Analysis of mutations in trfA, the replication initiation gene of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2

Rep protein accommodates together dsDNA and ssDNA which enables a loop-back mechanism to plasmid DNA replication initiation

For DNA replication initiation in Bacteria, replication initiation proteins bind to double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and interact with single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) at the replication origin. The structural-functional relationship of the nucleoprotein complex involving initiator proteins is still elusive and different models are proposed. In this work, based on crosslinking combined with mass spectrometry (MS), the analysis of mutant proteins and crystal structures, we defined amino acid residues essential for the interaction between plasmid Rep proteins, TrfA and RepE, and ssDNA. This interaction and Rep binding to dsDNA could not be provided in trans, and both are important for dsDNA melting at DNA unwinding element (DUE). We solved two crystal structures of RepE: one in a complex with ssDNA DUE, and another with both ssDNA DUE and dsDNA containing RepE-specific binding sites (iterons). The amino acid residues involved in interaction with ssDNA are located in the WH1 domain in stand β1, helices α1 and α2 and in the WH2 domain in loops preceding strands β1' and β2' and in these strands. It is on the opposite side compared to RepE dsDNA-recognition interface. Our data provide evidence for a loop-back mechanism through which the plasmid replication initiator molecule accommodates together dsDNA and ssDNA.

Defining a novel domain that provides an essential contribution to site-specific interaction of Rep protein with DNA

An essential feature of replication initiation proteins is their ability to bind to DNA. In this work, we describe a new domain that contributes to a replication initiator sequence-specific interaction with DNA. Applying biochemical assays and structure prediction methods coupled with DNA–protein crosslinking, mass spectrometry, and construction and analysis of mutant proteins, we identified that the replication initiator of the broad host range plasmid RK2, in addition to two winged helix domains, contains a third DNA-binding domain. The phylogenetic analysis revealed that the composition of this unique domain is typical within the described TrfA-like protein family. Both in vitro and in vivo experiments involving the constructed TrfA mutant proteins showed that the newly identified domain is essential for the formation of the protein complex with DNA, contributes to the avidity for interaction with DNA, and the replication activity of the initiator. The analysis of mutant proteins, each containing a single substitution, showed that each of the three domains composing TrfA is essential for the formation of the protein complex with DNA. Furthermore, the new domain, along with the winged helix domains, contributes to the sequence specificity of replication initiator interaction within the plasmid replication origin.

Genetic tools for reliable gene expression and recombineering in Pseudomonas putida

Pseudomonas putida is a promising bacterial host for producing natural products, such as polyketides and nonribosomal peptides. In these types of projects, researchers need a genetic toolbox consisting of plasmids, characterized promoters, and techniques for rapidly editing the genome. Past reports described constitutive promoter libraries, a suite of broad host range plasmids that replicate in P. putida, and genome-editing methods. To augment those tools, we have characterized a set of inducible promoters and discovered that IPTG-inducible promoter systems have poor dynamic range due to overexpression of the LacI repressor. By replacing the promoter driving lacI expression with weaker promoters, we increased the fold induction of an IPTG-inducible promoter in P. putida KT2440 to 80-fold. Upon discovering that gene expression from a plasmid was unpredictable when using a high-copy mutant of the BBR1 origin, we determined the copy numbers of several broad host range origins and found that plasmid copy numbers are significantly higher in P. putida KT2440 than in the synthetic biology workhorse, Escherichia coli. Lastly, we developed a λRed/Cas9 recombineering method in P. putida KT2440 using the genetic tools that we characterized. This method enabled the creation of scarless mutations without the need for performing classic two-step integration and marker removal protocols that depend on selection and counterselection genes. With the method, we generated four scarless deletions, three of which we were unable to create using a previously established genome-editing technique.

Handcuffing reversal is facilitated by proteases and replication initiator monomers

Specific nucleoprotein complexes are formed strictly to prevent over-initiation of DNA replication. An example of those is the so-called handcuff complex, in which two plasmid molecules are coupled together with plasmid-encoded replication initiation protein (Rep). In this work, we elucidate the mechanism of the handcuff complex disruption. In vitro tests, including dissociation progress analysis, demonstrate that the dimeric variants of plasmid RK2 replication initiation protein TrfA are involved in assembling the plasmid handcuff complex which, as we found, reveals high stability. Particular proteases, namely Lon and ClpAP, disrupt the handcuff by degrading TrfA, thus affecting plasmid stability. Moreover, our data demonstrate that TrfA monomers are able to dissociate handcuffed plasmid molecules. Those monomers displace TrfA molecules, which are involved in handcuff formation, and through interaction with the uncoupled plasmid replication origins they re-initiate DNA synthesis. We discuss the relevance of both Rep monomers and host proteases for plasmid maintenance under vegetative and stress conditions.

Proteolysis in plasmid DNA stable maintenance in bacterial cells

Plasmids, as extrachromosomal genetic elements, need to work out strategies that promote independent replication and stable maintenance in host bacterial cells. Their maintenance depends on constant formation and dissociation of nucleoprotein complexes formed on plasmid DNA. Plasmid replication initiation proteins (Rep) form specific complexes on direct repeats (iterons) localized within the plasmid replication origin. Formation of these complexes along with a strict control of Rep protein cellular concentration, quaternary structure, and activity, is essential for plasmid maintenance. Another important mechanism for maintenance of low-copy-number plasmids are the toxin-antitoxin (TA) post-segregational killing (psk) systems, which prevent plasmid loss from the bacterial cell population. In this mini review we discuss the importance of nucleoprotein complex processing by energy-dependent host proteases in plasmid DNA replication and plasmid type II toxin-antitoxin psk systems, and draw attention to the elusive role of DNA in this process.

Iteron Plasmids

Iteron-containing plasmids are model systems for studying the metabolism of extrachromosomal genetic elements in bacterial cells. Here we describe the current knowledge and understanding of the structure of iteron-containing replicons, the structure of the iteron plasmid encoded replication initiation proteins, and the molecular mechanisms for iteron plasmid DNA replication initiation. We also discuss the current understanding of control mechanisms affecting the plasmid copy number and how host chaperone proteins and proteases can affect plasmid maintenance in bacterial cells.

Two replication initiators - one mechanism for replication origin opening?

DNA replication initiation has been well-characterized; however, studies in the past few years have shown that there are still important discoveries to be made. Recent publications concerning the bacterial DnaA protein have revealed how this replication initiator, via interaction with specific sequences within the origin region, causes local destabilization of double stranded DNA. Observations made in the context of this bacterial initiator have also been converging with those recently made for plasmid Rep proteins. In this mini review we discuss the relevance of new findings for the RK2 plasmid replication initiator, TrfA, with regard to new data on the structure of complexes formed by the chromosomal replication initiator DnaA. We discuss structure-function relationships of replication initiation proteins.

Synchronous waves of failed soft sweeps in the laboratory: remarkably rampant clonal interference of alleles at a single locus

It has increasingly been recognized that adapting populations of microbes contain not one, but many lineages continually arising and competing at once. This process, termed "clonal interference," alters the rate and dynamics of adaptation and biases winning mutations toward those with the largest selective effect. Here we uncovered a dramatic example of clonal interference between multiple similar mutations occurring at the same locus within replicate populations of Methylobacterium extorquens AM1. Because these mutational events involved the transposition of an insertion sequence into a narrow window of a single gene, they were both readily detectable at low frequencies and could be distinguished due to differences in insertion sites. This allowed us to detect up to 17 beneficial alleles of this type coexisting in a single population. Despite conferring a large selective benefit, the majority of these alleles rose and then fell in frequency due to other lineages emerging that were more fit. By comparing allele-frequency dynamics to the trajectories of fitness gains by these populations, we estimated the fitness values of the genotypes that contained these mutations. Collectively across all populations, these alleles arose upon backgrounds with a wide range of fitness values. Within any single population, however, multiple alleles tended to rise and fall synchronously during a single wave of multiple genotypes with nearly identical fitness values. These results suggest that alleles of large benefit arose repeatedly in failed "soft sweeps" during narrow windows of adaptation due to the combined effects of epistasis and clonal interference.

Optimization of gene expression through divergent mutational paths

Adaptation under similar selective pressure often leads to comparable phenotypes. A longstanding question is whether such phenotypic repeatability entails similar (parallelism) or different genotypic changes (convergence). To better understand this, we characterized mutations that optimized expression of a plasmid-borne metabolic pathway during laboratory evolution of a bacterium. Expressing these pathway genes was essential for growth but came with substantial costs. Starting from overexpression, replicate populations founded by this bacterium all evolved to reduce expression. Despite this phenotypic repetitiveness, the underlying mutational spectrum was highly diverse. Analysis of these plasmid mutations identified three distinct means to modulate gene expression: (1) reducing the gene copy number, (2) lowering transcript stability, and (3) integration of the pathway-bearing plasmid into the host genome. Our study revealed diverse molecular changes beneath convergence to a simple phenotype. This complex genotype-phenotype mapping presents a challenge to inferring genetic evolution based solely on phenotypic changes.

Shifts in the host range of a promiscuous plasmid through parallel evolution of its replication initiation protein

The ability of bacterial plasmids to adapt to novel hosts and thereby shift their host range is key to their long-term persistence in bacterial communities. Promiscuous plasmids of the incompatibility group P (IncP)-1 can colonize a wide range of hosts, but it is not known if and how they can contract, shift or further expand their host range. To understand the evolutionary mechanisms of host range shifts of IncP-1 plasmids, an IncP-1β mini-replicon was experimentally evolved in four hosts in which it was initially unstable. After 1000 generations in serial batch cultures under antibiotic selection for plasmid maintenance (kanamycin resistance), the stability of the mini-plasmid dramatically improved in all coevolved hosts. However, only plasmids evolved in Shewanella oneidensis showed improved stability in the ancestor, indicating that adaptive mutations had occurred in the plasmid itself. Complete genome sequence analysis of nine independently evolved plasmids showed seven unique plasmid genotypes that had various kinds of single mutations at one locus, namely, the N-terminal region of the replication initiation protein TrfA. Such parallel evolution indicates that this region was under strong selection. In five of the seven evolved plasmids, these trfA mutations resulted in a significantly higher plasmid copy number. Evolved plasmids were found to be stable in four other naive hosts, but could no longer replicate in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This study shows that plasmids can specialize to a novel host through trade-offs between improved stability in the new host and the ability to replicate in a previously permissive host.

Conformation of a plasmid replication initiator protein affects its proteolysis by ClpXP system

Proteins from the Rep family of DNA replication initiators exist mainly as dimers, but only monomers can initiate DNA replication by interaction with the replication origin (ori). In this study, we investigated both the activation (monomerization) and the degradation of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 replication initiation protein TrfA, which we found to be a member of a class of DNA replication initiators containing winged helix (WH) domains. Our in vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrated that the ClpX-dependent activation of TrfA leading to replicationally active protein monomers and mutations affecting TrfA dimer formation, result in the inhibition of TrfA protein degradation by the ClpXP proteolytic system. These data revealed that the TrfA monomers and dimers are degraded at substantially different rates. Our data also show that the plasmid replication initiator activity and stability in E. coli cells are affected by ClpXP system only when the protein sustains dimeric form.

Cooperative action of Escherichia coli ClpB protein and DnaK chaperone in the activation of a replication initiation protein

The Escherichia coli molecular chaperone protein ClpB is a member of the highly conserved Hsp100/Clp protein family. Previous studies have shown that the ClpB protein is needed for bacterial thermotolerance. Purified ClpB protein has been shown to reactivate chemically and heat-denatured proteins. In this work we demonstrate that the combined action of ClpB and the DnaK, DnaJ, and GrpE chaperones leads to the activation of DNA replication of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2. In contrast, ClpB is not needed for the activation of the oriC-dependent replication of E. coli. Using purified protein components we show that the ClpB/DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE synergistic action activates the plasmid RK2 replication initiation protein TrfA by converting inactive dimers to an active monomer form. In contrast, Hsp78/Ssc1/Mdj1/Mge1, the corresponding protein system from yeast mitochondria, cannot activate the TrfA replication protein. Our results demonstrate for the first time that the ClpB/DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE system is involved in protein monomerization and in the activation of a DNA replication factor.

Role of bacterial chaperones in DNA replication

Studies on the involvement of chaperone proteins in DNA replication have been limited to a few replication systems, belonging primarily to the prokaryotic world. The insights gained from these studies have substantially contributed to our understanding of the eukaryotic DNA replication process as well. The finding that molecular chaperones can activate some initiation proteins before DNA synthesis has led to the more general suggestion that molecular chaperones can influence the DNA-binding activity of many proteins, including transcriptional factors involved in cell regulatory systems. The DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE molecular chaperone system became a paradigm of our understanding of fundamental processes, such as protein folding, translocation, selective proteolysis and autoregulation of the heat-shock response. Studies on the Clp ATPase family of molecular chaperones will help to define the nature of signals involved in chaperone-dependent proteins' refolding and the degradation of misfolded proteins.

TrfA dimers play a role in copy-number control of RK2 replication

Copy-number regulation of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 is dependent on the plasmid-encoded initiator protein, TrfA, and the RK2 origin of replication. The handcuffing model for copy-number control proposes that TrfA-bound oris reversibly couple to prevent the further initiation of plasmid replication when the copy number in vivo is at or above the replicon-specific copy number. TrfA mutants have been isolated which allow for oriV replication at elevated copy numbers. To better understand the mechanism of 'handcuffing', the copy-up TrfA(G254D/S267L) mutant was characterized further. In the present study we show by size exclusion chromatography and native gel electrophoresis that unlike wt TrfA which is largely dimeric, purified His6-TrfA(G254D/S267L) is primarily monomeric. In vivo, TrfA33(G254D/S267L) supports replication of an RK2 ori plasmid in trans at a greatly elevated copy number, while in cis the plasmid exhibits runaway replication. However, expression of either of two previously isolated DNA-binding defective TrfA mutants, TrfA33(P151S) or TrfA33(S257F), in a cell transformed with a mini-RK2 replicon encoding TrfA33(G254D/S267L) results in suppression of the runaway phenotype. His6-TrfA(P151S) and His6-TrfA(S257F) purify as dimers, and when expressed in vivo are incapable of supporting RK2 plasmid replication. In contrast, combination of the trfA(P151S) or trfA(S257F) mutation with the trfA(G254D/S267L) mutations results in the expression of mutant TrfA proteins which are mainly monomers and which can no longer restore copy control to replication directed by TrfA33(G254D/S267L) in vivo. On the basis of these findings a handcuffing model is proposed, whereby oriV-bound TrfA monomers are coupled by dimeric TrfA molecules.

Replication and control of circular bacterial plasmids

An essential feature of bacterial plasmids is their ability to replicate as autonomous genetic elements in a controlled way within the host. Therefore, they can be used to explore the mechanisms involved in DNA replication and to analyze the different strategies that couple DNA replication to other critical events in the cell cycle. In this review, we focus on replication and its control in circular plasmids. Plasmid replication can be conveniently divided into three stages: initiation, elongation, and termination. The inability of DNA polymerases to initiate de novo replication makes necessary the independent generation of a primer. This is solved, in circular plasmids, by two main strategies: (i) opening of the strands followed by RNA priming (theta and strand displacement replication) or (ii) cleavage of one of the DNA strands to generate a 3'-OH end (rolling-circle replication). Initiation is catalyzed most frequently by one or a few plasmid-encoded initiation proteins that recognize plasmid-specific DNA sequences and determine the point from which replication starts (the origin of replication). In some cases, these proteins also participate directly in the generation of the primer. These initiators can also play the role of pilot proteins that guide the assembly of the host replisome at the plasmid origin. Elongation of plasmid replication is carried out basically by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme (and, in some cases, by DNA polymerase I at an early stage), with the participation of other host proteins that form the replisome. Termination of replication has specific requirements and implications for reinitiation, studies of which have started. The initiation stage plays an additional role: it is the stage at which mechanisms controlling replication operate. The objective of this control is to maintain a fixed concentration of plasmid molecules in a growing bacterial population (duplication of the plasmid pool paced with duplication of the bacterial population). The molecules involved directly in this control can be (i) RNA (antisense RNA), (ii) DNA sequences (iterons), or (iii) antisense RNA and proteins acting in concert. The control elements maintain an average frequency of one plasmid replication per plasmid copy per cell cycle and can "sense" and correct deviations from this average. Most of the current knowledge on plasmid replication and its control is based on the results of analyses performed with pure cultures under steady-state growth conditions. This knowledge sets important parameters needed to understand the maintenance of these genetic elements in mixed populations and under environmental conditions.

The replication initiation protein of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 is activated by the ClpX chaperone

Initiation and control of replication of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 requires two plasmid-encoded elements, the replication origin (oriV) and the initiation protein TrfA. Purified TrfA is largely in the form of a dimer; however, only the monomeric form of the protein can bind specifically to the direct repeats (iterons) at the RK2 origin. The largely dimeric form of wild-type TrfA is inactive in the initiation of replication of RK2 in an in vitro replication system reconstituted from purified components. However, preincubation of the TrfA protein with the ClpX molecular chaperone isolated from Escherichia coli activates the initiator protein for replication in the purified system. We further observed that ClpX, in an ATP-dependent reaction, greatly increases the proportion of TrfA monomers and, therefore, the ability of this protein to bind to iterons localized within RK2 origin. Finally, a copy-up mutant of the TrfA protein which is largely in the monomer form is active in the reconstituted in vitro replication system, and its activity is not affected by ClpX.

Role of TrfA and DnaA proteins in origin opening during initiation of DNA replication of the broad host range plasmid RK2

The Escherichia coli protein DnaA and the plasmid RK2-encoded TrfA protein are required for initiation of replication of the broad host range plasmid RK2. The TrfA protein has been shown to bind to five 17-base pair repeat sequences, referred to as iterons, at the minimal replication origin (oriV). Using DNase I footprinting and a gel mobility shift assay, purified DnaA protein was found to bind to four DnaA consensus binding sequences immediately upstream of the five iterons at the RK2 origin of replication. Binding of the TrfA protein to the iterons results in localized strand opening within the A+T-rich region of the replication origin as determined by reactivity of the top and bottom strands to potassium permanganate (KMnO4). The presence of either the E. coli DnaA or HU protein is required for the TrfA-mediated strand opening. Although the DnaA protein itself did not produce an RK2 open complex, it did enhance and/or stabilize the TrfA-induced strand opening.

The plasmid RK2 initiation protein binds to the origin of replication as a monomer

The TrfA protein encoded by the broad host range bacterial plasmid RK2 specifically binds to eight direct repeats (iterons) present at the plasmid replication origin to initiate DNA replication. Purified TrfA protein is largely in the form of a dimer, and using a dimerization test system that involves the fusion of the amino-terminal domain of the lambda cI repressor protein to TrfA, we show that the TrfA protein forms dimers in vivo. Because of the high stability of the dimer form of TrfA, the formation of heterodimers between the wild-type and different sized TrfA proteins requires in vivo de novo folding of the primary protein sequence or in vitro denaturation and renaturation. The results of gel mobility shift assays using in vitro or in vivo formed heterodimers indicated that the TrfA protein binds to the iteron DNA as a monomer. Furthermore, when the monomeric and dimeric forms of TrfA are separated by gel filtration chromatography, only the protein in the chromatographic position of the monomeric form demonstrated significant DNA binding activity. These results indicate that only the monomer form of the TrfA protein is active for binding to the iterons at the RK2 replication origin.

Host growth temperature and a conservative amino acid substitution in the replication protein of pPS10 influence plasmid host range

pPS10 is a replicon isolated from Pseudomonas syringe pv. savastanoi that can be established at 37 degrees C efficiently in Pseudomonas aeruginosa but very inefficiently in Escherichia coli. The establishment of the wild-type pPS10 replicon in E. coli is favored at low temperatures (30 degrees C or below). RepA protein of pPS10 promotes in vitro plasmid replication in extracts from E. coli, and this replication depends on host proteins DnaA, DnaB, DnaG, and SSB. Mutant plasmids able to efficiently replicate in E. coli at 37 degrees C were obtained. Three of four mutants whose mutations were mapped show a conservative Ala-->Val change in the amino-terminal region of the replication protein RepA. Plasmids carrying this mutation maintain the capacity to replicate in P. aeruginosa and have a fourfold increase in copy number in this host. The mutation does not substantially alter the autoregulation mediated by RepA. These results show that the physiological conditions of the host as well as subtle changes in the plasmid replication protein can modulate the host range of the pPS10 replicon.

Replication of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2: isolation and characterization of a spontaneous deletion mutant that can replicate in Agrobacterium tumefaciens but not in Escherichia coli

Two spontaneous deletions of a derivative of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2 were isolated from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The two deletions have lost 56 and 505 bp, respectively, near the origin of replication (oriV). Of the eight 17-bp repeats present in the RK2 oriV, the smaller deletion has lost the first two while the larger one has lost the first three. The deletions led to a significant increase (3- to 7-fold) in plasmid copy number in A. tumefaciens, indicating their importance in copy number control. While the smaller deletion could replicate in Escherichia coli, the larger one could not. The role of the oriV sequences in the replication of pRK2 in A. tumefaciens and in E. coli is discussed.