Mechanism of binding of the antisense and target RNAs involved in the regulation of IncB plasmid replication

Understanding the genetic basis of the incompatibility of IncK1 and IncK2 plasmids

Antimicrobial resistance is a persistent challenge in human and veterinary medicine, which is often encoded on plasmids which are transmissible between bacterial cells. Incompatibility is the inability of two plasmids to be stably maintained in one cell which is caused by the presence of identical or closely related shared determinants between two plasmids originating from partition or replication mechanisms. For I-complex plasmids in Enterobacteriacae, replication- based incompatibility is caused by the small antisense RNA stem-loop structure called RNAI. The I-complex plasmid group IncK consists of two compatible subgroups, IncK1 and IncK2, for which the RNAI differs only by five nucleotides. In this study we focussed on the interaction of the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI structures by constructing minireplicons containing the replication region of IncK1 or IncK2 plasmids coupled with a kanamycin resistance marker. Using minireplicons excludes involvement of incompatibility mechanisms other than RNAI. Additionally, we performed single nucleotide mutagenesis targeting the five nucleotides that differ between the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI sequences of these minireplicons. The obtained results show that a single nucleotide change in the RNAI structure is responsible for the compatible phenotype of IncK1 with IncK2 plasmids. Only nucleotides in the RNAI top loop and interior loop have an effect on minireplicon incompatibility with wild type plasmids, while mutations in the stem of the RNAI structure had no significant effect on incompatibility. Understanding the molecular basis of incompatibility is relevant for future in silico predictions of plasmid incompatibility.

Regulation of Gene Expression Through Effector-dependent Conformational Switching by Cobalamin Riboswitches

Riboswitches are an outstanding example of genetic regulation mediated by RNA conformational switching. In these non-coding RNA elements, the occupancy status of a ligand-binding domain governs the mRNA's decision to form one of two mutually exclusive structures in the downstream expression platform. Temporal constraints upon the function of many riboswitches, requiring folding of complex architectures and conformational switching in a limited co-transcriptional timeframe, make them ideal model systems for studying these processes. In this review, we focus on the mechanism of ligand-directed conformational changes in one of the most widely distributed riboswitches in bacteria: the cobalamin family. We describe the architectural features of cobalamin riboswitches whose structures have been determined by x-ray crystallography, which suggest a direct physical role of cobalamin in effecting the regulatory switch. Next, we discuss a series of experimental approaches applied to several model cobalamin riboswitches that interrogate these structural models. As folding is central to riboswitch function, we consider the differences in folding landscapes experienced by RNAs that are produced in vitro and those that are allowed to fold co-transcriptionally. Finally, we highlight a set of studies that reveal the difficulties of studying cobalamin riboswitches outside the context of transcription and that co-transcriptional approaches are essential for developing a more accurate picture of their structure-function relationships in these switches. This understanding will be essential for future advancements in the use of small-molecule guided RNA switches in a range of applications such as biosensors, RNA imaging tools, and nucleic acid-based therapies.

Using in-cell SHAPE-Seq and simulations to probe structure-function design principles of RNA transcriptional regulators

Antisense RNA-mediated transcriptional regulators are powerful tools for controlling gene expression and creating synthetic gene networks. RNA transcriptional repressors derived from natural mechanisms called attenuators are particularly versatile, though their mechanistic complexity has made them difficult to engineer. Here we identify a new structure-function design principle for attenuators that enables the forward engineering of new RNA transcriptional repressors. Using in-cell SHAPE-Seq to characterize the structures of attenuator variants within Escherichia coli, we show that attenuator hairpins that facilitate interaction with antisense RNAs require interior loops for proper function. Molecular dynamics simulations of these attenuator variants suggest these interior loops impart structural flexibility. We further observe hairpin flexibility in the cellular structures of natural RNA mechanisms that use antisense RNA interactions to repress translation, confirming earlier results from in vitro studies. Finally, we design new transcriptional attenuators in silico using an interior loop as a structural requirement and show that they function as desired in vivo. This work establishes interior loops as an important structural element for designing synthetic RNA gene regulators. We anticipate that the coupling of experimental measurement of cellular RNA structure and function with computational modeling will enable rapid discovery of structure-function design principles for a diverse array of natural and synthetic RNA regulators.

Plasmid Replication Control by Antisense RNAs

Plasmids are selfish genetic elements that normally constitute a burden for the bacterial host cell. This burden is expected to favor plasmid loss. Therefore, plasmids have evolved mechanisms to control their replication and ensure their stable maintenance. Replication control can be either mediated by iterons or by antisense RNAs. Antisense RNAs work through a negative control circuit. They are constitutively synthesized and metabolically unstable. They act both as a measuring device and a regulator, and regulation occurs by inhibition. Increased plasmid copy numbers lead to increasing antisense-RNA concentrations, which, in turn, result in the inhibition of a function essential for replication. On the other hand, decreased plasmid copy numbers entail decreasing concentrations of the inhibiting antisense RNA, thereby increasing the replication frequency. Inhibition is achieved by a variety of mechanisms, which are discussed in detail. The most trivial case is the inhibition of translation of an essential replication initiator protein (Rep) by blockage of the rep-ribosome binding site. Alternatively, ribosome binding to a leader peptide mRNA whose translation is required for efficient Rep translation can be prevented by antisense-RNA binding. In 2004, translational attenuation was discovered. Antisense-RNA-mediated transcriptional attenuation is another mechanism that has, so far, only been detected in plasmids of Gram-positive bacteria. ColE1, a plasmid that does not need a plasmid-encoded replication initiator protein, uses the inhibition of primer formation. In other cases, antisense RNAs inhibit the formation of an activator pseudoknot that is required for efficient Rep translation.

A modular strategy for engineering orthogonal chimeric RNA transcription regulators

Antisense RNA transcription attenuators are a key component of the synthetic biology toolbox, with their ability to serve as building blocks for both signal integration logic circuits and transcriptional cascades. However, a central challenge to building more sophisticated RNA genetic circuitry is creating larger families of orthogonal attenuators that function independently of each other. Here, we overcome this challenge by developing a modular strategy to create chimeric fusions between the engineered transcriptional attenuator from plasmid pT181 and natural antisense RNA translational regulators. Using in vivo gene expression assays in Escherichia coli, we demonstrate our ability to create chimeric attenuators by fusing sequences from five different translational regulators. Mutagenesis of these functional attenuators allowed us to create a total of 11 new chimeric attenutaors. A comprehensive orthogonality test of these culminated in a 7 × 7 matrix of mutually orthogonal regulators. A comparison between all chimeras tested led to design principles that will facilitate further engineering of orthogonal RNA transcription regulators, and may help elucidate general principles of non-coding RNA regulation. We anticipate that our strategy will accelerate the development of even larger families of orthogonal RNA transcription regulators, and thus create breakthroughs in our ability to construct increasingly sophisticated RNA genetic circuitry.

Antisense-RNA-mediated plasmid copy number control in pCG1-family plasmids, pCGR2 and pCG1, in Corynebacterium glutamicum

pCGR2 and pCG1 belong to different subfamilies of the pCG1 family of Corynebacterium glutamicum plasmids. Nonetheless, they harbour homologous putative antisense RNA genes, crrI and cgrI, respectively. The genes in turn share identical positions complementary to the leader region of their respective repA (encoding plasmid replication initiator) genes. Determination of their precise transcriptional start- and end-points revealed the presence of short antisense RNA molecules (72 bp, CrrI; and 73 bp, CgrI). These short RNAs and their target mRNAs were predicted to form highly structured molecules comprising stem–loops with known U-turn motifs. Abolishing synthesis of CrrI and CgrI by promoter mutagenesis resulted in about sevenfold increase in plasmid copy number on top of an 11-fold (CrrI) and 32-fold (CgrI) increase in repA mRNA, suggesting that CrrI and CgrI negatively control plasmid replication. This control is accentuated by parB, a gene that encodes a small centromere-binding plasmid-partitioning protein, and is located upstream of repA. Simultaneous deactivation of CrrI and parB led to a drastic 87-fold increase in copy number of a pCGR2-derived shuttle vector. Moreover, the fact that changes in the structure of the terminal loops of CrrI and CgrI affected plasmid copy number buttressed the important role of the loop structure in formation of the initial interaction complexes between antisense RNAs and their target mRNAs. Similar antisense RNA control systems are likely to exist not only in the two C. glutamicum pCG1 subfamilies but also in related plasmids across Corynebacterium species.

Bacterial chromosome-encoded small regulatory RNAs

Small RNAs (sRNAs) that act as regulators of gene expression have been identified in all kingdoms of life. Until 1999, only about 10 abundant sRNAs had been identified in Escherichia coli, but the function of most of them remained elusive for a long time. However, since 2001, a series of systematic computational approaches have revealed that bacteria encode a tremendous number of sRNAs. In E. coli more than 100 sRNAs are now known. However, approximately only 20 of them have been assigned a biological function, indicating that this is still a challenging issue. Systematic searches have been performed for a few Gram-positive bacterial species, too. sRNAs can be divided into two major groups: the first group comprises so-called bona fide antisense RNAs, which regulate gene expression by a base-pairing mechanism with mRNA. The second group of sRNAs encompasses RNAs that act by binding to small proteins.

Exposing plasmids as the Achilles' heel of drug-resistant bacteria

Many multidrug-resistant bacterial pathogens harbor large plasmids that encode proteins conferring resistance to antibiotics. Although the acquisition of these plasmids often enables bacteria to survive in the presence of antibiotics, it is possible that plasmids also represent a vulnerability that can be exploited in tailored antibacterial therapy. This review highlights three recently described strategies designed to specifically combat bacteria harboring such plasmids: inhibition of plasmid conjugation, inhibition of plasmid replication, and exploitation of plasmid-encoded toxin-antitoxin systems.

Transcriptional analysis of the genetic element pSSVx: differential and temporal regulation of gene expression reveals correlation between transcription and replication

pSSVx from Sulfolobus islandicus strain REY15/4 is a hybrid between a plasmid and a fusellovirus. A systematic study performed by a combination of Northern blot analysis, primer extension, and reverse transcriptase PCR revealed the presence of nine major transcripts whose expression was differentially and temporally regulated over the growth cycle of S. islandicus. The map positions of the RNAs as well as the clockwise and the anticlockwise directions of their transcription were determined. Some genes were clustered and appeared to be transcribed as polycistronic messengers, among which one long transcriptional unit comprised the genes for the plasmid copy number control protein ORF60 (CopG), ORF91, and the replication protein ORF892 (RepA). We propose that a termination readthrough mechanism might be responsible for the formation of more than one RNA species from a single 5' end and therefore that the nine different RNAs corresponded to only seven different transcriptional starts. Three transcripts, ORF76 and two antisense RNAs, countertranscribed RNA1 (ctRNA1) and ctRNA2, were found to be specifically expressed during (and hence correlated to) the phase in which the pSSVx copy number is kept under stringent control, as they were completely switched off upon the onset of the induction of replication.

Replication control of staphylococcal multiresistance plasmid pSK41: an antisense RNA mediates dual-level regulation of Rep expression

Replication of staphylococcal multiresistance plasmid pSK41 is negatively regulated by the antisense transcript RNAI. pSK41 minireplicons bearing rnaI promoter (PrnaI) mutations exhibited dramatic increases in copy number, approximately 40-fold higher than the copy number for the wild-type replicon. The effects of RNAI mutations on expression of the replication initiator protein (Rep) were evaluated using transcriptional and translational fusions between the rep control region and the cat reporter gene. The results suggested that when PrnaI is disrupted, the amount of rep mRNA increases and it becomes derepressed for translation. These effects were reversed when RNAI was provided in trans, demonstrating that it is responsible for significant negative regulation at two levels, with the greatest repression exerted on rep translation initiation. Mutagenesis provided no evidence for RNAI-mediated transcriptional attenuation as a basis for the observed reduction in rep message associated with expression of RNAI. However, RNA secondary-structure predictions and supporting mutagenesis data suggest a novel mechanism for RNAI-mediated repression of rep translation initiation, where RNAI binding promotes a steric transition in the rep mRNA leader to an alternative thermodynamically stable stem-loop structure that sequesters the rep translation initiation region, thereby preventing translation.

Combating drug-resistant bacteria: small molecule mimics of plasmid incompatibility as antiplasmid compounds

A major mechanism for bacterial resistance to antibiotics is through the acquisition of a plasmid coding for resistance-mediating proteins. Described herein is a strategy to eliminate these plasmids from bacteria, thus resensitizing the bacteria to antibiotics. This approach involves mimicking a natural mechanism for plasmid elimination, known as plasmid incompatibility. The compound apramycin was identified as a tight binder to SLI RNA (Kd = 93 nM), the in vivo target of the plasmid incompatibility determinate RNA I, and footprinting/mutagenesis studies indicate apramycin binds SLI in the important regulatory region that dictates plasmid replication control and incompatibility. In vivo studies demonstrate that this compound causes significant plasmid loss and resensitizes bacteria to conventional antibiotics. The demonstration that a small molecule can mimic incompatibility, cause plasmid elimination, and resensitize bacteria to antibiotics opens up new targets for antibacterial research.

Control of replication in I-complex plasmids

The closely related plasmids that make up the I-complex group and the more distantly related IncL/M plasmids regulate the frequency of initiation of their replication by controlling the efficiency of translation of the rate limiting replication initiator protein, RepA. Translation initiation of repA is dependent on the formation of a pseudoknot immediately upstream of its Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Formation of this pseudoknot involves base pairing between two complementary sequences in the repA mRNA and requires that the secondary structure sequestering the distal sequence be disrupted by movement of the ribosome translating and terminating a leader peptide, whose coding sequence precedes and overlaps that of repA. Expression of repA is controlled by a small antisense RNA, RNAI, which on binding to its complementary target in the repA mRNA not only pre-empts formation of the pseudoknot, but also inhibits translation of the leader peptide. The requirement that translation of the leader peptide be completed for the pseudoknot to form increases the time available for the inhibitory interaction of RNAI with its target, so that at high copy number the frequency of pseudoknot formation is lowered, reducing the proportion of repA mRNA that are translated. At low copy number, when concentration of RNAI is low, repA is translated with increased frequency, leading to increased frequency of plasmid replication.

Role of RepA and DnaA proteins in the opening of the origin of DNA replication of an IncB plasmid

The replication initiator protein RepA of the IncB plasmid pMU720 was shown to induce localized unwinding of its cognate origin of replication in vitro. DnaA, the initiator protein of Escherichia coli, was unable to induce localized unwinding of this origin of replication on its own but enhanced the opening generated by RepA. The opened region lies immediately downstream of the last of the three binding sites for RepA (RepA boxes) and covers one turn of DNA helix. A 6-mer sequence, 5'-TCTTAA-3', which lies within the opened region, was essential for the localized unwinding of the origin in vitro and origin activity in vivo. In addition, efficient unwinding of the origin of replication of pMU720 in vitro required the native positioning of the binding sites for the initiator proteins. Interestingly, binding of RepA to RepA box 1, which is essential for origin activity, was not required for the localized opening of the origin in vitro.

Staphylococcus aureus multiresistance plasmid pSK41: analysis of the replication region, initiator protein binding and antisense RNA regulation

The vast majority of large staphylococcal plasmids characterized to date appear to possess an evolutionarily common replication system, which has clearly had a major impact on the evolution of antimicrobial resistant staphylococci worldwide. Related systems have also been found in plasmids from other Gram-positive genera, including enterococci, streptococci and bacilli. The 46.4 kb plasmid pSK41 is the prototype of a family of conjugative staphylococcal multiresistance plasmids. The replication region of pSK41 encodes a protein product, Rep, which was shown to be essential for replication; mutations that truncated Rep could be complemented in trans. Rep was found to bind in vitro to four tandem repeat sequences located centrally within the rep coding region. An A + T-rich inverted repeat sequence upstream of rep was required for efficient replication, whereas no sequences downstream of rep were necessary. An antisense countertranscript, RNAI, encoded upstream of rep was identified and transcriptional start points for both RNAI and the rep-mRNA were defined.

Loop swapping in an antisense RNA/target RNA pair changes directionality of helix progression

The binding pathway of the natural antisense RNA CopA to its target CopT proceeds through a hierarchical order of steps. It initiates by reversible loop-loop contacts followed by unidirectional helix progression into the upper stems. This involves extensive breakage of intramolecular base pairs and the subsequent formation of two intermolecular helices, B and B'. Based on the known tRNA anticodon loop structure and on results from the Sok/Hok antisense/target RNA system, it had been suggested that a U-turn (or pi-turn) in the loop of CopT might determine the directionality of helix progression. Data presented here show that the putative U-turn is one of the structural elements of antisense/target RNA pairs required to achieve fast binding kinetics. Swapping of the hypothetical U-turn structure from the target RNA to the antisense RNA retained regulatory performance in vivo and binding rates in vitro but altered the binding pathway by changing the direction in which the initiating helix was extended. In addition, our data indicate that a helical stem immediately adjacent to the target loop sequence is required to provide a scaffold for the U-turn.

Interaction of the initiator protein of an IncB plasmid with its origin of DNA replication

The replication initiator protein RepA of the IncB plasmid pMU720 was purified and used in DNase I protection assays in vitro. RepA protected a 68-bp region of the origin of replication of pMU720. This region, which lies immediately downstream of the DnaA box, contains four copies of the sequence motif 5'AANCNGCAA3'. Mutational analyses identified this sequence as the binding site specifically recognized by RepA (the RepA box). Binding of RepA to the RepA boxes was ordered and sequential, with the box closest to the DnaA binding site (box 1) occupied first and the most distant boxes (boxes 3 and 4) occupied last. However, only boxes 1, 2, and 4 were essential for origin activity, with box 3 playing a lesser role. Changing the spacing between box 1 and the other three boxes affected binding of RepA in vitro and origin activity in vivo, indicating that the RepA molecules bound to ori(B) interact with one another.

Pseudoknot-dependent translational coupling in repBA genes of the IncB plasmid pMU720 involves reinitiation

Replication of the IncB miniplasmid pMU720 requires synthesis of the replication initiator protein, RepA, whose translation is coupled to that of a leader peptide, RepB. The unusual feature of this system is that translational coupling in repBA has to be activated by the formation of a pseudoknot immediately upstream of the repA Shine-Dalgarno sequence. A small antisense RNA, RNAI, controls replication of pMU720 by interacting with repBA mRNA to inhibit expression of repA both directly, by preventing formation of the pseudoknot, and indirectly, by inhibiting translation of repB. The mechanism of translational coupling in repBA was investigated using the specialized ribosome system, which directs a subpopulation of ribosomes that carry an altered anti-Shine-Dalgarno sequence to translate mRNA molecules whose Shine-Dalgarno sequences have been altered to be complementary to the mutant anti-Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Our data indicate that translation of repA involves reinitiation by the ribosome that has terminated translation of repB. The role of the pseudoknot in this process and its effect on the control of copy number in pMU720 are discussed.

RNA loop-loop interactions as dynamic functional motifs

RNA loop-loop interactions are frequently used to trigger initial recognition between two RNA molecules. In this review, we present selected well-documented cases that illustrate the diversity of biological processes using RNA loop-loop recognition properties. The first one is related to natural antisense RNAs that play a variety of regulatory functions in bacteria and their extra-chromosomal elements. The second one concerns the dimerization of HIV-1 genomic RNA, which is responsible for the encapsidation of a diploid RNA genome. The third one concerns RNA interactions involving double-loop interactions. These are used by the bicoid mRNA to form dimers, a property that appears to be important for mRNA localization in drosophila embryo, and by bacteriophage phi29 pRNA which forms hexamers that participate in the translocation of the DNA genome through the portal vertex of the capsid. Despite the high diversity of systems and mechanisms, some common features can be highlighted. (1) Efficient recognition requires rapid bi-molecular binding rates, regardless of the RNA pairing scheme. (2) The initial recognition is favored by particular conformations of the loops enabling a proper presentation of nucleotides (generally a restricted number) that initiate the recognition process. (3) The fate of the initial reversible loop-loop complex is dictated by both functional and structural constraints. RNA structures have evolved either to "freeze" the initial complex, or to convert it into a more stable one, which involves propagation of intermolecular interactions along topologically feasible pathways. Stabilization of the initial complex may also be assisted by proteins and/or formation of additional contacts.

Dimerization of the 3'UTR of bicoid mRNA involves a two-step mechanism

The proper localization of bicoid (bcd) mRNA requires cis-acting signals within its 3' untranslated region (UTR) and trans-acting factors such as Staufen. Dimerization of bcd mRNA through intermolecular base-pairing between two complementary loops of domain III of the 3'UTR was proposed to be important for particle formation in the embryo. The participation in the dimerization process of each domain building the 3'UTR was evaluated by thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of various mutated and truncated RNAs. Although sequence complementarity between the two loops of domain III is required for initiating mRNA dimerization, the initial reversible loop-loop complex is converted rapidly into an almost irreversible complex. This conversion involves parts of RNA outside of domain III that promote initial recognition, and dimerization can be inhibited by sense or antisense oligonucleotides only before conversion has proceeded. Injection of the different bcd RNA variants into living Drosophila embryos shows that all elements that inhibit RNA dimerization in vitro prevent formation of localized particles containing Staufen. Particle formation appeared to be dependent on both mRNA dimerization and other element(s) in domains IV and V. Domain III of bcd mRNA could be substituted by heterologous dimerization motifs of different geometry. The resulting dimers were converted into stable forms, independently of the dimerization module used. Moreover, these chimeric RNAs were competent in forming localized particles and recruiting Staufen. The finding that the dimerization domain of bcd mRNA is interchangeable suggests that dimerization by itself, and not the precise geometry of the intermolecular interactions, is essential for the localization process. This suggests that the stabilizing interactions that are formed during the second step of the dimerization process might represent crucial elements for Staufen recognition and localization.

Antisense RNA regulation of the par post-segregational killing system: structural analysis and mechanism of binding of the antisense RNA, RNAII and its target, RNAI

The par stability determinant of the Enterococcus faecalis plasmid pAD1 is the first antisense RNA regulated post-segregational killing system (PSK) identified in a Gram-positive organism. Par encodes two small, convergently transcribed RNAs, designated RNAI and RNAII, which are the toxin and antitoxin of the par PSK system respectively. RNAI encodes an open reading frame for a 33 amino acid toxin called Fst. Expression of fst is regulated post-transcriptionally by RNAII. RNAII interacts with RNAI by a unique antisense RNA mechanism involving binding at the 5' and 3' ends of both RNAs. Par RNA interaction requires a complementary transcriptional terminator stem-loop and a set of direct repeat sequences, DRa and DRb, located at the 5' end of both RNAs. The secondary structures of RNAI, RNAII and the RNAI-RNAII complex were analysed by partial digestion with Pb(II) and ribonucleases. Probing data for RNAI and RNAII are consistent with previously reported computer generated models, and also confirm that complementary direct repeat and terminator sequences are involved in the formation of the RNAI-RNAII complex. Mutant par RNAs were used to show that the binding reaction occurs in at least two steps. The first step is the formation of an initial kissing interaction between the transcriptional terminator stem-loops of both RNAs. The subsequent step(s) involves an initial pairing of the complementary direct repeat sequences followed by complete hybridization of the 5' nucleotides to stabilize the RNAI-RNAII complex.

Bulged residues promote the progression of a loop-loop interaction to a stable and inhibitory antisense-target RNA complex

In several groups of bacterial plasmids, antisense RNAs regulate copy number through inhibition of replication initiator protein synthesis. These RNAs are characterized by a long hairpin structure interrupted by several unpaired residues or bulged loops. In plasmid R1, the inhibitory complex between the antisense RNA (CopA) and its target mRNA (CopT) is characterized by a four-way junction structure and a side-by-side helical alignment. This topology facilitates the formation of a stabilizer intermolecular helix between distal regions of both RNAs, essential for in vivo control. The bulged residues in CopA/CopT were shown to be required for high in vitro binding rate and in vivo activity. This study addresses the question of why removal of bulged nucleotides blocks stable complex formation. Structure mapping, modification interference, and molecular modeling of bulged-less mutant CopA-CopT complexes suggests that, subsequent to loop-loop contact, helix propagation is prevented. Instead, a fully base paired loop-loop interaction is formed, inducing a continuous stacking of three helices. Consequently, the stabilizer helix cannot be formed, and stable complex formation is blocked. In contrast to the four-way junction topology, the loop-loop interaction alone failed to prevent ribosome binding at its loading site and, thus, inhibition of RepA translation was alleviated.

Four-way junctions in antisense RNA-mRNA complexes involved in plasmid replication control: a common theme?

In several groups of bacterial plasmids, antisense RNAs regulate copy number through inhibition of replication initiator protein synthesis. In plasmid R1, we have recently shown that the inhibitory complex between the antisense RNA (CopA) and its target mRNA (CopT) is characterized by the formation of two intermolecular helices, resulting in a four-way junction structure and a side-by-side helical alignment. Based on lead-induced cleavage and ribonuclease (RNase) V(1) probing combined with molecular modeling, a strikingly similar topology is supported for the complex formed between the antisense RNA (Inc) and mRNA (RepZ) of plasmid Col1b-P9. In particular, the position of the four-way junction and the location of divalent ion-binding site(s) indicate that the structural features of these two complexes are essentially the same in spite of sequence differences. Comparisons of several target and antisense RNAs in other plasmids further indicate that similar binding pathways are used to form the inhibitory antisense-target RNA complexes. Thus, in all these systems, the structural features of both antisense and target RNAs determine the topologically possible and kinetically favored pathway that is essential for efficient in vivo control.

Progression of a loop-loop complex to a four-way junction is crucial for the activity of a regulatory antisense RNA

The antisense RNA, CopA, regulates the replication frequency of plasmid R1 through inhibition of RepA translation by rapid and specific binding to its target RNA (CopT). The stable CopA-CopT complex is characterized by a four-way junction structure and a side-by-side alignment of two long intramolecular helices. The significance of this structure for binding in vitro and control in vivo was tested by mutations in both CopA and CopT. High rates of stable complex formation in vitro and efficient inhibition in vivo required initial loop-loop complexes to be rapidly converted to extended interactions. These interactions involve asymmetric helix progression and melting of the upper stems of both RNAs to promote the formation of two intermolecular helices. Data presented here delineate the boundaries of these helices and emphasize the need for unimpeded helix propagation. This process is directional, i.e. one of the two intermolecular helices (B) must form first to allow formation of the other (B'). A binding pathway, characterized by a hierarchy of intermediates leading to an irreversible and inhibitory RNA-RNA complex, is proposed.

Plasmid copy number control: an ever-growing story

Bacterial plasmids maintain their number of copies by negative regulatory systems that adjust the rate of replication per plasmid copy in response to fluctuations in the copy number. Three general classes of regulatory mechanisms have been studied in depth, namely those that involve directly repeated sequences (iterons), those that use only antisense RNAs and those that use a mechanism involving an antisense RNA in combination with a protein. The first class of control mechanism will not be discussed here. Within the second class (the most 'classical' one), exciting insights have been obtained on the molecular basis of the inhibition mechanism that prevents the formation of a long-range RNA structure (pseudoknot), which is an example of an elegant solution reached by some replicons to control their copy number. Among the third class, it is possible to distinguish between (i) cases in which proteins play an auxiliary role; and (ii) cases in which transcriptional repressor proteins play a real regulatory role. This latter type of regulation is relatively new and seems to be widespread among plasmids from Gram-positive bacteria, at least for the rolling circle-replicating plasmids of the pMV158 family and the theta-replicating plasmids of the Inc18 streptococcal family.

Antisense RNA regulation of the pAD1 par post-segregational killing system requires interaction at the 5' and 3' ends of the RNAs

The par stability determinant of the Enterococcus faecalis plasmid pAD1 is the first antisense RNA-regulated post-segregational killing system (PSK) identified in a Gram-positive organism. Par encodes two small, convergently transcribed RNAs, designated RNA I and RNA II, which are the toxin and antidote of the par PSK system respectively. RNA I encodes an open reading frame for a 33-amino-acid toxin called Fst. Expression of fst is regulated post-transcriptionally by RNA II. In this paper, RNA II is shown to interact with RNA I by a unique antisense RNA mechanism. RNA I and RNA II contain complementary direct repeats at their 5' ends and a complementary transcriptional terminator stem-loop at their 3' ends. Deletion of the terminator or mutations within the terminator loop of RNA II severely reduced the rate of interaction in vitro. Mutations in the 5' direct repeats of RNA II prevented the RNAs from interacting in vitro. For these mutations in RNA II, complementary mutations in RNA I were shown to restore interaction. The reduced binding efficiency of the RNA II mutants was paralleled by the failure of these mutants to suppress par-mediated killing in vivo. These results indicate that regions at both the 5' and the 3' ends of the par transcripts are important for RNA I-RNA II interaction.

Effect of CIS on activity in trans of the replication initiator protein of an IncB plasmid

RepA, the replication initiator protein of the IncB plasmid pMU720, acts preferentially in cis. The cis activity of RepA is thought to be mediated by CIS, a 166-bp region of DNA separating the coding region of repA from the origin of replication (ori) of pMU720. To investigate the trans activity of RepA, the repA gene, without its cognate ori, was cloned on a multicopy plasmid, pSU39. The ori on which RepA acts was cloned on pAM34, a plasmid whose replicon is inactive without induction by isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG). Thus, in the absence of IPTG, replication of the pAM34 derivatives was dependent on activation of the cloned ori by RepA produced in trans from the pSU39 derivatives. The effect of CIS, when present either on the RepA-producing or the ori plasmid or both, on the efficiency of replication of the ori plasmid in vivo, was determined. The presence of CIS, in its native position and orientation, on the RepA-producing plasmid reduced the efficiency of replication of the ori plasmid. This inhibitory activity of CIS was sequence specific and involved interaction with the C-terminal 20 to 37 amino acids of RepA. By contrast, CIS had no effect when present on the ori plasmid. Initiation of replication from the ori in trans was independent of transcription into CIS.

U-turns and regulatory RNAs

Conventional antisense RNAs, such as those controlling plasmid replication and maintenance, inhibit the function of their target RNAs rapidly and efficiently. Novel findings show that a common U-turn loop structure mediates fast RNA pairing in the majority of these RNA controlled systems. Usually, an antisense RNA regulates a single, cognate target RNA only. Recent reports, however, show that antisense RNAs can act as promiscuous regulators that control multiple genes in concert to integrate complex physiological responses in Escherichia coli.

An unusual structure formed by antisense-target RNA binding involves an extended kissing complex with a four-way junction and a side-by-side helical alignment

The antisense RNA CopA binds to the leader region of the repA mRNA (target: CopT). Previous studies on CopA-CopT pairing in vitro showed that the dominant product of antisense RNA-mRNA binding is not a full RNA duplex. We have studied here the structure of CopA-CopT complex, combining chemical and enzymatic probing and computer graphic modeling. CopI, a truncated derivative of CopA unable to bind CopT stably, was also analyzed. We show here that after initial loop-loop interaction (kissing), helix propagation resulted in an extended kissing complex that involves the formation of two intermolecular helices. By introducing mutations (base-pair inversions) into the upper stem regions of CopA and CopT, the boundaries of the two newly formed intermolecular helices were delimited. The resulting extended kissing complex represents a new type of four-way junction structure that adopts an asymmetrical X-shaped conformation formed by two helical domains, each one generated by coaxial stacking of two helices. This structure motif induces a side-by-side alignment of two long intramolecular helices that, in turn, facilitates the formation of an additional intermolecular helix that greatly stabilizes the inhibitory CopA-CopT RNA complex. This stabilizer helix cannot form in CopI-CopT complexes due to absence of the sequences involved. The functional significance of the three-dimensional models of the extended kissing complex (CopI-CopT) and the stable complex (CopA-CopT) are discussed.

Antisense RNA-mediated transcriptional attenuation: an in vitro study of plasmid pT181

Antisense RNAs regulate plasmid replication by several different mechanisms. One of these mechanisms, transcriptional attenuation, was first described for the staphylococcal plasmid pT181, and later for the streptococcal plasmids pIP501 and pAMbeta1. Previously, we performed detailed in vitro and in vivo analyses of the pIP501 system. Here, we present an in vitro analysis of the antisense system of plasmid pT181. The secondary structures of antisense and sense RNA species of different lengths were determined. Binding rate constants for sense/antisense RNA pairs were measured, and functional segments required for complex formation were determined. A single-round transcription assay was used for in vitro analysis of transcriptional attenuation. A comparison between pT181 and pIP501 revealed several differences; whereas a truncated derivative of pIP501 antisense RNA was sufficient for stable complex formation, both stem-loop structures of pT181-RNAI were required. In contrast to the sense RNA of pIP501, which showed an intrinsic propensity to terminate (30-50% in the absence of antisense RNA), the sense RNA of pT181 required antisense RNA for induced termination. Rate constants of formation of pT181 sense-antisense RNA complexes were similar to inhibition rate constants, in striking contrast to pIP501, in which inhibition occurred at least 10-fold faster than stable binding.

Structural analysis of late intermediate complex formed between plasmid ColIb-P9 Inc RNA and its target RNA. How does a single antisense RNA repress translation of two genes at different rates?

The antisense Inc RNA encoded by the IncIalpha ColIb-P9 plasmid replicon controls the translation of repZ encoding the replication initiator and its leader peptide repY at different rates with different mechanisms. The initial loop-loop base pairing between Inc RNA and the target in the repZ mRNA leader inhibits formation of a pseudoknot required for repZ translation. A subsequent base pairing at the 5' leader of Inc RNA blocks repY translation. To delineate the molecular basis for the differential control, we analyzed the intermediate complexes formed between RepZ mRNA and Inc RNA(54), a 5'-truncated Inc RNA derivative. We found that the initial base pairing at the loops transforms into a more stable intermediate complex by its propagation in both directions. The resulting extensive base pairing indicates that the inhibition of the pseudoknot formation is established at this stage. Furthermore, the region of extensive base pairing includes bases different in related plasmids showing different incompatibility. Thus, the observed extensive base pairing is important for determining the incompatibility of the low-copy-number plasmids. We discuss the evolution of replication control systems found in IncIalpha, IncB, and IncFII group plasmids.

Antisense RNA regulation in prokaryotes: rapid RNA/RNA interaction facilitated by a general U-turn loop structure

Efficient gene control by antisense RNA requires rapid bi-molecular interaction with a cognate target RNA. A comparative analysis revealed that a YUNR motif (Y=pyrimidine, R=purine) is ubiquitous in RNA recognition loops in antisense RNA-regulated gene systems. The (Y)UNR sequence motif specifies two intraloop hydrogen bonds forming U-turn structures in many anticodon-loops and all T-loops of tRNAs, the hammerhead ribozyme and in other conserved RNA loops. This structure creates a sharp bend in the RNA phosphate-backbone and presents the following three to four bases in a solvent-exposed, stacked configuration providing a scaffold for rapid interaction with complementary RNA. Sok antisense RNA from plasmid R1 inhibits translation of the hok mRNA by preventing ribosome entry at the mok Shine & Dalgarno element. The 5' single-stranded region of Sok-RNA recognizes a loop in the hok mRNA. We show here, that the initial pairing between Sok antisense RNA and its target in hok mRNA occurs with an observed second-order rate-constant of 2 x 10(6) M(-1) s(-1). Mutations that eliminate the YUNR motif in the target loop of hok mRNA resulted in reduced antisense RNA pairing kinetics, whereas mutations maintaining the YUNR motif were silent. In addition, RNA phosphate-backbone accessibility probing by ethylnitrosourea was consistent with a U-turn structure formation promoted by the YUNR motif. Since the YUNR U-turn motif is present in the recognition units of many antisense/target pairs, the motif is likely to be a generally employed enhancer of RNA pairing rates. This suggestion is consistent with the re-interpretation of the mutational analyses of several antisense control systems including RNAI/RNAII of ColE1, CopA/CopT of R1 and RNA-IN/RNA-OUT of IS10.

Role of CIS in replication of an IncB plasmid

Replication of the IncB plasmid pMU720 requires the synthesis of the cis-acting RepA protein and the presence of two DNA elements, ori and CIS. CIS is the 166-bp sequence separating the RepA coding sequence from ori. To investigate how this organization of the pMU720 replicon contributes to the mechanism of initiation of replication, mutations in the sequence and/or the length of CIS were introduced into the CIS region and their effects on the efficiency of replication of the pMU720 replicon in vivo was determined. The CIS region was found to be composed of two domains. The repA-proximal domain, which showed strong transcription termination activity, could be replaced by equivalent sequences from I-complex and IncL/M plasmids, whose replicons are organized in the same fashion as pMU720. Replacement by a trpA transcription terminator afforded only partial replication activity. The repA-distal domain was shown to be a spacer whose role was to position sequence(s) within ori on the correct face of the DNA helix vis-à-vis the repA-proximal portion of CIS. A model for the loading of RepA protein onto ori is discussed.

The Escherichia coli OxyS regulatory RNA represses fhlA translation by blocking ribosome binding

OxyS is a small untranslated RNA which is induced in response to oxidative stress in Escherichia coli. This novel RNA acts as a global regulator to activate or repress the expression of as many as 40 genes, including the fhlA-encoded transcriptional activator and the rpoS-encoded sigma(s) subunit of RNA polymerase. Deletion analysis of OxyS showed that different domains of the small RNA are required for the regulation of fhlA and rpoS. We examined the mechanism of OxyS repression of fhlA and found that the OxyS RNA inhibits fhlA translation by pairing with a short sequence overlapping the Shine-Dalgarno sequence, thereby blocking ribosome binding/translation.

Structural basis for binding of the plasmid ColIb-P9 antisense Inc RNA to its target RNA with the 5'-rUUGGCG-3' motif in the loop sequence

The sequence 5'-rUUGGCG-3' is conserved within the loop regions of antisense RNAs or their targets involved in replication of various prokaryotic plasmids. In IncIalpha plasmid ColIb-P9, the partially base paired 21-nucleotide loop of a stem-loop called structure I within RepZ mRNA contains this hexanucleotide sequence, and comprises the target site for the antisense Inc RNA. In this report, we find that the base pairing interaction at the 5'-rGGC-3' sequence in the hexanucleotide motif is important for interaction between Inc RNA and structure I. In addition, the 21-base loop domain of structure I is folded tighter than predicted, with the hexanucleotide sequence at the top. The second U residue in the sequence is favored for Inc RNA binding in a base-specific manner. On the other hand, the upper domain of the Inc RNA stem-loop is loosely structured, and maintaining the loop sequence single-stranded is important for the intermolecular interaction. Based on these results, we propose that a structural feature in the loop I domain, conferred probably by the conserved 5'-rUUGGCG-3' sequence, favors binding to a complementary, single-stranded RNA. This model also explains how the RepZ mRNA pseudoknot, described in the accompanying paper (Asano, K., and Mizobuchi, K. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 11815-11825) is formed specifically with structure I. A possible conformation adopted by the 5'-rUUGGCG-3' loop sequence is discussed.

Programmed cell death by hok/sok of plasmid R1: processing at the hok mRNA 3'-end triggers structural rearrangements that allow translation and antisense RNA binding

The hok/sok locus of plasmid R1 mediates plasmid stabilization by killing of plasmid-free cells. The locus specifies two RNAs, hok mRNA and Sok antisense RNA. The post-segregational killing mediated by hok/sok is governed by a complicated control mechanism that involves both post-transcriptional inhibition of translation by Sok-RNA and activation of hok translation by mRNA 3' processing. Sok-RNA inhibits translation of a reading frame (mok) that overlaps with hok, and translation of hok is coupled to translation of mok. In the inactive full-length hok mRNA, the translational activator element at the mRNA 5'-end (tac) is sequestered by the fold-back-inhibitory element located at the mRNA 3'-end (fbi). The 5' to 3' pairing locks the RNA in an inert configuration in which the SDmok and Sok-RNA target regions are sequestered. Here we show that the 3' processing leads to major structural rearrangements in the mRNA 5'-end. The structure of the refolded RNA explains activation of translation and antisense RNA binding. The refolded RNA contains an antisense RNA target stem-loop that presents the target nucleotides in a single-stranded conformation. The stem of the target hairpin contains SDmok and AUGmok in a paired configuration. Using toeprinting analysis, we show that this pairing keeps SDmok in an accessible configuration. Furthermore, a mutational analysis shows that an internal loop in the target stem is prerequisite for efficient translation and antisense RNA binding.

Antisense RNA control of plasmid R1 replication. The dominant product of the antisense rna-mrna binding is not a full RNA duplex

The replication frequency of plasmid R1 is controlled by an antisense RNA (CopA) that binds to its target site (CopT) in the leader region of repA mRNA and inhibits the synthesis of the replication initiator protein RepA. Previous studies on CopA-CopT pairing in vitro revealed the existence of a primary loop-loop interaction (kissing complex) that is subsequently converted to an almost irreversible duplex. However, the structure of more stable binding intermediates that lead to the formation of a complete duplex was speculative. Here, we investigated the interaction between CopA and CopT by using Pb(II)-induced cleavages. The kissing complex was studied using a truncated antisense RNA (CopI) that is unable to form a full duplex with CopT. Furthermore, RNase III, which is known to process the CopA-CopT complex in vivo, was used to detect the existence of a full duplex. Our data indicate that the formation of a full CopA-CopT duplex appears to be a very slow process in vitro. Unexpectedly, we found that the loop-loop interaction persists in the predominant CopA-CopT complex and is stabilized by intermolecular base pairing involving the 5'-proximal 30 nucleotides of CopA and the complementary region of CopT. This almost irreversible complex suffices to inhibit ribosome binding at the tap ribosome binding site and may be the inhibitory complex in vivo.

Importance of structural differences between complementary RNA molecules to control of replication of an IncB plasmid

Replication of the IncB miniplasmid pMU720 is dependent on the expression of repA, the gene encoding replication initiator protein RepA. Binding of a small antisense RNA (RNAI) to its complementary target (stem-loop I [SLI]) in the RepA mRNA prevents the participation of SLI in the formation of a pseudoknot that is an enhancer of translation of this mRNA. Thus, RNAI regulates the frequency of replication of pMU720 by controlling the efficiency of translation of the RepA mRNA. Mutational analysis of the two seven-base complementary sequences involved in formation of the pseudoknot showed that only the five central bases of each were critical for the formation of the pseudoknot. Physical analysis of SLI showed that despite the complete complementarity of its sequence to that of RNAI, the structures of the two molecules are different. The most prominent difference between the two structures is the presence of a 4-base internal loop immediately below the hairpin loop of SLI but not that of RNAI. Closure of this internal loop in SLI resulted in a 40-fold reduction in repA expression and loss of sensitivity of the residual expression to inhibition by RNAI. By contrast, repA expression was largely unaffected by the closure of a lower internal loop whose presence in SLI and RNAI is essential for effective interaction between these two molecules. These results suggest that the interaction of SLI with the distal pseudoknot bases is fundamentally different from the RNAI-SLI binding interaction and that the differences in structure between RNAI and SLI are necessary to allow SLI to be able to efficiently bind RNAI and to participate in pseudoknot formation.

Quantitative hybridization kinetics of DNA probes to RNA in solution followed by diffusional fluorescence correlation analysis

Binding kinetics in solution of six N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-5-carboxyrhodamine-labeled oligodeoxyribonucleotide probes to a 101mer target RNA comprising the primer binding site for HIV-1 reverse transcriptase were characterized using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). FCS allows a sensitive, non-radioactive real time observation of hybridization of probes to the RNA target in the buffer of choice without separation of free and bound probe. The binding process could directly be monitored by the change in translational diffusion time of the 17mer to 37mer DNA probe upon specific hybridization with the larger RNA target. The characteristic diffusion time through a laser-illuminated open volume element with 0.5 micron in diameter increased from 0.13-0.2 ms (free) to 0.37-0.50 ms (bound), depending on the probe. Hybridization was approximated by biphasic irreversible second-order reaction kinetics, yielding first-phase association rate constants between 3 x 10(4) and 1.5 x 10(6) M-1 s-1 for the different probes. These varying initial rates reflected the secondary structures of probes and target sites, being consistent with a hypothetical binding pathway starting from loop-loop interactions in a kissing complex, and completion of hybridization requiring an additional interaction involving single-stranded regions of both probe and target. FCS thus permits rapid screening for suitable antisense nucleic acids directed against an important target like HIV-1 RNA with low consumption of probes and target.

An unusually long-lived antisense RNA in plasmid copy number control: in vivo RNAs encoded by the streptococcal plasmid pIP501

The main regulator of pIP501 replication is an antisense RNA (RNAIII) that induces transcriptional attenuation of the essential RNAII. Previous studies identified the termination point in vivo and demonstrated attenuation in vitro. This in vivo analysis confirms the appearance of attenuated RNAII dependent on RNAIII. Half-lives and intracellular levels of RNAII and RNAIII were determined: in a Bacillus subtilis cell harboring a wild-type pIP501 plasmid, approximately 50 molecules RNAII and 1000 to 2000 molecules of RNAIII were measured, respectively. The half-life of RNAII was in the range of that of other target RNAs, whereas that of RNAIII (approximately 30 minutes) was unusually long, representing a so far unprecedented case of a metabolically stable antisense RNA regulating plasmid copy number. Long antisense RNA half-life is predicted to yield sluggish control and instability of maintenance. We propose a model for how plasmid pIP501 may avoid this problem by using both the repressor CopR and the antisense RNAIII for control. Four stem-loop mutants of RNAII/RNAIII with elevated copy numbers were characterized for in vitro antisense/target RNA binding, RNAIII half-life, incompatibility, and attenuation in vivo. Two classes were found: interaction mutants and half-life mutants. The former suggest a key function for loop LIII of RNAIII as recognition loop in the primary steps of RNAII/RNAIII interaction.

Transgenes and gene suppression: telling us something new?

Transgenes provide unique opportunities to assess the relationship between genotype and phenotype in an organism. In most cases, introduction and subsequent expression of a transgene will increase (with a sense RNA) or decrease (with an antisense RNA) the steady-state level of a specific gene product. However, a number of surprising observations have been made in the course of many transgenic studies. We develop a hypothesis that suggests that many examples of endogenous gene suppression by either antisense or sense transcripts are mediated by the same cellular mechanism.

Bulged-out nucleotides in an antisense RNA are required for rapid target RNA binding in vitro and inhibition in vivo

Naturally occurring antisense RNAs in prokaryotes are generally short, highly structured and untranslated. Stem-loops are always present, and loop regions serve as primary recognition structures in most cases. Single-stranded tails or internal unstructured regions are required for initiation of stable pairing between antisense and target RNA. Most antisense RNAs contain bulged-out nucleotides or small internal loops in upper stem regions. Here we investigated the role of the bulged-out nucleotides of CopA (the copy number regulator of plasmid R1) in determining the binding properties of this antisense RNA to its target in vitro and the efficiency of a translational inhibition in vivo. The introduction of perfect helicity in the region of the two bulges in CopA decreased pairing rate constants by up to 180-fold, increased equilibrium dissociation constants of the 'kissing intermediate' up to 14-fold, and severely impaired inhibition of repA expression. A previously described loop size mutant of CopA showed decreased pairing rates, but, in contrast to the bulge-less mutant CopAs, shows a decreased dissociation constant of the 'kissing complex'. We conclude that removal of the specific bulges/internal loops within the stem-loop II of CopA impairs the inhibitor, and that creation of an internal loop at a different position does not restore activity, emphasizing the optimal folding of wild-type CopA. The accompanying paper shows that an additional function of bulges can be protection from RNase III cleavage.

Molecular analysis of RNAI control of repB translation in IncB plasmids

The translation of RepA, the replication initiation protein of the IncB plasmid pMU720, requires that its mRNA (RNAII) folds to form a pseudoknot immediately upstream of the repA Shine-Dalgarno sequence. The formation of this pseudoknot is dependent in turn on the translation and correct termination of a leader peptide, RepB. A small countertranscript RNA, RNAI, controls the replication of pMU720 by interacting with RNAII to negatively regulate the expression of repA both directly, by sequestering the proximal bases required for pseudoknot formation, and indirectly, by inhibiting the translation of repB. Inhibition of the translation of repB by RNAI was found to depend on the close proximity of the RNAI-RNAII complex to the translational initiation region of repB, indicating that the primary mechanism of RNAI control involves steric hindrance. Disruption of RNAI control of repB had only a small effect on the copy number of the IncB plasmid, indicating that inhibition of the expression of repA by RNAI is achieved predominantly by inhibition of pseudoknot formation rather than by inhibition of repB translation.