Bacillus subtilis 168 genetic transformation mediated by outgrowing spores: necessity for cell contact

Stress-Induced, Highly Efficient, Donor Cell-Dependent Cell-to-Cell Natural Transformation in Bacillus subtilis

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is a driving force for bacterial evolution that occurs via conjugation, transduction, and transformation. Whereas conjugation and transduction depend on nonbacterial vehicles, transformation is considered a naturally occurring process in which naked DNA molecules are taken up by a competent recipient cell. Here, we report that HGT occurred between two Bacillus subtilis strains cocultured on a minimum medium agar plate for 10 h. This process was almost completely resistant to DNase treatment and appeared to require close proximity between cells. The deletion of comK in the recipient completely abolished gene transfer, indicating that the process involved transformation. This process was also highly efficient, reaching 1.75 × 10⁶ transformants/μg DNA compared to 5.3 × 10³ and 1.86 × 10⁵ transformants/μg DNA for DNA-to-cell transformation by the same agar method and the standard two-step procedure, respectively. Interestingly, when three distantly localized chromosomal markers were selected simultaneously, the efficiency of cell-to-cell transformation still reached 6.26 × 10⁴ transformants/μg DNA, whereas no transformants were obtained when free DNA was used as the donor. Stresses, such as starvation and exposure to antibiotics, further enhanced transformation efficiency by affecting the donor cells, suggesting that stress served as an important signal for promoting this type of HGT. Taken together, our results defined a bona fide process of cell-to-cell natural transformation (CTCNT) in B. subtilis and related species. This finding reveals the previously unrecognized role of donor cells in bacterial natural transformation and improves our understanding of how HGT drives bacterial evolution at a mechanistic level.IMPORTANCE Because DNA is easily prepared, studies of bacterial natural genetic transformation traditionally focus on recipient cells. However, such laboratory artifacts cannot explain how this process occurs in nature. In most cases, competence is only transient and involves approximately 20 to 50 genes, and it is unreasonable for bacteria to spend so many genetic resources on unpredictable and uncertain environmental DNA. Here, we characterized a donor cell-dependent CTCNT process in B. subtilis and related species that was almost completely resistant to DNase treatment and was more efficient than classical natural transformation using naked DNA as a donor, i.e., DNA-to-cell transformation, suggesting that DNA donor cells were also important in the transformation process in natural environments.

GENETIC EXCHANGE BETWEEN BACILLUS SUBTILIS AND BACILLUS LICHENIFORMIS: VARIABLE HYBRID STABILITY AND THE NATURE OF BACTERIAL SPECIES

Experiments employing both broth and soil cultures demonstrated the capacity for bidirectional genetic exchange between the eubacterial species Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus licheniformis. The process was studied using standard laboratory strains and wild isolates of these species. The genetic exchange in soil occurs spontaneously. The interspecific recombination involved markers for antibiotic resistance and for the use of specific carbon sources (API characters). Hybrids frequently had unstable phenotypes, i.e., lacked a consistent expression of foreign genes over repeated transfer and growth. This instability often involved a "correction" back toward the phenotype of one or the other of the parental species for many differentiating characters; the final phenotype was always that of the more probable or actually known recipient species. This "correction" process is reminiscent of phenomena associated with the instability of artificial fusion protoplasts or noncomplementing diploids of B. subtilis, as well as the merodiploids formed by intergeneric crosses with enteric bacteria. The hybrids observed here must also be diploid, in some manner, because they sequentially express traits of both parental species at rates well above the frequency of mutation. Among the unstable changes in hybrids of the wild strains there was a 3:1 bias in favor of "correction." The dynamics of the hybridization process in soil are described. It appears that the hybrids are formed most rapidly following outgrowth from spores and during the early growth of parental vegetative cell populations. Later on, the hybrids are much less frequent in the soil cultures, suggesting that they are competitively inferior to the parental species. It is argued that the capacity for recombination found between B. subtilis and B. licheniformis could locally erase their distinctness, even though they possess only about 15% DNA sequence homology. Yet they remain distinct in the wild. The methods and results of these experiments prepare the way for detailed studies of the nature of species and species boundaries throughout the genus Bacillus.

Potential for horizontal gene transfer in microbial communities of the terrestrial subsurface

The deep terrestrial subsurface is a vast, largely unexplored environment that is oligotrophic, highly heterogeneous, and may contain extremes of both physical and chemical factors. In spite of harsh conditions, subsurface studies at several widely distributed geographic sites have revealed diverse communities of viable organisms, which have provided evidence of low but detectable metabolic activity. Although much of the terrestrial subsurface may be considered to be distant and isolated, the concept of horizontal gene transfer (HGT) in this environment has far-reaching implications for bioremediation efforts and groundwater quality, industrial harvesting of subsurface natural resources such as petroleum, and accurate assessment of the risks associated with DNA release and transport from genetically modified organisms. This chapter will explore what is known about some of the major mechanisms of HGT, and how the information gained from surface organisms might apply to conditions in the terrestrial subsurface. Evidence for the presence of mobile elements in subsurface bacteria and limited retrospective studies examining genetic signatures of potential past gene transfer events will be discussed.

Acinetobacter calcoaceticus liberates chromosomal DNA during induction of competence by cell lysis

A transformation assay was used to assay the amount of DNA present in the extracellular medium of a growing culture of Acinetobacter calcoaceticus. It was observed that small amounts of DNA were liberated during the entire exponential growth phase in a batch culture. Release of DNA could be fully accounted for by lysis of cells. Lysis was quantified via simultaneous measurement of beta-galactosidase activity of cells and supernatant, with a strain that contained a plasmid (pAPA100) with lacZ under control of a constitutive beta-lactamase promoter. In conclusion, no evidence could be obtained indicating that Acinetobacter calcoaceticus actively excretes DNA, to be used for DNA exchange.

Bacterial gene transfer by natural genetic transformation in the environment

Natural genetic transformation is the active uptake of free DNA by bacterial cells and the heritable incorporation of its genetic information. Since the famous discovery of transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae by Griffith in 1928 and the demonstration of DNA as the transforming principle by Avery and coworkers in 1944, cellular processes involved in transformation have been studied extensively by in vitro experimentation with a few transformable species. Only more recently has it been considered that transformation may be a powerful mechanism of horizontal gene transfer in natural bacterial populations. In this review the current understanding of the biology of transformation is summarized to provide the platform on which aspects of bacterial transformation in water, soil, and sediments and the habitat of pathogens are discussed. Direct and indirect evidence for gene transfer routes by transformation within species and between different species will be presented, along with data suggesting that plasmids as well as chromosomal DNA are subject to genetic exchange via transformation. Experiments exploring the prerequisites for transformation in the environment, including the production and persistence of free DNA and factors important for the uptake of DNA by cells, will be compiled, as well as possible natural barriers to transformation. The efficiency of gene transfer by transformation in bacterial habitats is possibly genetically adjusted to submaximal levels. The fact that natural transformation has been detected among bacteria from all trophic and taxonomic groups including archaebacteria suggests that transformability evolved early in phylogeny. Probable functions of DNA uptake other than gene acquisition will be discussed. The body of information presently available suggests that transformation has a great impact on bacterial population dynamics as well as on bacterial evolution and speciation.

Bioenergetic aspects of the translocation of macromolecules across bacterial membranes

Bacteria are extremely versatile in the sense that they have gained the ability to transport all three major classes of biopolymers through their cell envelope: proteins, nucleic acids, and polysaccharides. These macromolecules are translocated across membranes in a large number of cellular processes by specific translocation systems. Members of the ABC (ATP binding cassette) superfamily of transport ATPases are involved in the translocation of all three classes of macromolecules, in addition to unique transport ATPases. An intriguing aspect of these transport processes is that the barrier function of the membrane is preserved despite the fact the dimensions of the translocated molecules by far surpasses the thickness of the membrane. This raises questions like: How are these polar compounds translocated across the hydrophobic interior of the membrane, through a proteinaceous pore or through the lipid phase; what drives these macromolecules across the membrane; which energy sources are used and how is unidirectionality achieved? It is generally believed that macromolecules are translocated in a more or less extended, most likely linear form. A recurring theme in the bioenergetics of these translocation reactions in bacteria is the joint involvement of free energy input in the form of ATP hydrolysis and via proton sym- or antiport, driven by a proton gradient. Important similarities in the bioenergetic mechanisms of the translocation of these biopolymers therefore may exist.

Intergeneric natural plasmid transformation between E. coli and a marine Vibrio species

Natural transformation is the mechanism of procaryotic gene transfer that involves the uptake and expression of genetic information encoded in extracellular DNA. This process has been regarded as a mechanism to transfer genes (primarily chromosomal markers) between closely related strains or species. Here we demonstrate the cell-contact-dependent transfer of a non-conjugative plasmid from a laboratory E. coli strain to a marine Vibrio species, the first report of intergeneric natural plasmid transformation involving a marine bacterium. The nucleic acid synthesis inhibitors nalidixic acid and rifampicin inhibited the ability of the E. coli to function as a donor. However, dead cells also served as efficient donors. There was an obligate requirement for cell contact. No transfer occurred in the presence of DNase I, when donors and recipients were separated by a 0.2-micron filter, or when spent medium alone was used as a source of transforming DNA. These results indicate that contact-mediated intergeneric plasmid exchange can occur in the absence of detectable viable donor cells and that small non-conjugative plasmids can be spread through heterogeneous microbial communities by a process previously not recognized, natural plasmid transformation. These findings are important in the assessment of genetic risk to the environment, particularly from wastewater treatment systems and the use of genetically engineered organisms in the environment.

Evidence for an active role of donor cells in natural transformation of Pseudomonas stutzeri

The transfer of chromosomal genes in a cell mat of Pseudomonas stutzeri was ca. 10(3) times more efficient per microgram of DNA if DNA was added as a constituent of intact donor cells rather than as a solution. Such intact cell-mediated transfer appears to depend on cell contact. It is independent of the presence of plasmids in donor strains and is DNase I sensitive, thus fitting the usual definition of transformation. It is bidirectional: cells of either strain in a transformation mixture served as the donor and recipients. The donor function in cell contact transformation was inhibited by nalidixic acid but was unaffected by rifampin and streptomycin at growth-inhibiting concentrations. Concentrations of nalidixic acid sufficient to inhibit donor function completely had no effect on the ability of nalidixic acid-resistant recipients to take up DNA from solution. These experiments suggest that certain cells donate DNA to others in the cell mat: they argue against the hypothesis that the function of donor cells is merely cell lysis.

On the question of chromosomal gene transfer via conjugation in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Transfer of chromosomal markers between cells of Neisseria gonorrhoeae does not require the presence of a 24.5-megadalton conjgal plasmid in the donor. Apparent conjugal transfer of chromosomal markers may be the result of leakage of deoxyribonucleic acid by some cells in the mating mixture and subsequent uptake of this deoxyribonucleic acid by others.

Specific inhibition of outgrowth of Bacillus subtilis spores by novobiocin

Spores of a Bacillus subtilis mutant temperature sensitive in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) replication proceeded through outgrowth at the nonpermissive temperature to the same extent as the wild-type parent spores. In contrast, the DNA synthesis inhibitor novobiocin completely prevented spore outgrowth while displaying a marginal effect on logarithmic growth during one generation time. Inhibition of outgrowth by novobiocin occurred in the absence of DNA replication, as demonstrated in an experiment with spores of the temperature-sensitive DNA synthesis mutant at the restrictive temperature. Novobiocin inhibited the initial rate of ribonucleic acid synthesis to the same extent in germinated spores and in exponentially growing cells. A novobiocin-resistant mutant underwent normal outgrowth in the presence of novobiocin. Therefore, novobiocin inhibition was independent of its effect on chromosome replication per se.