Regulation of DNA superhelicity by rpoB mutations that suppress defective Rho-mediated transcription termination in Escherichia coli

Mastering the control of the Rho transcription factor for biotechnological applications

The present review represents an update on the fundamental role played by the Rho factor, which facilitates the process of Rho-dependent transcription termination in the prokaryotic world; it also provides a summary of relevant mutations in the Rho factor and the insights they provide into the functions carried out by this protein. Furthermore, a section is dedicated to the putative future use of Rho (the 'taming' of Rho) to facilitate biotechnological processes and adapt them to different technological contexts. Novel bacterial strains can be designed, containing mutations in the rho gene, that are better suited for different biotechnological applications. This process can obtain novel microbial strains that are adapted to lower temperatures of fermentation, shorter production times, exhibit better nutrient utilization, or display other traits that are beneficial in productive Biotechnology. Additional important issues reviewed here include epistasis, the design of TATA boxes, the role of small RNAs, and the manipulation of clathrin-mediated endocytosis, by some pathogenic bacteria, to invade eukaryotic cells. KEY POINTS: • It is postulated that controlling the action of the prokaryotic Rho factor could generate major biotechnological improvements, such as an increase in bacterial productivity or a reduction of the microbial-specific growth rate. • The review also evaluates the putative impact of epistatic mechanisms on Biotechnology, both as possible responsible for unexpected failures in gene cloning and more important for the genesis of new strains for biotechnological applications • The use of clathrin-coated vesicles by intracellular bacterial microorganisms is included too and proposed as a putative delivery mechanism, for drugs and vaccines.

A Screen for rfaH Suppressors Reveals a Key Role for a Connector Region of Termination Factor Rho

RfaH activates horizontally acquired operons that encode lipopolysaccharide core components, pili, toxins, and capsules. Unlike its paralog NusG, which potentiates Rho-mediated silencing, RfaH strongly inhibits Rho. RfaH is recruited to its target operons via a network of contacts with an elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP) and a specific DNA element called ops to modify RNAP into a pause- and NusG-resistant state. rfaH null mutations confer hypersensitivity to antibiotics and detergents, altered susceptibility to bacteriophages, and defects in virulence. Here, we carried out a selection for suppressors that restore the ability of a ΔrfaH mutant Escherichia coli strain to grow in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. We isolated rho, rpoC, and hns suppressor mutants with changes in regions previously shown to be important for their function. In addition, we identified mutants with changes in an unstructured region that connects the primary RNA-binding and helicase domains of Rho. The connector mutants display strong defects in vivo, consistent with their ability to compensate for the loss of RfaH, and act synergistically with bicyclomycin (BCM), which has been recently shown to inhibit Rho transformation into a translocation-competent state. We hypothesize that the flexible connector permits the reorientation of Rho domains and serves as a target for factors that control the motor function of Rho allosterically. Our results, together with the existing data, support a model in which the connector segment plays a hitherto overlooked role in the regulation of Rho-dependent termination.IMPORTANCE The transcription termination factor Rho silences foreign DNA, reduces antisense transcription, mediates surveillance of mRNA quality, and maintains genome integrity by resolving transcription-replication collisions and deleterious R loops. Upon binding to RNA, Rho undergoes a rate-limiting transition from an open "lock washer" state to a closed ring capable of processive translocation on, and eventually the release of, the nascent transcript. Recent studies revealed that Rho ligands, including its cofactor NusG and inhibitor bicyclomycin, control the ring dynamics allosterically. In this work, we used a genetic selection for suppressors of RfaH, a potent inhibitor of Rho, to isolate a new class of mutations in a flexible region that connects the primary RNA-binding and ATPase/translocase domains of Rho. We propose that the connector is essential for the modulation of Rho activity by different RNA sequences and accessory proteins.

Virulence Gene Regulation in Shigella

Shigella species are the causative agents of bacillary dysentery in humans, an invasive disease in which the bacteria enter the cells of the epithelial layer of the large intestine, causing extensive tissue damage and inflammation. They rely on a plasmid-encoded type III secretion system (TTSS) to cause disease; this system and its regulation have been investigated intensively at the molecular level for decades. The lessons learned have not only deepened our knowledge of Shigella biology but also informed in important ways our understanding of the mechanisms used by other pathogenic bacteria to cause disease and to control virulence gene expression. In addition, the Shigella story has played a central role in the development of our appreciation of the contribution of horizontal DNA transfer to pathogen evolution.A 30-kilobase-pair "Entry Region" of the 230-kb virulence plasmid lies at the heart of the Shigella pathogenesis system. Here are located the virB and mxiE regulatory genes and most of the structural genes involved in the expression of the TTSS and its effector proteins. Expression of the virulence genes occurs in response to an array of environmental signals, including temperature, osmolarity, and pH.At the top of the regulatory hierarchy and lying on the plasmid outside the Entry Region isvirF, encoding an AraC-like transcription factor.Virulence gene expression is also controlled by chromosomal genes,such as those encoding the nucleoid-associated proteins H-NS, IHF, and Fis, the two-component regulators OmpR/EnvZ and CpxR/CpxA, the anaerobic regulator Fnr, the iron-responsive regulator Fur, and the topoisomerases of the cell that modulate DNA supercoiling. Small regulatory RNAs,the RNA chaperone Hfq,and translational modulation also affect the expression of the virulence phenotypetranscriptionally and/orposttranscriptionally.

Structural coupling between RNA polymerase composition and DNA supercoiling in coordinating transcription: a global role for the omega subunit?

In growing bacterial cells, the global reorganization of transcription is associated with alterations of RNA polymerase composition and the superhelical density of the DNA. However, the existence of any regulatory device coordinating these changes remains elusive. Here we show that in an exponentially growing Escherichia coli rpoZ mutant lacking the polymerase ω subunit, the impact of the Eσ(38) holoenzyme on transcription is enhanced in parallel with overall DNA relaxation. Conversely, overproduction of σ(70) in an rpoZ mutant increases both overall DNA supercoiling and the transcription of genes utilizing high negative superhelicity. We further show that transcription driven by the Eσ(38) and Eσ(70) holoenzymes from cognate promoters induces distinct superhelical densities of plasmid DNA in vivo. We thus demonstrate a tight coupling between polymerase holoenzyme composition and the supercoiling regimen of genomic transcription. Accordingly, we identify functional clusters of genes with distinct σ factor and supercoiling preferences arranging alternative transcription programs sustaining bacterial exponential growth. We propose that structural coupling between DNA topology and holoenzyme composition provides a basic regulatory device for coordinating genome-wide transcription during bacterial growth and adaptation. IMPORTANCE Understanding the mechanisms of coordinated gene expression is pivotal for developing knowledge-based approaches to manipulating bacterial physiology, which is a problem of central importance for applications of biotechnology and medicine. This study explores the relationships between variations in the composition of the transcription machinery and chromosomal DNA topology and suggests a tight interdependence of these two variables as the major coordinating principle of gene regulation. The proposed structural coupling between the transcription machinery and DNA topology has evolutionary implications and suggests a new methodology for studying concerted alterations of gene expression during normal and pathogenic growth both in bacteria and in higher organisms.

General organisational principles of the transcriptional regulation system: a tree or a circle?

Recent advances of systemic approaches to gene expression and cellular metabolism provide unforeseen opportunities for relating and integrating extensive datasets describing the transcriptional regulation system as a whole. However, due to the multifaceted nature of the phenomenon, these datasets often contain logically distinct types of information determined by underlying approach and adopted methodology of data analysis. Consequently, to integrate the datasets comprising information on the states of chromatin structure, transcriptional regulatory network and cellular metabolism, a novel methodology enabling interconversion of logically distinct types of information is required. Here we provide a holistic conceptual framework for analysis of global transcriptional regulation as a system coordinated by structural coupling between the transcription machinery and DNA topology, acting as interdependent sensors and determinants of metabolic functions. In this operationally closed system any transition in physiological state represents an emergent property determined by shifts in structural coupling, whereas genetic regulation acts as a genuine device converting one logical type of information into the other.

Host factor titration by chromosomal R-loops as a mechanism for runaway plasmid replication in transcription termination-defective mutants of Escherichia coli

Two Escherichia coli genes, rnhA and recG, encode products that disrupt R-loops by hydrolysis and unwinding, respectively. It is known that the propensity for R-loop formation in vivo is increased during growth at 21 degrees C. We have identified several links between rnhA, recG, and R-loop-dependent plasmid replication on the one hand, and genes rho and nusG involved in factor-dependent transcription termination on the other. A novel nusG-G146D mutation phenocopied a rho-A243E mutation in conferring global deficiency in transcription termination, and both mutants were killed at 21 degrees C following overexpression of rnhA(+). Mutant combinations rnhA-nusG or recG-rho were synthetically lethal at 21 degrees C, with the former being suppressed by recG(+) overexpression. rho and nusG mutants were killed following transformation with plasmids such as pACYC184 or pUC19 (which have R-loop replication intermediates) even at 30 degrees C or 37 degrees C, and the lethality was correlated with greatly increased content of supercoiled monomer species of these and other co-resident R-loop-dependent plasmids. Plasmid-mediated lethality in the mutants was suppressed by overexpression of rnhA(+) or recG(+). Two additional categories of trans-acting suppressors of the plasmid-mediated lethality were identified whose primary effects were, respectively, a reduction in plasmid copy number even in the wild-type strain, and a restoration of the proficiency of in vivo transcription termination in the nusG and rho mutant strains. The former category of suppressors included rom(+), and mutations in rpoB(Q513L), pcnB, and polA, whereas the latter included a mutation in rho (R221C) and several non-null mutations (E74K, L26P, and delta64-137) in the gene encoding the nucleoid protein H-NS. We propose that an increased occurrence of chromosomal R-loops in the rho and nusG mutants leads to titration of a cyloplasmic host factor(s) that negatively modulates the stability of plasmid R-loop replication intermediates and consequently to runaway plasmid replication.

Roles of topoisomerases in maintaining steady-state DNA supercoiling in Escherichia coli

DNA supercoiling is essential for bacterial cell survival. We demonstrated that DNA topoisomerase IV, acting in concert with topoisomerase I and gyrase, makes an important contribution to the steady-state level of supercoiling in Escherichia coli. Following inhibition of gyrase, topoisomerase IV alone relaxed plasmid DNA to a final supercoiling density (sigma) of -0.015 at an initial rate of 0.8 links min(-1). Topoisomerase I relaxed DNA at a faster rate, 5 links min(-1), but only to a sigma of -0.05. Inhibition of topoisomerase IV in wild-type cells increased supercoiling to approximately the same level as in a mutant lacking topoisomerase I activity (to sigma = -0.08). The role of topoisomerase IV was revealed by two functional assays. Removal of both topoisomerase I and topoisomerase IV caused the DNA to become hyper-negatively supercoiled (sigma = -0.09), greatly stimulating transcription from the supercoiling sensitive leu-500 promoter and increasing the number of supercoils trapped by lambda integrase site-specific recombination.

Incompatibility of Escherichia coli rho mutants with plasmids is mediated by plasmid-specific transcription

The Escherichia coli rho-15 mutant (deficient in transcription termination) is known to be incompatible with pBR322 and other plasmids (J. S. Fassler, G. F. Arnold, and I. Tessman, Mol. Gen. Genet. 204:424-429, 1986). We show that failure of pBR322 to transform rho-15 is mediated by transcription from the tet promoter and readthrough from the tet gene into the rom region. Using an isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside-inducible promoter to replace the tet promoter, we have demonstrated that plasmid-specific transcription inhibits growth of the rho-15 host, possibly due to the expression of the Rom protein. The involvement of Rom protein in pBR322-rho-15 incompatibility is further indicated by the following two experiments. (i) Functional inactivation of the rom gene in pBR322 enabled plasmids to transform E. coli rho-15. (ii) Specific overexpression of the rom gene abolished plasmid transformation into E. coli rho-15. An rpoB8(Ts) mutant RNA polymerase which compensated for the termination defect in E. coli rho-15 also restored plasmid-host compatibility, suggesting that Rom-mediated plasmid-host incompatibility is linked to a defect in transcription termination.

Supercoiling and map stability in the bacterial chromosome

A major goal of comparative genomics is an understanding of the forces which control gene order. This assumes that gene order is important, a supposition backed by the existence of genomic colinearity between many related species. In the bacterial chromosome, a polarity in the order of genes has been suggested, influenced by distance and orientation relative to the origin of DNA replication. We propose a model of the bacterial chromosome in which gene order is maintained by the adaptation of gene expression to local superhelical context. This force acts not directly at the genomic level but rather at the local gene level. A full understanding of gene-order conservation must therefore come from the bottom up.

RNA polymerase (rpoB) mutants selected for increased resistance to gyrase inhibitors in Salmonella typhimurium

Some rifampicin-resistance (RifR) mutations make bacteria slightly resistant to the gyrase inhibitors novobiocin (Nov) and nalidixic acid (Nal). This suggested that it might be possible to isolate rpoB mutants using either drug for positive selection. In an initial test, we confirmed the presence of Rif-resistant isolates among clones selected for Nov resistance. These mutants are also more resistant to Nal. In a subsequent experiment, we found that mutants selected for low-level resistance to Nal include isolates harboring mutations genetically linked to the rpoB locus; of two such mutants studied, one is temperature-sensitive for growth. These two mutants, which are only marginally affected in their response to Nov, are normally sensitive to Rif and thus might be representative of a new class of rpoB alleles. The Rif-resistant and Rif-sensitive rpoB alleles that increase resistance to gyrase inhibitors have one property in common: they all suppress, to varying degrees, the defect in his operon regulation (transcriptional deattenuation) caused by a gyrase defect or inhibition by novobiocin. To further analyse the transcription-supercoiling relationships in these mutants, we examined the ability of RNA polymerase to recruit gyrase activity during transcription. This was done by two independent approaches: (i) observing transcription-induced accumulation of hyper-negatively supercoiled plasmid DNA in a topA mutant background and (ii) measuring transcription-induced plasmid DNA cleavage in the presence of oxolinic acid. Results indicate that the rpoB alleles described in this study diminish the recruitment of gyrase activity by the transcription process. This property correlates with a decrease in the rate of transcription initiation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Streptomycin- and rifampin-resistant mutants of Escherichia coli perturb F exclusion of bacteriophage T7 by affecting synthesis of the F plasmid protein PifA

Certain alleles of rpsL that confer resistance to the antibiotic streptomycin almost completely relieve F exclusion of bacteriophage T7. Introduction of a specific rpoB allele conferring resistance to rifampin into the rpsL strain restores the ability of the F-containing strain to exclude T7. This variation in the severity of F exclusion is reflected in the levels of the F-encoded inhibitor protein PifA: F'-containing cells that harbor specific rpsL alleles are phenotypically Pif-, but become Pif+ by the further acquisition of a specific rpoB allele. F-containing cells harboring the gyrA43(Ts) mutation also appear phenotypically Pif-, possibly because repression of the pif operon is enhanced by an altered DNA conformation in the gyrase mutant strain.

Deregulation of temperature-dependent transcription of the invasion regulatory gene, virB, in Shigella by rho mutation

Expression of the virB gene, the transcriptional regulator for the invasion genes encoded by the large plasmid of Shigella flexneri, is temperature-regulated. virB transcription is under the control of VirF and H-NS, which act as positive and negative regulators, respectively, and is highly responsive to changes in DNA superhelicity. To further investigate the molecular mechanisms underlying the thermoregulation of virB transcription, a mutant which expressed an invasion phenotype at both 30 degrees C and 37 degrees C was isolated using miniTn10-kan (miniKAN) random insertion mutagenesis. The insertion site was mapped to the rho gene, and resulted in the addition of 11 amino acids to the C-terminus of the Rho protein. Consequently, decreased transcription termination activity at a rho-dependent terminator, lambda tL1, was observed. In the rho mutant, both the transcription of virB and expression of invasion genes were activated at 30 degrees C and were less responsive to changes in temperature. The deregulation of virB expression by the mutation was dependent upon the virB promoter, since the effects of the mutation on virB transcription were abolished when its promoter region was replaced by the tac promoter. Temperature-responsive changes in DNA topology, as determined by linking numbers of a reporter plasmid, showed that changes in DNA superhelicity in the rho mutant were smaller than that in the wild type. Furthermore, when the mutant was grown in medium containing novobiocin, an inhibitor of DNA gyrase, virB transcription at 30 degrees C as well as at 37 degrees C was greatly diminished. These results indicated that Rho protein could have a profound effect on topological temperature-dependent changes in DNA structure, thus contributing to thermoregulation of virB transcription.

DNA topology and bacterial virulence gene regulation

The topology of bacterial DNA varies in response to extracellular environmental stimuli, providing a possible mechanism for environmental control of gene expression during bacterial pathogenesis. The contribution of DNA topology to the control of transcription is complex, but an appreciation of the distinction between local and global DNA topological effects is helping to clarify this complexity.

Mechanism of initiation of transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase on supercoiled template

DNA supercoiling is known to influence the pattern of gene expression in prokaryotes. Thus the mechanism of transcription initiation and the topological state of the template are intimately related. Using in vitro reconstituted transcription assays, composed of purified RNA polymerase and promoters in their natural topological state, we have conducted a detailed study of transcription initiation from T7 early promoters including the following steps: the formation of ternary complexes, acquisition of rifampicin resistance, release of sigma factor and the capacity for RNA chain elongation in complexes. We determined the order of these events and the length of the transcripts when each step occurred during initiation of transcription on supercoiled templates. The length of the transcripts varied in a promoter-specific manner. Analysis of abortive products formed during the initiation showed that stronger promoters go to the elongation mode at transcript lengths shorter than that required for weaker promoters.

Control of bacterial DNA supercoiling

Two DNA topoisomerases control the level of negative supercoiling in bacterial cells. DNA gyrase introduces supercoils, and DNA topoisomerase I prevents supercoiling from reaching unacceptably high levels. Perturbations of supercoiling are corrected by the substrate preferences of these topoisomerases with respect to DNA topology and by changes in expression of the genes encoding the enzymes. However, supercoiling changes when the growth environment is altered in ways that also affect cellular energetics. The ratio of [ATP] to [ADP], to which gyrase is sensitive, may be involved in the response of supercoiling to growth conditions. Inside cells, supercoiling is partitioned into two components, superhelical tension and restrained supercoils. Shifts in superhelical tension elicited by nicking or by salt shock do not rapidly change the level of restrained supercoiling. However, a steady-state change in supercoiling caused by mutation of topA does alter both tension and restrained supercoils. This communication between the two compartments may play a role in the control of supercoiling.

A novel rho promoter::Tn10 mutation suppresses and ftsQ1(Ts) missense mutation in an essential Escherichia coli cell division gene by a mechanism not involving polarity suppression

An extragenic suppressor of the Escherichia coli cell division gene ftsQ1(Ts) was isolated. The suppressor is a Tn10 insertion into the -35 promoter consensus sequence of the rho gene, designated rho promoter::Tn10. The ftsQ1(Ts) mutation was also suppressed by the rho-4 mutant allele. The rho promoter::Tn10 strain does not exhibit rho mutant polarity suppressor phenotypes. In addition, overexpression of the ftsQ1(Ts) mutation does not reverse temperature sensitivity. Furthermore, DNA sequence analysis of the ftsQ1(Ts) allele revealed that the salt-remediable, temperature-sensitive phenotype arose from a single missense mutation. The most striking phenotype of the rho promoter::Tn10 mutant strain is an increase in the level of negative supercoiling. On the basis of these observations, we conclude that the ftsQ1(Ts) mutation may be suppressed by a change in supercoiling.

Levels of DNA topoisomerases, single-stranded-DNA-binding protein, and DNA polymerase I in rho+ and rho-15 strains of Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli rho-15 mutant, which is highly defective in transcription termination, was examined to see whether its reduced DNA superhelicity could be explained by altered expression of proteins that may affect DNA structure. Levels of DNA gyrase and topoisomerase I were normal; levels of single-stranded-DNA-binding protein, DNA polymerase I, and a protein tentatively identified as Lon were significantly altered.

DNA supercoiling in Escherichia coli: topA mutations can be suppressed by DNA amplifications involving the tolC locus

The level of DNA supercoiling is crucial for many cellular processes, including gene expression, and is determined, primarily, by the opposing actions of two enzymes: topoisomerase I and DNA gyrase. Escherichia coli strains lacking topoisomerase I (topA mutants) normally fail to grow in the absence of compensatory mutations which are presumed to relax DNA. We have found that, in media of low osmolarity, topA mutants are viable in the absence of any compensatory mutation, consistent with the view that decreased extracellular osmolarity causes a relaxation of cellular DNA. At higher osmolarity most compensatory mutations, as expected, are in the gyrA and gyrB genes. The only other locus at which compensatory mutations arise, designated toc, is shown to involve the amplification of a region of chromosomal DNA which includes the tolC gene. However, amplification of tolC alone is insufficient to explain the phenotypes of toc mutants. tolC insertion mutations alter the distribution of plasmid topoisomers in vivo. This effect is probably indirect, possibly a result of altered membrane structure and an alteration in the cell's osmotic barrier. As tolC is a highly pleiotropic locus, affecting the expression of many genes, it is possible that some of the TolC phenotypes are a direct result of this topological change. The possible relationship between toc and tolC mutations, and the means by which tolC mutations might affect DNA supercoiling, are discussed.