Impact on routine diagnosis of echovirus infections of intratypic differentiation and antigenic variation in echovirus type 25 studied by using monoclonal antibodies

A genotypic characterization of enteroviral antigenic variants isolated in eastern Canada

Antigenic variation within serotypes of enteroviruses can have a significant impact on the effectiveness of routine diagnosis by neutralization assays. The focus of this particular study was to initiate a genetic characterization of echovirus type 9 (E9) antigenic variants and nontypeable strains isolated in Canada from 1991 to 1993. All variant strains were initially identified by the serological parameter of neutralization 'breakthrough' during conventional serotyping using the Lim-Benyesh-Melnick antiserum pools and by assessing neutralization endpoints using micro-neutralization methodology. Both E9 variant and non-variant isolates were further characterized by sequencing amplicons generated from the VP2 capsid protein-coding region of these particular strains. Variants from the provinces of Ontario and New Brunswick were shown to include a number of genotypically distinct strains and all the variant strains were significantly different from non-variant E9 isolates when nucleotide sequences were compared. A similar genetic analysis of two completely non-typeable isolates from Quebec showed that these viruses seemed to belong to a genetic cluster of enteroviruses that included coxsackievirus A16 and enterovirus 71 serotypes. The use of genetic typing by sequence analysis provides a molecular tool for determining the genotypic diversity of variant and non-typeable isolates and their possible relatedness to other enteroviral strains.

Molecular typing of enteroviruses: current status and future requirements. The European Union Concerted Action on Virus Meningitis and Encephalitis

Human enteroviruses have traditionally been typed according to neutralization serotype. This procedure is limited by the difficulty in culturing some enteroviruses, the availability of antisera for serotyping, and the cost and technical complexity of serotyping procedures. Furthermore, the impact of information derived from enterovirus serotyping is generally perceived to be low. Enteroviruses are now increasingly being detected by PCR rather than by culture. Classical typing methods will therefore no longer be possible in most instances. An alternative means of enterovirus typing, employing PCR in conjunction with molecular genetic techniques such as nucleotide sequencing or nucleic acid hybridization, would complement molecular diagnosis, may overcome some of the problems associated with serotyping, and would provide additional information regarding the epidemiology and biological properties of enteroviruses. We argue the case for developing a molecular typing system, discuss the genetic basis of such a system, review the literature describing attempts to identify or classify enteroviruses by molecular methods, and suggest ways in which the goal of molecular typing may be realized.

Comparative sensitivities of Sabin and Mahoney poliovirus type 1 prototype strains and two recent isolates to low concentrations of glutaraldehyde

Significant intratypic differences in the glutaraldehyde (GTA) sensitivity of echovirus isolates have been shown. While exploring ways to optimize the study of GTA sensitivity of enteroviruses, we also observed intratypic differences in poliovirus type 1 isolates collected in France. A suspension procedure was used for assessing the virucidal effect of GTA at low concentrations (< or = 0.10%) against purified viruses. Two recent isolates of poliovirus type 1 tested were first fully characterized by the PCR restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) test. The RFLP pattern of clinical isolate 5617 was similar to that of poliovirus type 1 LS-c, 2ab (Sabin strain), confirming the vaccine origin of strain 5617. The RFLP pattern of strain 5915 recovered from sewage was different from that of the Mahoney strain, suggesting a genetic variation in this wild isolate. We then analyzed under the same controlled conditions the GTA sensitivities of both isolates and their respective prototype strains. The wild Mahoney and 5915 strains exhibited significantly lower sensitivities to GTA than did the vaccine Sabin and 5617 strains. The inactivation rates of clinical isolates 5617 and 5915 were very similar to those of their corresponding reference Sabin and Mahoney strains. Both the conformational structure of the capsid of each strain and the amino acid constitution of structural polypeptides could be involved in the variations observed. The relevance of our comparative sensitivity studies to standardization of virucidal tests is discussed.

Sequence comparison of echovirus type 30 isolates to other enteroviruses in the 5'noncoding region

The genetic relationship between echovirus type 30 (E30) isolates were characterised by means of amplification of a part of the 5'noncoding region by polymerase chain reaction and direct sequencing. Later, the E30 sequences were compared with other enteroviruses. Homology between recent clinical E30 isolates from different years exceeds 98% at the nucleotide level. Comparing the E30 sequence with other enteroviruses, homology varied between 68% (coxsackievirus A24) and 93% (coxsackievirus B3). E30 appeared to have coxsackie B-like characteristics in this genomic part. It is considered that E30 and coxsackie B viruses belong to the same enterovirus subgroup.

Identification of enteroviruses by indirect immunofluorescence using monoclonal antibodies

BACKGROUND

Serum neutralization (Nt) is used most often to type enterovirus isolates, but it is labor-intensive, expensive, and supplies of reference antisera for Nt are limited. Alternative methods of enterovirus typing are needed.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the use of indirect immunofluorescence (IFA) with commercially available monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) as an alternative to Nt for the identification of enteroviruses.

STUDY DESIGN

Two MAb blends (one for coxsackie B viruses and one for echoviruses 4, 6, 9, 11, 30, and 34) and a coxsackie A9 MAb were used to screen 465 clinical isolates over a period of two years. Virus isolates which tested positive with one of the blends were typed with the individual MAbs of the respective blend. Individual MAbs for polioviruses 1, 2, and 3 acquired late in the study were used to screen 45 viral isolates.

RESULTS

The antibodies identified 251/465 (54%) of the total number of isolates tested. IFA results for 451 of 465 viral isolates were in agreement with conventional identification methods. The sensitivity of the IFA screen using the MAb blends and coxsackie A9 MAb was 93% and the specificity was 99%. Thirteen discrepant isolates were negative by IFA, with twelve positive by Nt for echovirus 30 and one isolate positive by Nt for coxsackie A9. The remaining discrepant isolate was positive by IFA for both coxsackie A9 and coxsackie B5, but positive by Nt for coxsackie A9 only.

CONCLUSIONS

IFA is highly specific for the identification of enteroviruses, but may not be sensitive enough to identify all strains within an enterovirus type. Procedures which utilize an IFA screen and confirm final results by Nt decrease turnaround time and reduce the number of cell culture tubes required for the identification of each enterovirus isolate.

Replication of echo virus type 25 JV-4 reference strain and wild type strains in MRC5 cells compared with that of poliovirus type 1

In echo virus type 25/JV-4 the shut off of host cell protein synthesis took significantly longer and the kinetics of the synthesis of viral proteins and viral RNA occurred much later than in the poliovirus. However, these characteristics impaired neither polyprotein processing nor virus production in the JV-4 strain. In contrast the two wild strains M.1262 and Th.222 had a lower virus yield than strain JV-4. The presence of a high Mr protein in the pattern of viral proteins of wild strains suggested that a defect in the polyprotein processing was responsible for the decreased virus yield. The infectious cycle of strain Th.222 differed from that of strains JV-4 and M.1262 in the rapid inhibition of host cell translation and the extent of viral protein synthesis. The sensitivity to actinomycin D was also investigated. Strain M.1262 was found to be insensitive. The virus yield of strains JV-4 and Th.222 was three- and fourfold lower respectively in the presence of actinomycin D. This sensitivity to the antibiotic was observed during viral RNA synthesis in strain JV-4 and during viral protein synthesis in strain Th.222. These results suggest that cellular factors are involved in the replication of echo virus type 25 strains in MRC5 cells.

Comparative sensitivity of the echovirus type 25 JV-4 prototype strain and two recent isolates to glutaraldehyde at low concentrations

The sensitivity of two recently isolated antigenic variants of echovirus type 25 (Montpellier 76-1262 and Thionville 86-222) to glutaraldehyde (GTA) at low concentrations was compared with that of the JV-4 prototype strain. The purified viruses were treated under the same conditions with GTA at concentrations ranging from 0.002 to 0.10%. The wild strains exhibited significantly lower sensitivity to GTA than did the prototype strain; with 0.10% GTA, a 2 log10 unit reduction was obtained in 5 min for JV-4 and in 60 and 80 min for Montpellier 76-1262 and Thionville 86-222, respectively. A comparison with previous results obtained with poliovirus type 1 showed that the inactivation rates of echovirus type 25 wild strains were fivefold lower than those of the poliovirus type 1 Sabin strain. The comparative electrophoretic and immunoblot analyses showed differences in the results of GTA binding with capsid proteins of the viruses. Unlike in the poliovirus type 1 Mahoney strain and in the echovirus type 25 JV-4 reference strain, GTA produced only minor intermolecular cross-linkings in the viral particles of the two wild strains of echovirus type 25. Our results suggest that there are both intertypic and intratypic differences in the GTA sensitivities of enterovirus strains. They are of relevance to disinfection procedures in digestive endoscopy and to the choice of the enterovirus strain used for evaluating the efficacy of disinfectants.

Use of the polymerase chain reaction with a murine model of picornavirus-induced myocarditis

Enteroviruses are common pathogens responsible for a wide spectrum of systemic infections. Conventional diagnosis of these infections relies on the isolation of viruses in cell culture and their identification by seroneutralization with polyclonal or monoclonal antibodies. Among enteroviruses, coxsackieviruses B have been involved as causative agents for viral myocarditis. Most of the time, in the case of cardiac pathologies, viral isolation is negative. Molecular biology techniques appear to be an alternative to conventional diagnosis and could supply evidence for the direct implication of enteroviruses in these severe pathologies. In this paper, we describe a murine experimental model of infection with the presumed highly cardiopathogenic coxsackie-virus B type 3. A kinetics of infection was observed for a period of 31 days, and the classical virological markers (viral isolation from feces and heart biopsies, seroconversion) were monitored and compared by means of molecular techniques (molecular hybridization, polymerase chain reaction [PCR]). In this 31-day period, the detection of coxsackievirus B type 3 RNA in the heart was possible only by using two successive seminested PCRs. After 9 to 11 days of active viral replication, when all other virological markers were negative, positive PCR signals were obtained, which supports the hypothesis of a shift to persistent enteroviral infection.

Activity of glutaraldehyde at low concentrations against capsid proteins of poliovirus type 1 and echovirus type 25

The activity of glutaraldehyde (GTA) against capsid proteins of poliovirus type 1 and echovirus type 25 was studied to understand the mode of action of this reagent against enteroviruses. The viruses were treated with GTA concentrations ranging from 0.005 to 0.10%. In the poliovirus particles, high-molecular-weight products were formed by 0.05% GTA, whereas in the echovirus particles, they were formed at 0.005% GTA. These products consist of complexes composed essentially of VP1 and VP3. There seemed to be differences in the composition of the complexes in the two viruses. Cross-linkings between the two polypeptides of the poliovirus capsid may be due to the accessibility to GTA of lysine residues on the loops of VP1 and VP3, which twist out from the surface of the shell.

Heterogeneity of capsid proteins of echovirus type 25 wild-type strain and prototype strain, studied by using sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting

Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting were used to compare the capsid proteins of 19 antigenic variants of echovirus type 25 wild-type strains isolated in France between 1976 and 1987 with those of the prototype JV-4 reference strain isolated in 1957. Immunoblots were developed by using polyclonal sera from rabbits and mice immunized with the reference strain. Immunoblotting patterns revealed reactivity only against viral protein VP1 for sera from both animals. Comparative immunoblotting patterns showed differences in the electrophoretic mobilities of viral protein VP1, especially for the Montpellier 76.1262 wild-type strain. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis of [35S]methioinine-labeled viral polypeptides revealed that the two variant strains, Montpellier 76.1262 and Thionville 86.222, exhibited significant and reproducible shifts in the relative mobilities of VP1 and VP3 and, to a lesser extent, in those of VP0 and VP2. The relative mobility of VP4 seemed very similar for the JV-4 reference strain and the two variants. Interestingly, the structural differences in VP1 and VP3 of Montpellier 76.1262 were not correlated with the pattern of neutralization by monoclonal antibodies, unlike in our previous study, in which this strain differed from the prototype strain in only two epitopes. We concluded that, in addition to the heterogeneity of their biological and antigenic properties that we observed previously, echovirus type 25 wild-type strains may exhibit differences in their structural proteins.