3 h after MC addition. Among these genes, several genes related to DNA replication were downregulated; however, genes involved in DNA repair were upregulated. Metabolism-related pathways were the most significantly upregulated (q < 0.05), including photosynthesis and oxidative phosphorylation. The results also showed that MC reduced most of the biomass of the dominant phytoplankton species, likely by removing apical dominance, which increased the diversity and stability of the phytoplankton community. In addition to reducing the pathogenic bacterial density, MC reduced the concentrations of PO₄^3- (96.22%) and SiO₃^2- (66.77%), thus improving the aquaculture water quality, altering the phytoplankton community structure (the proportion of Diatomea decreased, and that of Chlorophyta increased), and inhibiting phytoplankton growth. These effects hindered the rapid development of large phytoplankton biomasses and allowed the community structure to remain stable, reducing HAB threats. This study illustrates the molecular mechanisms through which MC controls HABs in the field and provides a scientific method for removing HABs in aquacultural waters.

Elucidating colony bloom formation mechanism of a harmful alga Phaeocystis globosa (Prymnesiophyceae) using metaproteomics

Phaeocystis is a globally distributed Prymnesiophyte genus and usually forms massive harmful colony blooms, which impact marine ecosystem, mariculture, human health, and even threaten coastal nuclear power plant safety. However, the mechanisms behind the colony formation from the solitary cells remain poorly understood. Here, we investigated metabolic processes of both solitary and non-flagellated colonial cells of Phaeocystis globosa at different colony bloom stages in the subtropical Beibu Gulf using a metaproteomic approach. Temperature was significantly correlated with Phaeocystis colony bloom formation, and the flagellated motile solitary cells with abundant flagellum-associated proteins, such as tubulin and dynein, were the exclusive cellular morphotype at the solitary cell stage featured with temperatures ≥21 °C. When the temperature decreased to <21 °C, tiny colonies appeared and the flagellum-associated proteins were down-regulated in both solitary and non-flagellated colonial cells, while proteins involved in biosynthesis, chain polymerization and aggregation of glycosaminoglycan (GAG), a key constituent of gelatinous matrix, were up-regulated, indicating the central role of active GAG biosynthesis during the colony formation. Furthermore, light utilization, carbon fixation, nitrogen assimilation, and amino acid and protein synthesis were also enhanced to provide sufficient energy and substrates for GAG biosynthesis. This study highlighted that temperature induced re-allocation of energy and substances toward GAG biosynthesis is essential for colony bloom formation of P. globosa.

Metaproteomics reveals unique metabolic niches of dominant bacterial groups in response to rapid regime shifts during a mixed dinoflagellate bloom

The dynamics of bacterial composition and metabolic activity during a distinct phytoplankton bloom have been reported. However, there is limited information on the bacterial community response to drastic environmental changes caused by species succession during a mixed-species bloom. This study investigated active bacterial groups and metabolic activity during a mixed bloom formed by dinoflagellates Prorocentrum obtusidens and Karenia mikimotoi using a metaproteomic approach. Bacterial community structure and dominant bacterial groups varied rapidly with the bloom regime shifts caused by species succession. Pseudoalteromonas and Vibrio dominated the bacterial community in the P. obtusidens-dominated regime, while Alteromonas, Cytophaga-Flavobacteria-Bacteroides (CFB) group, and marine Roseobacter clade (MRC) were the major contributors in other regimes, with the most abundant taxa being Alteromonas in the K. mikimotoi-dominated regime and the CFB group in the dissipation regime. Specific metabolic niches and unique substrate specificity of different bacterial groups enabled them to dominate and thrive in different bloom regimes. High metabolic plasticity in signal response, substrate utilization, motility, and adhesion are essential for bacteria to respond to drastic bloom regime shift, and the predominance of specific bacteria under unique bloom regimes may be the result of long-term coevolution between bacteria and bloom-forming phytoplankton species.

An overview of Prorocentrum donghaiense blooms in China: Species identification, occurrences, ecological consequences, and factors regulating prevalence

Prorocentrum donghaiense Lu (also identified as Prorocentrum shikokuense Hada and Prorocentrum obtusidens Schiller) is a bloom-forming dinoflagellate species distributed worldwide. Blooms of P. donghaiense occur annually in adjacent waters of the East China Sea (ECS), especially in the waters near the Changjiang River Estuary. Blooms of this species have also been reported in nearby Japanese and Korean waters. There has been an apparent bloom-forming species succession pattern in the ECS since 2000, with diatom blooms in the early spring, shifting to long-lasting and large-scale dinoflagellate blooms dominated by P. donghaiense during the spring, and finally ended by diatom and/or Noctiluca scintillans blooms in summer. These bloom succession patterns were closely correlated with changes in environmental factors, such as temperature increase and anthropogenic eutrophication. Decreasing silicate by the construction of the Three Gorges Dam and increasing dissolved inorganic nitrogen flux were mainly influenced by high intensity human activities in the Changjiang River watershed, resulting in low Si/N ratio and high N/P ratios, possibly accelerating outbreak of P. donghaiense blooms. Phosphorous deficiency might be the most critical factor controlling the succession of microalgal blooms from diatoms to dinoflagellates. Prorocentrum donghaiense is a nontoxic species, but it can disrupt marine ecosystem by decreasing phytoplankton biodiversity and changing the structure of the food chain. Prorocentrum donghaiense blooms in the ECS have been intensively studied during the last two decades. Several possible mechanisms that contribute or trigger the annual blooms of this species have been proposed, but further research is required particularly on the aspect of nutrient budget, ecosystem impacts, as well as social-economic impact assessment.

Metabarcoding dissection of harmful algal bloom species in the East China Sea off Southern Zhejiang Province in late spring

The coastal region of the East China Sea (ECS) is a famous "hotspot" for harmful algal blooms (HABs) in China. We hypothesize that such frequent occurrences of diverse HABs in the ECS are determined by the presence of unique HAB species in this region. In this project, we identified 3966 amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) representing 35 classes in six protist phyla/divisions. Among the 237 annotated protist species, we identified 58 HAB species, of which 23 HAB species had never been previously reported in the ECS. Many HAB species also displayed unique spatial distribution patterns in the ECS. Notably, we identified three HAB species Prorocentrum donghaiense, Lebouridinium glaucum and Noctiluca scintillans in the site S05-1 with substantially elevated abundance, suggesting that this sampling site was experiencing a multiple-species HAB event. This study was the first attempt in applying ASV-based metabarcoding analysis in studying protist and HAB species in the ECS.

Illuminating key microbial players and metabolic processes involved in the remineralization of particulate organic carbon in the ocean's twilight zone by metaproteomics

The twilight zone (from the base of the euphotic zone to the depth of 1000 m) is the major area of particulate organic carbon (POC) remineralization in the ocean, and heterotrophic microbes contribute to more than 70% of the estimated remineralization. However, little is known about the microbial community and metabolic activity directly associated with POC remineralization in this chronically understudied realm. Here, we characterized the microbial community proteomes of POCs collected from the twilight zone of three contrasting sites in the Northwest Pacific Ocean using a metaproteomic approach. The particle-attached bacteria from Alteromonadales, Rhodobacterales, and Enterobacteriales were the primary POC remineralizers. Hydrolytic enzymes, including proteases and hydrolases, that degrade proteinaceous components and polysaccharides, the main constituents of POC, were abundant and taxonomically associated with these bacterial groups. Furthermore, identification of diverse species-specific transporters and metabolic enzymes implied niche specialization for nutrient acquisition among these bacterial groups. Temperature was the main environmental factor driven the active bacterial groups and metabolic processes, and Enterobacteriales replaced Alteromonadales as the predominant group under low temperature. This study provides insight into the key bacteria and metabolic processes involved in POC remineralization, and niche complementarity and species substitution among bacterial groups are critical for efficient POC remineralization in the twilight zone. IMPORTANCE The Ocean's twilight zone is a critical zone where more than 70% of the sinking particulate organic carbon (POC) are remineralized. Therefore, the twilight zone determines the size of biological carbon storage in the ocean, and regulates the global climate. Prokaryotes are major players that govern remineralization of POC in this region. However, knowledge of microbial community structure and metabolic activity is still lacking. This study unveiled microbial communities and metabolic activities of POCs collected from the twilight zone of three contrasting environments in the Northwest Pacific Ocean using a metaproteomic approach. Alteromonadales, Rhodobacterales and Enterobacteriales were the major remineralizers of POC. They excreted diverse species-specific hydrolytic enzymes to split POC to solubilized POC or dissolved organic carbon. Temperature played a crucial role in regulating the community composition and metabolism. Furthermore, niche complementarity or species substitution among bacterial groups guaranteed the efficient remineralization of POC in the twilight zone.

Omics study of harmful algal blooms in China: Current status, challenges, and future perspectives

In the past two decades, the frequency, scale, and scope of harmful algal blooms (HABs) have increased significantly in the coastal waters of China. HABs have become a major ecological and environmental problem in China that seriously threatens the structure and function of marine ecosystems, the sustainable development of mariculture, and the health of human beings. Much effort has been devoted to studying HABs in China, and great achievements have been made in understanding the oceanographic and ecological mechanisms of HABs as well as the biology and physiological ecology of HAB-causing species. Furthermore, state-of-the-art omics technologies, such as transcriptomics and proteomics, have been used to elucidate the physiological responses of HAB-causing species to environmental changes, the biosynthesis of paralytic shellfish toxin, and the mechanisms underlying the formation of HABs. This review summarizes omics studies of HABs in China over the past few years and discusses challenges and future perspectives of HAB research.

Molecular characterization of harmful algal blooms in the Bohai Sea using metabarcoding analysis

Although the occurrences of harmful algal blooms (HABs) have been intensifying, many HABs in coastal waters may have been neglected despite their damaging impact directly on ecology and indirectly on human and animal health. The current detection of HABs depends primarily on the water coloration, chlorophyll intensity, cell density, and mortality due to HAB toxicity. Such methods may not be adequately sensitive to detecting HABs that are relatively transient or small scale. The Bohai Sea is the largest inlet of the Yellow Sea located on the northeast coast of China and famous for shipping and marine aquacultures. HABs frequently occur in the Bohai Sea. In this study, we explored the composition, diversity, and distribution of HAB species using the metabarcoding approach. Through sequencing and the analyzing the 18S rDNA V4 region of 15 samples collected from spatially isolated sites in the Bohai Sea during an expedition in the summer of 2019, we identified 74 potential HAB species including 34 that had not been reported in the Bohai Sea in previous studies. This project provided a detailed analysis of phytoplankton composition, and molecular detection of HAB species in the Bohai Sea. In particular, these analyses revealed extremely high relative abundances of the ichthyotoxic phytoplankton species Vicicitus globosus (Dictyochophyceae) at multiple adjacent sampling sites in the Bohai Bay, which were close to the Yellow River Estuary during the expedition. The results revealed the occurrence of a potential HAB event that would be otherwise undetected using conventional methods, highlighting the sensitivity and power of metabarcoding analysis in detecting HABs and HAB species. This research suggested the value for routine and long-term monitoring of HAB species as an approach for monitoring HABs.

Metaproteomics reveals the molecular mechanism underlying bloom maintenance of a marine dinoflagellate under low ambient CO2 and inorganic nutrients

Dinoflagellate blooming periods are paradoxically characterized by high biomass growth rate and low ambient dissolved CO₂ and inorganic nutrients, however, the underlying mechanisms linking cell growth and nutrient acquisition are poorly understood. Here, we compared metaproteomes of non-bloom, mid-blooming and late-blooming cells of a marine dinoflagellate Prorocentrum donghaiense. Cell division, metabolism of carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, lipid, porphyrin and chlorophyll were more active in blooming cells than in non-bloom cells. Up-regulation of carbonic anhydrase, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase II, and C₄-cycle proteins enhanced CO₂ assimilation of P. donghaiense. Proteins participating in external organic nutrient acquisition and conversion, such as transporters for fatty acids, peptides and amino acids, external- and internal-phosphomonoester hydrolase, and diverse peptidases and amino acid transaminases, exhibited higher expression in blooming cells relative to non-bloom cells. Interestingly, dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) such as urea and aspartate significantly down-regulated expression and activity of carbon assimilation proteins except for RuBisCO form II, suggesting that DON provided sufficient carbon source which reduced the need to concentrate internal CO₂. This study demonstrates that coupling of efficient CO₂ assimilation with DON utilization are essential for bloom maintenance of P. donghaiense, and future efforts should be devoted to dissolved organic nutrients for prevention and management of dinoflagelllate blooms.

Metaproteomics Reveals Similar Vertical Distribution of Microbial Transport Proteins in Particulate Organic Matter Throughout the Water Column in the Northwest Pacific Ocean

Solubilized particulate organic matter (POM) rather than dissolved organic matter (DOM) has been speculated to be the major carbon and energy sources for heterotrophic prokaryotes in the ocean. However, the direct evidence is still lack. Here we characterized microbial transport proteins of POM collected from both euphotic (75 m, deep chlorophyll maximum DCM, and 100 m) and upper-twilight (200 m and 500 m) zones in three contrasting environments in the northwest Pacific Ocean using a metaproteomic approach. The proportion of transport proteins was relatively high at the bottom of the euphotic zone (200 m), indicating that this layer was the most active area of microbe-driven POM remineralization in the water column. In the upper-twilight zone, the predicted substrates of the identified transporters indicated that amino acids, carbohydrates, taurine, inorganic nutrients, urea, biopolymers, and cobalamin were essential substrates for the microbial community. SAR11, Rhodobacterales, Alteromonadales, and Enterobacteriales were the key contributors with the highest expression of transporters. Interestingly, both the taxonomy and function of the microbial communities varied among water layers and sites with different environments; however, the distribution of transporter types and their relevant organic substrates were similar among samples, suggesting that microbial communities took up similar compounds and were functionally redundant in organic matter utilization throughout the water column. The similar vertical distribution of transport proteins from the euphotic zone to the upper twilight zone among the contrasting environments indicated that solubilized POM rather than DOM was the preferable carbon and energy sources for the microbial communities.

Transcriptome profiling reveals versatile dissolved organic nitrogen utilization, mixotrophy, and N conservation in the dinoflagellate Prorocentrum shikokuense under N deficiency

Harmful algal blooms formed by certain dinoflagellate species often occur when environmental nitrogen nutrients (N) are limited. However, the molecular mechanism by which dinoflagellates adapt to low N environments is poorly understood. In this study, we characterized the transcriptomic responses of Prorocentrum shikokuense to N deficiency, along with its physiological impact. Under N deficiency, P. shikokuense cultures exhibited growth inhibition, a reduction in cell size, and decreases in cellular chlorophyll a and nitrogen contents but an increase in carbon content. Accordingly, gene expression profiles indicated that carbon fixation and catabolism and fatty acid metabolism were enhanced. Transporter genes of nitrate/nitrite, ammonium, urea, and amino acids were significantly upregulated, indicating that P. shikokuense cells invest to enhance the uptake of available dissolved N. Notably, upregulated genes included those involved in endocytosis and phagosomes, evidence that P. shikokuense is a mixotrophic organism that activates phagotrophy to overcome N deficiency. Additionally, vacuolar amino acid transporters, the urea cycle, and urea hydrolysis genes were upregulated, indicating N recycling within the cells under N deficiency. Our study indicates that P. shikokuense copes with N deficiency by economizing nitrogen use and adopting multiple strategies to maximize N acquisition and reuse while maintaining carbon fixation. The remarkable low N adaptability may confer competitive advantages to P. shikokuense for forming harmful blooms in DIN-limited environments.

Utilization of various forms of nitrogen and expression regulation of transporters in the harmful alga Heterosigma akashiwo (Raphidophyceae)

Nitrogen (N) is an essential nutrient for phytoplankton growth. There is ample evidence that N enrichment promotes harmful algae blooms (HABs) but molecular mechanisms regulating N-nutrient uptake and metabolism are not so clear, especially for the raphidophyte Heterosigma akashiwo, which forms ichthyotoxic HABs in many coastal waters. In this study, the utilization of three different chemical forms of N (nitrate, ammonium, and urea) by H. akashiwo CCMA 369 was investigated in batch culture conditions. Results showed that H. akashiwo grew well on all three N compounds, and the highest cell yield occurred in the NH₄⁺ culture group. Reverse transcription quantitative PCR analysis revealed that the expression of high-affinity NO₃^- transporter (NIT), NH₄⁺ transporter (AMT) and high-affinity urea active transporter (DUR3), were significantly up-regulated under N-limitation compared to the N-replete control. The mRNA levels of AMT and DUR3 also displayed a clear diel rhythm, with high levels at midnight. In addition, NH₄⁺ addition (5 μM) did not depress the transcript abundance of any of the three N transporters. Compared with the co-occurring immobile diatom Skeletonema costatum, the high expression of AMT in dark period in H. akashiwo is consistent with its diel vertical migration behavior, which may promote N-nutrient acquisition from deeper layers and give advantages for H. akashiwo to form blooms.