A double-blind, adjuvant-controlled trial of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) immunogen (Remune) monotherapy in asymptomatic, HIV-1-infected thai subjects with CD4-cell counts of >300

HIV-1 Immunogen: an overview of almost 30 years of clinical testing of a candidate therapeutic vaccine

INTRODUCTION

Although current antiretroviral therapy (ART) has transformed HIV infection into a chronic, manageable disease, ART does not cure HIV infection. Furthermore, the majority of the world's infected individuals live in resource-limited countries in which access to ART is limited. Thus, the development of an effective therapeutic HIV vaccine would be an invaluable treatment alternative.

AREAS COVERED

Developed by the late Dr. Jonas Salk, HIV-1 Immunogen (Remune®) is a candidate therapeutic vaccine that has been studied in thousands of HIV-infected individuals in more than a dozen clinical trials during almost three decades. This Drug Evaluation, which summarizes the results of these trials that have shown the vaccine to be safe and immunogenic, also discusses the contradictory and controversial conclusions drawn from the phases 2, 2/3 and 3 trials that assessed the clinical efficacy of this vaccine.

EXPERT OPINION

Given the lack of unequivocal clinical benefits of HIV-1 Immunogen despite almost 30 years of extensive testing, it does not appear, in our view, that this vaccine is a clinically effective immunotherapy. However, inclusion of this vaccine in the newly proposed 'Kick/Shock and Kill' strategy for HIV eradication, or use as a prophylactic vaccine, could be considered for future trials.

Application of radiation technology in vaccines development

One of the earliest methods used in the manufacture of stable and safe vaccines is the use of chemical and physical treatments to produce inactivated forms of pathogens. Although these types of vaccines have been successful in eliciting specific humoral immune responses to pathogen-associated immunogens, there is a large demand for the development of fast, safe, and effective vaccine manufacturing strategies. Radiation sterilization has been used to develop a variety of vaccine types, because it can eradicate chemical contaminants and penetrate pathogens to destroy nucleic acids without damaging the pathogen surface antigens. Nevertheless, irradiated vaccines have not widely been used at an industrial level because of difficulties obtaining the necessary equipment. Recent successful clinical trials of irradiated vaccines against pathogens and tumors have led to a reevaluation of radiation technology as an alternative method to produce vaccines. In the present article, we review the challenges associated with creating irradiated vaccines and discuss potential strategies for developing vaccines using radiation technology.

HIV vaccines

A prophylactic vaccine for HIV-1 is badly needed. Despite 20 years of effort, it is still a long way off. However, considerable progress has been made in understanding the problem. The virus envelope has evolved to evade neutralizing antibodies in an extraordinary way, yet a vaccine that can stimulate such antibodies remains the best hope. Anti-HIV-1 T cell responses are evaded by continuous mutation of the virus. Vaccine strategies that concentrate on stimulating T cell immunity will at best generate broadly reactive and persisting T cell responses that can suppress virus without preventing infection, limiting or preventing the damage the virus causes. The SIV macaque models give encouragement that this is possible, but they need further understanding. Therapeutic vaccination should also be considered.

Phase II placebo-controlled study of V-1 Immunitor as a therapeutic modality for treatment of HIV

BACKGROUND

V-1 Immunitor (V1) is an oral AIDS vaccine containing heat- and chemically-inactivated viral antigens derived from pooled blood of HIV-positive donors. V1 has a pending status as an investigational drug but is currently marketed as a dietary supplement. Earlier published, uncontrolled studies of V1 demonstrated body weight gain, increase in T-lymphocyte numbers, decrease in viral load, and improved survival of end-stage AIDS patients.

OBJECTIVES AND STUDY DESIGN

In order to substantiate prior observations we have undertaken a placebo-controlled phase II clinical trial involving 47 antiviral therapy naive, asymptomatic individuals who had over 350 mm(3) CD4 T-cells (mean/median 538/480) at study entry. Both placebo and treatment arms were identical demographically and by every clinical parameter measured at baseline.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

At the end of 6-month follow-up 29 volunteers who received V1 b.i.d. had gained on average 43 CD4 T-cells (540 versus 583). This gain was statistically significant (p=0.01) while changes in T-cell numbers in placebo group failed to reach the significance threshold (p=0.33). The clinical potential of V1 is further supported by an elevation in CD4/CD8 ratio among V1 recipients and decline in CD4/CD8 ratio in patients on placebo (0.575 versus 0.524; p=0.02). The average weight gain among patients on V1 was 1.8 kg while placebo group lost 0.5 kg. These results suggest that V1 may delay or reverse the disease progression without any concurrent toxicity and support our prior open-label studies indicating that V1 confers clinical benefit. A phase III clinical study is required to confirm these findings and to allow us to seek license for V1 as a therapeutic AIDS vaccine.

Delayed progression to AIDS in volunteers treated with long-term HIV-1 Immunogen (REMUNE) therapy in Thailand

OBJECTIVES

To observe the long-term effects of an immune-based therapy HIV-1 Immunogen (REMUNE; Immune Response Corp., Carlsbad, CA, USA) as a first course of treatment designed to sustain the immune system and thus delay the initiation of therapy with antiretroviral drugs and/or delay disease progression.

METHODS

In this open-label, multi-institute extended phase II P2101B study, disease progression, CD4 and CD8 T-cell counts, HIV-1 RNA levels, and genotypic antiretroviral drug resistance were examined in 223 asymptomatic HIV-1-infected Thai volunteers receiving REMUNE every 12 weeks over 132 weeks. A subset of subjects was randomly selected by the physicians to receive antiretroviral drugs for 10 months.

RESULTS

Patients treated with REMUNE demonstrated a low rate of clinical disease progression (0.72 per 100 person-years), higher CD4 and CD8 T-cell counts, higher body weight before and after treatment in the same patient, and stable viral load with no serious adverse events. We found no genotypic evidence of drug resistance in subgroups of patients on REMUNE monotherapy or REMUNE plus antiretrovirals (ARTs).

CONCLUSIONS

This Thai study, like previous US and European studies, confirms that therapeutic immunization of HIV-infected volunteers modifies disease progression, as evidenced by stabilization of CD4 and CD8 T-cell counts, body weight, and viral load. As the majority of asymptomatic patients demonstrated an objective response to immunization, this study suggests that REMUNE may be utilized prior to initiation of antiviral drug therapy when CD4 cell counts are still above the current ART guidelines. Further work should be carried out to examine its potential use in combination with ART in order to reduce the increasingly common occurrence of drug resistance.

HIV type 1 antigen-responsive CD4+ T-lymphocytes in exposed yet HIV Type 1 seronegative Ugandans

CD4(+) T cell help is important for the functionality of CD8(+) cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTLs) in limiting viral replication and may contribute to mediation of apparent resistance to HIV-1 infection in exposed seronegative (ESN) individuals. Using five HIV-1 antigens in an intracellular cytokine assay, the presence of specific antigen-responsive interferon- gamma-positive (IFN-gamma(+)) CD69(+) CD4(+) T-lymphocytes was evaluated in ESNs, their seropositive partners, and unexposed seronegative controls. Ten ESNs (five females, five uncircumcised males) were identified from 10 HIV-1 serodiscordant couples with a history of frequent unprotected sexual intercourse. All ESNs and controls were negative on two EIAs and for HIV-1 proviral DNA. The frequency of ESNs with antigen-responsive IFN-gamma(+) CD69(+) CD4(+) T-lymphocytes ranged from three to five of eight for the different HIV-1 antigens. Six of eight ESNs tested had a positive response to at least one of the five antigens. Responses were on average 3.5 times higher among seropositives compared to ESNs and absent in the five unexposed controls. A negative correlation was noted between responses in ESNs and the plasma viral load of their seropositive spouse. Clade-specific and cross-clade reactivity were noted in both ESNs and seropositive partners tested. The findings confirm that ESNs are in a state of HIV-1-specific immune activation and suggest that HIV-1-specific IFN-gamma(+) CD69(+) CD4(+) T-lymphocytes in addition to HIV-1-specific CD8(+) CTLs already described by others are potential immunological correlates of protection from persistent HIV-1 infection.

Therapeutic vaccination against chronic viral infections

Chronic viral infections such as those caused by hepatitis B virus, human papilloma virus, herpes simplex virus, and HIV, in theory, present logical targets of active specific immunotherapy. Indeed, immunological mechanisms are involved in several aspects of their pathogenesis and natural course, such as virus persistence, destruction of infected cells and control of viral replication. Therapeutic vaccination could therefore be an adequate replacement for, or adjunct to, existing therapies. Almost all approaches to therapeutic vaccination have been evaluated in those four disease areas. Despite encouraging results in animals none of these attempts has, so far, been completely successful in the human setting. However, with a better understanding of the immunological mechanisms involved in the control of disease successful therapeutic vaccines, used alone or in combination with other therapies, are an achievable goal.

Safety and efficacy of an oral HIV vaccine (V-1 Immunitor) in AIDS patients at various stages of the disease

PURPOSE

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of an orally available, therapeutic HIV vaccine (V-1 Immunitor) in patients who were not treated with antiviral drugs.

METHOD

All entrants who had been tested at least once at entry and at postimmunization were considered for analysis. Main endpoints were vaccine safety and differential effects on CD4 and CD8 cell counts, plasma HIV RNA levels, and body weight change. Forty patients, 21 females (52%) and 19 males (48%), aged 22-65 years (mean/median age, 35/32 years) with a mean 225/mm3 CD4 cells at baseline were retrospectively analyzed. Patients self-administered two 850-mg pills containing inactivated HIV-1 antigens b.i.d. for 27 weeks (median, 24 weeks).

RESULTS

The treatment was well tolerated without significant adverse effects. The mean body weight gain was 2.2 kg (p =.0004). The mean increase in absolute CD4 and CD8 cells was 51 (18%; p =.0088) and 172 (16%; p =.0199) cells/mm3. Viral load was measured by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 8 individuals; although overall decrease did not reach standard cut-off statistical significance (Friedman p =.0588), the trend in reduction of viremia attributable to vaccine administration was highly significant (Spearman correlation test: r = 0.96, p =.0005).

CONCLUSION

Mucosal delivery of HIV antigens provides compelling results and deserves further evaluation in placebo-controlled clinical trials.

The basis for HIV immunotherapeutic vaccines

The drug treatments introduced in recent years for HIV infection have enabled a marked reduction in morbidity and prolongation of life. These treatments, however, are often associated with acute and chronic toxicities, the development of resistant virus can limit their effectiveness, and they are too expensive and difficult to administer in most third world settings. A successful HIV immunotherapeutic vaccine has the potential to overcome these problems, and would be a valuable advance. The most promising approaches have induced the type of immune response found to correlate with reduced activity of HIV in man, especially cytotoxic T-cell responses, or have led to reduced HIV or SIV viral load and increased CD4 counts in non-human primates or man. The agents that have led to one or both of these effects have been selected for review, and include inactivated envelope depleted virus, recombinant envelope glycoprotein, DNA vaccines utilising HIV peptides or gene products, viral vectors, such as canarypox or attenuated vaccinia, with HIV core proteins. There are other approaches, such as alloimmunity, for which no candidate products yet exist, but which conceptually appear promising. Currently, however, only a few phase III studies of HIV therapeutic vaccines have been completed in man, and there has been a modest therapeutic effect. Further development of both existing and new candidates remains one of the key priorities in our fight against HIV.

Study protocol for the evaluation of the potential for durable viral suppression after quadruple HAART with or without HIV vaccination: the QUEST study

PURPOSE

By protecting and stimulating HIV-specific CD4 cell responses, treatment of primary HIV infection (PHI) with potent quadruple HAART could lead to prolonged suppression of HIV replication after cessation of antiretroviral therapy. The QUEST trial investigates this hypothesis and aims to determine whether addition of a therapeutic vaccine to HAART increases the likelihood of prolonged viral suppression compared to HAART alone.

METHOD

148 patients with PHI were recruited. Participants were treated with open-label HAART for at least 76 weeks. Participants with sustained viremia <50 copies/mL were randomized to one of three 5-month, double-blinded study treatment groups: HAART alone, HAART + ALVAC-HIV (vCP1452), or HAART + ALVAC-HIV (vCP1452) + Remune. After a further month of HAART alone, all treatment was stopped where plasma HIV-1 RNA remained at <50 copies/mL. Intensive virologic and immunologic monitoring during a 24-week observation period followed treatment interruption. Patients who met treatment reintroduction criteria were offered HAART rescue.

Development of immunotherapeutic strategies for HIV-1

In the majority of untreated patients, HIV-1 infection presents as a progressive disease of the immune system. Recent studies indicate that immune responses can be induced in HIV-1 infected individuals, leading to some immune control of virus replication. Such immune responses are also observed in small numbers of untreated HIV-1 infected long-term non-progressor (LTNP) patients, as well as in other viral infections (including those with human herpes viruses). Emerging novel technologies, animal studies and detailed immunological studies have proven invaluable in defining the immune responses that are associated with a favourable clinical outcome. Central effector and regulatory cells are HIV-1-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL) and CD4+ helper T-lymphocytes respectively. Fully functional antigen-presenting cells (APC) are also essential in all stages of HIV-1 infection and possibly some (but not all) antibody responses contribute to beneficial immunity. The availability of combination anti-retroviral drug therapy, which successfully controls viraemia, has enabled a beneficial outcome in many HIV-1 infected individuals. Since no chronically HIV-1 infected patient has been shown to eradicate virus, novel approaches utilising therapeutic immunisation and various cytokines to manipulate immune responses and to induce and steer immunity towards a desired phenotype are required. There is a clear rationale for immunotherapeutic intervention in chronic progressive HIV-1 infection, which forms the foundation for novel approaches aimed at inducing and maintaining immune control. Here we review the immunopathogenesis of HIV-1 infection and discuss the promises of therapeutic immunisation and immunotherapy in general and their potential in the treatment of chronic HIV-1 disease.

Long-term follow-up of HIV-1-infected Thai patients immunized with Remune monotherapy

PURPOSE

The purpose of this 2-year follow-up study was to investigate the long-term effect of Remune as monotherapy for HIV-1 infection.

BACKGROUND

Participants previously enrolled in the phase II double-blind, randomized, adjuvant-controlled study of the HIV-1 Immunogen (Remune) were followed for 2 years. Open-label immunization with Remune monotherapy was given to each participant every 12 weeks. Remune, a gp 120-depleted HIV-1 that was inactivated in beta-propiolactone and irradiation, was emulsified with mineral oil (incomplete Freund's adjuvant).

METHOD

In Study 2101B, the effect of four doses of Remune given every 12 weeks over 40 weeks was compared to placebo in 297 asymptomatic type E HIV-infected patients [Churdboonchart et al., 2000]. A group of 17 volunteers were separated into a subset study and another 57 were excluded from analysis due to discontinuation or addition of other treatments. This 2-year follow-up study continued with open-label dosing of HIV-1 Immunogen every 12 weeks for the remaining 223 patients. Changes in CD4+ cells, CD8+ cells, and body weight were monitored at each patient visit.

RESULTS

Overall, immunizations were safe; common adverse events were tolerable injection site reactions. CD4+ T-cell counts remained stable over the 132-week observation period for this cohort with a slight increase of 36.01 cells/microL. CD8+ T-cell counts showed an increase from baseline during the follow-up period (415.21 cells/microL). Furthermore, we also observed an increase in body weight from baseline (1.08 kg) at week 132. In addition, baseline CD4 count appeared to predict CD4 count at week 132 (slope = 0.31, p <.0001).

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that long-term treatment of HIV-1 infection with Remune monotherapy is safe and results in a stabilization of CD4+ counts. Furthermore, it is likely that HIV-1 therapeutic immunization may show its greatest clinical benefit in participants with higher CD4+ cell counts. Such an approach may have important ramifications in developing countries where access to antiviral drugs is limited and also in early chronic HIV-1 infection when CD4+ cells are still over 300 cells/microL in order to limit the cost and toxicity.