Expression level of a chimeric kinase governs entry into sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis Histidine Kinase KinC Activates Biofilm Formation by Controlling Heterogeneity of Single-Cell Responses

In Bacillus subtilis, biofilm and sporulation pathways are both controlled by a master regulator, Spo0A, which is activated by phosphorylation via a phosphorelay-a cascade of phosphotransfer reactions commencing with autophosphorylation of histidine kinases KinA, KinB, KinC, KinD, and KinE. However, it is unclear how the kinases, despite acting via the same regulator, Spo0A, differentially regulate downstream pathways, i.e., how KinA mainly activates sporulation genes and KinC mainly activates biofilm genes. In this work, we found that KinC also downregulates sporulation genes, suggesting that KinC has a negative effect on Spo0A activity. To explain this effect, with a mathematical model of the phosphorelay, we revealed that unlike KinA, which always activates Spo0A, KinC has distinct effects on Spo0A at different growth stages: during fast growth, KinC acts as a phosphate source and activates Spo0A, whereas during slow growth, KinC becomes a phosphate sink and contributes to decreasing Spo0A activity. However, under these conditions, KinC can still increase the population-mean biofilm matrix production activity. In a population, individual cells grow at different rates, and KinC would increase the Spo0A activity in the fast-growing cells but reduce the Spo0A activity in the slow-growing cells. This mechanism reduces single-cell heterogeneity of Spo0A activity, thereby increasing the fraction of cells that activate biofilm matrix production. Thus, KinC activates biofilm formation by controlling the fraction of cells activating biofilm gene expression. IMPORTANCE In many bacterial and eukaryotic systems, multiple cell fate decisions are activated by a single master regulator. Typically, the activities of the regulators are controlled posttranslationally in response to different environmental stimuli. The mechanisms underlying the ability of these regulators to control multiple outcomes are not understood in many systems. By investigating the regulation of Bacillus subtilis master regulator Spo0A, we show that sensor kinases can use a novel mechanism to control cell fate decisions. By acting as a phosphate source or sink, kinases can interact with one another and provide accurate regulation of the phosphorylation level. Moreover, this mechanism affects the cell-to-cell heterogeneity of the transcription factor activity and eventually determines the fraction of different cell types in the population. These results demonstrate the importance of intercellular heterogeneity for understanding the effects of genetic perturbations on cell fate decisions. Such effects can be applicable to a wide range of cellular systems.

Genetically Intact Bioengineered Spores of Bacillus subtilis

Developments in genome editing offer potential solutions to challenges in agriculture, industry, medicine, and the environment. However, many technologies remain unexploited due to limitations in the use of genetically altered organisms. In this study, we use B. subtilis spores to explore the possibility of bioengineering organisms while leaving their genome intact. Taking advantage of the differential expression between the mother cell and the fore-spore compartments during sporulation, we created plasmids programmed to modify the spore phenotype from the mother cell compartment, but to "self-digest" in the fore-spore. At the end of sporulation, the mother cell undergoes lysis and releases the phenotypically engineered, genetically unaltered spores. Using this approach, we demonstrated the potential to express foreign proteins in B. subtilis spores without genome alterations by producing spores expressing GFP in their protective coats, where approximately 90% of the spore population had no detectable plasmid or chromosome alterations. In a separate demonstration, we programmed KinA overexpression during vegetative growth to artificially induce sporulation, and also obtained spores with nearly 90% of them free of detectable plasmid. Artificial induction of sporulation could potentially simplify the bioprocess for industrial spore production, as it reduces the number of steps involved. Overall, these findings demonstrate the potential to create genetically intact bioengineered organisms.

Manipulation of Bacterial Signaling Using Engineered Histidine Kinases

Two-component systems allow bacteria to respond to changes in environmental or cytosolic conditions through autophosphorylation of a histidine kinase (HK) and subsequent transfer of the phosphate group to its downstream cognate response regulator (RR). The RR then elicits a cellular response, commonly through regulation of transcription. Engineering two-component system signaling networks provides a strategy to study bacterial signaling mechanisms related to bacterial cell survival, symbiosis, and virulence, and to develop sensory devices in synthetic biology. Here we focus on the principles for engineering the HK to identify unknown signal inputs, test signal transmission mechanisms, design small molecule sensors, and rewire two-component signaling networks.

The PAS domains of the major sporulation kinase in Bacillus subtilis play a role in tetramer formation that is essential for the autokinase activity

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis is induced upon starvation. In a widely accepted model, an N‐terminal “sensor” domain of the major sporulation kinase KinA recognizes a hypothetical starvation signal(s) and autophosphorylates a histidine residue to activate the master regulator Spo0A via a multicomponent phosphorelay. However, to date no confirmed signal has been found. Here, we demonstrated that PAS‐A, the most N‐terminal of the three PAS domains (PAS‐ABC), is dispensable for the activity, contrary to a previous report. Our data indicated that the autokinase activity is dependent on the formation of a functional tetramer, which is mediated by, at least, PAS‐B and PAS‐C. Additionally, we ruled out the previously proposed notion that NAD⁺/NADH ratio controls KinA activity through the PAS‐A domain by demonstrating that the cofactors show no effects on the kinase activity in vitro. In support of these data, we found that the cofactors exist in approximately 1000‐fold excess of KinA in the cell and the cofactors’ ratio does not change significantly during growth and sporulation, suggesting that changes in the cofactor ratio might not play a role in controlling KinA activity. These data may refute the widely‐held belief that the activity of KinA is regulated in response to an unknown starvation signal(s).

Slowdown of growth controls cellular differentiation

How can changes in growth rate affect the regulatory networks behavior and the outcomes of cellular differentiation? We address this question by focusing on starvation response in sporulating Bacillus subtilis We show that the activity of sporulation master regulator Spo0A increases with decreasing cellular growth rate. Using a mathematical model of the phosphorelay-the network controlling Spo0A-we predict that this increase in Spo0A activity can be explained by the phosphorelay protein accumulation and lengthening of the period between chromosomal replication events caused by growth slowdown. As a result, only cells growing slower than a certain rate reach threshold Spo0A activity necessary for sporulation. This growth threshold model accurately predicts cell fates and explains the distribution of sporulation deferral times. We confirm our predictions experimentally and show that the concentration rather than activity of phosphorelay proteins is affected by the growth slowdown. We conclude that sensing the growth rates enables cells to indirectly detect starvation without the need for evaluating specific stress signals.

A cell cycle kinase with tandem sensory PAS domains integrates cell fate cues

All cells must integrate sensory information to coordinate developmental events in space and time. The bacterium Caulobacter crescentus uses two-component phospho-signalling to regulate spatially distinct cell cycle events through the master regulator CtrA. Here, we report that CckA, the histidine kinase upstream of CtrA, employs a tandem-PAS domain sensor to integrate two distinct spatiotemporal signals. Using CckA reconstituted on liposomes, we show that one PAS domain modulates kinase activity in a CckA density-dependent manner, mimicking the stimulation of CckA kinase activity that occurs on its transition from diffuse to densely packed at the cell poles. The second PAS domain interacts with the asymmetrically partitioned second messenger cyclic-di-GMP, inhibiting kinase activity while stimulating phosphatase activity, consistent with the selective inactivation of CtrA in the incipient stalked cell compartment. The integration of these spatially and temporally regulated signalling events within a single signalling receptor enables robust orchestration of cell-type-specific gene regulation.

The membrane-bound kinase CckA controls the activity of the Caulobacter crescentus master regulator CtrA, which in turn coordinates asymmetric cell division. Here, the authors show that CckA contains two sensory domains that have distinct sensitivities to fluctuations in cyclic-di-GMP concentration and subcellular niche.

Evidence that Autophosphorylation of the Major Sporulation Kinase in Bacillus subtilis Is Able To Occur in trans

Entry into sporulation in Bacillus subtilis is governed by a multicomponent phosphorelay, a complex version of a two-component system which includes at least three histidine kinases (KinA to KinC), two phosphotransferases (Spo0F and Spo0B), and a response regulator (Spo0A). Among the three histidine kinases, KinA is known as the major sporulation kinase; it is autophosphorylated with ATP upon starvation and then transfers a phosphoryl group to the downstream components in a His-Asp-His-Asp signaling pathway. Our recent study demonstrated that KinA forms a homotetramer, not a dimer, mediated by the N-terminal domain, as a functional unit. Furthermore, when the N-terminal domain was overexpressed in the starving wild-type strain, sporulation was impaired. We hypothesized that this impairment of sporulation could be explained by the formation of a nonfunctional heterotetramer of KinA, resulting in the reduced level of phosphorylated Spo0A (Spo0A∼P), and thus, autophosphorylation of KinA could occur in trans. To test this hypothesis, we generated a series of B. subtilis strains expressing homo- or heterogeneous KinA protein complexes consisting of various combinations of the phosphoryl-accepting histidine point mutant protein and the catalytic ATP-binding domain point mutant protein. We found that the ATP-binding-deficient protein was phosphorylated when the phosphorylation-deficient protein was present in a 1:1 stoichiometry in the tetramer complex, while each of the mutant homocomplexes was not phosphorylated. These results suggest that ATP initially binds to one protomer within the tetramer complex and then the γ-phosphoryl group is transmitted to another in a trans fashion. We further found that the sporulation defect of each of the mutant proteins is complemented when the proteins are coexpressed in vivo. Taken together, these in vitro and in vivo results reinforce the evidence that KinA autophosphorylation is able to occur in a trans fashion.

IMPORTANCE

Autophosphorylation of histidine kinases is known to occur by either the cis (one subunit of kinase phosphorylating itself within the multimer) or the trans (one subunit of the multimer phosphorylates the other subunit) mechanism. The present study provided direct in vivo and in vitro evidence that autophosphorylation of the major sporulation histidine kinase (KinA) is able to occur in trans within the homotetramer complex. While the physiological and mechanistic significance of the trans autophosphorylation reaction remains obscure, understanding the detailed reaction mechanism of the sporulation kinase is the first step toward gaining insight into the molecular mechanisms of the initiation of sporulation, which is believed to be triggered by unknown factors produced under conditions of nutrient depletion.

In vivo functional characterization of the transmembrane histidine kinase KinC in Bacillus subtilis

In response to starvation, Bacillus subtilis cells differentiate into different subsets, undergoing cannibalism, biofilm formation or sporulation. These processes require a multiple component phosphorelay, wherein the master regulator Spo0A is activated upon phosphorylation by one or a combination of five histidine kinases (KinA-KinE) via two intermediate phosphotransferases, Spo0F and Spo0B. In this study, we focused on KinC, which was originally identified as a sporulation kinase and was later shown to regulate cannibalism and biofilm formation. First, genetic experiments using both the domesticated and undomesticated (biofilm forming) strains revealed that KinC activity and the membrane localization are independent of both the lipid raft marker proteins FloTA and cytoplasmic potassium concentration, which were previously shown to be required for the kinase activity. Next, we demonstrated that KinC controls cannibalism and biofilm formation in a manner dependent on phosphorelay. For further detailed characterization of KinC, we established an IPTG-inducible expression system in the domesticated strain, in which biofilm formation is defective, for simplicity of study. Using this system, we found that the N-terminal transmembrane domain is dispensable but the PAS domain is needed for the kinase activity. An in vivo chemical cross-linking experiment demonstrated that the soluble and functional KinC (KinC(ΔTM1+2)) forms a tetramer. Based on these results, we propose a revised model in which KinC becomes active by forming a homotetramer via the N-terminal PAS domain, but its activity is independent of both the lipid raft and the potassium leakage, which was previously suggested to be induced by surfactin.

Repeated triggering of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis selects against a protein that affects the timing of cell division

Bacillus subtilis sporulation is a last-resort phenotypical adaptation in response to starvation. The regulatory network underlying this developmental pathway has been studied extensively. However, how sporulation initiation is concerted in relation to the environmental nutrient availability is poorly understood. In a fed-batch fermentation set-up, in which sporulation of ultraviolet (UV)-mutagenized B. subtilis is repeatedly triggered by periods of starvation, fitter strains with mutated tagE evolved. These mutants display altered timing of phenotypical differentiation. The substrate for the wall teichoic acid (WTA)-modifying enzyme TagE, UDP-glucose, has recently been shown to be an intracellular proxy for nutrient availability, and influences the timing of cell division. Here we suggest that UDP-glucose also influences timing of cellular differentiation.

Role of the PAS sensor domains in the Bacillus subtilis sporulation kinase KinA

Histidine kinases are sophisticated molecular sensors that are used by bacteria to detect and respond to a multitude of environmental signals. KinA is the major histidine kinase required for initiation of sporulation upon nutrient deprivation in Bacillus subtilis. KinA has a large N-terminal region (residues 1 to 382) that is uniquely composed of three tandem Per-ARNT-Sim (PAS) domains that have been proposed to constitute a sensor module. To further enhance our understanding of this "sensor" region, we defined the boundaries that give rise to the minimal autonomously folded PAS domains and analyzed their homo- and heteroassociation properties using analytical ultracentrifugation, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and multiangle laser light scattering. We show that PAS(A) self-associates very weakly, while PAS(C) is primarily a monomer. In contrast, PAS(B) forms a stable dimer (K(d) [dissociation constant] of <10 nM), and it appears to be the main N-terminal determinant of KinA dimerization. Analysis of KinA mutants deficient for one or more PAS domains revealed a critical role for PAS(B), but not PAS(A), in autophosphorylation of KinA. Our findings suggest that dimerization of PAS(B) is important for keeping the catalytic domain of KinA in a functional conformation. We use this information to propose a model for the structure of the N-terminal sensor module of KinA.

Expression of kinA and kinB of Bacillus subtilis, necessary for sporulation initiation, is under positive stringent transcription control

Bacillus subtilis cells were exposed to decoyinine to trigger stringent transcription control through inhibition of GMP synthase; amino acid starvation results in the same control through inhibition of GMP kinase by 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate guanosine. The positive and negative transcription control of the stringent genes involves adenine and guanine at the transcription initiation sites, whereby they sense an increase and a decrease in the in vivo ATP and GTP pools, respectively. Decoyinine also induces sporulation in minimum medium. DNA microarray analysis revealed that decoyinine induced two major sensor kinase genes, kinA and kinB, involved in the phosphorelay leading to spore formation. lacZ fusion experiments involving the core promoter regions of kinA and kinB, whose transcription initiation bases are adenines, indicated that decoyinine induced their expression. This induction was independent of CodY and AbrB. When the adenines were replaced with guanines or cytosines, the induction by decoyinine decreased. The in situ replacement of the adenines with guanines actually affected this decoyinine-induced sporulation as well as massive sporulation in nutrient medium. These results imply that operation of the positive stringent transcription control of kinA and kinB, which is mediated by an increase in the ATP pool, is likely a prerequisite for the phosphorelay to transfer the phosphoryl group to Spo0A to initiate sporulation.

Novel modulators controlling entry into sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Upon nutrient deprivation, Bacillus subtilis initiates the developmental process of sporulation by integrating environmental and extracellular signals. These signals are channeled into a phosphorelay ultimately activating the key transcriptional regulator of sporulation, Spo0A. Subsequently, phosphorylated Spo0A regulates the expression of genes required for sporulation to initiate. Here we identified a group of genes whose transcription levels are controlled by Spo0A during exponential growth. Among them, three upregulated genes, termed sivA, sivB (bslA), and sivC, encode factors found to inhibit Spo0A activation. We furthermore show that the Siv factors operate by reducing the activity of histidine kinases located at the top of the sporulation phosphorelay, thereby decreasing Spo0A phosphorylation. Thus, we demonstrate the existence of modulators, positively controlled by Spo0A, which inhibit inappropriate entry into the costly process of sporulation, when conditions are favorable for exponential growth.