Study of tyrosine transfer ribonucleic acid modification in relation to sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Conformation effects of base modification on the anticodon stem-loop of Bacillus subtilis tRNA(Tyr)

tRNA molecules contain 93 chemically unique nucleotide base modifications that expand the chemical and biophysical diversity of RNA and contribute to the overall fitness of the cell. Nucleotide modifications of tRNA confer fidelity and efficiency to translation and are important in tRNA-dependent RNA-mediated regulatory processes. The three-dimensional structure of the anticodon is crucial to tRNA-mRNA specificity, and the diverse modifications of nucleotide bases in the anticodon region modulate this specificity. We have determined the solution structures and thermodynamic properties of Bacillus subtilis tRNA(Tyr) anticodon arms containing the natural base modifications N(6)-dimethylallyl adenine (i(6)A(37)) and pseudouridine (ψ(39)). UV melting and differential scanning calorimetry indicate that the modifications stabilize the stem and may enhance base stacking in the loop. The i(6)A(37) modification disrupts the hydrogen bond network of the unmodified anticodon loop including a C(32)-A(38)(+) base pair and an A(37)-U(33) base-base interaction. Although the i(6)A(37) modification increases the dynamic nature of the loop nucleotides, metal ion coordination reestablishes conformational homogeneity. Interestingly, the i(6)A(37) modification and Mg(2+) are sufficient to promote the U-turn fold of the anticodon loop of Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe), but these elements do not result in this signature feature of the anticodon loop in tRNA(Tyr).

Functional characterization of the YmcB and YqeV tRNA methylthiotransferases of Bacillus subtilis

Methylthiotransferases (MTTases) are a closely related family of proteins that perform both radical-S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) mediated sulfur insertion and SAM-dependent methylation to modify nucleic acid or protein targets with a methyl thioether group (-SCH(3)). Members of two of the four known subgroups of MTTases have been characterized, typified by MiaB, which modifies N(6)-isopentenyladenosine (i(6)A) to 2-methylthio-N(6)-isopentenyladenosine (ms(2)i(6)A) in tRNA, and RimO, which modifies a specific aspartate residue in ribosomal protein S12. In this work, we have characterized the two MTTases encoded by Bacillus subtilis 168 and find that, consistent with bioinformatic predictions, ymcB is required for ms(2)i(6)A formation (MiaB activity), and yqeV is required for modification of N(6)-threonylcarbamoyladenosine (t(6)A) to 2-methylthio-N(6)-threonylcarbamoyladenosine (ms(2)t(6)A) in tRNA. The enzyme responsible for the latter activity belongs to a third MTTase subgroup, no member of which has previously been characterized. We performed domain-swapping experiments between YmcB and YqeV to narrow down the protein domain(s) responsible for distinguishing i(6)A from t(6)A and found that the C-terminal TRAM domain, putatively involved with RNA binding, is likely not involved with this discrimination. Finally, we performed a computational analysis to identify candidate residues outside the TRAM domain that may be involved with substrate recognition. These residues represent interesting targets for further analysis.

Structural aspects of messenger RNA reading frame maintenance by the ribosome

One key question in protein biosynthesis is how the ribosome couples mRNA and tRNA movements to prevent disruption of weak codon-anticodon interactions and loss of the translational reading frame during translocation. Here we report the complete path of mRNA on the 70S ribosome at the atomic level (3.1-A resolution), and we show that one of the conformational rearrangements that occurs upon transition from initiation to elongation is a narrowing of the downstream mRNA tunnel. This rearrangement triggers formation of a network of interactions between the mRNA downstream of the A-site codon and the elongating ribosome. Our data elucidate the mechanism by which hypermodified nucleoside 2-methylthio-N6 isopentenyl adenosine at position 37 (ms(2)i(6)A37) in tRNA(Phe)(GAA) stabilizes mRNA-tRNA interactions in all three tRNA binding sites. Another network of contacts is formed between this tRNA modification and ribosomal elements surrounding the mRNA E/P kink, resulting in the anchoring of P-site tRNA. These data allow rationalization of how modification deficiencies of ms(2)i(6)A37 in tRNAs may lead to shifts of the translational reading frame.

The YqfN protein of Bacillus subtilis is the tRNA: m1A22 methyltransferase (TrmK)

N¹-methylation of adenosine to m¹A occurs in several different positions in tRNAs from various organisms. A methyl group at position N¹ prevents Watson–Crick-type base pairing by adenosine and is therefore important for regulation of structure and stability of tRNA molecules. Thus far, only one family of genes encoding enzymes responsible for m¹A methylation at position 58 has been identified, while other m¹A methyltransferases (MTases) remain elusive. Here, we show that Bacillus subtilis open reading frame yqfN is necessary and sufficient for N¹-adenosine methylation at position 22 of bacterial tRNA. Thus, we propose to rename YqfN as TrmK, according to the traditional nomenclature for bacterial tRNA MTases, or TrMet(m¹A22) according to the nomenclature from the MODOMICS database of RNA modification enzymes. tRNAs purified from a ΔtrmK strain are a good substrate in vitro for the recombinant TrmK protein, which is sufficient for m¹A methylation at position 22 as are tRNAs from Escherichia coli, which natively lacks m¹A22. TrmK is conserved in Gram-positive bacteria and present in some Gram-negative bacteria, but its orthologs are apparently absent from archaea and eukaryota. Protein structure prediction indicates that the active site of TrmK does not resemble the active site of the m¹A58 MTase TrmI, suggesting that these two enzymatic activities evolved independently.

Modified nucleotides in Bacillus subtilis tRNA(Trp) hyperexpressed in Escherichia coli

In the present study, modified nucleotides in the B. subtilis tRNA(Trp) cloned and hyperexpressed in E. coli have been identified by TLC and HPLC analyses. The modification patterns of the two isoacceptors of cloned B. subtilis tRNA(Trp) have been compared with those of native tRNA(Trp) from B. subtilis and from E. coli. The modifications of the A73 mutant of B. subtilis tRNA(Trp), which is inactive toward its cognate TrpRS, were also investigated. The results indicate the formation of the modified nucleotides S4U8, Gm18, D20, Cm32, i6A/ms2i6A37, T54 and psi 55 on cloned B. subtilis tRNA(Trp). This modification pattern resembles the pattern of E. coli tRNA(Trp), except that m7G is missing from the cloned tRNA(Trp), probably on account of its short extra loop. In contrast, the pattern departs substantially from that of native B. subtilis tRNA(Trp). Therefore, the cloned B. subtilis tRNA(Trp) has taken on largely the modification pattern of E. coli tRNA(Trp) despite the 26% sequence difference between the two species of tRNA, gaining in particular the Cm32 and Gm18 modifications from the E. coli host. A notable difference between the isoacceptors of the cloned tRNA(Trp) was seen in the extent of modification of A37, which occurred as either the hypomodified i6A or the hypermodified ms2i6A form. Surprisingly, base substitution of guanosine by adenosine at position 73 of the cloned tRNA(Trp) has led to the abolition of the 2'-O-methylation modification of the remote G18 residue.

Resolution of RNA using high-performance liquid chromatography

High-performance liquid chromatographic techniques can be very effective for the resolution and isolation of nucleic acids. The characteristic ionic (phosphodiesters) and hydrophobic (nucleobases) properties of RNAs can be exploited for their separation. In this respect anion-exchange and reversed-phase chromatography have been successfully employed in the analysis and/or isolation of RNAs. In some cases, particularly tRNAs, chromatographic separations which rely upon multiple interactions between the solute and mobile and/or stationary phases have been highly effective. Mixed-mode chromatography involving simultaneous ionic and hydrophobic interactions, has been employed to resolve complex mixtures of tRNAs. Hydrophobic-interaction chromatography using gradients of decreasing salt concentration and weakly hydrophobic stationary phases has allowed the resolution of some tRNA mixtures as well as the analysis of modified materials.

Polyacrylamide gel mapping of chicken tRNA: comparison of polysome-bound and whole-cell tRNA from normal and avian sarcoma virus-infected chicken embryo fibroblasts

Analysis of the tRNA population from chicken cells was performed by means of polyacrylamide gel mapping. About 60 species were detected; most of these were positively identified by their acceptor specificity. The comparison of polysome-bound and overall cellular tRNA gel patterns from normal and Rous sarcoma virus-infected chicken embryo fibroblasts led us to the following observations: some tRNA species were present in the same relative proportions in all the preparations, and within isoaccepting groups the same species was preponderant; however, although about 8% of whole-cell tRNA was recovered in polysomal preparations, amounts ranging from 3 to 30% were found for individual tRNA species. This points to the absence of a direct correlation between the amount of each mature tRNA species produced and the frequency with which it is used in this case of embryonic cells. No significant difference was observed between the whole-cell tRNA patterns from normal and infected cells. Thus, tRNA transcription appears unaltered when cells are transformed and virus producing. No change was observed in the extent of a post-transcriptional modification of tRNAPhe (the base Y). However, viral infection led to some changes in the relative proportions of individual species from polysomal preparations.

Polyacrylamide gel mapping of chicken tRNA: comparison of polysome-bound and whole-cell tRNA from normal and avian sarcoma virus-infected chicken embryo fibroblasts

Analysis of the tRNA population from chicken cells was performed by means of polyacrylamide gel mapping. About 60 species were detected; most of these were positively identified by their acceptor specificity. The comparison of polysome-bound and overall cellular tRNA gel patterns from normal and Rous sarcoma virus-infected chicken embryo fibroblasts led us to the following observations: some tRNA species were present in the same relative proportions in all the preparations, and within isoaccepting groups the same species was preponderant; however, although about 8% of whole-cell tRNA was recovered in polysomal preparations, amounts ranging from 3 to 30% were found for individual tRNA species. This points to the absence of a direct correlation between the amount of each mature tRNA species produced and the frequency with which it is used in this case of embryonic cells. No significant difference was observed between the whole-cell tRNA patterns from normal and infected cells. Thus, tRNA transcription appears unaltered when cells are transformed and virus producing. No change was observed in the extent of a post-transcriptional modification of tRNAPhe (the base Y). However, viral infection led to some changes in the relative proportions of individual species from polysomal preparations.

cis 2-Methylthio-ribosylzeatin (ms2io6A) is present in the transfer RNA of Salmonella typhimurium, but not Escherichia coli

We have identified the cis isomer of N6-(4-hydroxy-isopentenyl)-2-methylthioadenosine (ms2io6A) as a component of the tRNA of Salmonella typhimurium. This is the first report of this compound in the tRNA of any member of the enterobacteriaceae: the nucleoside was previously thought to be found exclusively in plants or plant associated bacteria. Interestingly, all E. coli strains examined were found to lack ms2io6A. Evidence is presented which suggests S. typhimurium tRNA also contains low levels of 5-carboxymethylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine (cmnm5s2U) in addition to 5-methylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine (mnm5s2U).

Thiomethylation of tyrosine transfer ribonucleic acid is associated with initiation of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis: effect of phosphate concentration

The thiomethylation of Bacillus subtilis tyrosine transfer ribonucleic acid (tRNATyr) (i6A) has been shown to occur during the slowing-down of growth. The extent of this modification in stationary-phase cells grown in defined medium has been determined in parallel with the sporulation frequency. We observed that the presence of phosphate repressed sporulation and also inhibited the thiomethylation of tRNATyr (i6A) of B. subtilis W168. These effects were partially eliminated by decreasing the glucose concentration until it was growth limiting. In the case of strain W23S, in which sporulation is insensitive to glucose repression, sporulation and tRNATyr thiomethylation were not inhibited by nonlimiting concentrations of phosphate. These results suggest that both sporulation and tRNATyr hyper-modification share some common regulatory process.

Transfer ribonucleic acid synthesis during sporulation and spore outgrowth in Bacillus subtilis studied by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

The synthesis of transfer ribonucleic acid (tRNA) was examined during spore formation and spore outgrowth in Bacillus subtilis by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of in vivo 32P-labeled RNA. The two-dimensional gel system separated the B. subtilis tRNA's into 32 well-resolved spots, with the relative abundances ranging from 0.9 to 17% of the total. There were several spots (five to six) resolved which were not quantitated due to their low abundance. All of the tRNA species resolved by this gel system were synthesized at every stage examined, including vegetative growth, different stages of sporulation, and different stages of outgrowth. Quantitation of the separated tRNA's showed that in general the tRNA species were present in approximately the same relative abundances at the different developmental periods. tRNA turnover and compartmentation occurring during sporulation were examined by labeling during vegetative growth followed by the addition of excess phosphate to block further 32P incorporation. The two-dimensional gels of these samples showed the same tRNA's seen during vegetative growth, and they were in approximately the same relative abundances, indicating minimal differences in the rates of turnover of individual tRNA's. Vegetatively labeled samples, chased with excess phosphate into mature spores, also showed all of the tRNA species seen during vegetative growth, but an additional five to six minor spots were also observed. These are hypothesized to arise from the loss of 3'-terminal residues from preexisting tRNA's.

Function of modified nucleosides 7-methylguanosine, ribothymidine, and 2-thiomethyl-N6-(isopentenyl)adenosine in procaryotic transfer ribonucleic acid

To elucidate subtle functions of transfer ribonucleic acid (tRNA) modifications in protein synthesis, pairs of tRNA's that differ in modifications at specific positions were prepared from Bacillus subtilis. The tRNA's differ in modifications in the anticodon loop, the extra arm, and the TUC loop. The functional properties of these species were compared in aminoacylation, as well as in initiation and peptide bond formation, at programmed ribosomes. These experiments demonstrated the following. (i) In tRNA(f) (Met) the methylation of guanosine 46 in the extra arm to 7-methylguanosine by the 7-methylguanosine-forming enzyme from Escherichia coli changes the aminoacylation kinetics for the B. subtilis methionyl-tRNA synthetase. In repeated experiments the V(max) value is decreased by one-half. (ii) tRNA(f) (Met) species with ribothymidine at position 54 (rT54) or uridine at position 54 (U54) were obtained from untreated or trimethoprim-treated B. subtilis. The formylated fMet-tRNA(f) (Met) species with U54 and rT54, respectively, function equally well in an in vitro initiation system containing AUG, initiation factors, and 70s ribosomes. The unformylated Met-tRNA(t) (Met) species, however, differ from each other: "Met-tRNA(f) (Met) rT" is inactive, whereas the U54 counter-upart effectively forms the initiation complex. (iii) Two isoacceptors, tRNA(1) (Phe) and tRNA(2) (Phe), were obtained from B. subtilis. tRNA(1) (Phe) accumulates only under special growth conditions and is an incompletely modified precursor oftRNA(2) (Phe): in the first position of the anticodon, guanosine replaces Gm, and next to the 3' end of the anticodon (isopentenyl)adenosine replaces 2-thiomethyl-N(6)-(isopentenyl)adenosine. Both tRNA's behave identically in aminoacylation kinetics. In the factor-dependent AUGU(3)-directed formation of fMet-Phe, the undermodified tRNA(1) (Phe) is always less efficient at Mg(2+) concentrations between 5 and 15 mM than its mature counterpart.

Post-transcriptional modifications of the anticodon loop region: alterations in isoaccepting species of tRNA's during development in Bacillus subtilis

Structural similarities of tRNA's were compared using three sets of isoaccepting species that had previously been shown to undergo significant changes in chromatographic elution properties as a function of developmental stage in Bacillus subtilis. Comparisons of the structures of the tRNA's were based on the composition of their modified nucleosides, comparisons of oligonucleotide elution profiles from RPC-5 columns, and two-dimensional electrophoretic fingerprint analysis of oligonucleotides. The tRNA's studied were tRNA(Lys) (1) and tRNA(Lys) (3); tRNA(Tyr) (1) and tRNA(Tyr) (2); and tRNA(Trp) (1) and tRNA(Trp) (2). The results suggest that the difference among these pairs of isoaccepting species is a difference in the degree of post-transcriptional modifications of the anticodon loop region. The nucleosides involved were N(6)-(Delta(2)-isopentenyl)adenosine (i(6)A), 2-methylthio-N(6)-(Delta(2)-isopentenyl)adenosine (ms(2)i(6)A), and an unknown nucleoside K, which occurred in a position analogous to N-[9-(beta-d-ribofuranosyl)purin-6-ylcarbamoyl]threonine. The amounts of i(6)A and ms(2)i(6)A, determined using total tRNA from exponential-or stationary-phase cells, suggest that the thiomethylation of i(6)A is a pleiotropic phenomenon affecting several tRNA species. As opposed to the situation in Escherichia coli tRNA, where ms(2)i(6)A constitutes about 90% of the total hydrophobic nucleosides at all growth stages, B. subtilis tRNA's have i(6)A as the predominant hydrophobic nucleoside in exponential growth and ms(2)i(6)A as the predominant nucleoside in stationary phase. Thus, the enzyme system which forms i(6)A and the enzyme system which thiomethylates i(6)A are not coordinated during growth in B. subtilis as they are in E. coli. It is suggested that these changes in anticodon loop modifications in B. subtilis may be related to changes in the translational apparatus which occur during sporulation.