Analysis of the role of vaccinia virus H7 in virion membrane biogenesis with an H7-deletion mutant

Evolution of the orthopoxvirus core genome

Orthopoxviruses comprise several relevant pathogens, including the causative agent of smallpox and monkeypox virus. Analysis of orthopoxvirus genome evolution mainly focused on gene gains/losses. We instead analyzed core genes, which are conserved in all orthopoxviruses. We show that, despite their strong constraint, some genes involved in viral morphogenesis and transcription/replication were targets of pervasive positive selection, which was relatively uncommon in immunomodulatory genes. However at least three of the positively selected genes, E3L, A24R, and H3L, might have evolved in response to immune selection. Episodic positive selection was particularly common on the internal branches of the orthopox phylogeny and on the monkeypox virus lineage. The latter showed evidence of episodic positive selection at the D14L gene, which encodes a modulator of complement activation (MOPICE). Notably, two genes (B1R and A33R) targeted by episodic selection on more than one branch are involved in forms of intra-genomic conflict. Finally, we found that, in orthopoxvirus proteomes, intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) tend to be less constrained and are common targets of positive selection. Extension of our analysis to all poxviruses showed no evidence that the IDR fraction differs with host range. Conversely, we found a strong effect of base composition, which was however not sufficient to explain IDR fraction. We thus suggest that, in poxviruses, the IDR fraction is maintained by modulating GC content to accommodate disorder-promoting codons. Overall, our data provide novel insight in orthopoxvirus evolution and provide a list of genes and sites that are expected to modulate viral phenotypes.

Structure-Function Analysis of Two Interacting Vaccinia Proteins That Are Critical for Viral Morphogenesis: L2 and A30.5

An enduring mystery in poxvirology is the mechanism by which virion morphogenesis is accomplished. A30.5 and L2 are two small regulatory proteins that are essential for this process. Previous studies have shown that vaccinia A30.5 and L2 localize to the ER and interact during infection, but how they facilitate morphogenesis is unknown. To interrogate the relationship between A30.5 and L2, we generated inducible complementing cell lines (CV1-HA-L2; CV1-3xFLAG-A30.5) and deletion viruses (vΔL2; vΔA30.5). Loss of either protein resulted in a block in morphogenesis and a significant (>100-fold) decrease in infectious viral yield. Structure-function analysis of L2 and A30.5, using transient complementation assays, identified key functional regions in both proteins. A clustered charge-to-alanine L2 mutant (L2-RRD) failed to rescue a vΔL2 infection and exhibits a significantly retarded apparent molecular weight in vivo (but not in vitro), suggestive of an aberrant posttranslational modification. Furthermore, an A30.5 mutant with a disrupted putative N-terminal α-helix failed to rescue a vΔA30.5 infection. Using our complementing cell lines, we determined that the stability of A30.5 is dependent on L2 and that wild-type L2 and A30.5 coimmunoprecipitate in the absence of other viral proteins. Further examination of this interaction, using wild-type and mutant forms of L2 or A30.5, revealed that the inability of mutant alleles to rescue the respective deletion viruses is tightly correlated with a failure of L2 to stabilize and interact with A30.5. L2 appears to function as a chaperone-like protein for A30.5, ensuring that they work together as a complex during viral membrane biogenesis. IMPORTANCE Vaccinia virus is a large, enveloped DNA virus that was successfully used as the vaccine against smallpox. Vaccinia continues to be an invaluable biomedical research tool in basic research and in gene therapy vector and vaccine development. Although this virus has been studied extensively, the complex process of virion assembly, termed morphogenesis, still puzzles the field. Our work aims to better understand how two small viral proteins that are essential for viral assembly, L2 and A30.5, function during early morphogenesis. We show that A30.5 requires L2 for stability and that these proteins interact in the absence of other viral proteins. We identify regions in each protein required for their function and show that mutations in these regions disrupt the interaction between L2 and A30.5 and fail to restore virus viability.

Generation of Vaccinia Virus Gene Deletion Mutants Using Complementing Cell Lines

This protocol describes how to couple two techniques, the generation of complementing cells lines and production of viral deletion mutants, to rapidly construct novel tools for poxvirus analysis. Specifically, the production and utilization of a complementing cell line expressing a poxvirus gene of interest are critical for the generation of poxvirus mutants in which essential genes are disrupted. Complementing cells are also valuable for the characterization of vaccinia genes in the absence of infection. Here, we detail the process of isolating vaccinia virus deletion mutants. Deletion mutant generation involves homologous recombination between replicating viral DNA and transfected DNA followed by selection and screening on a complementing cell line that provides the deleted gene in trans. Finally, deletion is confirmed by polymerase chain reaction, sequencing, and functional assays if available.

Assessing the Structure and Function of Vaccinia Virus Gene Products by Transient Complementation

Poxviruses are large, complex dsDNA viruses that are highly unusual in replicating solely within the cytoplasm of the infected cell. The most infamous poxvirus was variola virus, the etiological agent of smallpox; today, poxviruses remain of biomedical significance, both as pathogens and as recombinant vaccines and oncolytic therapies. Vaccinia virus is the prototypic poxvirus for experimental analysis. The 195 kb dsDNA genome contains >200 genes that encode proteins involved in such processes as viral entry, gene expression, genome replication and maturation, virion assembly, virion egress, and immune evasion.Molecular genetic analysis has been instrumental in the study of the structure and function of many viral gene products. Temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants have been especially useful in this endeavor; inducible recombinants and deletion mutants are now also important tools. Once a phenotype is observed following the repression, deletion, or inactivation of a particular gene product, the technique of transient complementation becomes central for further study.Simply put, transient complementation involves the transient expression of a variety of alleles of a given viral gene within infected cells, and the evaluation of which of these alleles can "complement" or "rescue" the phenotype caused by the loss of the endogenous allele. This analysis leads to the identification of key domains, motifs, and sites of posttranslational modification. Subcellular localization and protein:protein interactions can also be evaluated in these studies. The development of a reliable toolbox of vectors encoding viral promoters of different temporal classes, and the use of a variety of epitope tags, has greatly enhanced the utility of this experimental approach for poxvirus research.

Enigmatic origin of the poxvirus membrane from the endoplasmic reticulum shown by 3D imaging of vaccinia virus assembly mutants

The long-standing inability to visualize connections between poxvirus membranes and cellular organelles has led to uncertainty regarding the origin of the viral membrane. Indeed, there has been speculation that viral membranes form de novo in cytoplasmic factories. Another possibility, that the connections are too short-lived to be captured by microscopy during a normal infection, motivated us to identify and characterize virus mutants that are arrested in assembly. Five conserved vaccinia virus proteins, referred to as Viral Membrane Assembly Proteins (VMAPs), that are necessary for formation of immature virions were found. Transmission electron microscopy studies of two VMAP deletion mutants had suggested retention of connections between viral membranes and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). We now analyzed cells infected with each of the five VMAP deletion mutants by electron tomography, which is necessary to validate membrane continuity, in addition to conventional transmission electron microscopy. In all cases, connections between the ER and viral membranes were demonstrated by 3D reconstructions, supporting a role for the VMAPs in creating and/or stabilizing membrane scissions. Furthermore, coexpression of the viral reticulon-like transmembrane protein A17 and the capsid-like scaffold protein D13 was sufficient to form similar ER-associated viral structures in the absence of other major virion proteins. Determination of the mechanism of ER disruption during a normal VACV infection and the likely participation of both viral and cell proteins in this process may provide important insights into membrane dynamics.

Deletion of the Vaccinia Virus I2 Protein Interrupts Virion Morphogenesis, Leading to Retention of the Scaffold Protein and Mislocalization of Membrane-Associated Entry Proteins

The I2L open reading frame of vaccinia virus (VACV) encodes a conserved 72-amino-acid protein with a putative C-terminal transmembrane domain. Previous studies with a tetracycline-inducible mutant demonstrated that I2-deficient virions are defective in cell entry. The purpose of the present study was to determine the step of replication or entry that is affected by loss of the I2 protein. Fluorescence microscopy experiments showed that I2 colocalized with a major membrane protein of immature and mature virions. We generated a cell line that constitutively expressed I2 and allowed construction of the VACV I2L deletion mutant vΔI2. As anticipated, vΔI2 was unable to replicate in cells that did not express I2. Unexpectedly, morphogenesis was interrupted at a stage after immature virion formation, resulting in the accumulation of dense spherical particles instead of brick-shaped mature virions with well-defined core structures. The abnormal particles retained the D13 scaffold protein of immature virions, were severely deficient in the transmembrane proteins that comprise the entry fusion complex (EFC), and had increased amounts of unprocessed membrane and core proteins. Total lysates of cells infected with vΔI2 also had diminished EFC proteins due to instability attributed to their hydrophobicity and failure to be inserted into viral membranes. A similar instability of EFC proteins had previously been found with unrelated mutants blocked earlier in morphogenesis that also accumulated viral membranes retaining the D13 scaffold. We concluded that I2 is required for virion morphogenesis, release of the D13 scaffold, and the association of EFC proteins with viral membranes.IMPORTANCE Poxviruses comprise a large family that infect vertebrates and invertebrates, cause disease in both in humans and in wild and domesticated animals, and are being engineered as vectors for vaccines and cancer therapy. In addition, investigations of poxviruses have provided insights into many aspects of cell biology. The I2 protein is conserved in all poxviruses that infect vertebrates, suggesting an important role. The present study revealed that this protein is essential for vaccinia virus morphogenesis and that its absence results in an accumulation of deformed virus particles retaining the scaffold protein and deficient in surface proteins needed for cell entry.

Vaccinia Virus A6 Is a Two-Domain Protein Requiring a Cognate N-Terminal Domain for Full Viral Membrane Assembly Activity

Poxvirus virion biogenesis is a complex, multistep process, starting with the formation of crescent-shaped viral membranes, followed by their enclosure of the viral core to form spherical immature virions. Crescent formation requires a group of proteins that are highly conserved among poxviruses, including A6 and A11 of vaccinia virus (VACV). To gain a better understanding of the molecular function of A6, we established a HeLa cell line that inducibly expressed VACV-A6, which allowed us to construct VACV mutants with an A6 deletion or mutation. As expected, the A6 deletion mutant of VACV failed to replicate in noncomplementing cell lines with defects in crescent formation and A11 localization. Surprisingly, a VACV mutant that had A6 replaced with a close ortholog from the Yaba-like disease virus YLDV-97 also failed to replicate. This mutant, however, developed crescents and had normal A11 localization despite failing to form immature virions. Limited proteolysis of the recombinant A6 protein identified an N domain and a C domain of approximately 121 and 251 residues, respectively. Various chimeras of VACV-A6 and YLDV-97 were constructed, but only one that precisely combined the N domain of VACV-A6 and the C domain of YLDV-97 supported VACV replication albeit at a reduced efficiency. Our results show that VACV-A6 has a two-domain architecture and functions in both crescent formation and its enclosure to form immature virions. While a cognate N domain is not required for crescent formation, it is required for virion formation, suggesting that interactions of the N domain with cognate viral proteins may be critical for virion assembly.IMPORTANCE Poxviruses are unique among enveloped viruses in that they acquire their primary envelope not through budding from cellular membranes but by forming and extending crescent membranes. The crescents are highly unusual, open-ended membranes, and their origin and biogenesis have perplexed virologists for decades. A group of five viral proteins were recently identified as being essential for crescent formation, including the A6 protein of vaccinia virus. It is thus important to understand the structure and function of A6 in order to solve the long-standing mystery of poxvirus membrane biogenesis. Here, we established an experimental system that allowed the genetic manipulation of the essential A6L gene. By studying A6 mutant viruses, we found that A6 plays an essential role not only in the formation of crescents but also in their subsequent enclosure to form immature virions. We defined the domain architecture of A6 and suggested that one of its two domains cooperates with cognate viral proteins.

Poxvirus membrane biogenesis

Poxviruses differ from most DNA viruses by replicating entirely within the cytoplasm. The first discernible viral structures are crescents and spherical immature virions containing a single lipoprotein membrane bilayer with an external honeycomb lattice. Because this viral membrane displays no obvious continuity with a cellular organelle, a de novo origin was suggested. Nevertheless, transient connections between viral and cellular membranes could be difficult to resolve. Despite the absence of direct evidence, the intermediate compartment (ERGIC) between the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi apparatus and the ER itself were considered possible sources of crescent membranes. A break-through in understanding poxvirus membrane biogenesis has come from recent studies of the abortive replication of several vaccinia virus null mutants. Novel images showing continuity between viral crescents and the ER and the accumulation of immature virions in the expanded ER lumen provide the first direct evidence for a cellular origin of this poxvirus membrane.

Structure-function analysis of vaccinia virus H7 protein reveals a novel phosphoinositide binding fold essential for poxvirus replication

Phosphoinositides and phosphoinositide binding proteins play a critical role in membrane and protein trafficking in eukaryotes. Their critical role in replication of cytoplasmic viruses has just begun to be understood. Poxviruses, a family of large cytoplasmic DNA viruses, rely on the intracellular membranes to develop their envelope, and poxvirus morphogenesis requires enzymes from the cellular phosphoinositide metabolic pathway. However, the role of phosphoinositides in poxvirus replication remains unclear, and no poxvirus proteins show any homology to eukaryotic phosphoinositide binding domains. Recently, a group of poxvirus proteins, termed viral membrane assembly proteins (VMAPs), were identified as essential for poxvirus membrane biogenesis. A key component of VMAPs is the H7 protein. Here we report the crystal structure of the H7 protein from vaccinia virus. The H7 structure displays a novel fold comprised of seven α-helices and a highly curved three-stranded antiparallel β-sheet. We identified a phosphoinositide binding site in H7, comprised of basic residues on a surface patch and the flexible C-terminal tail. These residues were found to be essential for viral replication and for binding of H7 to phosphatidylinositol-3-phosphate (PI3P) and phosphatidylinositol-4-phosphate (PI4P). Our studies suggest that phosphoinositide binding by H7 plays an essential role in poxvirus membrane biogenesis.

IMPORTANCE

Poxvirus viral membrane assembly proteins (VMAPs) were recently shown to be essential for poxvirus membrane biogenesis. One of the key components of VMAPs is the H7 protein. However, no known structural motifs could be identified from its sequence, and there are no homologs of H7 outside the poxvirus family to suggest a biochemical function. We have determined the crystal structure of the vaccinia virus (VACV) H7 protein. The structure displays a novel fold with a distinct and positively charged surface. Our data demonstrate that H7 binds phosphatidylinositol-3-phosphate and phosphatidylinositol-4-phosphate and that the basic surface patch is indeed required for phosphoinositide binding. In addition, mutation of positively charged residues required for lipid binding disrupted VACV replication. Phosphoinositides and phosphoinositide binding proteins play critical roles in membrane and protein trafficking in eukaryotes. Our study demonstrates that VACV H7 displays a novel fold for phosphoinositide binding, which is essential for poxvirus replication.

From crescent to mature virion: vaccinia virus assembly and maturation

Vaccinia virus (VACV) has achieved unprecedented success as a live viral vaccine for smallpox which mitigated eradication of the disease. Vaccinia virus has a complex virion morphology and recent advances have been made to answer some of the key outstanding questions, in particular, the origin and biogenesis of the virion membrane, the transformation from immature virion (IV) to mature virus (MV), and the role of several novel genes, which were previously uncharacterized, but have now been shown to be essential for VACV virion formation. This new knowledge will undoubtedly contribute to the rational design of safe, immunogenic vaccine candidates, or effective antivirals in the future. This review endeavors to provide an update on our current knowledge of the VACV maturation processes with a specific focus on the initiation of VACV replication through to the formation of mature virions.

Direct formation of vaccinia virus membranes from the endoplasmic reticulum in the absence of the newly characterized L2-interacting protein A30.5

Crescents consisting of a single lipoprotein membrane with an external protein scaffold comprise the initial structural elements of poxvirus morphogenesis. Crescents enlarge to form spherical immature virions, which enclose viroplasm consisting of proteins destined to form the cores of mature virions. Previous studies suggest that the L2 protein participates in the recruitment of endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-derived membranes to form immature virions within assembly sites of cytoplasmic factories. Here we show that L2 interacts with the previously uncharacterized 42-amino-acid A30.5 protein. An open reading frame similar in size to the one encoding A30.5 is at the same genome location in representatives of all chordopoxvirus genera. A30.5 has a putative transmembrane domain and colocalized with markers of the endoplasmic reticulum and with L2. By constructing a complementing cell line expressing A30.5, we isolated a deletion mutant virus that exhibits a defect in morphogenesis in normal cells. Large electron-dense cytoplasmic inclusions and clusters of scaffold protein-coated membranes that resemble crescents and immature virions devoid of viroplasm were seen in place of normal structures. Crescent-shaped membranes were continuous with the endoplasmic reticulum membrane and oriented with the convex scaffold protein-coated side facing the lumen, while clusters of completed spherical immature-virion-like forms were trapped within the expanded lumen. Immature-virion-like structures were more abundant in infected RK-13 cells than in BS-C-1 or HeLa cells, in which cytoplasmic inclusions were decorated with scaffold protein-coated membrane arcs. We suggest that the outer surface of the poxvirus virion is derived from the luminal side of the ER membrane.