Failure of multiple passages to increase chlamydial recovery

The effect of polyethylene glycol (PEG) on the isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis in H-1 HeLa cells

One hundred and ninety-six urethral and endocervical swabs were processed for isolation of C. trachomatis, using H-1 HeLa cells on shell vials, in the presence and absence of 7% PEG in the chlamydial overlay medium. The results were divided into three evaluable groups based on the number of inclusions per coverslip in the shell vials without PEG. The number of inclusions were compared with that of PEG-treated cultures using the paired t-test. The ranges for the three evaluable groups were one to ten, 11-100 and 101-1000 inclusions per coverslip. All three groups showed a significant increase (2.8- to 3.8-fold) in the number of inclusion bodies in the PEG-treated cultures compared to the untreated cultures.

Quantitation of Chlamydia trachomatis by culture, direct immunofluorescence and competitive polymerase chain reaction

OBJECTIVES

Methods to quantitate Chlamydia trachomatis have never been compared although it would be relevant to periodically evaluate the sensitivity of a detection system. We compared the sensitivity and reproducibility of culture, direct immunofluorescence and the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to quantitate C trachomatis.

METHODS

A competitive semiquantitative PCR procedure was developed. The number of inclusions in culture, particles by direct immunofluorescence and DNA copies by PCR were measured for 12 patient specimens. Variation was determined by measuring a sample 10 times for each method.

RESULTS

Patient C trachomatis major outer membrane protein gene DNA was measured semiquantitatively by amplifying together with reference DNA. DNA molecules, particles and infectious units were quantitated in clinical samples with, on average, 595 DNA molecules and 87 immunofluorescent particles observed per inclusion-forming-unit. Similar coefficients of variation (47-52%) were observed for the 3 procedures.

CONCLUSION

Competitive PCR and counting immunofluorescent particles provide reproducible and sensitive methods of quantitating C trachomatis.

Occurrence of antibodies against chlamydial lipopolysaccharide in human sera as measured by ELISA using an artificial glycoconjugate antigen

An artificial glycoconjugate containing, as a ligand, the deacylated carbohydrate backbone of a recombinant Chlamydia-specific lipopolysaccharide was used as a solid-phase antigen in ELISA to measure antibodies against chlamydial LPS. The specificity and reproducibility of the assay was shown by using a panel of prototype monoclonal antibodies representing the spectrum of antibodies also occurring in patient sera. These mAbs recognized Chlamydia-specific epitopes [alpha 2-->8-linked disaccharide of 3-deoxy-D-manno-octulosonic acid (Kdo) or the trisaccharide alpha Kdo-(2-->8)-alpha Kdo-(2-->4)-alpha Kdo] or those shared between chlamydial and Re-type LPS (alpha Kdo, alpha 2-->4-linked Kdo disaccharide). The assay was used to measure IgG, IgA and IgM antibodies against chlamydial LPS in patients with genital or respiratory tract infections. In comparison to the results obtained with sera from blood donors, it became evident that both types of infection result in significant changes in the profile of LPS antibodies.

Sensitive detection and typing of Chlamydia trachomatis using nested polymerase chain reaction

OBJECTIVES

A method based on a nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was developed to detect and to type Chlamydia trachomatis from low titre samples by amplifying a large portion of the major outer membrane protein gene. The sensitivity of this procedure was evaluated in urogenital clinical samples in comparison with culture.

SPECIMENS

A series of 787 urogenital specimens, including 37 (4.7%) positive by culture, together with 227 other samples that had been found to yield less than 25 chlamydial inclusions in culture were tested.

METHODS

Samples were pelleted, resuspended in 1 mM NaOH, heated and amplified without further purification. After 40 cycles of PCR, 1 microliters of product was amplified by a further 30 cycles of PCR using a second set of primers nested within the initial pair. Positives were detected by agarose gel electrophoresis and confirmed by repeating the PCR analyses and determining the serovar of both amplified samples by restriction fragment length polymorphism.

RESULTS

Nested PCR allowed detection of 96% and culture 77% of positives with only three samples repeatedly positive by PCR but considered false positives because a different serovar was identified in the two amplifications. Of culture-positive samples with less than 11 chlamydia inclusion-forming-units 97% could be detected by nested PCR and most still gave a positive signal when diluted hundred fold.

CONCLUSIONS

Nested PCR provided the basis for a very sensitive C trachomatis detection and typing strategy. Repetition and typing positive samples facilitated detection of false-positive PCR specimens resulting from contamination of the PCR process or any reagent except the original sample.

Infection due to Chlamydia trachomatis in pregnancy and the newborn

Bacteria in the genus Chlamydia comprise three species, C. trachomatis, C. psittaci and C. pneumoniae. C. trachomatis infection is common, varying in prevalence in women from 0% to 37%. In the United States, the prevalence rate is estimated currently to be about 5%. Pregnancy may predispose to an increased chance of infection with C. trachomatis, through physiological immunosuppression and/or cervical ectopy. Maternal antibodies to C. trachomatis provide limited, if any, protection for the newborn. C. trachomatis causes pelvic inflammatory disease--which can result in tubal infertility or ectopic pregnancy and postabortal or late postpartum endometritis. It may also cause chorioamnionitis and premature delivery of the fetus. The incidence of vertical transmission of chlamydiae from mother to baby varies; if the mother is untreated, 20-50% of the newborns will develop conjunctivitis and 10-20% will develop pneumonia. C. psittaci infection in pregnancy is rare, but can cause spontaneous abortion. Whether C. pneumoniae infection in pregnancy has any influence on the outcome has not been ascertained. C. trachomatis can be detected by one or more of several methods; enzyme immunoassays are the least sensitive, but the most widely used. Screening for C. trachomatis in pregnancy may be of benefit in areas of high prevalence, and is generally regarded as being cost-effective if the prevalence rate is more than 5%. Pregnant women are best treated with erythromycin, 250 mg four times daily for 7 days. This will prevent infection of the newborn in more than 90% of cases. The infected neonate should be treated with erythromycin, given systemically and also with topical tetracycline if conjunctivitis is present.

Improved isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis from a low-prevalence population by using polyethylene glycol

The effect of polyethylene glycol (PEG) on the isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis was evaluated in our laboratory. Initial range-finding experiments demonstrated that the number of chlamydial inclusion bodies increased with increasing PEG concentrations. However, PEG concentrations above 10.5% became progressively more toxic to the McCoy cell monolayers. When 50 frozen clinical Chlamydia isolates were inoculated onto McCoy cell cultures with and without 7% PEG, the PEG-treated cultures produced three- to fivefold more chlamydial inclusions than cultures without PEG. This enhancement was also observed when 1,144 fresh clinical specimens from a low-prevalence population were tested. With fresh clinical specimens, PEG-treated cultures produced two- to sixfold more inclusions than standard cultures. The addition of 7% PEG to the chlamydial overlay medium significantly increased the number of inclusions in each culture, improved the sensitivity of the culture, and decreased the probability of missing a weakly positive specimen.

Comparison of two culture approaches, blind passage and dual observation, for detecting Chlamydia trachomatis in various prevalence populations

Chlamydia trachomatis diagnosis in our laboratory consisted of dual inoculation of shell vials and detection of inclusions by using fluorescein-conjugated monoclonal antiserum; the second culture vial was conventionally used for blind passage when the first vial was negative. We compared the increase in positivity using blind passage with that of a strategy utilizing observation of two stained monolayers (dual observation) without blind passage, in an effort to reduce the reporting time and labor associated with the conventional approach. A total of 4,329 specimens were obtained from an obstetrics and gynecology (OB-GYN) clinic (2,563 specimens) and the sexually transmitted disease clinic (1,766 specimens). These specimens were used to compare the two strategies. Blind passage of 1,269 initially culture-negative specimens from the OB-GYN clinic resulted in an additional 6 positive chlamydial diagnoses. In comparison, a similar number of specimens (1,294) from the OB-GYN clinic collected subsequently to the first group were tested by dual observation. There were five additional positive findings. A similar evaluation of specimens from the sexually transmitted disease clinic was performed. Blind passage of 313 initially culture-negative specimens yielded 3 additional positive diagnoses, whereas dual observation of 1,435 similar specimens resulted in 9 positive diagnoses. On the basis of analysis of 4,332 specimens, sensitivity of dual observation is comparable to that of blind passage; labor, cost, and reporting time of dual observation are reduced in comparison to those of blind passage.

Detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by use of polymerase chain reaction

A polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay was developed for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis DNA. One primer set was used, from the published sequence of the common C. trachomatis plasmid. Detection of amplified sequences was carried out by agarose gel electrophoresis. Analysis of 106 clinical samples tested by cell culture and PCR showed a sensitivity of 100% when PCR was compared with cell culture.

Detection of Chlamydia trachomatis endocervical infection in asymptomatic and symptomatic women: comparison of deoxyribonucleic acid probe test with tissue culture

A deoxyribonucleic acid probe assay (PACE 2, Gen-Probe, San Diego) was compared with a standard tissue culture method for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis endocervical infection in both asymptomatic and symptomatic women. The results of the probe test were expressed as a ratio of relative light units of the specimen per relative light units of the cutoff recommended by the manufacturer. Samples with sample/cutoff ratios near 1.0 were repeated until two or more consistent ratios were obtained. A total of 426 specimens were obtained, with an overall disease prevalence of 10.1%. Of the 426 specimens examined, seven (1.6%) were near the cutoff and were retested. The results of 426 samples with matching cultures indicated that the manufacturer's discrete cutoff was adequate for results determination. The deoxyribonucleic acid probe test was essentially equivalent to standard tissue culture in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values in a low-prevalence patient population.

Laboratory techniques for the diagnosis of chlamydial infections

Yolk-sac inoculation of embryonated eggs was superseded 25 years ago by the use of cell cultures (often McCoy) for the isolation of Chlamydia trachomatis. Centrifugation of specimens onto the cell monolayers was shown to increase sensitivity, but little of late has further improved sensitivity which is at least ten-fold greater than that of eggs. However, culture is slow and labour intensive so that non-cultural techniques without these drawbacks have come to dominate. Direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) tests are rapid and have sensitivities that range from 70% to 100% for men and 68% to 100% for women, and specificities that range from 87% to 99% for men and 82% to 100% for women; if the tests are read by competent observers the values are at the top end of the ranges. The detection rate may be enhanced even further by relatively low-speed centrifugation of specimens before staining. Skilled reading is not a feature of enzyme immunoassays (EIAs) which according to the literature have sensitivities that range from 62% to 97% for men and 64% to 100% for women, and specificities that range from 92% to 100% for men and 89% to 100% for women. However, comparison against poor reference tests is responsible for most of the higher values and the clinician should not be misled into believing that EIAs have excellent sensitivity; the lower values in the ranges are closer to reality. Furthermore, EIAs that are being designed for use by general practitioners should be regarded with the greatest caution since lack of sensitivity means that chlamydia-positive patients will go undetected. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is not bedevilled by insensitivity but it is no more sensitive than the most sensitive cell culture or DFA tests. PCR is unsuitable for routine diagnosis but has a place as a research tool. For men, examination of "first-catch" urine samples by the best of the non-cultural procedures provides an acceptable non-invasive approach to diagnosis; for women, the value of examining urine may be less, but needs to be thoroughly tested. However, there is little doubt that a Cytobrush used to obtain cervical specimens holds no practical advantage over a swab. Serological tests are reliant on the provision of paired sera for making a diagnosis; high antibody titres in single sera may be suggestive of an aetiological association in deep-seated chlamydial infections (epididymitis, arthritis, salpingitis, etc), but unequivocal interpretation is unusual, particularly in an individual case, since the distinction between a current and past infection is problematical.

Quantitative culture of endocervical Chlamydia trachomatis

We examined the number of Chlamydia trachomatis inclusions produced in the initial passage of cell cultures of endocervical specimens from 1,231 women with positive chlamydial cultures who attended a sexually transmitted diseases clinic. Youth, white race, oral contraceptive use, and concurrent infection by Neisseria gonorrhoeae were associated with high chlamydial inclusion counts. Youth, white race, and oral contraceptive use were independent determinants of a high chlamydial inclusion count in women without concurrent gonorrhea but not in women with gonorrhea. Results of our study suggest that the degree of chlamydial excretion from the infected cervix may be influenced by characteristics of the patient being tested and may affect the ability to detect C. trachomatis in different patient groups.

Evaluation of a nonisotopic probe for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in endocervical specimens

A nonisotopic probe (Gen-Probe PACE; Gen-Probe, Inc., San Diego, Calif.) for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in endocervical specimens was evaluated in 344 women attending a dysplasia clinic or an obstetrics clinic and 158 women who visited an emergency room. For each patient, the probe, a tissue cell culture, and a direct immunofluorescent-antibody test (DFA; MicroTrak; Syva Co., Palo Alto, Calif.) were used. C. trachomatis was detected in 54 specimens by at least one method. Forty-four, 44, and 37 specimens were positive by culture, probe, and DFA, respectively, and 31 were positive by all three methods. Considering culture-positive plus both probe- and DFA-positive results as the "gold standard," we determined the overall sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of the probe to be 80, 98, 82, and 98%, respectively. These values were 94, 98, 84, and 99%, respectively, in emergency room patients and 71, 98, 80, and 97%, respectively, in clinic patients. The sensitivities, specificities, and negative predictive values of the DFA and probe were comparable. The positive predictive values of the DFA in all patients and in emergency room and clinic patients were 97, 100, and 95%, respectively. Given the number of probe-positive results that were not confirmed by culture, we do not recommend using the Gen-Probe PACE to screen for C. trachomatis in women with a low to moderate risk for infection.

Evaluation of a radioactive rRNA:cDNA-hybridisation assay for the direct detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in urogenital specimens

A radioactive cDNA probe complementary to chlamydial ribosomal RNA was used to detect C trachomatis in urogenital specimens. Of 37 specimens positive with cell culture 31 were confirmed by the rRNA:cDNA hybridisation test, the sensitivity being 83.8%. The specificity of the hybridisation test was 94.4%, as 186 of 197 specimens that were negative by cell culture were also negative when assessed by the hybridisation method. Given a prevalence of 15.8% the predictive values for positive and negative results were 73.8% and 96.9%, respectively. In additional experiments the possible role of microorganisms added to the specimen collection medium was investigated. However, no indication for crosshybridisation was found; at high concentrations microorganisms interfered with the test procedure.

Cytobrush in collection of cervical specimens for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis

Methods of collecting endocervical samples for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis were evaluated. We compared Calgiswab and cytobrush for isolation in cell culture and Dacron swab and cytobrush for direct fluorescent-antibody (DFA) testing for 632 females attending a sexually transmitted disease clinic. An additional specimen for enzyme immunoassay (EIA) was also collected. True-positives were identified as tissue culture positive and/or both DFA and EIA positive. Use of the cytobrush significantly improved the sensitivity of both the culture (69% with swab and 100% with cytobrush) and DFA testing (68% with swab and 85% with cytobrush). The EIA sensitivity was 85%. The specificity of each test was greater than or equal to 98%. The cytobrush appears to be the superior method for the collection of cervical samples from nonpregnant women.

Recovery of Chlamydia trachomatis from endometrial and fallopian tube biopsies in women with infertility of tubal origin

In order to examine the role of chronic active chlamydial infection in tubal infertility, cultures for Chlamydia trachomatis were performed on endometrial biopsies from 38, and fallopian tube biopsies from all, of 52 women undergoing tubal surgery for infertility. C. trachomatis was recovered from one or both sites in 8 of 52 (15%). Five of 6 women with positive fallopian tube cultures had endometrial cultures performed, and of these, 4 (80%) were positive. Three culture-positive women had been treated with tetracycline or doxycycline. Multiple blind passage in tissue culture was required for recovery of all six fallopian tube and four of the six endometrial isolates. No specific anatomic lesion was associated with documented infection. Chronic active chlamydial infection is frequently associated with tubal infertility, may persist despite therapy, and often can be detected by endometrial biopsy culture.

Effect of differences in specimen processing and passage technique on recovery of Chlamydia trachomatis

We have previously found that optimum recovery of Chlamydia trachomatis in microdilution plate culture required multiple blind passages. However, others have found this not to be the case for culture in vials. In the present study, the effect on recovery of the use of vials (as opposed to microdilution plates) and the effect of vortexing, sonication, or both were compared. Three different passage techniques were also evaluated. Vortexing or sonication resulted in equivalent recoveries. However, compared with vortexing alone, a combination of vortexing and sonication increased recovery from 95 (78%) to 114 (94%) of 121 positive specimens (P = 0.002). In multiple-passage experiments, the combination of vortexing and sonication, compared with vortexing only, increased the proportion of isolates recovered with no more than a single passage from 81 to 96%. Substitution of vials for microdilution plates increased recovery with only a single passage to greater than 96%, irrespective of whether sonication was employed. The most sensitive technique for single-passage technique was one using blunt scraping of cell monolayers with passage of two monolayers to one. The sensitivity of cell culture for C. trachomatis is highly dependent on the technique(s) employed. However, the combination of sonication and vortexing of clinical specimens enhanced recovery in microdilution plates, and a single blind passage did so in both microdilution plates and vials. Consideration should be given to their use for routine clinical cultures.

Laboratory diagnosis of human chlamydial infections

Chlamydia trachomatis is a human pathogen that causes ocular disease (trachoma and inclusion conjunctivitis), genital disease (cervicitis, urethritis, salpingitis, and lymphogranuloma venereum), and respiratory disease (infant pneumonitis). Respiratory chlamydioses also occur with infection by avian strains of C. psittaci or infection by the newly described TWAR agent. Diagnosis of most acute C. trachomatis infections relies on detection of the infecting agent by cell culture, fluorescent antibody, immunoassay, cytopathologic, or nucleic acid hybridization methods. Individual non-culture tests for C. trachomatis are less sensitive and specific than the best chlamydial cell culture system but offer the advantages of reduced technology and simple transport of clinical specimens. Currently available nonculture tests for C. trachomatis perform adequately as screening tests in populations in which the prevalence of infection is greater than 10%. A negative culture or nonculture test for C. trachomatis does not, however, exclude infection. The predictive value of a positive nonculture test may be unsatisfactory when populations of low infection prevalence are tested. Tests that detect antibody responses to chlamydial infection have limited utility in diagnosis of acute chlamydial infection because of the high prevalence of persistent antibody in healthy adults and the cross-reactivity due to infection by the highly prevalent C. trachomatis and TWAR agents. Assays for changes in antibody titer to the chlamydial genus antigen are used for the diagnosis of respiratory chlamydioses. A single serum sample that is negative for chlamydial antibody excludes the diagnosis of lymphogranuloma venereum.

Detection of Chlamydia trachomatis. A study of the direct immunofluorescence technique and a review diagnostic limitations

Because of the high prevalence of Chlamydia trachomatis in adolescent females and the high cost of chlamydia cultures, we evaluated the use of the direct fluorescein conjugated monoclonal antibody test (DFA) in diagnosing C. trachomatis in adolescent females. Chlamydia trachomatis was found in 37 (20.1%) of 184 cultures. The sensitivity of the direct smear as compared with the culture was 89% and the specificity was 99%. The results of recent studies of the DFA and chlamydiazyme tests are reviewed as well as the problems in comparing techniques.

Screening for Chlamydia trachomatis infection in a pregnancy counseling clinic

Five hundred twenty asymptomatic women attending a pregnancy counseling clinic were interviewed and screened for cervical Chlamydia trachomatis infection before therapeutic abortion. Overall, 56 (10.8%) women were culture positive for C. trachomatis. Restricting testing to women with risk factors for infection or who had cervical leukocytosis on Gram staining of cervical mucus, or who were seropositive for C. trachomatis antibodies proved impractical because of insensitivity or nonspecificity. We evaluated three chlamydia diagnostic tests to determine which test had the best performance characteristics. In comparison with culture, the direct fluorescent antigen test had a sensitivity of 89% and a positive predictive value of 78%, whereas the enzyme immunoassay had 96% and 69%, respectively. When analysis was redone with any two positive laboratory tests to define true infection status, the performance parameters of enzyme immunoassay were sensitivity 98%, specificity 98%, and positive predictive value 87%. We conclude that all women undergoing therapeutic abortion require testing for C. trachomatis infection and that enzyme immunoassay is the most effective and practical test in this group of women.