Transformation-deficient mutants of Bacillus subtilis impaired in competence-specific nuclease activities

From isotopically labeled DNA to fluorescently labeled dynamic pili: building a mechanistic model of DNA transport to the cytoplasmic membrane

SUMMARYNatural competence, the physiological state wherein bacteria produce proteins that mediate extracellular DNA transport into the cytosol and the subsequent recombination of DNA into the genome, is conserved across the bacterial domain. DNA must successfully translocate across formidable permeability barriers during import, including the cell membrane(s) and the cell wall, that are normally impermeable to large DNA polymers. This review will examine the mechanisms underlying DNA transport from the extracellular space to the cytoplasmic membrane. First, the challenges inherent to DNA movement through the cell periphery will be discussed to provide context for DNA transport during natural competence. The following sections will trace the development of a comprehensive model for DNA translocation to the cytoplasmic membrane, highlighting the crucial studies performed over the last century that have contributed to building contemporary DNA import models. Finally, this review will conclude by reflecting on what is still unknown about the process and the possible solutions to overcome these limitations.

Differential expression of two closely related deoxyribonuclease genes, nucA and nucB, in Bacillus subtilis

Despite the lack of involvement of the competence-specific, membrane-associated deoxyribonuclease (DNase) in competence development, the expression of the gene encoding this protein, nucA, was shown to be dependent on the competence signal transduction pathway, and in particular on ComK, the competence transcription factor, which was shown to bind to the DNA region upstream of nucA. The expression of nucB, specifying an extracellular DNase, which was cloned on the basis of its homology to nucA, was shown to be sporulation-specific and dependent on the gene products of spo0A and spoIIG, the latter constituting an operon responsible for the synthesis of the mother-cell-specific sigma factor sigma E. The observed differential expression of nucA and nucB demarcates the appearance of DNase activities which are either associated with the cytoplasmic membrane or secreted into the medium during different post-exponential growth-phase processes.

Bioenergetic aspects of the translocation of macromolecules across bacterial membranes

Bacteria are extremely versatile in the sense that they have gained the ability to transport all three major classes of biopolymers through their cell envelope: proteins, nucleic acids, and polysaccharides. These macromolecules are translocated across membranes in a large number of cellular processes by specific translocation systems. Members of the ABC (ATP binding cassette) superfamily of transport ATPases are involved in the translocation of all three classes of macromolecules, in addition to unique transport ATPases. An intriguing aspect of these transport processes is that the barrier function of the membrane is preserved despite the fact the dimensions of the translocated molecules by far surpasses the thickness of the membrane. This raises questions like: How are these polar compounds translocated across the hydrophobic interior of the membrane, through a proteinaceous pore or through the lipid phase; what drives these macromolecules across the membrane; which energy sources are used and how is unidirectionality achieved? It is generally believed that macromolecules are translocated in a more or less extended, most likely linear form. A recurring theme in the bioenergetics of these translocation reactions in bacteria is the joint involvement of free energy input in the form of ATP hydrolysis and via proton sym- or antiport, driven by a proton gradient. Important similarities in the bioenergetic mechanisms of the translocation of these biopolymers therefore may exist.

Genetic and structural characterization of endA. A membrane-bound nuclease required for transformation of Streptococcus pneumoniae

The endA gene encoding the membrane nuclease of Streptococcus pneumoniae, which is necessary for DNA uptake in genetic transformation, was cloned in a streptococcal vector. This was accomplished by insertional mutagenesis of the gene, cloning of the mutant allele, and substitution of the wild-type allele by chromosomal facilitation of plasmid establishment. Plasmids carrying the endA+ gene complemented cells with endA- in the chromosome to restore DNAase activity and transformability. Determination of its DNA sequence showed the gene to encode a 30 kDa protein, EndA, with a typical signal sequence for membrane transport at its amino end. In vitro synthesis of EndA showed the initial translation product to be enzymatically active without further processing. Comparison with EndA found in cell membranes indicated that the enzyme retained its signal sequence, which apparently anchored the otherwise hydrophilic protein to the membrane. From the nucleotide sequence in the vicinity of endA and the effect of various insertions and deletions, it appears that endA is the last gene in an operon containing at least two other genes. Neither of these upstream genes, nor the downstream gene, are essential for either cell viability or transformability.

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: involvement of the 17-kilodalton DNA-entry nuclease and the competence-specific 18-kilodalton protein

A protein complex, consisting of a 17-kilodalton (kDa) nuclease and an 18-kDa protein, is believed to be involved in the binding and entry of donor DNA during transformation of Bacillus subtilis (H. Smith, K. Wiersman, S. Bron, and G. Venema, J. Bacteriol. 156:101-108, 1983). In this paper, the nucleotide sequences of the genes encoding both the nuclease and the 18-kDa protein are presented. The genes are encoded by a 904-base-pair PstI-HindIII fragment. The open reading frames encoding both proteins are partly overlapping. A B. subtilis mutant was constructed by insertion of a Cmr marker into the gene encoding the nuclease. This mutant lacked the competence-specific nuclease activity and the 18-kDa protein but retained 5% residual transformation. The total DNA association of the mutant was higher than that of the wild-type cells, and DNA entry was reduced to 30% of the wild-type level. These results suggest that an alternative pathway exists for the internalization of transforming DNA. A mutant, exclusively deficient for the 18-kDa protein, previously suggested to be involved in the binding of transforming DNA, was constructed by insertion of a kanamycin resistance gene into the coding sequence of the gene. Since the mutant showed wild-type DNA-binding activity, the 18-kDa protein is probably not involved in the binding of donor DNA to competent cells. The transforming activity of the mutant was reduced to 25% of the wild-type level, indicating that the 18-kDa protein has a function in the transformation process. In vitro experiments showed that the 18-kDa protein is capable of inhibiting the activity of the competence-specific nuclease. Its possible role in transformation is discussed.

An exocytoplasmic endonuclease with restriction function in Streptomyces antibioticus

Streptomyces antibioticus produces a strong endo-DNase which is located between the cytoplasmic membrane and the cell wall. All DNA substrates assayed, including the chromosomal DNA of this species and several bacteriophage DNAs, were completely degraded in vitro by the enzyme. The rate of synthesis of the nuclease depended on the growth medium. In NBG medium, in which the enzyme is not produced, the size of lytic plaques of several actinophages was larger than that in GYM or GAE medium, in which synthesis of the nuclease takes place late in growth. In addition, one of the phages assayed, phi A6, showed a diminution of its efficiency of plating in GYM medium with respect to that in NBG medium; another phage, phi A9, grew in NBG medium but not in the other two media. It is postulated that the presence of the host nuclease, together with the capability of the particular phage to absorb on S. antibioticus of different growth phases, determines the efficiency of growth and the plaque size of the phages on productive media. This hypothesis was confirmed when the growth of phi A6 and phi A9 in a mutant of S. antibioticus lacking the endonuclease activity was analyzed. It is concluded that the enzyme can assume, under some circumstances, a role in in vivo restriction.

Isolation and characterization of Tn917lac-generated competence mutants of Bacillus subtilis

We isolated 28 mutants of Bacillus subtilis deficient in the development of competence by using the transposon Tn917lacZ as a mutagen. The mutant strains were poorly transformable with plasmid and chromosomal DNAs but were normally transducible and exhibited wild-type resistance to DNA-damaging agents. The mutations were genetically mapped, and the mutants were characterized with respect to their abilities to bind and take up radiolabeled DNA. All were defective in uptake, and some failed to bind significant amounts of DNA. The abilities of the mutant strains to resolve into two buoyant density classes on Renografin gradients were studied. Most resolved normally, but several banded in Renografin only at the buoyant density of noncompetent cells. The genetic mapping studies and the other analyses suggested that the mutations define a minimum of seven distinct com genes.

Cloning in Escherichia coli of the gene specifying the DNA-entry nuclease of Bacillus subtilis

With the aim of cloning genes involved in transformation of Bacillus subtilis, a set of transformation-deficient mutants was isolated by means of insertional mutagenesis with plasmid pHV60 (Vosman et al., 1986). Analysis of these mutants showed that those mapping in the aroI region lacked the DNA-entry nuclease activity. Plasmid pHV60 derivatives, containing flanking chromosomal DNA fragments, were isolated from these mutants and were used to screen a library of B. subtilis chromosomal DNA in phage lambda EMBL4. In Escherichia coli lysates, prepared with the phages that hybridized to the pHV60-based probe, a prominent nuclease activity could be detected. The nuclease encoded by the phage DNA had the same Mr as the B. subtilis DNA-entry nuclease and its activity was strongly stimulated by Mn2+, which is also characteristic for the B. subtilis DNA-entry nuclease. From these results it was concluded that the gene specifying the B. subtilis DNA-entry nuclease had been cloned. It was shown that the nuclease activity was specified by a 700-bp EcoRI-PstI fragment.

Manganese: its acquisition by and function in the lactic acid bacteria

The transition metal manganese is considered to be a minor micronutrient in both pro- and eukaryotes, usually being required from the environment at subnanomolar levels. Until recently, Mn was only known to function in cells as a cofactor for a few enzymatic reactions. A notable exception has been reported in many lactic acid bacterial species which require micromolar medium Mn levels for growth and contain up to 35 mM Mn. These high Mn concentrations are accompanied by the near or complete absence of intracellular iron and superoxide dismutase (SOD). Lacking hemes, Lactobacillus plantarum and related species contain a unique Mn-cofactored catalase as well as millimolar Mn(II) in a nonenzymic complex performing the function of the micromolar superoxide dismutase found in most other aerotolerant cells. The high Mn(II) levels are accumulated via an efficient active transport system and are stored intracellularly in a high molecular weight complex. Study of Lactobacillus plantarum has provided an interesting example of the substitution of Mn for Fe in several of the biological roles of Fe, an alternative mechanism of aerotolerance, and a better understanding of the unique biochemistry of the lactic acid bacteria.

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: further characterization of a 75,000-dalton protein complex involved in binding and entry of donor DNA

A 75,000-dalton protein complex purified from membranes of competent Bacillus subtilis cells was previously shown to be involved in both binding and entry of donor DNA during transformation. The complex, consisting of two polypeptides, a and b, in approximately equal amounts, showed strong DNA binding as well as nuclease activity (H. Smith, K. Wiersma, S. Bron, and G. Venema, J. Bacteriol. 156:101-108, 1983). In the present experiments, peptide mapping indicated that the two polypeptides are not related. Chromatography on benzoylated, naphthoylated DEAE-cellulose showed that polypeptide b generated single-stranded regions in double-stranded DNA. A considerable amount of the DNA was rendered acid soluble by polypeptide b. The nuclease activity of polypeptide b was reduced in the presence of polypeptide a. This resulted in an increased fraction of high-molecular-weight double-stranded DNA containing single-stranded regions. The acid-soluble DNA degradation products formed by polypeptide b consisted exclusively of oligonucleotides. In contrast to its nuclease activity, which was specifically directed toward double-stranded DNA, the DNA binding of the native 75,000-dalton complex to single-stranded DNA was at least as efficient as to double-stranded DNA.

Heterospecific transformation in Bacillus subtilis: protein composition of a membrane-DNA complex containing unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex

Previously it was demonstrated that, in contrast to the homologous donor-recipient complex, the unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex remains bound to the cellular membrane. To examine whether proteins known to be involved in the processing of transforming DNA in Bacillus subtilis are associated with membrane fragments which carry chromosomal DNA, a crude membrane-DNA complex was subjected to electrophoresis through a sucrose gradient. This resulted in the separation of membrane fragments associated with DNA and free membrane fragments. By means of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis several proteins, either uniquely present or considerably enriched in the purified membrane-DNA complex, were detected. Among these proteins we identified the 45 kD recE gene product, required for recombination, the 18 kD binding protein involved in the binding of transforming DNA and a 17 kD nuclease involved in the entry of transforming DNA. These results suggest that the membrane sites at which donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome are in the vicinity of the sites of entry of donor DNA through the membrane.

Molecular fate of heterologous bacterial DNA in competent Bacillus subtilis: further characterization of unstable association between donor and recipient DNA and the involvement of the cellular membrane

Although heterospecific transformation is extremely inefficient and very little heterologous donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome in a stable way, we have previously shown that B. pumilus DNA entering competent B. subtilis efficiently associates with the recipient chromosome in an unstable way. This association can be stabilized by photocrosslinking in the presence of 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen; it depends on the recombination proficiency of the recipient strain and on strand-separation of the recipient chromosome (te Riele and Venema 1982b). The present study provides further evidence that the heterologous donor DNA and the recipient DNA are associated by regions of base-pairing. Based on the high sensitivity of the donor moiety in the complex to nuclease S1 (90%) and the high sensitivity of the complex to moderate denaturing conditions (Tm = 48 degrees C), we presume that donor and recipient DNA are associated either by several short sequences of 15-25 fairly well matched base pairs or by a region of base-pairing of about 200 bases, which contains 25% of mismatches. During incubation, the unstable complex disappears, probably due to nucleolytic degradation. The unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex (DRC) was found to be membrane-bound. However, in contrast to homologous DRC, the unstable heterologous DRC remains membrane bound during incubation. Apparently, the predominantly single-stranded character of the heterologous DRC prevents release of the complex from the membrane.

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: a 75,000-dalton protein complex is involved in binding and entry of donor DNA

A 75,000-dalton protein complex involved in DNA binding during transformation was purified from membranes of competent Bacillus subtilis cells. Previous results (Smith et al., J. Bacteriol. 156:101-108, 1983) showed that the complex contained two polypeptides, polypeptide a (molecular weight, 18,000; isoelectric point, 5.0) and polypeptide b (molecular weight, 17,000; isoelectric point, 4.7) in approximately equal amounts. In the present experiments the two polypeptides were extracted from two-dimensional gels and studied separately and in combination with respect to DNA binding and nuclease activities. For DNA binding the interaction of both polypeptides was required. DNA binding occurred efficiently in the presence of EDTA. Nuclease activity was restricted to polypeptide b. The nucleolytic properties of b were identical to those of the native 75,000-dalton complex. Polypeptide a affected b by reducing its nuclease activity. Analysis of the nuclease subunit b on DNA-containing polyacrylamide gels revealed nuclease activities at four different molecular weight positions. These activities were identical to the major competence-specific nuclease activities which were previously implicated in the entry of donor DNA during transformation (Mulder and Venema, J. Bacteriol. 152:166-174, 1982). These results indicate that the 75,000-dalton protein complex is composed of two different competence-specific polypeptides involved in both binding and entry of donor DNA. The possible roles of the two polypeptides in the transformation of B. subtilis are discussed.

Intracellular effects of phage phi W-14 DNA on transformation of Bacillus subtilis

Uptake of transforming DNA by competent Bacillus subtilis cells in the presence of phage phi W-14 DNA (in which half the thymine residues are replaced by alpha-putrescinyl-thymine) is accompanied by a decrease in the amount of trichloracetic acid-precipitable label of the former retained by recipient cells during subsequent incubation. Fractionation of lysates of cells incubated for 0.5 min at 37 degrees C after DNA uptake at 30 degrees C in the presence of low concentrations of phi W-14 DNA (0.1 microgram/ml) demonstrated the presence of single-stranded transforming DNA molecules, typical for DNA taken up by B. subtilis. The intracellular effect of phi W-14 DNA was enhanced by an increase in its concentration (to 0.5-1 microgram/ml), or by increasing the temperature of uptake (to 37 degrees C). With either of these treatments transforming DNA taken up was found in the form of a broad asymmetric band, indicative of degradation, and partially located at the density characteristic for single-stranded molecules. Fractionation of lysates of cells treated (0.1 microgram/ml) or untreated with phi W-14 DNA, and incubated for 20 min at 37 degrees C after DNA uptake, showed disappearance of the single-stranded band. Donor DNA label was then found exclusively in the recipient DNA band, its amount being lower in samples treated with phi W-14 DNA. The influence of a high concentration of phi W-14 DNA on retention of transforming DNA label was correlated with its effect on transformation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

D-(-)-poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate in membranes of genetically competent bacteria

D-(-)-Poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate is a constituent of the membranes and the cytoplasms of genetically competent Azotobacter vinelandii, Bacillus subtilis, and Haemophilus influenzae cells. Within each species the concentration of D-(-)-poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate in the membranes and cytoplasm correlates with transformability. Fluorescence analysis of the thermotropic lipid phase transitions in A. vinelandii and B. subtilis cells indicates that D-(-)-poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate forms an organized gel structure in the membranes which is very labile. The concentration of organized D-(-)-poly-beta-hydroxybutyrate in the membranes, which can be estimated from the intensity of its phase transition, can be used to assess the competence of a culture.

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: purification and partial characterization of a membrane-bound DNA-binding protein

In DNA binding-deficient mutants of Bacillus subtilis a competence-specific protein with a subunit molecular weight of 18,000 was absent. The native protein containing this subunit was purified from B. subtilis membranes by chromatography on hydroxyapatite, DEAE-cellulose, and Sephacryl S-200. This protein appeared to be complexed with a second protein of slightly lower molecular weight (17,000) and a different isoelectric point. The native protein complex (apparent molecular weight, 75,000) contained approximately equal amounts of the two polypeptides and showed a strong DNA-binding activity. Incubation of the complex with plasmid and bacteriophage DNA revealed nuclease activity, specifically directed toward double-stranded DNA. Predominantly single-stranded nicks and a limited number of double-stranded breaks were introduced in the presence of Mg2+ ions. In the presence of Mn2+ ions the complex produced low-molecular-weight breakdown products from the DNA.

Heat sensitivity of Azotobacter vinelandii genetic transformation

Heating competent Azotobacter vinelandii at 37 or 42 degrees C resulted in a total loss of competence with no loss of viability. The transformation process was relatively insensitive to heating at either temperature once DNase-resistant DNA binding was nearly complete. Although competent and 42 degrees C-treated cells bound equivalent amounts of [32P]DNA in a DNase-resistant state, no donor DNA marker (nif) or radioactivity was detected in the envelope-free cell lysate of heated cells, suggesting that DNA transport across the cell envelope was a heat-sensitive event. Competence was reacquired in a 42 degrees C-treated culture after 2 h of incubation at 30 degrees C by a process which required RNA and protein syntheses. The release of a surface glycoprotein, required for competence, from cells treated at 42 degrees C occurred in an insufficient amount to account for the total loss of competence. Recovery of competence in 42 degrees C-treated cells and further transformation of competent cells were prevented by the exposure of cells to saturating amounts of transforming DNA. Further DNase-resistant DNA binding, however, still occurred, suggesting that there were two types of receptors for DNase-resistant DNA binding to competent A. vinelandii. DNase-resistant DNA binding was dependent on magnesium ions, and at least one receptor type did not discriminate against heterologous DNA.

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: properties of DNA-binding-deficient mutants

Transformation-deficient mutants of Bacillus subtilis were selected after replica plating on agar plates containing transforming DNA. Out of 24 mutants tested, 3 showed highly reduced abilities to bind donor DNA; the residual levels of binding were similar to those of noncompetent cells. Transformation and transfection were reduced to nondetectable levels in the mutants. However, transduction with phage SPP1 occurred at normal frequencies. The nuclease activities involved in entry of donor DNA were present in the mutants. Comparison of protein patterns by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis revealed the absence of one major protein in the mutants as compared with the wild-type strain. This protein (molecular weight, approximately 18,000; isoelectric point, 5.0) appeared to be membrane associated. The protein was specific for competent cells, suggesting that it is involved in the binding of donor DNA.

Transformation of Bacillus subtilis competent cells: identification of a protein involved in recombination

With the use of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, the proteins present in a transformation-proficient B. subtilis strain were compared with those present in an isogenic, recombination-deficient strain carrying the recE4 mutation. One protein (molecular weight 45 kD, iso-electric point 5.4) was found to be virtually absent in the recE4 strain. This 45 kD protein is a prominent protein predominantly present in the competent fraction of a competent culture. The synthesis of the protein is substantially stimulated by irradiation with ultraviolet light or treatment with mitomycin C and, to a lesser extent, by treatment with nalidixic acid. Since the protein is also observed in a strain cured for SP beta and carrying non-inducible PBS X, it is unlikely that this protein is a gene product specified by one of these prophages usually present in B. subtilis strain 168. Based on these results we conclude that the 45 kD protein is involved in recombination in B. subtilis.