Analysis of the incompatibility determinants of I-complex plasmids

Understanding the genetic basis of the incompatibility of IncK1 and IncK2 plasmids

Antimicrobial resistance is a persistent challenge in human and veterinary medicine, which is often encoded on plasmids which are transmissible between bacterial cells. Incompatibility is the inability of two plasmids to be stably maintained in one cell which is caused by the presence of identical or closely related shared determinants between two plasmids originating from partition or replication mechanisms. For I-complex plasmids in Enterobacteriacae, replication- based incompatibility is caused by the small antisense RNA stem-loop structure called RNAI. The I-complex plasmid group IncK consists of two compatible subgroups, IncK1 and IncK2, for which the RNAI differs only by five nucleotides. In this study we focussed on the interaction of the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI structures by constructing minireplicons containing the replication region of IncK1 or IncK2 plasmids coupled with a kanamycin resistance marker. Using minireplicons excludes involvement of incompatibility mechanisms other than RNAI. Additionally, we performed single nucleotide mutagenesis targeting the five nucleotides that differ between the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI sequences of these minireplicons. The obtained results show that a single nucleotide change in the RNAI structure is responsible for the compatible phenotype of IncK1 with IncK2 plasmids. Only nucleotides in the RNAI top loop and interior loop have an effect on minireplicon incompatibility with wild type plasmids, while mutations in the stem of the RNAI structure had no significant effect on incompatibility. Understanding the molecular basis of incompatibility is relevant for future in silico predictions of plasmid incompatibility.

Genetic basis of I-complex plasmid stability and conjugation

Plasmids are major drivers of increasing antibiotic resistance, necessitating an urgent need to understand their biology. Here we describe a detailed dissection of the molecular components controlling the genetics of I-complex plasmids, a group of antibiotic resistance plasmids found frequently in pathogenic Escherichia coli and other Enterobacteriaceae that cause significant human disease. We show these plasmids cluster into four distinct subgroups, with the prototype IncI1 plasmid R64 subgroup displaying low nucleotide sequence conservation to other I-complex plasmids. Using pMS7163B, an I-complex plasmid distantly related to R64, we performed a high-resolution transposon-based genetic screen and defined genes involved in replication, stability, and conjugative transfer. We identified the replicon and a partitioning system as essential for replication/stability. Genes required for conjugation included the type IV secretion system, relaxosome, and several uncharacterised genes located in the pMS7163B leading transfer region that exhibited an upstream strand-specific transposon insertion bias. The overexpression of these genes severely impacted host cell growth or reduced fitness during mixed competitive growth, demonstrating that their expression must be controlled to avoid deleterious impacts. These genes were present in >80% of all I-complex plasmids and broadly conserved across multiple plasmid incompatibility groups, implicating an important role in plasmid dissemination.

Plasmid classifications

Plasmids are universally present in bacteria and play key roles in the dissemination of genes such as antibiotic resistance determinants. Major concepts in Plasmid Biology derive from the efforts to classify plasmids. Here, we review the main plasmid classification systems, starting by phenotype-based methods, such as fertility inhibition and incompatibility, followed by schemes based on a single gene (replicon type and MOB class), and finishing with recently developed approaches that use genetic distances between whole plasmid sequences. A comparison of the latter highlights significant differences between them. We further discuss the need for an operational definition of plasmid species that reveals their biological features, akin to plasmid taxonomic units (PTUs).

A degenerate primer MOB typing (DPMT) method to classify gamma-proteobacterial plasmids in clinical and environmental settings

Transmissible plasmids are responsible for the spread of genetic determinants, such as antibiotic resistance or virulence traits, causing a large ecological and epidemiological impact. Transmissible plasmids, either conjugative or mobilizable, have in common the presence of a relaxase gene. Relaxases were previously classified in six protein families according to their phylogeny. Degenerate primers hybridizing to coding sequences of conserved amino acid motifs were designed to amplify related relaxase genes from γ-Proteobacterial plasmids. Specificity and sensitivity of a selected set of 19 primer pairs were first tested using a collection of 33 reference relaxases, representing the diversity of γ-Proteobacterial plasmids. The validated set was then applied to the analysis of two plasmid collections obtained from clinical isolates. The relaxase screening method, which we call “Degenerate Primer MOB Typing” or DPMT, detected not only most known Inc/Rep groups, but also a plethora of plasmids not previously assigned to any Inc group or Rep-type.

Biotechnology techniques for the development of new tumor specific peptides

Peptides, proteins and antibodies are promising candidates as carriers for radionuclides in endoradiotherapy. This novel class of pharmaceuticals offers a great potential for the targeted therapy of cancer. The fact that some receptors are overexpressed in several tumor types and can be targeted by small peptides, proteins or antibodies conjugated to radionuclides has been used in the past for the development of peptide endoradiotherapeutic agents such as (90)Y-DOTATOC or radioimmunotherapy of lymphomas with Zevalin. These procedures have been shown to be powerful options for the treatment of cancer patients. Design of new peptide libraries and scaffolds combined with biopanning techniques like phage and ribosome display may lead to the discovery of new specific ligands for target structures overexpressed in malignant tumors. Display methods are high throughput systems which select for high affinity binders. These methods allow the screening of a vast amount of potential binding motifs which may be exposed to either cells overexpressing the target structures or in a cell-free system to the protein itself. Labelling these binders with radionuclides creates new potential tracers for application in diagnosis and endoradiotherapy. This review highlights the advantages and problems of phage and ribosome display for the identification and evaluation of new tumor specific peptides.

The genome sequence of E. coli W (ATCC 9637): comparative genome analysis and an improved genome-scale reconstruction of E. coli

BACKGROUND

Escherichia coli is a model prokaryote, an important pathogen, and a key organism for industrial biotechnology. E. coli W (ATCC 9637), one of four strains designated as safe for laboratory purposes, has not been sequenced. E. coli W is a fast-growing strain and is the only safe strain that can utilize sucrose as a carbon source. Lifecycle analysis has demonstrated that sucrose from sugarcane is a preferred carbon source for industrial bioprocesses.

RESULTS

We have sequenced and annotated the genome of E. coli W. The chromosome is 4,900,968 bp and encodes 4,764 ORFs. Two plasmids, pRK1 (102,536 bp) and pRK2 (5,360 bp), are also present. W has unique features relative to other sequenced laboratory strains (K-12, B and Crooks): it has a larger genome and belongs to phylogroup B1 rather than A. W also grows on a much broader range of carbon sources than does K-12. A genome-scale reconstruction was developed and validated in order to interrogate metabolic properties.

CONCLUSIONS

The genome of W is more similar to commensal and pathogenic B1 strains than phylogroup A strains, and therefore has greater utility for comparative analyses with these strains. W should therefore be the strain of choice, or 'type strain' for group B1 comparative analyses. The genome annotation and tools created here are expected to allow further utilization and development of E. coli W as an industrial organism for sucrose-based bioprocesses. Refinements in our E. coli metabolic reconstruction allow it to more accurately define E. coli metabolism relative to previous models.

Sequence of pR3521, an IncB plasmid from Escherichia coli encoding ACC-4, SCO-1, and TEM-1 beta-lactamases

The sequence of pR3521, a self-transmissible plasmid from Escherichia coli, was determined. pR3521 (110,416 bp) comprised a contiguous IncB sequence (84,034 bp) sharing extensive similarities with IncI replicons and an acquired region (26,382 bp) carrying sequences of diverse origin, containing bla(ACC-4), bla(SCO-1), bla(TEM-1b) (two copies), strA, strB, sul2, and aacC2.

Evidence that IncG (IncP-6) and IncU plasmids form a single incompatibility group

The Escherichia coli IncG and IncU plasmid incompatibility groups were assigned in 1980 and 1981, respectively. Complete plasmid sequences have recently been published for both these groups, and revealed that their replication proteins are related. We show that when cloned at high-copy-number, putative iterons from the previously identified IncG replicon cause strong incompatibility with IncU plasmids. Incompatibility, albeit weaker, was also demonstrated between the two replicons at their normal low-copy-number. This suggests that a single incompatibility group exists. The only known IncG plasmid, Rms149, can replicate in Pseudomonas species where it is designated IncP-6. We recommend that the combined group be known as IncU (IncP-6 in Pseudomonas spp.).

Control of replication in I-complex plasmids

The closely related plasmids that make up the I-complex group and the more distantly related IncL/M plasmids regulate the frequency of initiation of their replication by controlling the efficiency of translation of the rate limiting replication initiator protein, RepA. Translation initiation of repA is dependent on the formation of a pseudoknot immediately upstream of its Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Formation of this pseudoknot involves base pairing between two complementary sequences in the repA mRNA and requires that the secondary structure sequestering the distal sequence be disrupted by movement of the ribosome translating and terminating a leader peptide, whose coding sequence precedes and overlaps that of repA. Expression of repA is controlled by a small antisense RNA, RNAI, which on binding to its complementary target in the repA mRNA not only pre-empts formation of the pseudoknot, but also inhibits translation of the leader peptide. The requirement that translation of the leader peptide be completed for the pseudoknot to form increases the time available for the inhibitory interaction of RNAI with its target, so that at high copy number the frequency of pseudoknot formation is lowered, reducing the proportion of repA mRNA that are translated. At low copy number, when concentration of RNAI is low, repA is translated with increased frequency, leading to increased frequency of plasmid replication.

CIS display: In vitro selection of peptides from libraries of protein-DNA complexes

We describe the development of an in vitro library selection system (CIS display) that exploits the ability of a DNA replication initiator protein (RepA) to bind exclusively to the template DNA from which it has been expressed, a property called cis-activity. A diverse peptide library is created by ligation of DNA fragments of random sequence to a DNA fragment that encodes RepA. After in vitro transcription and translation, a pool of protein-DNA complexes is formed where each protein is stably associated with the DNA that encodes it. These complexes are amenable to the affinity selection of ligands to targets of interest. Here we show that RepA is a highly faithful cis-acting DNA-binding protein and demonstrate that libraries encoding >10(12) random 18-mer peptides can be constructed and used to isolate peptides that bind specifically to disparate targets. The use of DNA to encode the displayed peptides offers advantages over in vitro peptide display systems that use mRNA.

Mosaic plasmids and mosaic replicons: evolutionary lessons from the analysis of genetic diversity in IncFII-related replicons

The alpha replicons of the multi-replicon plasmids pGSH500 and pLV1402 have been characterized by DNA sequence analysis. Analysis of the DNA sequence of a 3672 bp HIN:dIII fragment from pFDT100, which contains the pGSH500 alpha replicon, revealed similarity to a number of replicons belonging to, or related to, those of the IncFII family. The replicon region contains copA, tapA, repA and oriR, and replication initiation and termination sites are related to those from the IncFII replicon of R1. A copB gene was found to lie upstream of the HIN:dIII site in the parental plasmid pGSH500. Downstream of oriR, a 707 bp region shows 72.6% identity to a region of the Escherichia coli chromosome at 43.3', suggesting this region of pGSH500 may have been incorporated into the plasmid during a past chromosomal recombination event. Oligonucleotide primers homologous to consensus regions in the copB and repA genes, and the oriR regions from a number of IncFII-related replicons were used to amplify replication regions from pLV1402. Analysis of the amplified regions has shown the presence of copB, copA, tapA and repA genes. Phylogenetic analysis of Rep protein sequences from the RepFIIA family of antisense-control-regulated replicons revealed the presence of three distinct subgroups of Rep proteins. Comparative analysis of DNA and protein sequences from members of the RepFIIA family provides evidence supporting the roles of both non-selective divergence in co-integrate (multi-replicon) plasmids and Chi-mediated-recombination in replicon evolution, and in particular, that such processes may have been widespread in the evolution of the RepFIIA family.

Structural analysis of late intermediate complex formed between plasmid ColIb-P9 Inc RNA and its target RNA. How does a single antisense RNA repress translation of two genes at different rates?

The antisense Inc RNA encoded by the IncIalpha ColIb-P9 plasmid replicon controls the translation of repZ encoding the replication initiator and its leader peptide repY at different rates with different mechanisms. The initial loop-loop base pairing between Inc RNA and the target in the repZ mRNA leader inhibits formation of a pseudoknot required for repZ translation. A subsequent base pairing at the 5' leader of Inc RNA blocks repY translation. To delineate the molecular basis for the differential control, we analyzed the intermediate complexes formed between RepZ mRNA and Inc RNA(54), a 5'-truncated Inc RNA derivative. We found that the initial base pairing at the loops transforms into a more stable intermediate complex by its propagation in both directions. The resulting extensive base pairing indicates that the inhibition of the pseudoknot formation is established at this stage. Furthermore, the region of extensive base pairing includes bases different in related plasmids showing different incompatibility. Thus, the observed extensive base pairing is important for determining the incompatibility of the low-copy-number plasmids. We discuss the evolution of replication control systems found in IncIalpha, IncB, and IncFII group plasmids.

Role of CIS in replication of an IncB plasmid

Replication of the IncB plasmid pMU720 requires the synthesis of the cis-acting RepA protein and the presence of two DNA elements, ori and CIS. CIS is the 166-bp sequence separating the RepA coding sequence from ori. To investigate how this organization of the pMU720 replicon contributes to the mechanism of initiation of replication, mutations in the sequence and/or the length of CIS were introduced into the CIS region and their effects on the efficiency of replication of the pMU720 replicon in vivo was determined. The CIS region was found to be composed of two domains. The repA-proximal domain, which showed strong transcription termination activity, could be replaced by equivalent sequences from I-complex and IncL/M plasmids, whose replicons are organized in the same fashion as pMU720. Replacement by a trpA transcription terminator afforded only partial replication activity. The repA-distal domain was shown to be a spacer whose role was to position sequence(s) within ori on the correct face of the DNA helix vis-à-vis the repA-proximal portion of CIS. A model for the loading of RepA protein onto ori is discussed.

Analysis of elements involved in pseudoknot-dependent expression and regulation of the repA gene of an IncL/M plasmid

Replication of the IncL/M plasmid pMU604 is controlled by a small antisense RNA molecule (RNAI), which, by inhibiting the formation of an RNA pseudoknot, regulates translation of the replication initiator protein, RepA. Efficient translation of the repA mRNA was shown to require the translation and correct termination of the leader peptide, RepB, and the formation of the pseudoknot. Although the pseudoknot was essential for the expression of repA, its presence was shown to interfere with the translation of repB. The requirement for pseudoknot formation could in large part be obviated by improving the ribosome binding region of repA, either by replacing the GUG start codon by AUG or by increasing the spacing between the start codon and the Shine-Dalgarno sequence (SD). The spacing between the distal pseudoknot sequence and the repA SD was shown to be suboptimal for maximal expression of repA.

Importance of structural differences between complementary RNA molecules to control of replication of an IncB plasmid

Replication of the IncB miniplasmid pMU720 is dependent on the expression of repA, the gene encoding replication initiator protein RepA. Binding of a small antisense RNA (RNAI) to its complementary target (stem-loop I [SLI]) in the RepA mRNA prevents the participation of SLI in the formation of a pseudoknot that is an enhancer of translation of this mRNA. Thus, RNAI regulates the frequency of replication of pMU720 by controlling the efficiency of translation of the RepA mRNA. Mutational analysis of the two seven-base complementary sequences involved in formation of the pseudoknot showed that only the five central bases of each were critical for the formation of the pseudoknot. Physical analysis of SLI showed that despite the complete complementarity of its sequence to that of RNAI, the structures of the two molecules are different. The most prominent difference between the two structures is the presence of a 4-base internal loop immediately below the hairpin loop of SLI but not that of RNAI. Closure of this internal loop in SLI resulted in a 40-fold reduction in repA expression and loss of sensitivity of the residual expression to inhibition by RNAI. By contrast, repA expression was largely unaffected by the closure of a lower internal loop whose presence in SLI and RNAI is essential for effective interaction between these two molecules. These results suggest that the interaction of SLI with the distal pseudoknot bases is fundamentally different from the RNAI-SLI binding interaction and that the differences in structure between RNAI and SLI are necessary to allow SLI to be able to efficiently bind RNAI and to participate in pseudoknot formation.

The replication of an IncL/M plasmid is subject to antisense control

A 2,385-bp sequence that contains the information for the autonomous replication of the IncL/M plasmid pMU604 was characterized. Genetic analyses revealed that the replicon specifies at least four structural genes, designated repA, repB, repC, and rnaI. The repA gene encodes a protein with a molecular weight of 40,861 which probably functions as an initiator for replication. The functions of the proteins of the repB and repC genes are unclear; however, mutations in the start codon of repB reduced the expression of both repB and repA, indicating that these two genes are translationally coupled. The rnal gene encodes a small antisense RNA of about 75 to 77 bases and is responsible for the incompatibility phenotype, thus implicating its role as the main copy number determinant. RNAI exerts its effect in trans to repress the expression of repA at the posttranscriptional level. Furthermore, two complementary sequences of 8 bases, with the potential to interact and form a putative pseudoknot structure, were identified in the leader region of the repA mRNA. Base-pairing between the two complementary sequences was shown to be critical for efficient repA expression. A model for the regulation of pMU604 replication involving both translational coupling and pseudoknot formation is proposed.

Comparative analysis of the replicon regions of eleven ColE2-related plasmids

The incA gene product of ColE2-P9 and ColE3-CA38 plasmids is an antisense RNA that regulates the production of the plasmid-coded Rep protein essential for replication. The Rep protein specifically binds to the origin and synthesizes a unique primer RNA at the origin. The IncB incompatibility is due to competition for the Rep protein among the origins of the same binding specificity. We localized the regions sufficient for autonomous replication of 15 ColE plasmids related to ColE2-P9 and ColE3-CA38 (ColE2-related plasmids), analyzed their incompatibility properties, and determined the nucleotide sequences of the replicon regions of 9 representative plasmids. The results suggest that all of these plasmids share common mechanisms for initiation of DNA replication and its control. Five IncA specificity types, 4 IncB specificity types, and 9 of the 20 possible combinations of the IncA and IncB types were found. The specificity of interaction of the Rep proteins and the origins might be determined by insertion or deletion of single nucleotides and substitution of several nucleotides at specific sites in the origins and by apparently corresponding insertion or deletion and substitution of amino acid sequences at specific regions in the C-terminal portions of the Rep proteins. For plasmids of four IncA specificity types, the nine-nucleotide sequences at the loop regions of the stem-loop structures of antisense RNAs are identical, suggesting an evolutionary significance of the sequence. The mosaic structures of the replicon regions with homologous and nonhomologous segments suggest that some of them were generated by exchanging functional parts through homologous recombination.

Mechanism of binding of the antisense and target RNAs involved in the regulation of IncB plasmid replication

The replication frequency of the IncB miniplasmid pMU720 is dependent upon the expression of the repA gene. Binding of a small, highly structured, antisense RNA (RNA I) to its complementary target in the RepA mRNA (RNA II) inhibits repA expression and thus regulates replication. Analyses of binding of RNA I to RNA II indicated that the reaction consists of three major steps. The first step, initial kissing complex formation, involves base pairing between complementary sequences in the hairpin loops of RNA I and RNA II. The second step is facilitated by interior loop structures in the upper stems of RNA I and RNA II and involves intrastand melting and interstrand pairing of the upper stem regions to form an extended kissing complex. This complex was shown to be sufficient for inhibition of repA expression. The third step involves stabilization of the extended kissing complex by pairing between complementary single-stranded tail regions of RNA I and RNA II. Thus, the final product of RNA I-RNA II binding is not a full duplex between the two molecules.

Interaction between the antisense and target RNAs involved in the regulation of IncB plasmid replication

Physical analysis of RNA I, the small antisense RNA which regulates the replication of IncB miniplasmid pMU720, showed that it is a highly structured molecule containing an imperfectly paired stem closed by a 6-base hairpin loop. Mutational studies revealed that a 3-base sequence in the hairpin loop is critical to the interaction between RNA I and its complementary target in the RepA mRNA (RNA II). Furthermore, a 2-base interior loop in the upper stem was found to play an important role in facilitating effective binding between RNA I and RNA II. From these analyses, a model describing the molecular mechanism of binding between RNA I and RNA II is proposed.

Mutations affecting translational coupling between the rep genes of an IncB miniplasmid

The nature of translational coupling between repB and repA, the overlapping rep genes of the IncB plasmid pMU720, was examined. Mutations in the start codon of the promoter proximal gene, repB, reduced the efficiency of translation of both rep genes. Moreover, there was no independent initiation of repA translation in the absence of repB translation. The position of the repB stop codon was crucial for the efficient expression of repA, with the wild-type positioning being optimal. Translational coupling was found to be totally dependent on the formation of a pseudoknot structure. A model which invokes formation of a pseudoknot to facilitate initiation of repA is proposed.

Comparative analysis of the replication regions of IncB, IncK, and IncZ plasmids

Minireplicons from the I-complex plasmids R387 (IncK) and pIE545 (IncZ) were constructed, and the nucleotide sequences of their replication regions were compared with that of the B plasmid, pMU720. The coding sequence of the putative replication protein, RepA, of each plasmid was located. RepA of K and B plasmids were homologous, whereas RepA of Z resembled RepA1 of FII plasmid. Sequences upstream of RepA were conserved in the three I-complex plasmids. Group B and Z plasmids were incompatible.

Posttranscriptional control of plasmid ColIb-P9 repZ gene expression by a small RNA

The replication frequency of plasmid ColIb-P9 depends on the level of repZ gene expression, which is negatively regulated by the action of the inc gene (C. Hama, T. Takizawa, H. Moriwaki, Y. Urasaki, and K. Mizobuchi, J. Bacteriol. 172:1983-1991, 1990). To further understand the mechanism of this regulation, we analyzed transcripts of the ColIb-P9 replication control region. Four RNA species, designated RNAI to RNAIV, were observed in plasmid pCH11, which contained the whole inc gene region and the 5' portion of the repZ gene. RNAII, RNAIII, and RNAIV, with sizes of approximately 200, 500, and 1,500 bases, respectively, were identified as rightward transcripts that shared common transcription initiation sites; RNAIV was determined to be equivalent to a part of repZ mRNA, which was observed in pCH10, a plasmid that contained sufficient information for replication and control of ColIb-P9. Conversely, RNAI, with a size of about 70 bases, was transcribed leftward and was identified as the product of the inc gene and hence equivalent to inc RNA detected by in vitro RNA synthesis. This small RNA was found to be complementary to a part of repZ mRNA. These results and quantitative analyses of the transcripts in Inc- mutants indicate that the inc RNA negatively regulates repZ expression mainly at the posttranscriptional level through the possible formation of an inc RNA-repZ mRNA hybrid in the host cells.

Organization of the replication control region of plasmid ColIb-P9

We identified a 1,845-base-pair sequence that contains essential information for the autonomous replication and regulation of the 93-kilobase-pair IncI alpha group ColIb-P9 plasmid. Biochemical and genetic analyses revealed that this sequence specifies at least two structural genes, designated repZ and inc. The repZ gene encodes a protein with a molecular weight of 39,000, which probably functions as an initiator for the ColIb-P9 replicon. The inc gene that phenotypically governs the incompatibility encodes an RNA with a size of about 70 bases. This small RNA acts in trans to repress the expression of repZ, thereby functioning to maintain a constant copy number of the ColIb-P9 replicon in host cells.

Role of countertranscript RNA in the copy number control system of an IncB miniplasmid

Transcriptional mapping studies of the IncB minireplicon pMU720 demonstrated the existence of a long RNA molecule, RNA II, whose 5' portion is complementary to the product of the incompatibility gene RNA I. By using gene fusion and transcriptional fusion plasmids, it was shown that RNA I regulated the expression of the RNA II gene product and that it did so primarily at the level of translation. The target of RNA I was mapped to lie within a 216-base region of RNA II containing the sequence complementary to RNA I. Introduction of the target for RNA I in trans increased the copy number of an IncB minireplicon, indicating that RNA I and RNA II form the basis of the copy number control system of IncB plasmids.

Identification and classification of bacterial plasmids

Images