Preferential cleavage of degradative intermediates of rpsT mRNA by the Escherichia coli RNA degradosome

Systematic Quantification of Sequence and Structural Determinants Controlling mRNA stability in Bacterial Operons

mRNA degradation is a central process that affects all gene expression levels, and yet, the determinants that control mRNA decay rates remain poorly characterized. Here, we applied a synthetic biology, learn-by-design approach to elucidate the sequence and structural determinants that control mRNA stability in bacterial operons. We designed, constructed, and characterized 82 operons in Escherichia coli, systematically varying RNase binding site characteristics, translation initiation rates, and transcriptional terminator efficiencies in the 5' untranslated region (UTR), intergenic, and 3' UTR regions, followed by measuring their mRNA levels using reverse transcription quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) assays during exponential growth. We show that introducing long single-stranded RNA into 5' UTRs reduced mRNA levels by up to 9.4-fold and that lowering translation rates reduced mRNA levels by up to 11.8-fold. We also found that RNase binding sites in intergenic regions had much lower effects on mRNA levels. Surprisingly, changing the transcriptional termination efficiency or introducing long single-stranded RNA into 3' UTRs had no effect on upstream mRNA levels. From these measurements, we developed and validated biophysical models of ribosome protection and RNase activity with excellent quantitative agreement. We also formulated design rules to rationally control a mRNA's stability, facilitating the automated design of engineered genetic systems with desired functionalities.

Translation Initiation Control of RNase E-Mediated Decay of Polycistronic gal mRNA

In bacteria, mRNA decay is a major mechanism for regulating gene expression. In Escherichia coli, mRNA decay initiates with endonucleolytic cleavage by RNase E. Translating ribosomes impede RNase E cleavage, thus providing stability to mRNA. In transcripts containing multiple cistrons, the translation of each cistron initiates separately. The effect of internal translation initiations on the decay of polycistronic transcripts remains unknown, which we have investigated here using the four-cistron galETKM transcript. We find that RNase E cleaves a few nucleotides (14-36) upstream of the translation initiation site of each cistron, generating decay intermediates galTKM, galKM, and galM mRNA with fewer but full cistrons. Blocking translation initiation reduced stability, particularly of the mutated cistrons and when they were the 5'-most cistrons. This indicates that, together with translation failure, the location of the cistron is important for its elimination. The instability of the 5'-most cistron did not propagate to the downstream cistrons, possibly due to translation initiation there. Cistron elimination from the 5' end was not always sequential, indicating that RNase E can also directly access a ribosome-free internal cistron. The finding in gal operon of mRNA decay by cistron elimination appears common in E. coli and Salmonella.

Synonymous Mutations in rpsT Lead to Ribosomal Assembly Defects That Can Be Compensated by Mutations in fis and rpoA

We previously described how four deleterious synonymous mutations in the Salmonella enterica rpsT gene (encoding ribosomal protein S20) result in low S20 levels that can be compensated by mutations that restore [S20]. Here, we have further studied the cause for the deleterious effects of S20 deficiency and found that the S20 mutants were also deficient in four other 30S proteins (S1, S2, S12, and S21), which is likely due to an assembly defect of the S20 deficient 30S subunits. We examined the compensatory effect by six additional mutations affecting the global regulator Fis and the C-terminal domain of the α subunit of RNA polymerase (encoded by rpoA). The fis and rpoA mutations restored the S20 levels, concomitantly restoring the assembly defect and the levels of S1, S2, S12, and S21. These results illustrate the complexity of compensatory evolution and how the negative effects of deleterious mutations can be suppressed by a multitude of mechanisms. Additionally, we found that the mutations in fis and rpoA caused reduced expression of other ribosomal components. Notably, some of the fis mutations and the rpoA mutation corrected the fitness of the rpsT mutants to wild-type levels, although expression of other ribosomal components was reduced compared to wild-type. This finding raises new questions regarding the relation between translation capacity and growth rate.

Identification of the RNA Pyrophosphohydrolase RppH of Helicobacter pylori and Global Analysis of Its RNA Targets

RNA degradation is crucial for regulating gene expression in all organisms. Like the decapping of eukaryotic mRNAs, the conversion of the 5'-terminal triphosphate of bacterial transcripts to a monophosphate can trigger RNA decay by exposing the transcript to attack by 5'-monophosphate-dependent ribonucleases. In both biological realms, this deprotection step is catalyzed by members of the Nudix hydrolase family. The genome of the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori, a Gram-negative epsilonproteobacterium, encodes two proteins resembling Nudix enzymes. Here we present evidence that one of them, HP1228 (renamed HpRppH), is an RNA pyrophosphohydrolase that triggers RNA degradation in H. pylori, whereas the other, HP0507, lacks such activity. In vitro, HpRppH converts RNA 5'-triphosphates and diphosphates to monophosphates. It requires at least two unpaired nucleotides at the 5' end of its substrates and prefers three or more but has only modest sequence preferences. The influence of HpRppH on RNA degradation in vivo was examined by using RNA-seq to search the H. pylori transcriptome for RNAs whose 5'-phosphorylation state and cellular concentration are governed by this enzyme. Analysis of cDNA libraries specific for transcripts bearing a 5'-triphosphate and/or monophosphate revealed at least 63 potential HpRppH targets. These included mRNAs and sRNAs, several of which were validated individually by half-life measurements and quantification of their 5'-terminal phosphorylation state in wild-type and mutant cells. These findings demonstrate an important role for RppH in post-transcriptional gene regulation in pathogenic Epsilonproteobacteria and suggest a possible basis for the phenotypes of H. pylori mutants lacking this enzyme.

Regulation of mRNA Decay in Bacteria

Gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria use a variety of enzymatic pathways to degrade mRNAs. Although several recent reviews have outlined these pathways, much less attention has been paid to the regulation of mRNA decay. The functional half-life of a particular mRNA, which affects how much protein is synthesized from it, is determined by a combination of multiple factors. These include, but are not necessarily limited to, (a) stability elements at either the 5' or the 3' terminus, (b) posttranscriptional modifications, (c) ribosome density on individual mRNAs, (d) small regulatory RNA (sRNA) interactions with mRNAs, (e) regulatory proteins that alter ribonuclease binding affinities, (f) the presence or absence of endonucleolytic cleavage sites, (g) control of intracellular ribonuclease levels, and (h) physical location within the cell. Changes in physiological conditions associated with environmental alterations can significantly alter the impact of these factors in the decay of a particular mRNA.

Distinct Requirements for 5'-Monophosphate-assisted RNA Cleavage by Escherichia coli RNase E and RNase G

RNase E and RNase G are homologous endonucleases that play important roles in RNA processing and decay in Escherichia coli and related bacterial species. Rapid mRNA degradation is facilitated by the preference of both enzymes for decay intermediates whose 5' end is monophosphorylated. In this report we identify key characteristics of RNA that influence the rate of 5'-monophosphate-assisted cleavage by these two ribonucleases. In vitro, both require at least two and prefer three or more unpaired 5'-terminal nucleotides for such cleavage; however, RNase G is impeded more than RNase E when fewer than four unpaired nucleotides are present at the 5' end. Each can tolerate any unpaired nucleotide (A, G, C, or U) at either of the first two positions, with only modest biases. The optimal spacing between the 5' end and the scissile phosphate appears to be eight nucleotides for RNase E but only six for RNase G. 5'-Monophosphate-assisted cleavage also occurs, albeit more slowly, when that spacing is greater or at most one nucleotide shorter than the optimum, but there is no simple inverse relationship between increased spacing and the rate of cleavage. These properties are also manifested during 5'-end-dependent mRNA degradation in E. coli.

Determinants in the rpsT mRNAs recognized by the 5'-sensor domain of RNase E

RNase E plays a central role in processing virtually all classes of cellular RNA in many bacterial species. A characteristic feature of RNase E and its paralogue RNase G, as well as several other unrelated ribonucleases, is their preference for 5'-monophosphorylated substrates. The basis for this property has been explored in vitro. At limiting substrate, cleavage of the rpsT mRNA by RNase E (residues 1-529) is inefficient, requiring excess enzyme. The rpsT mRNA is cleaved sequentially in a 5' to 3' direction, with the initial cleavage(s) at positions 116/117 or 190/191 being largely driven by direct entry, independent of the 5'-terminus or the 5'-sensor domain of RNase E. Generation of the 147 nt 3'-limit product requires sequential cleavages that generate 5'-monophosphorylated termini on intermediates, and the 5'-sensor domain of RNase E. These requirements can be bypassed with limiting enzyme by deleting a stem-loop structure adjacent to the site of the major, most distal cleavage. Alternatively, this specific cleavage can be activated substantially by a 5'-phosphorylated oligonucleotide annealed 5' to the cleavage site. This finding suggests that monophosphorylated small RNAs may destabilize their mRNA targets by recruiting the 5-sensor domain of RNase E 'in trans'.

Influence of translation on RppH-dependent mRNA degradation in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, the endonuclease RNase E can access internal cleavage sites in mRNA either directly or by a 5' end-dependent mechanism in which cleavage is facilitated by prior RppH-catalysed conversion of the 5'-terminal triphosphate to a monophosphate, to which RNase E can bind. The characteristics of transcripts that determine which of these two pathways is primarily responsible for their decay are poorly understood. Here we report the influence of ribosome binding and translocation on each pathway, using yeiP and trxB as model transcripts. Ribosome binding to the translation initiation site impedes degradation by both mechanisms. However, because the effect on the rate of 5' end-independent decay is greater, poor ribosome binding favours degradation by that pathway. Arresting translation elongation with chloramphenicol quickly inhibits RNase E cleavage downstream of the initiation codon but has little or no immediate effect on cleavage upstream of the ribosome binding site. RNase E binding to a monophosphorylated 5' end appears to increase the likelihood of cleavage at sites within the 5' untranslated region. These findings indicate that ribosome binding and translocation can have a major impact on 5' end-dependent mRNA degradation in E. coli and suggest a possible sequence of events that follow pyrophosphate removal.

Initiation of decay of Bacillus subtilis rpsO mRNA by endoribonuclease RNase Y

rpsO mRNA, a small monocistronic mRNA that encodes ribosomal protein S15, was used to study aspects of mRNA decay initiation in Bacillus subtilis. Decay of rpsO mRNA in a panel of 3'-to-5' exoribonuclease mutants was analyzed using a 5'-proximal oligonucleotide probe and a series of oligonucleotide probes that were complementary to overlapping sequences starting at the 3' end. The results provided strong evidence that endonuclease cleavage in the body of the message, rather than degradation from the native 3' end, is the rate-determining step for mRNA decay. Subsequent to endonuclease cleavage, the upstream products were degraded by polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), and the downstream products were degraded by the 5' exonuclease activity of RNase J1. The rpsO mRNA half-life was unchanged in a strain that had decreased RNase J1 activity and no RNase J2 activity, but it was 2.3-fold higher in a strain with decreased activity of RNase Y, a recently discovered RNase of B. subtilis encoded by the ymdA gene. Accumulation of full-length rpsO mRNA and its decay intermediates was analyzed using a construct in which the rpsO transcription unit was under control of a bacitracin-inducible promoter. The results were consistent with RNase Y-mediated initiation of decay. This is the first report of a specific mRNA whose stability is determined by RNase Y.

Substrate binding and active site residues in RNases E and G: role of the 5'-sensor

The paralogous endoribonucleases, RNase E and RNase G, play major roles in intracellular RNA metabolism in Escherichia coli and related organisms. To assay the relative importance of the principal RNA binding sites identified by crystallographic analysis, we introduced mutations into the 5'-sensor, the S1 domain, and the Mg(+2)/Mn(+2) binding sites. The effect of such mutations has been measured by assays of activity on several substrates as well as by an assay of RNA binding. RNase E R169Q and the equivalent mutation in RNase G (R171Q) exhibit the strongest reductions in both activity (the k(cat) decrease approximately 40- to 100-fold) and RNA binding consistent with a key role for the 5'-sensor. Our analysis also supports a model in which the binding of substrate results in an increase in catalytic efficiency. Although the phosphate sensor plays a key role in vitro, it is unexpectedly dispensable in vivo. A strain expressing only RNase E R169Q as the sole source of RNase E activity is viable, exhibits a modest reduction in doubling time and colony size, and accumulates immature 5 S rRNA. Our results point to the importance of alternative RNA binding sites in RNase E and to alternative pathways of RNA recognition.

Messenger RNA decay and maturation in Bacillus subtilis

Our understanding of the ribonucleases that act to process and turn over RNA in Bacillus subtilis, a model Gram-positive organism, has increased greatly in recent years. This chapter discusses characteristics of B. subtilis ribonucleases that have been shown to participate in messenger RNA maturation and decay. Distinct features of a recently discovered ribonuclease, RNase J1, are reviewed, and are put in the context of a mechanism for the mRNA decay process in B. subtilis that differs greatly from the classical model developed for E. coli. This chapter is divided according to three parts of an mRNA-5' end, body, and 3' end-that could theoretically serve as sites for initiation of decay. How 5'-proximal elements affect mRNA half-life, and especially how these elements interface with RNase J1, forms the basis for a set of "rules" that may be useful in predicting mRNA stability.

Endonucleolytic initiation of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli

Instability is a fundamental property of mRNA that is necessary for the regulation of gene expression. In E. coli, the turnover of mRNA involves multiple, redundant pathways involving 3'-exoribonucleases, endoribonucleases, and a variety of other enzymes that modify RNA covalently or affect its conformation. Endoribonucleases are thought to initiate or accelerate the process of mRNA degradation. A major endoribonuclease in this process is RNase E, which is a key component of the degradative machinery amongst the Proteobacteria. RNase E is the central element in a multienzyme complex known as the RNA degradosome. Structural and functional data are converging on models for the mechanism of activation and regulation of RNase E and its paralog, RNase G. Here, we discuss current models for mRNA degradation in E. coli and we present current thinking on the structure and function of RNase E based on recent crystal structures of its catalytic core.

Post-transcriptional processing of the LEE4 operon in enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli

Enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC) employs a type III secretion system (T3SS) to export translocator and effector proteins required for mucosal colonization. The T3SS is encoded in a pathogenicity island called the locus of enterocyte effacement (LEE) that is organized in five major operons, LEE1 to LEE5. LEE4 encodes a regulator of secretion (SepL), translocators (EspA, D and B), two chaperones (CesD2 and L0017), a T3SS component (EscF) and an effector protein (EspF). It was originally proposed that the esp transcript is transcribed from a promoter located at the end of sepL but other authors suggested that this transcript is the result of a post-transcriptional processing event. In this study, we established that the espADB mRNA is generated by post-transcriptional processing at the end of the sepL coding sequence. RNase E is the endonuclease involved in the cleavage, but the interaction of this enzyme with other proteins through its C-terminal half is dispensable. A putative transcription termination event in the cesD2 coding region would generate the 3' end of the transcript. Similar to what has been described for other processed transcripts, the cleavage of LEE4 seems a mechanism to differentially regulate SepL and Esp protein production.

Initiation of RNA decay in Escherichia coli by 5' pyrophosphate removal

The common belief that endonucleolytic cleavage is the initial, rate-determining step of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli fails to explain the influence of 5' termini on the half-lives of primary transcripts. We have re-examined the initial events of RNA degradation in that organism by devising an assay to probe the 5' phosphorylation state of RNA and by employing a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme to investigate the degradative consequences of an unphosphorylated 5' end. These studies have identified a previously unrecognized prior step in decay that triggers subsequent internal cleavage by the endonuclease RNase E and thereby governs RNA longevity: the rate-determining conversion of a triphosphorylated to a monophosphorylated 5' terminus. Our findings redefine the role of RNase E in RNA degradation and explain how unpaired 5'-terminal nucleotides can facilitate access to internal cleavage sites within primary transcripts. Moreover, these results reveal a striking parallel between the mechanisms of mRNA decay in prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms.

Quaternary Structure and Catalytic Activity of the Escherichia coli Ribonuclease E Amino-Terminal Catalytic Domain

RNase E is an essential endoribonuclease that plays a central role in the processing and degradation of RNA in Escherichia coli and other bacteria. Most endoribonucleases have been shown to act distributively; however, Feng et al. [(2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 99, 14746-14751] have recently found that RNase E acts via a scanning mechanism. A structural explanation for the processivity of RNase E is provided here, with our finding that the conserved catalytic domain of E. coli RNase E forms a homotetramer. Nondissociating nanoflow-electrospray mass spectrometry suggests that the tetramer binds up to four molecules of a specific substrate RNA analogue. The tetrameric assembly of the N-terminal domain of RNase E is consistent with crystallographic analyses, which indicate that the tetramer possesses approximate D(2) dihedral symmetry. Using X-ray solution scattering data and symmetry restraints, a solution shape is calculated for the tetramer. This shape, together with limited proteolysis data, suggests that the S1-RNA binding domains of RNase E lie on the periphery of the tetramer. These observations have implications for the structure and function of the RNase E/RNase G ribonuclease family and for the assembly of the E. coli RNA degradosome, in which RNase E is the central component.

Genomic analysis in Escherichia coli demonstrates differential roles for polynucleotide phosphorylase and RNase II in mRNA abundance and decay

Previous work has shown that simultaneous inactivation of polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase) and RNase II (both 3' 5' exonucleases) in Escherichia coli leads to the loss of cell viability and the accumulation of partially degraded mRNA species. In order to help to distinguish how these two enzymes globally affect the abundance and decay of mRNAs, we have carried out a genome-wide analysis of the steady-state levels of E. coli transcripts using deletion mutations in either rnb or pnp. The data show that, in exponentially growing cells, inactivation of PNPase leads to an increase in the steady-state level of more expressed mRNAs (17.3%) than inactivation of RNase II (7.3%). In contrast, the steady-state levels of a large number of E. coli mRNAs (31%) are decreased in the absence of RNase II, including almost all the ribosomal protein genes, suggesting that a major function of this enzyme is to protect specific mRNAs from the activity of other ribonucleases. Array data were confirmed by Northern analysis of 12 individual mRNAs. A comparison between the steady-state levels and the half-lives of individual mRNAs indicates that there may be a direct interaction between transcription and mRNA decay for some of the transcripts. In addition, results are presented to show significant phenotypic differences between the pnp-7 point mutant and the pnp delta 683 deletion allele.

Ectopic RNase E sites promote bypass of 5'-end-dependent mRNA decay in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, 5'-terminal stem-loops form major impediments to mRNA decay, yet conditions that determine their effectiveness or the use of alternative decay pathway(s) are unclear. A synthetic 5'-terminal hairpin stabilizes the rpsT mRNA sixfold. This stabilization is dependent on efficient translational initiation and ribosome transit through at least two-thirds of the coding sequence past a major RNase E cleavage site in the rpsT mRNA. Insertion of a 12-15 residue 'ectopic' RNase E cleavage site from either the rne leader or 9S pre-rRNA into the 5'-non-coding region of the rpsT mRNA significantly reduces the stabilizing effect of the terminal stem-loop, dependent on RNase E. A similar insertion into the rpsT coding sequence is partially destabilizing. These findings demonstrate that RNase E can bypass an interaction with the 5'-terminus, and exploit an alternative 'internal entry' pathway. We propose a model for degradation of the rpsT mRNA, which explains the hierarchy of protection afforded by different 5'-termini, the use of internal entry for bypass of barriers to decay, 'ectopic sites' and the role of translating ribosomes.

The catalytic domain of RNase E shows inherent 3' to 5' directionality in cleavage site selection

RNase E, a multifunctional endoribonuclease of Escherichia coli, attacks substrates at highly specific sites. By using synthetic oligoribonucleotides containing repeats of identical target sequences protected from cleavage by 2'-O-methylated nucleotide substitutions at specific positions, we investigated how RNase E identifies its cleavage sites. We found that the RNase E catalytic domain (i.e., N-Rne) binds selectively to 5'-monophosphate RNA termini but has an inherent mode of cleavage in the 3' to 5' direction. Target sequences made uncleavable by the introduction of 2'-O-methyl-modified nucleotides bind to RNase E and impede cleavages at normally susceptible sites located 5' to, but not 3' to, the protected target. Our results indicate that RNase E can identify cleavage sites by a 3' to 5' "scanning" mechanism and imply that anchoring of the enzyme to the 5'-monophosphorylated end of these substrates orients the enzyme for directional cleavages that occur in a processive or quasiprocessive mode. In contrast, we find that RNase G, which has extensive structural homology with and size similarity to N-Rne, and can functionally complement RNase E gene deletions when overexpressed, has a nondirectional and distributive mode of action.

Consequences of RNase E scarcity in Escherichia coli

The endoribonuclease RNase E plays an important role in RNA processing and degradation in Escherichia coli. The construction of an E. coli strain in which the cellular concentration of RNase E can be precisely controlled has made it possible to examine and quantify the effect of RNase E scarcity on RNA decay, gene regulation and cell growth. These studies show that RNase E participates in a step in the degradation of its RNA substrates that is partially or fully rate-determining. Our data also indicate that E. coli growth requires a cellular RNase E concentration at least 10-20% of normal and that the feedback mechanism that limits overproduction of RNase E is also able to increase its synthesis when its concentration drops below normal. The magnitude of the in-crease in RNA longevity under conditions of RNase E scarcity may be limited by an alternative pathway for RNA degradation. Additional experiments show that RNase E is a stable protein in E. coli. No other E. coli gene product, when either mutated or cloned on a multicopy plasmid, seems to be capable of compensating for an inadequate supply of this essential protein.