Gene V protein-mediated translational regulation of the synthesis of gene II protein of the filamentous bacteriophage M13: a dispensable function of the filamentous-phage genome

Filamentous phages: masters of a microbial sharing economy

Bacteriophage ("bacteria eaters") or phage is the collective term for viruses that infect bacteria. While most phages are pathogens that kill their bacterial hosts, the filamentous phages of the sub-class Inoviridae live in cooperative relationships with their bacterial hosts, akin to the principal behaviours found in the modern-day sharing economy: peer-to-peer support, to offset any burden. Filamentous phages impose very little burden on bacteria and offset this by providing service to help build better biofilms, or provision of toxins and other factors that increase virulence, or modified behaviours that provide novel motile activity to their bacterial hosts. Past, present and future biotechnology applications have been built on this phage-host cooperativity, including DNA sequencing technology, tools for genetic engineering and molecular analysis of gene expression and protein production, and phage-display technologies for screening protein-ligand and protein-protein interactions. With the explosion of genome and metagenome sequencing surveys around the world, we are coming to realize that our knowledge of filamentous phage diversity remains at a tip-of-the-iceberg stage, promising that new biology and biotechnology are soon to come.

Various mutations compensate for a deleterious lacZα insert in the replication enhancer of M13 bacteriophage

M13 and other members of the Ff class of filamentous bacteriophages have been extensively employed in myriad applications. The Ph.D. series of phage-displayed peptide libraries were constructed from the M13-based vector M13KE. As a direct descendent of M13mp19, M13KE contains the lacZα insert in the intergenic region between genes IV and II, where it interrupts the replication enhancer of the (+) strand origin. Phage carrying this 816-nucleotide insert are viable, but propagate in E. coli at a reduced rate compared to wild-type M13 phage, presumably due to a replication defect caused by the insert. We have previously reported thirteen compensatory mutations in the 5'-untranslated region of gene II, which encodes the replication initiator protein gIIp. Here we report several additional mutations in M13KE that restore a wild-type propagation rate. Several clones from constrained-loop variable peptide libraries were found to have ejected the majority of lacZα gene in order to reconstruct the replication enhancer, albeit with a small scar. In addition, new point mutations in the gene II 5'-untranslated region or the gene IV coding sequence have been spontaneously observed or synthetically engineered. Through phage propagation assays, we demonstrate that all these genetic modifications compensate for the replication defect in M13KE and restore the wild-type propagation rate. We discuss the mechanisms by which the insertion and ejection of the lacZα gene, as well as the mutations in the regulatory region of gene II, influence the efficiency of replication initiation at the (+) strand origin. We also examine the presence and relevance of fast-propagating mutants in phage-displayed peptide libraries.

Simulation of the M13 life cycle I: Assembly of a genetically-structured deterministic chemical kinetic simulation

To expand the quantitative, systems level understanding and foster the expansion of the biotechnological applications of the filamentous bacteriophage M13, we have unified the accumulated quantitative information on M13 biology into a genetically-structured, experimentally-based computational simulation of the entire phage life cycle. The deterministic chemical kinetic simulation explicitly includes the molecular details of DNA replication, mRNA transcription, protein translation and particle assembly, as well as the competing protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions that control the timing and extent of phage production. The simulation reproduces the holistic behavior of M13, closely matching experimentally reported values of the intracellular levels of phage species and the timing of events in the M13 life cycle. The computational model provides a quantitative description of phage biology, highlights gaps in the present understanding of M13, and offers a framework for exploring alternative mechanisms of regulation in the context of the complete M13 life cycle.

Simulation of the M13 life cycle II: Investigation of the control mechanisms of M13 infection and establishment of the carrier state

Bacteriophage M13 is a true parasite of bacteria, able to co-opt the infected cell and control the production of progeny across many cellular generations. Here, our genetically-structured simulation of M13 is applied to quantitatively dissect the interplay between the host cellular environment and the controlling interactions governing the phage life cycle during the initial establishment of infection and across multiple cell generations. Multiple simulations suggest that phage-encoded feedback interactions constrain the utilization of host DNA polymerase, RNA polymerase and ribosomes. The simulation reveals the importance of p5 translational attenuation in controlling the production of phage double-stranded DNA and suggests an underappreciated role for p5 translational self-attenuation in resource allocation. The control elements active in a single generation are sufficient to reproduce the experimentally-observed multigenerational curing of the phage infection. Understanding the subtleties of regulation will be important for maximally exploiting M13 particles as scaffolds for nanoscale devices.

A target-unrelated peptide in an M13 phage display library traced to an advantageous mutation in the gene II ribosome-binding site

Screening of the commercially available Ph.D.-7 phage-displayed heptapeptide library for peptides that bind immobilized Zn2+ resulted in the repeated selection of the peptide HAIYPRH, although binding assays indicated that HAIYPRH is not a zinc-binding peptide. HAIYPRH has also been selected in several other laboratories using completely different targets, and its ubiquity suggests that it is a target-unrelated peptide. We demonstrated that phage displaying HAIYPRH are enriched after serial amplification of the library without exposure to target. The amplification of phage displaying HAIYPRH was found to be dramatically faster than that of the library itself. DNA sequencing uncovered a mutation in the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence for gIIp, a protein involved in phage replication, imparting to the SD sequence better complementarity to the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA). Introducing this mutation into phage lacking a displayed peptide resulted in accelerated propagation, whereas phage displaying HAIYPRH with a wild-type SD sequence were found to amplify normally. The SD mutation may alter gIIp expression and, consequently, the rate of propagation of phage. In the Ph.D.-7 library, the mutation is coincident with the displayed peptide HAIYPRH, accounting for the target-unrelated selection of this peptide in multiple reported panning experiments.

In‐frame overlapping genes: the challenges for regulating gene expression

In-frame overlapping genes in phage, plasmid and bacterial genomes permit synthesis of more than one form of protein from the same gene. Having one gene entirely within another rather than two separate genes presumably precludes recombination events between the identical sequences. However, studies of such gene pairs indicate that the overlapping arrangement can make regulation of the genes more difficult. Here, we extend studies of in-frame overlapping genes II and X from filamentous phage f1 to determine if translational controls are required to regulate the gene properly. These genes encode proteins (pII and pX) with essential but opposing roles in phage DNA replication. They must be tightly regulated to maintain production of the proteins at relative steady state levels that permit continuous replication without killing the host. To determine why little or no pX appears to be made on the gene II/X mRNA, gene II translation was lowered by progressively deleting into the gene II initiator region. Increased pX translation resulted, suggesting that elongating ribosomes on the gene II mRNA interfere with internal initiation on the gene X ribosome binding site and limit gene X translation. As judged from systematically lowering the efficiency of suppression at a gene II amber codon upstream from the gene X start, the already modest level of gene II translation would have to be reduced by more than twofold to relieve all interference with internal initiation. Further downregulation of gene X expression proved to be required to maintain pX at levels relative to pII that are tolerated by the cell. Site-directed mutagenesis and nuclease mapping revealed that the gene X initiation site is sequestered in an extended RNA secondary structure that lowers gene X translation on the two mRNAs encoding it. The more general implications of the results for expression of in-frame overlapping genes are discussed.

Divergence of the mRNA targets for the Ssb proteins of bacteriophages T4 and RB69

The single-strand binding (Ssb) protein of phage T4 (T4 gp32, product of gene 32) is a mRNA-specific autogenous translational repressor, in addition to being a sequence-independent ssDNA-binding protein that participates in phage DNA replication, repair and recombination. It is not clear how this physiologically essential protein distinguishes between specific RNA and nonspecific nucleic acid targets. Here, we present phylogenetic evidence suggesting that ssDNA and specific RNA bind the same gp32 domain and that plasticity of this domain underlies its ability to configure certain RNA structures for specific binding. We have cloned and characterized gene 32 of phage RB69, a relative of T4 We observed that RB69 gp32 and T4 gp32 have nearly identical ssDNA binding domains, but diverge in their C-terminal domains. In T4 gp32, it is known that the C-terminal domain interacts with the ssDNA-binding domain and with other phage-induced proteins. In translation assays, we show that RB69 gp32 is, like T4 gp32, an autogenous translational repressor. We also show that the natural mRNA targets (translational operators) for the 2 proteins are diverged in sequence from each other and yet can be repressed by either gp32. Results of chemical and RNase sensitivity assays indicate that the gp32 mRNA targets from the 2 related phages have similar structures, but differ in their patterns of contact with the 2 repressors. These and other observations suggest that a range of gp32-RNA binding specificities may evolve in nature due to plasticity of the protein-nucleic acid interaction and its response to modulation by the C-terminal domain of this translational repressor.

RNA determinants of translational operator recognition by the DNA polymerases of bacteriophages T4 and RB69

The DNA polymerases (gp43s) of the two related phages T4 and RB69 are DNA-binding proteins that also function as mRNA-binding autogenous translational repressors. As repressors, T4 gp43 is narrowly specific to its own mRNA whereas RB69 gp43 is equally effective against mRNA for either protein. We used in vitro RNase-sensitivity and RNA footprinting assays to identify features of the non-identical T4 and RB69 mRNA targets (translational operators) that allow for their identical binding affinities and biological responses to RB69 gp43. We observed that T4 gp43 and RB69 gp43 produce identical footprints on RNA substrates bearing the T4-derived operator, suggesting that the two gp43s make identical contacts with this operator. In contrast, the footprint produced by RB69 gp43 on its autogenous RNA target was shorter than its footprint on operator RNA from T4. As expected, we also observed only weak protection of RB69-derived operator RNA from RNase by T4 gp43; however, photocross-linking studies suggested that T4 gp43 recognizes structural features of the RB69-derived operator that are not detected by RNase- sensitivity assays. The results suggest that RB69 gp43 and T4 gp43 differ in their abilities to use RNA-sequence-independent interactions to configure potential RNA targets for translational repression.

The binding affinity of Ff gene 5 protein depends on the nearest-neighbor composition of the ssDNA substrate

The Ff gene 5 protein (g5p) is considered to be a nonspecific single-stranded DNA binding protein, because it binds cooperatively to and saturates the Ff bacteriophage single-stranded DNA genome and other single-stranded polynucleotides. However, the binding affinity Komega (the intrinsic binding constant times a cooperativity factor) differs by over an order of magnitude for binding to single-stranded polynucleotides such as poly[d(A)] and poly[d(C)]. A polynucleotide that is more stacked, like poly[d(A)], binds more weakly than one that is less stacked, like poly[d(C)]. To test the hypothesis that DNA base stacking, a nearest-neighbor property, is involved in the binding affinity of the Ff g5p for different DNA sequences, Komega values were determined as a function of NaCl concentration for binding to six synthetic sequences 48 nucleotides in length: dA48, dC48, d(AAC)16, d(ACC)16, d(AACC)12, and d(AAACC)9A3. The binding affinities of the protein for these sequences were indeed found to be related to the nearest-neighbor compositions of the sequences, rather than to simple base compositions. That is, the g5p binding site, which is spanned by four nucleotides, discriminates among these sequences on the basis of the relative numbers of nearest neighbors (AA, CC, and AC plus CA) in the sequence. The results support the hypothesis that the extent of base stacking/unstacking of the free, nonbound ssDNA plays an important role in the binding affinity of the Ff gene 5 protein.

Translation limits synthesis of an assembly-initiating coat protein of filamentous phage IKe

Translation is shown to be downregulated sharply between genes V and VII of IKe, a filamentous bacteriophage classed with the Ff group (phages f1, M13, and fd) but having only 55% DNA sequence identity to it. Genes V and VII encode the following proteins which are used in very different amounts: pV, used to coat the large number of viral DNA molecules prior to assembly, and pVII, used to serve as a cap with pIX in 3 to 5 copies on the end of the phage particle that emerges first from Escherichia coli. The genes are immediately adjacent to each other and are represented in the same amounts on the Ff and IKe mRNAs. Ff gene VII has an initiation site that lacks detectable intrinsic activity yet through coupling is translated at a level 10-fold lower than that of upstream gene V. The experiments reported reveal that by contrast, the IKe gene VII initiation site had detectable activity but was coupled only marginally to upstream translation. The IKe gene V and VII initiation sites both showed higher activities than the Ff sites, but the drop in translation at the IKe V-VII junction was unexpectedly severe, approximately 75-fold. As a result, gene VII is translated at similarly low levels in IKe- and Ff-infected hosts, suggesting that selection to limit its expression has occurred.

Direct measurement of oligonucleotide binding stoichiometry of gene V protein by mass spectrometry

The binding stoichiometry of gene V protein from bacteriophage f1 to several oligonucleotides was studied using electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Using mild mass spectrometer interface conditions that preserve noncovalent associations in solution, gene V protein was observed as dimer ions from a 10 mM NH4OAc solution. Addition of oligonucleotides resulted in formation of protein-oligonucleotide complexes with stoichiometry of approximately four nucleotides (nt) per protein monomer. A 16-mer oligonucleotide gave predominantly a 4:1 (protein monomer: oligonucleotide) complex while oligonucleotides shorter than 15 nt showed stoichiometries of 2:1. Stoichiometries and relative binding constants for a mixture of oligonucleotides were readily measured using mass spectrometry. The binding stoichiometry of the protein with the 16-mer oligonucleotide was measured independently using size-exclusion chromatography and the results were consistent with the mass spectrometric data. These results demonstrate, for the first time, the observation and stoichiometric measurement of protein-oligonucleotide complexes using ESI-MS. The sensitivity and high resolution of ESI-MS should make it a useful too] in the study of protein-DNA interactions.

Structure of the gene V protein of bacteriophage f1 determined by multiwavelength x-ray diffraction on the selenomethionyl protein

The crystal structure of the dimeric gene V protein of bacteriophage f1 was determined using multiwavelength anomalous diffraction on the selenomethionine-containing wild-type and isoleucine-47-->methionine mutant proteins with x-ray diffraction data phased to 2.5 A resolution. The structure of the wild-type protein has been refined to an R factor of 19.2% using native data to 1.8 A resolution. The structure of the gene V protein was used to obtain a model for the protein portion of the gene V protein-single-stranded DNA complex.