Human Host Range Restriction of the Vaccinia Virus C7/K1 Double Deletion Mutant Is Mediated by an Atypical Mode of Translation Inhibition

Human SAMD9 is a poxvirus-activatable anticodon nuclease inhibiting codon-specific protein synthesis

As a defense strategy against viruses or competitors, some microbes use anticodon nucleases (ACNases) to deplete essential tRNAs, effectively halting global protein synthesis. However, this mechanism has not been observed in multicellular eukaryotes. Here, we report that human SAMD9 is an ACNase that specifically cleaves phenylalanine tRNA (tRNAPhe), resulting in codon-specific ribosomal pausing and stress signaling. While SAMD9 ACNase activity is normally latent in cells, it can be activated by poxvirus infection or rendered constitutively active by SAMD9 mutations associated with various human disorders, revealing tRNAPhe depletion as an antiviral mechanism and a pathogenic condition in SAMD9 disorders. We identified the N-terminal effector domain of SAMD9 as the ACNase, with substrate specificity primarily determined by a eukaryotic tRNAPhe-specific 2'-O-methylation at the wobble position, making virtually all eukaryotic tRNAPhe susceptible to SAMD9 cleavage. Notably, the structure and substrate specificity of SAMD9 ACNase differ from known microbial ACNases, suggesting convergent evolution of a common immune defense strategy targeting tRNAs.

Viral host range factors antagonize pathogenic SAMD9 and SAMD9L variants

SAMD9 and SAMD9L encode homologous interferon-induced genes that can inhibit cellular translation as well as proliferation and can restrict viral replication. Gain-of-function (GoF) variants in these ancient, yet rapidly evolving genes are associated with life-threatening disease in humans. Potentially driving population sequence diversity, several viruses have evolved host range factors that antagonize cell-intrinsic SAMD9/SAMD9L function. Here, to gain insights into the molecular regulation of SAMD9/SAMD9L activity and to explore the prospect of directly counteracting the activity of pathogenic variants, we examined whether dysregulated activity of pathogenic SAMD9/SAMD9L variants can be modulated by the poxviral host range factors M062, C7 and K1 in a co-expression system. We established that the virally encoded proteins retain interactions with select SAMD9/SAMD9L missense GoF variants. Furthermore, expression of M062, C7 and K1 could principally ameliorate the translation-inhibiting and growth-restrictive effect instigated by ectopically expressed SAMD9/SAMD9L GoF variants, yet with differences in potency. K1 displayed the greatest potency and almost completely restored cellular proliferation and translation in cells co-expressing SAMD9/SAMD9L GoF variants. However, neither of the viral proteins tested could antagonize a truncated SAMD9L variant associated with severe autoinflammation. Our study demonstrates that pathogenic SAMD9/SAMD9L missense variants can principally be targeted through molecular interactions, opening an opportunity for therapeutic modulation of their activity. Moreover, it provides novel insights into the complex intramolecular regulation of SAMD9/SAMD9L activity.

Identification of a Trm732 Motif Required for 2'-O-methylation of the tRNA Anticodon Loop by Trm7

Posttranscriptional tRNA modifications are essential for proper gene expression, and defects in the enzymes that perform tRNA modifications are associated with numerous human disorders. Throughout eukaryotes, 2'-O-methylation of residues 32 and 34 of the anticodon loop of tRNA is important for proper translation, and in humans, a lack of these modifications results in non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability. In yeast, the methyltransferase Trm7 forms a complex with Trm732 to 2'-O-methylate tRNA residue 32 and with Trm734 to 2'-O-methylate tRNA residue 34. Trm732 and Trm734 are required for the methylation activity of Trm7, but the role of these auxiliary proteins is not clear. Additionally, Trm732 and Trm734 homologs are implicated in biological processes not directly related to translation, suggesting that these proteins may have additional cellular functions. To identify critical amino acids in Trm732, we generated variants and tested their ability to function in yeast cells. We identified a conserved RRSAGLP motif in the conserved DUF2428 domain of Trm732 that is required for tRNA modification activity by both yeast Trm732 and its human homolog, THADA. The identification of Trm732 variants that lack tRNA modification activity will help to determine if other biological functions ascribed to Trm732 and THADA are directly due to tRNA modification or to secondary effects due to other functions of these proteins.

Structure and function of an effector domain in antiviral factors and tumor suppressors SAMD9 and SAMD9L

SAMD9 and SAMD9L (SAMD9/9L) are antiviral factors and tumor suppressors, playing a critical role in innate immune defense against poxviruses and the development of myeloid tumors. SAMD9/9L mutations with a gain-of-function (GoF) in inhibiting cell growth cause multisystem developmental disorders including many pediatric myelodysplastic syndromes. Predicted to be multidomain proteins with an architecture like that of the NOD-like receptors, SAMD9/9L molecular functions and domain structures are largely unknown. Here, we identified a SAMD9/9L effector domain that functions by binding to double-stranded nucleic acids (dsNA) and determined the crystal structure of the domain in complex with DNA. Aided with precise mutations that differentially perturb dsNA binding, we demonstrated that the antiviral and antiproliferative functions of the wild-type and GoF SAMD9/9L variants rely on dsNA binding by the effector domain. Furthermore, we showed that GoF variants inhibit global protein synthesis, reduce translation elongation, and induce proteotoxic stress response, which all require dsNA binding by the effector domain. The identification of the structure and function of a SAMD9/9L effector domain provides a therapeutic target for SAMD9/9L-associated human diseases.

SAMD9L autoinflammatory or ataxia pancytopenia disease mutations activate cell-autonomous translational repression

The experiments here advance understanding of the function of the SAMD9L gene and protein in innate immune mechanisms in resisting virus infection and in the pathogenesis of inflammatory, hematological, and neurological disorders. The clinical syndrome defined in two children with de novo truncating SAMD9L mutations expands the phenotypes in this newly recognized autoinflammatory disorder. Analysis of cells expressing normal or mutant SAMD9L reveals the protein represses protein translation, with the truncating mutations greatly exaggerating this activity. The experiments find equally potent gain of function caused by the truncating mutations or a recurrent missense mutation associated with clinically milder ataxia and pancytopenia syndromes, demonstrating that diverse clinical manifestations can arise from mutations that appear cell-biologically equivalent.

Sterile α motif domain-containing protein 9-like (SAMD9L) is encoded by a hallmark interferon-induced gene with a role in controlling virus replication that is not well understood. Here, we analyze SAMD9L function from the perspective of human mutations causing neonatal-onset severe autoinflammatory disease. Whole-genome sequencing of two children with leukocytoclastic panniculitis, basal ganglia calcifications, raised blood inflammatory markers, neutrophilia, anemia, thrombocytopaenia, and almost no B cells revealed heterozygous de novo SAMD9L mutations, p.Asn885Thrfs*6 and p.Lys878Serfs*13. These frameshift mutations truncate the SAMD9L protein within a domain a region of homology to the nucleotide-binding and oligomerization domain (NOD) of APAF1, ∼80 amino acids C-terminal to the Walker B motif. Single-cell analysis of human cells expressing green fluorescent protein (GFP)-SAMD9L fusion proteins revealed that enforced expression of wild-type SAMD9L repressed translation of red fluorescent protein messenger RNA and globally repressed endogenous protein translation, cell autonomously and in proportion to the level of GFP-SAMD9L in each cell. The children’s truncating mutations dramatically exaggerated translational repression even at low levels of GFP-SAMD9L per cell, as did a missense Arg986Cys mutation reported recurrently as causing ataxia pancytopenia syndrome. Autoinflammatory disease associated with SAMD9L truncating mutations appears to result from an interferon-induced translational repressor whose activity goes unchecked by the loss of C-terminal domains that may normally sense virus infection.

Spontaneous and targeted mutations in the decapping enzyme enhance replication of modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) in monkey cells

Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) was derived by repeated passaging in chick fibroblasts, during which deletions and mutations rendered the virus unable to replicate in most mammalian cells. Marker rescue experiments demonstrated that the host range defect could be overcome by replacing DNA that had been deleted from near the left end of the genome. One virus isolate, however, recovered the ability to replicate in monkey BS-C-1 cells but not human cells without added DNA suggesting it arose from a spontaneous mutation. Here we showed that variants with enhanced ability to replicate in BS-C-1 cells could be isolated by blind passaging MVA and that in each there was a point mutation leading to an amino acid substitution in the D10 decapping enzyme. The sufficiency of these single mutations to enhance host range was confirmed by constructing recombinant viruses. The D10 mutations occurred at N- or C-terminal locations distal from the active site, suggesting an indirect effect on decapping or on another previously unknown role of D10. Although increased amounts of viral mRNA and proteins were found in BS-C-1 cells infected with the mutants compared to parental MVA, the increase was much less than the one to two logs higher virus yields. Nevertheless, a contributing role for diminished decapping in overcoming the host range defect was consistent with increased replication and viral protein synthesis in BS-C-1 cells infected with an MVA engineered to have active site mutations that abrogate decapping activity entirely. Optimal decapping may vary depending on the biological context. IMPORTANCE Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is an attenuated virus that is approved as a smallpox vaccine and is in clinical trials as a vector for other pathogens. The safety of MVA is due in large part to its inability to replicate in mammalian cells. Although, host-range restriction is considered a stable feature of the virus, we describe the occurrence of spontaneous mutations in MVA that increase replication considerably in monkey BS-C-1 cells but only slightly in human cells. The mutants contain single nucleotide changes that lead to amino acid substitutions in one of the two decapping enzymes. Although the spontaneous mutations are distant from the decapping enzyme active site, engineered active site-mutations also increased virus replication in BS-C-1 cells. The effects of these mutations on the immunogenicity of MVA vectors remain to be determined.

Germline SAMD9L truncation variants trigger global translational repression

SAMD9L is an interferon-induced tumor suppressor implicated in a spectrum of multisystem disorders, including risk for myeloid malignancies and immune deficiency. We identified a heterozygous de novo frameshift variant in SAMD9L in an infant with B cell aplasia and clinical autoinflammatory features who died from respiratory failure with chronic rhinovirus infection. Autopsy demonstrated absent bone marrow and peripheral B cells as well as selective loss of Langerhans and Purkinje cells. The frameshift variant led to expression of a truncated protein with interferon treatment. This protein exhibited a gain-of-function phenotype, resulting in interference in global protein synthesis via inhibition of translational elongation. Using a mutational scan, we identified a region within SAMD9L where stop-gain variants trigger a similar translational arrest. SAMD9L variants that globally suppress translation had no effect or increased mRNA transcription. The complex-reported phenotype likely reflects lineage-dominant sensitivities to this translation block. Taken together, our findings indicate that interferon-triggered SAMD9L gain-of-function variants globally suppress translation.

Pediatric MDS and bone marrow failure-associated germline mutations in SAMD9 and SAMD9L impair multiple pathways in primary hematopoietic cells

Pediatric myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are a heterogeneous disease group associated with impaired hematopoiesis, bone marrow hypocellularity, and frequently have deletions involving chromosome 7 (monosomy 7). We and others recently identified heterozygous germline mutations in SAMD9 and SAMD9L in children with monosomy 7 and MDS. We previously demonstrated an antiproliferative effect of these gene products in non-hematopoietic cells, which was exacerbated by their patient-associated mutations. Here, we used a lentiviral overexpression approach to assess the functional impact and underlying cellular processes of wild-type and mutant SAMD9 or SAMD9L in primary mouse or human hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC). Using a combination of protein interactome analyses, transcriptional profiling, and functional validation, we show that SAMD9 and SAMD9L are multifunctional proteins that cause profound alterations in cell cycle, cell proliferation, and protein translation in HSPCs. Importantly, our molecular and functional studies also demonstrated that expression of these genes and their mutations leads to a cellular environment that promotes DNA damage repair defects and ultimately apoptosis in hematopoietic cells. This study provides novel functional insights into SAMD9 and SAMD9L and how their mutations can potentially alter hematopoietic function and lead to bone marrow hypocellularity, a hallmark of pediatric MDS.

COVID-19, varying genetic resistance to viral disease and immune tolerance checkpoints

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID‐19) is a zoonosis like most of the great plagues sculpting human history, from smallpox to pandemic influenza and human immunodeficiency virus. When viruses jump into a new species the outcome of infection ranges from asymptomatic to lethal, historically ascribed to “genetic resistance to viral disease.” People have exploited these differences for good and bad, for developing vaccines from cowpox and horsepox virus, controlling rabbit plagues with myxoma virus and introducing smallpox during colonization of America and Australia. Differences in resistance to viral disease are at the core of the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS‐CoV‐2) crisis, yet our understanding of the mechanisms in any interspecies leap falls short of the mark. Here I review how the two key parameters of viral disease are countered by fundamentally different genetic mechanisms for resistance: (1) virus transmission, countered primarily by activation of innate and adaptive immune responses; and (2) pathology, countered primarily by tolerance checkpoints to limit innate and adaptive immune responses. I discuss tolerance thresholds and the role of CD8 T cells to limit pathological immune responses, the problems posed by tolerant superspreaders and the signature coronavirus evasion strategy of eliciting only short‐lived neutralizing antibody responses. Pinpointing and targeting the mechanisms responsible for varying pathology and short‐lived antibody were beyond reach in previous zoonoses, but this time we are armed with genomic technologies and more knowledge of immune checkpoint genes. These known unknowns must now be tackled to solve the current COVID‐19 crisis and the inevitable zoonoses to follow.

Rescue of a Vaccinia Virus Mutant Lacking IFN Resistance Genes K1L and C7L by the Parapoxvirus Orf Virus

Type 1 interferons induce the upregulation of hundreds of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs) that combat viral replication. The parapoxvirus orf virus (ORFV) induces acute pustular skin lesions in sheep and goats and can reinfect its host, however, little is known of its ability to resist IFN. Vaccinia virus (VACV) encodes a number of factors that modulate the IFN response including the host-range genes C7L and K1L. A recombinant VACV-Western Reserve (WR) strain in which the K1L and C7L genes have been deleted does not replicate in cells treated with IFN-β nor in HeLa cells in which the IFN response is constitutive and is inhibited at the level of intermediate gene expression. Furthermore C7L is conserved in almost all poxviruses. We provide evidence that shows that although ORFV is more sensitive to IFN-β compared with VACV, and lacks homologues of KIL and C7L, it nevertheless has the ability to rescue a VACV KIL- C7L- gfp+ mutant in which gfp is expressed from a late promoter. Co-infection of HeLa cells with the mutant and ORFV demonstrated that ORFV was able to overcome the block in translation of intermediate transcripts in the mutant virus, allowing it to progress to late gene expression and new viral particles. Our findings strongly suggest that ORFV encodes a factor(s) that, although different in structure to C7L or KIL, targets an anti-viral cellular mechanism that is a highly potent at killing poxviruses.

Investigating Viruses During the Transformation of Molecular Biology: Part II

My scientific career started at an extraordinary time, shortly after the discoveries of the helical structure of DNA, the central dogma of DNA to RNA to protein, and the genetic code. Part I of this series emphasizes my education and early studies highlighted by the isolation and characterization of numerous vaccinia virus enzymes, determination of the cap structure of messenger RNA, and development of poxviruses as gene expression vectors for use as recombinant vaccines. Here I describe a shift in my research focus to combine molecular biology and genetics for a comprehensive understanding of poxvirus biology. The dominant paradigm during the early years was to select a function, isolate the responsible proteins, and locate the corresponding gene, whereas later the common paradigm was to select a gene, make a mutation, and determine the altered function. Motivations, behind-the-scenes insights, importance of new technologies, and the vital roles of trainees and coworkers are emphasized.

Non-replicating Vaccinia Virus TianTan Strain (NTV) Translation Arrest of Viral Late Protein Synthesis Associated With Anti-viral Host Factor SAMD9

NTV is a highly attenuated virus that was created by genetically deleting 26 genes related to host range and virulence from TianTan strain. Since NTV is highly attenuated, it has been used widely as an optimizing viral vector. In this study, we explored the biological characteristics in vitro and the host restriction mechanism of NTV. Most cell lines do not support sufficient dissemination and replication of NTV, and in non-permissive cell line HeLa, the replication block of NTV occurred at the translation stage of viral late protein expression. Lack of PKR activity was not sufficient to rescue expression of viral late proteins and replication, even though the phosphorylation level of eIF2α increased in NTV-infected HeLa cells. Moreover, the translation inhibition of NTV in HeLa cells was dependent upon a SAMD9 signaling pathway, as demonstrated by silencing SAMD9 expression with siRNA and observing the colocalization of SAMD9 and AVGs. Reinserting C7L or K1L into NTV rescued the late viral protein expression and replication of NTV in HeLa cells. Among the genes deleted in NTV, C7L or/and K1L gene was mainly responsible for its replication defect. Protein C7 interacted with SAMD9, which antagonized the antiviral response of SAMD9 to ensure viral protein translation and replication of NTV in non-permissive cell lines. Our finding will serve as a baseline for modification of NTV in future application.

tRNA 2'-O-methylation by a duo of TRM7/FTSJ1 proteins modulates small RNA silencing in Drosophila

2′-O-Methylation (Nm) represents one of the most common RNA modifications. Nm affects RNA structure and function with crucial roles in various RNA-mediated processes ranging from RNA silencing, translation, self versus non-self recognition to viral defense mechanisms. Here, we identify two Nm methyltransferases (Nm-MTases) in Drosophila melanogaster (CG7009 and CG5220) as functional orthologs of yeast TRM7 and human FTSJ1. Genetic knockout studies together with MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry and RiboMethSeq mapping revealed that CG7009 is responsible for methylating the wobble position in tRNA^Phe, tRNA^Trp and tRNA^Leu, while CG5220 methylates position C32 in the same tRNAs and also targets additional tRNAs. CG7009 or CG5220 mutant animals were viable and fertile but exhibited various phenotypes such as lifespan reduction, small RNA pathways dysfunction and increased sensitivity to RNA virus infections. Our results provide the first detailed characterization of two TRM7 family members in Drosophila and uncover a molecular link between enzymes catalyzing Nm at specific tRNAs and small RNA-induced gene silencing pathways.

Strategies for Success. Viral Infections and Membraneless Organelles

Regulation of RNA homeostasis or “RNAstasis” is a central step in eukaryotic gene expression. From transcription to decay, cellular messenger RNAs (mRNAs) associate with specific proteins in order to regulate their entire cycle, including mRNA localization, translation and degradation, among others. The best characterized of such RNA-protein complexes, today named membraneless organelles, are Stress Granules (SGs) and Processing Bodies (PBs) which are involved in RNA storage and RNA decay/storage, respectively. Given that SGs and PBs are generally associated with repression of gene expression, viruses have evolved different mechanisms to counteract their assembly or to use them in their favor to successfully replicate within the host environment. In this review we summarize the current knowledge about the viral regulation of SGs and PBs, which could be a potential novel target for the development of broad-spectrum antiviral therapies.

Viral Regulation of RNA Granules in Infected Cells

RNA granules are cytoplasmic, microscopically visible, non-membrane ribo-nucleoprotein structures and are important posttranscriptional regulators in gene expression by controlling RNA translation and stability. TIA/G3BP/PABP-specific stress granules (SG) and GW182/DCP-specific RNA processing bodies (PB) are two major distinguishable RNA granules in somatic cells and contain various ribosomal subunits, translation factors, scaffold proteins, RNA-binding proteins, RNA decay enzymes and helicases to exclude mRNAs from the cellular active translational pool. Although SG formation is inducible due to cellular stress, PB exist physiologically in every cell. Both RNA granules are important components of the host antiviral defense. Virus infection imposes stress on host cells and thus induces SG formation. However, both RNA and DNA viruses must confront the hostile environment of host innate immunity and apply various strategies to block the formation of SG and PB for their effective infection and multiplication. This review summarizes the current research development in the field and the mechanisms of how individual viruses suppress the formation of host SG and PB for virus production.

RNA granules associated with SAMD9-mediated poxvirus restriction are similar to antiviral granules in composition but do not require TIA1 for poxvirus restriction

Stress granule (SG)-like antiviral granules (AVG) had been found in some vaccinia virus infection conditions and shown to repress translation. Similar RNA granules are also associated with translational inhibition and poxvirus restriction mediated by the host restriction factor SAMD9, but their function is less clear. We studied the composition of these RNA granules by immunofluorescence and found them enriched with SG component TIA1 and viral dsRNA binding protein E3. However, TIA1 was not required for granule formation or SAMD9-mediated poxvirus restriction, in contrast to its critical role in SG formation and AVG function. The granule formation was abolished by blocking viral DNA replication or intermediate viral gene transcription, suggesting that post-replicative viral mRNA was important for granule formation. Our data show that TIA1 is not universally antiviral against poxviruses and support a model that the RNA granules are formed as the result of untranslated mRNA accumulation in viral DNA factories.