Demonstration in vivo that interaction of maltose-binding protein with SecB is determined by a kinetic partitioning

Selective ribosome profiling reveals a role for SecB in the co-translational inner membrane protein biogenesis

The chaperone SecB has been implicated in de novo protein folding and translocation across the membrane, but it remains unclear which nascent polypeptides SecB binds, when during translation SecB acts, how SecB function is coordinated with other chaperones and targeting factors, and how polypeptide engagement contributes to protein biogenesis. Using selective ribosome profiling, we show that SecB binds many nascent cytoplasmic and translocated proteins generally late during translation and controlled by the chaperone trigger factor. Revealing an uncharted role in co-translational translocation, inner membrane proteins (IMPs) are the most prominent nascent SecB interactors. Unlike other substrates, IMPs are bound early during translation, following the membrane targeting by the signal recognition particle. SecB remains bound until translation is terminated, and contributes to membrane insertion. Our study establishes a role of SecB in the co-translational maturation of proteins from all cellular compartments and functionally implicates cytosolic chaperones in membrane protein biogenesis.

The Sec System: Protein Export in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, proteins found in the periplasm or the outer membrane are exported from the cytoplasm by the general secretory, Sec, system before they acquire stably folded structure. This dynamic process involves intricate interactions among cytoplasmic and membrane proteins, both peripheral and integral, as well as lipids. In vivo, both ATP hydrolysis and proton motive force are required. Here, we review the Sec system from the inception of the field through early 2016, including biochemical, genetic, and structural data.

The rate of folding dictates substrate secretion by the Escherichia coli hemolysin type 1 secretion system

Secretion of the Escherichia coli toxin hemolysin A (HlyA) is catalyzed by the membrane protein complex HlyB-HlyD-TolC and requires a secretion sequence located within the last 60 amino acids of HlyA. The Hly translocator complex exports a variety of passenger proteins when fused N-terminal to this secretion sequence. However, not all fusions are secreted efficiently. Here, we demonstrate that the maltose binding protein (MalE) lacking its natural export signal and fused to the HlyA secretion signal is poorly secreted by the Hly system. We anticipated that folding kinetics might be limiting secretion, and we therefore introduced the "folding" mutation Y283D. Indeed this mutant fusion protein was secreted at a much higher level. This level was further enhanced by the introduction of a second MalE folding mutation (V8G or A276G). Secretion did not require the molecular chaperone SecB. Folding analysis revealed that all mutations reduced the refolding rate of the substrate, whereas the unfolding rate was unaffected. Thus, the efficiency of secretion by the Hly system is dictated by the folding rate of the substrate. Moreover, we demonstrate that fusion proteins defective in export can be engineered for secretion while still retaining function.

SecB-mediated protein export need not occur via kinetic partitioning

In Escherichia coli, the cytosolic chaperone SecB is responsible for the selective entry of a subset of precursor proteins into the Sec pathway. In vitro, SecB binds to a variety of unfolded substrates without apparent sequence specificity, but not native proteins. Selectivity has therefore been suggested to occur by kinetic partitioning of substrates between protein folding and SecB association. Evidence for kinetic partitioning is based on earlier observations that SecB blocks the refolding of the precursor form of maltose-binding protein (preMBP)(5) and slow-folding maltose-binding protein (MBP) mutants, but not faster-folding mature wild-type MBP. In order to quantitatively validate the kinetic partitioning model, we have independently measured each of the rate constants involved in the interaction of SecB with refolding preMBP (a physiological substrate of SecB) and mature MBP. The measured rate constants correctly predict substrate folding kinetics over a wide range of SecB, MBP, and preMBP concentrations. Analysis of the data reveals that, for many substrates, kinetic partitioning is unlikely to be responsible for SecB-mediated protein export. Instead, the ability of SecB-bound substrates to continue folding while bound to SecB and their ability to interact with other components of the secretory machinery such as SecA may be key opposing determinants that inhibit and promote protein export, respectively.

Antifolding activity of the SecB chaperone is essential for secretion of HasA, a quickly folding ABC pathway substrate

We have previously shown that SecB, the ATP-independent chaperone of the Sec pathway, is required for the secretion of the HasA hemophore from Serratia marcescens via its type I secretion pathway, both in the reconstituted system in Escherichia coli and in the original host. The refolding of apo-HasA after denaturation with guanidine HCl was followed by stopped-flow measurements of fluorescence of its single tryptophan, both in the absence and presence of SecB. In the absence of SecB, HasA folds very quickly with one main phase (45 s(-1)) accounting for 92% of the signal. SecB considerably slows down HasA folding. At stoichiometric amounts of SecB and HasA, a single phase (0.014 s(-1)) of refolding is observed. Two double point mutants of HasA were made, abolishing two hydrogen bonds between N-terminal and C-terminal side chain residues. In both cases, the mutants essentially maintained the same secondary and tertiary structure as wild-type HasA and were fully functional. Refolding of both mutants was much slower than that of wild-type HasA and they were secreted essentially independently of SecB. We conclude that SecB has mainly an antifolding function in the HasA ABC secretion pathway.

DnaK promotes the selective export of outer membrane protein precursors in SecA-deficient Escherichia coli

Consistent with many other results indicating that SecA plays an essential role in the translocation of presecretory proteins across the Escherichia coli inner membrane, we previously found that a approximately 95% depletion of SecA completely blocks the export of periplasmic proteins in vivo. Surprisingly, we found that about 25% of the outer membrane protein (OMP) OmpA synthesized after SecA depletion was gradually translocated across the inner membrane. In this study we analyzed the export of several other OMPs after SecA depletion. We found that 25-50% of each OMP as well as an OmpA-alkaline phosphatase fusion protein was exported from SecA-deficient cells. This partial export was completely abolished by the SecA inhibitor sodium azide and therefore still required the participation of SecA. Examination of a variety of OmpA derivatives, however, ruled out the possibility that OMPs are selectively translocated in SecA-deficient cells because SecA binds to their N termini with unusually high affinity. Export after SecA depletion was observed in cells that lack SecB, the primary targeting factor for OMPs, but was abolished by partial inactivation of DnaK. Furthermore, OmpA could be isolated in a stable complex with DnaK. The data strongly suggest that OMPs require only a relatively low level of translocase activity to cross the inner membrane because they can be preserved in a prolonged export-competent state by DnaK.

Complexes between protein export chaperone SecB and SecA. Evidence for separate sites on SecA providing binding energy and regulatory interactions

During localization to the periplasmic space or to the outer membrane of Escherichia coli some proteins are dependent on binding to the cytosolic chaperone SecB, which in turn is targeted to the membrane by specific interaction with SecA, a peripheral component of the translocase. Five variant forms of SecB, previously demonstrated to be defective in mediating export in vivo (Gannon, P. M., and Kumamoto, C. A. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 1590-1595; Kimsey, H. K., Dagarag, M. D., and Kumamoto, C. A. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 22831-22835) were investigated with respect to their ability to bind SecA both in solution and at the membrane translocase. We present evidence that at least two regions of SecA are involved in the formation of active complexes with SecB. The variant forms of SecB were all capable of interacting with SecA in solution to form complexes with stability similar to that of complexes between SecA and wild-type SecB. However, the variant forms were defective in interaction with a separate region of SecA, which was shown to trigger a change that was correlated to activation of the complex. The region of SecA involved in activation of the complexes was defined as the extreme carboxyl-terminal 21 aminoacyl residues.

A thermodynamic coupling mechanism for the disaggregation of a model peptide substrate by chaperone secB

Molecular chaperones prevent protein aggregation in vivo and in vitro. In a few cases, multichaperone systems are capable of dissociating aggregated state(s) of substrate proteins, although little is known of the mechanism of the process. SecB is a cytosolic chaperone, which forms part of the precursor protein translocation machinery in Escherichia coli. We have investigated the interaction of the B-chain of insulin with chaperone SecB by light scattering, pyrene excimer fluorescence, and electron spin resonance spectroscopy. We show that SecB prevents aggregation of the B-chain of insulin. We show that SecB is capable of dissociating soluble B-chain aggregates as monitored by pyrene fluorescence spectroscopy. The kinetics of dissociation of the B-chain aggregate by SecB has been investigated to understand the mechanism of dissociation. The data suggests that SecB does not act as a catalyst in dissociation of the aggregate to individual B-chains, rather it binds the small population of free B-chains with high affinity, thereby shifting the equilibrium from the ensemble of the aggregate toward the individual B-chains. Thus SecB can rescue aggregated, partially folded/misfolded states of target proteins by a thermodynamic coupling mechanism when the free energy of binding to SecB is greater than the stability of the aggregate. Pyrene excimer fluorescence and ESR methods have been used to gain insights on the bound state conformation of the B-chain to chaperone SecB. The data suggests that the B-chain is bound to SecB in a flexible extended state in a hydrophobic cleft on SecB and that the binding site accommodates approximately 10 residues of substrate.

Substrate specificity of the SecB chaperone

The bacterial chaperone SecB assists translocation of proteins across the inner membrane. The mechanism by which it differentiates between secretory and cytosolic proteins is poorly understood. To identify its binding motif, we screened 2688 peptides covering sequences of 23 proteins for SecB binding. The motif is approximately 9 residues long and is enriched in aromatic and basic residues, whereas acidic residues are disfavored. Its identification allows the prediction of binding regions within protein sequences with up to 87% accuracy. SecB-binding regions occur statistically every 20-30 residues. The occurrence and affinity of binding regions are similar in SecB-dependent and -independent secretory proteins and in cytosolic proteins, and SecB lacks specificity toward signal sequences. SecB cannot thus differentiate between secretory and non-secretory proteins via its binding specificity. This conclusion is supported by the finding that SecB binds denatured luciferase, thereby allowing subsequent refolding by the DnaK system. SecB may rather be a general chaperone whose involvement in translocation is mediated by interactions of SecB and signal sequences of SecB-bound preproteins with the translocation apparatus.

SecA: the ubiquitous component of preprotein translocase in prokaryotes

SecA is an obligatory component of the complex hetero-septameric translocase of prokaryotes. It is unique in that it exists as two forms within the holoenzyme; first, as a structural component of the preprotein channel and second, as an ATP-dependent membrane cycling factor facilitating the translocation of a broad class of proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane. While the translocase activity of SecA appears to be functionally conserved, it is not clear whether the mechanisms of regulation of the secA gene are similarly maintained. The recent characterization of an ATP-dependent RNA helicase activity of SecA offers a unique mechanism for SecA to communicate the secretion status of the cell to the appropriate regulatory circuits simply by the unwinding of an appropriate RNA target. Resolution of these two activities through combined biochemical, genetic, and biophysical studies should lead to a better understanding of the role of SecA in bacterial secretion.

Overproduction of SecA suppresses the export defect caused by a mutation in the gene encoding the Escherichia coli export chaperone secB

SecB is a cytosolic protein required for rapid and efficient export of particular periplasmic and outer membrane proteins in Escherichia coli. SecB promotes export by stabilizing newly synthesized precursor proteins in a nonnative conformation and by targeting the precursors to the inner membrane. Biochemical studies suggest that SecB facilitates precursor targeting by binding to the SecA protein, a component of the membrane-embedded translocation apparatus. To gain more insight into the functional interaction of SecB and SecA, in vivo, mutations in the secA locus that compensate for the export defect caused by the secB missense mutation secBL75Q were isolated. Two suppressors were isolated, both of which led to the overproduction of wild-type SecA protein. In vivo studies demonstrated that the SecBL75Q mutant protein releases precursor proteins at a lower rate than does wild-type SecB. Increasing the level of SecA protein in the cell was found to reverse this slow-release defect, indicating that overproduction of SecA stimulates the turnover of SecBL75Q-precursor complexes. These findings lend additional support to the proposed pathway for precursor targeting in which SecB promotes targeting to the translocation apparatus by binding to the SecA protein.

SecB binds only to a late native-like intermediate in the folding pathway of barstar and not to the unfolded state

SecB is a cytosolic, tetrameric chaperone of Escherichia coli which maintains precursor proteins in a translocation competent state. We have investigated the effect of SecB on the refolding kinetics of the small protein barstar in 1 M guanidine hydrochloride at pH 7.0 and 25 degreesC using fluorescence spectroscopy. We show that SecB does not bind either the native or the unfolded states of barstar but binds to a late near-native intermediate along the folding pathway. For barstar, polypeptide collapse and formation of a hydrophobic surface are required for binding to SecB. SecB does not change the apparent rate constant of barstar refolding. The kinetic data for SecB binding to barstar are not consistent with simple kinetic partitioning models.

Recognition of protein substrates by the prolyl isomerase trigger factor is independent of proline residues

The trigger factor is associated with bacterial ribosomes and catalyzes proline-limited protein folding reactions. Its folding activity is very high and conserved in evolution, as shown for the homologous enzymes from Escherichia coli and Mycoplasma genitalium. The folding protein substrate (a variant of ribonuclease T1) binds with high affinity to the trigger factors, and permanently unfolded proteins are strong, competitive inhibitors. We used this inhibition to characterize the substrate binding sites of the trigger factors. Unfolded alpha-lactalbumin binds very tightly and inhibits the trigger factor from M. genitalium with a KI value of 50 nM. The binding of inhibitory proteins is independent of proline residues, as shown for unfolded tendamistat, which binds to the trigger factor with equal affinity in the presence and in the absence of its three proline residues. The good inhibition by a non-folding variant of ribonuclease T1 that lacks Pro39 showed that this proline, at which the catalysis of folding occurs, is dispensable for substrate binding. The trigger factors cannot catalyze prolyl isomerization when proteins are partially folded already. They preferentially recognize unstructured protein chains, which bind with high affinity to a site distinct from the catalytic prolyl isomerase center in the FKBP domain.

Correlation between requirement for SecA during export and folding properties of precursor polypeptides

The structural complexity of a ligand in association with the molecular chaperones SecB and SecA was investigated using three species of precursor maltose-binding protein, which differ in their stability as a result of an amino acid substitution in each that affects the rate of folding of the polypeptide. In the presence of high concentrations of both SecB and SecA, the precursors were translocated in vitro with indistinguishable kinetics. However, when SecA was limiting, the translocation was more rapid for precursor species, which had lower stability in the native state relative to the stability of the wild-type precursor. We propose that, when in complex with SecB, precursors can form an element of tertiary structure and that these tertiary contacts are blocked when SecA is bound.

The amino terminus of the F1-ATPase beta-subunit precursor functions as an intramolecular chaperone to facilitate mitochondrial protein import

Mitochondrial import signals have been shown to function in many steps of mitochondrial protein import. Previous studies have shown that the F1-ATPase beta-subunit precursor (pre-F1beta) of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains an extended, functionally redundant mitochondrial import signal at its amino terminus. However, the full significance of this functionally redundant targeting sequence has not been determined. We now report that the extended pre-F1beta signal acts to maintain the precursor in an import-competent conformation prior to import, in addition to its previously characterized roles in mitochondrial targeting and translocation. We found that this extended signal is required for the efficient posttranslational mitochondrial import of pre-F1beta both in vivo and in vitro. To determine whether the pre-F1beta signal directly influences precursor conformation, fusion proteins that contain wild-type and mutant forms of the pre-F1beta import signal attached to the model passenger protein dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) were constructed. Deletions that reduced the import signal to a minimal functional unit decreased both the half-time of precursor folding and the efficiency of mitochondrial import. To confirm that the reduced mitochondrial import associated with this truncated signal was due to a defect in its ability to maintain DHFR in a loosely folded conformation, we introduced structurally destabilizing missense mutations into the DHFR passenger to block precursor folding independently of the import signal. We found that the truncated signal imported this destabilized form of DHFR as efficiently as the intact targeting signal, indicating that the primary defect associated with the minimal signal is an inability to maintain the precursor in a loosely folded conformation. Our results suggest that the loss of this intramolecular chaperone function leads to defects in the early stages of the import process.

Folding of barnase in the presence of the molecular chaperone SecB

SecB is a molecular chaperone dedicated to interact exclusively with proteins destined for translocation across membranes. We find that SecB interacts with barnase during its folding in a similar manner to its interaction with GroEL. On mixing acid-denatured barnase with SecB in a stopped-flow spectrofluorimeter under conditions that favour refolding, we observe a series of fluorescence changes, corresponding to the binding of the denatured protein and the subsequent refolding of multiply and singly bound forms. The different phases were assigned using a combination of kinetics and mutant proteins. The refolding of barnase when bound to SecB is strongly retarded but never blocked. Multiply bound barnase is less tightly bound and refolds with a higher rate constant than singly bound barnase. Up to 4 mol of denatured barnase bind to 1 mol of tetrameric SecB.

Chaperone SecB from Escherichia coli mediates kinetic partitioning via a dynamic equilibrium with its ligands

We have shown that the complexes between SecB, a chaperone from Escherichia coli, and two physiological ligands, galactose-binding protein and maltose-binding protein, are in rapid, dynamic equilibrium between the bound and free states. Binding to SecB is readily reversible, and each time the ligand is released it undergoes a kinetic partitioning between folding to its native state and re-binding to SecB. Binding requires that the polypeptide be devoid of tertiary structure; once the protein has folded, it is no longer a ligand. Conditions were established in which folding of the polypeptides was sufficiently slow so that at each cycle of dissociation rebinding was favored over folding and a kinetically stable complex between SecB and each polypeptide ligand was observed. Evidence that the ligand is continually released to the bulk solution and rebound was obtained by altering the conditions to increase the rate of folding of each ligand so that folding of the ligand was faster than reassociation with SecB thereby allowing the system to partition to free SecB and folded polypeptide ligand. We conclude that complexes between the chaperone SecB and ligands are in dynamic, rapid equilibrium with the free states. This mode of binding is simpler than that documented for chaperones that function to facilitate folding such as the Hsp70s and Hsp60s, where hydrolysis of ATP is coupled to the binding and release of ligands. This difference may reflect the fact that SecB does not mediate folding but is specialized to facilitate protein export. Without a requirement for exogenous energy it efficiently performs its sole duty: to keep proteins in a nonnative conformation and thus competent for export.

Thermodynamic characterization of the reversible, two-state unfolding of maltose binding protein, a large two-domain protein

The folding and stability of maltose binding protein (MBP) have been investigated as a function of pH and temperature by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence, far- and near-UV circular dichroism, and high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetric measurements. MBP is a monomeric, two-domain protein containing 370 amino acids. The protein is stable in the pH range of 4-10.5 at 25 degrees C. The protein exhibits reversible, two-state, thermal and guanidine hydrochloride-mediated denaturation at neutral pH. The thermostability of MBP is maximal at pH 6, with a Tm of 64.9 degrees C and a deltaHm of 259.7 kcal mol(-1). The linear dependence of deltaHm on Tm was used to estimate a value of deltaCp of 7.9 kcal mol(-1) K(-1) or 21.3 cal (mol of residue)(-1) K(-1). These values are higher than the corresponding deltaCp's for most globular proteins studied to date. However, the extrapolated values of deltaH and deltaS (per mole of residue) at 110 degrees C are similar to those of other globular proteins. These data have been used to show that the temperature at which a protein undergoes cold denaturation depends primarily on the deltaCp (per mol of residue) and that this temperature increases with an increase in deltaCp. The predicted decrease in stability of MBP at low temperatures was experimentally confirmed by carrying out denaturant-mediated unfolding studies at neutral pH at 2 and 28 degrees C.

Binding of SecB to ribosome-bound polypeptides has the same characteristics as binding to full-length, denatured proteins

The interaction of the chaperone SecB with ribosome-bound polypeptides that are in the process of elongation has been studied using an in vitro protein synthesis system. The binding is characterized by the same properties as those demonstrated for the binding of SecB to full-length proteins that are in nonnative conformation: it is readily reversible and has no specificity for the leader peptide. In addition, it is shown that the growing polypeptide chains must achieve a critical length to bind tightly enough to allow their isolation in complex with SecB. This explains the longstanding observation that, even when export is cotranslational, it begins late in synthesis. Furthermore, the required length is approximately the same as the length that defines the binding frame within denatured, full-length proteins bound to SecB.

Growing up in a dangerous environment: a network of multiple targeting and folding pathways for nascent polypeptides in the cytosol

The first events in the lives of proteins are the most hazardous. Starting at the ribosome, nascent polypeptides undergo complex folding processes endangered by aggregation reactions. Proteins with organellar destinations require correct targeting to the translocation machineries and prevention from premature folding. The high precision and speed of these processes is ensured by a cystosolic system consisting of molecular chaperones, folding catalysts and targeting factors. This review focuses on the interactions of this system with nascent polypeptides and discusses new concepts for protein folding in the cytosol. It is proposed that folding and targeting are promoted by a flexible network of multiple unassisted and assisted pathways.

Mapping of the binding frame for the chaperone SecB within a natural ligand, galactose-binding protein

The chaperone SecB selectively binds polypeptides that are in a non-native state; however, the details of the interaction between SecB and its ligands are unknown. As a step in elucidation of the molecular mechanism of binding, we have mapped the region of a physiologic ligand (galactose-binding protein) that is in contact with SecB. The binding frame comprises approximately 160 aminoacyl residues and is located in the central portion of the primary sequence. Comparison to the binding frame within maltose-binding protein, which is similarly long and positioned around the center of that polypeptide, reveals no similarity in sequence or in folding motif. The results are consistent with the proposal that the selectivity in binding exhibited by SecB is based on the simultaneous occupancy of multiple binding sites, each of which demonstrates low specificity, by flexible stretches of polypeptide that are only accessible in non-native proteins.