Structural plasticity and rapid evolution in a viral RNA revealed by in vivo genetic selection

Trade-off between local replication and long-distance dissemination during experimental evolution of a satellite RNA

Satellite RNAs (satRNAs) are molecular parasites that depend on their non-homologous helper viruses (HVs) for essential biological functions. While there are multiple molecular and phylogenetic studies on satRNAs, there is no experimental evolution study on how satRNAs may evolve in common infection conditions. In this study, we serially passaged the Bamboo mosaic virus (BaMV) associated-satRNA (satBaMV) under conditions in which satBaMV either coinfects an uninfected host plant, Nicotiana benthamiana, with BaMV or superinfects a transgenic N. benthamiana expressing the full-length BaMV genome. Single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of satBaMV populations were analyzed by deep sequencing. Forty-eight SNPs were identified across four different experimental treatments. Most SNPs are treatment-specific, and some are also ephemeral. However, mutations at positions 30, 34, 63, and 82, all located at the 5' untranslated region (UTR), are universal in all treatments. These universal SNPs are configured into several haplotypes and follow different population dynamics. We constructed isogenic satBaMV strains only differing at positions 30 and 82 and conducted competition experiments in protoplasts and host plants. We found that the haplotype that reached high frequency in protoplasts and inoculation leaves also exhibited poor dissemination to systemic leaves and vice versa, thus suggesting an apparent trade-off between local replication and long-distance dissemination. We posit that the trade-off is likely caused by antagonistic pleiotropy at the 5' UTR. Our findings revealed a hitherto under-explored connection between satRNA genome replication and movement within a host plant. The significance of such a connection during satRNA evolution warrants a more thorough investigation.

Virology in the Classroom: Current Approaches and Challenges to Undergraduate- and Graduate-Level Virology Education

The pervasive effects of the current coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic are but one reason for educators to refocus their efforts on virology teaching. Additionally, it is critical to understand how viruses function and to elucidate the relationship between virus and host. An understanding of current virology education may improve pedagogical approaches for educating our students and trainees. Faculty who teach undergraduate microbiology indicate that approximately 10% of the course content features viruses; stand-alone virology courses are infrequently offered to undergraduates. Fortunately, virology taught to undergraduates includes foundational material; several approaches for delivery of lecture- and lab-based content exist. At the graduate education level, there is growing appreciation that an emphasis on logic, reasoning, inference, and statistics must be reintroduced into the curriculum to create a generation of scientists who have a greater capacity for creativity and innovation. Educators also need to remove barriers to student success, at all levels of education. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Virology, Volume 8 is September 2021. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Molecular interactions of plant viral satellites

Plant viral satellites fall under the category of subviral agents. Their genomes are composed of small RNA or DNA molecules a few hundred nucleotides in length and contain an assortment of highly complex and overlapping functions. Each lacks the ability to either replicate or undergo encapsidation or both in the absence of a helper virus (HV). As the number of known satellites increases steadily, our knowledge regarding their sequence conservation strategies, means of replication and specific interactions with host and helper viruses is improving. This review demonstrates that the molecular interactions of these satellites are unique and highly complex, largely influenced by the highly specific host plants and helper viruses that they associate with. Circularized forms of single-stranded RNA are of particular interest, as they have recently been found to play a variety of novel cellular functions. Linear forms of satRNA are also of great significance as they may complement the helper virus genome in exacerbating symptoms, or in certain instances, actively compete against it, thus reducing symptom severity. This review serves to describe the current literature with respect to these molecular mechanisms in detail as well as to discuss recent insights into this emerging field in terms of evolution, classification and symptom development. The review concludes with a discussion of future steps in plant viral satellite research and development.

RNA aptamers selected against yeast cells inhibit Candida albicans biofilm formation in vitro

Aptamers that bind live bacterial cells have been widely investigated, but their potential to inhibit Candida albicans biofilm formation needs to be further explored. The aims of this study were to evaluate the binding of C. albicans to RNA aptamers and to examine the potential of aptamers to inhibit C. albicans biofilm formation in vitro. In this study, RNA aptamers selected against yeast cells of C. albicans ATCC 10231 were developed using the systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) technique. The binding affinity of the resulting aptamers was then determined by an aptamer‐linked immobilized sorbent assay (ALISA), and a colorimetric (MTT) assay was used to measure the metabolic activity of Candida biofilms. After 11 rounds of SELEX, two candidate aptamers, Ca‐apt‐1 and Ca‐apt‐12, were identified. The Ca‐apt‐1 aptamer also recognized C. albicans isolated from clinical specimens but did not recognize other oral microorganisms (i.e., Streptococcus mutans and Saccharomyces cerevisiae). The ALISA results showed that the binding affinity of these aptamers was comparable to that of an anti‐C. albicans monoclonal antibody. In addition, Ca‐apt‐1 could inhibit biofilm and hyphal formation of C. albicans in vitro, as demonstrated using biofilm assays. This study shows that RNA aptamers could potentially be used in diagnostic and therapeutic applications for C. albicans‐related disease in the future.

SELEX and SHAPE reveal that sequence motifs and an extended hairpin in the 5' portion of Turnip crinkle virus satellite RNA C mediate fitness in plants

Noncoding RNAs use their sequence and/or structure to mediate function(s). The 5' portion (166 nt) of the 356-nt noncoding satellite RNA C (satC) of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) was previously modeled to contain a central region with two stem-loops (H6 and H7) and a large connecting hairpin (H2). We now report that in vivo functional selection (SELEX) experiments assessing sequence/structure requirements in H2, H6, and H7 reveal that H6 loop sequence motifs were recovered at nonrandom rates and only some residues are proposed to base-pair with accessible complementary sequences within the 5' central region. In vitro SHAPE of SELEX winners indicates that the central region is heavily base-paired, such that along with the lower stem and H2 region, one extensive hairpin exists composing the entire 5' region. As these SELEX winners are highly fit, these characteristics facilitate satRNA amplification in association with TCV in plants.

Requirement for Host RNA-Silencing Components and the Virus-Silencing Suppressor when Second-Site Mutations Compensate for Structural Defects in the 3' Untranslated Region

Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) contains a structured 3' region with hairpins and pseudoknots that form a complex network of noncanonical RNA:RNA interactions supporting higher-order structure critical for translation and replication. We investigated several second-site mutations in the p38 coat protein open reading frame (ORF) that arose in response to a mutation in the asymmetric loop of a critical 3' untranslated region (UTR) hairpin that disrupts local higher-order structure. All tested second-site mutations improved accumulation of TCV in conjunction with a partial reversion of the primary mutation (TCV-rev1) but had neutral or a negative effect on wild-type (wt) TCV or TCV with the primary mutation. SHAPE (selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension) structure probing indicated that these second-site mutations reside in an RNA domain that includes most of p38 (domain 2), and evidence for RNA:RNA interactions between domain 2 and 3'UTR-containing domain 1 was found. However, second-site mutations were not compensatory in the absence of p38, which is also the TCV silencing suppressor, or in dcl-2/dcl4 or ago1/ago2 backgrounds. One second-site mutation reduced silencing suppressor activity of p38 by altering one of two GW motifs that are required for p38 binding to double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs) and interaction with RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC)-associated AGO1/AGO2. Another second-site mutation substantially reduced accumulation of TCV-rev1 in the absence of p38 or DCL2/DCL4. We suggest that the second-site mutations in the p38 ORF exert positive effects through a similar downstream mechanism, either by enhancing accumulation of beneficial DCL-produced viral small RNAs that positively regulate the accumulation of TCV-rev1 or by affecting the susceptibility of TCV-rev1 to RISC loaded with viral small RNAs.

IMPORTANCE

Genomes of positive-strand RNA viruses fold into high-order RNA structures. Viruses with mutations in regions critical for translation and replication often acquire second-site mutations that exert a positive compensatory effect through reestablishment of canonical base pairing with the altered region. In this study, two distal second-site mutations that individually arose in response to a primary mutation in a critical 3' UTR hairpin in the genomic RNA of turnip crinkle virus did not directly interact with the primary mutation. Although different second-site changes had different attributes, compensation was dependent on the production of the viral p38 silencing suppressor and on the presence of silencing-required DCL and AGO proteins. Our results provide an unexpected connection between a 3' UTR primary-site mutation proposed to disrupt higher-order structure and the RNA-silencing machinery.

Rapid evolution of in vivo-selected sequences and structures replacing 20% of a subviral RNA

The 356 nt noncoding satellite RNA C (satC) of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) is composed of 5' sequences from a second TCV satRNA (satD) and 3' sequences derived from TCV. SHAPE structure mapping revealed that 76 nt in the poorly-characterized satD-derived region form an extended hairpin (H2). Pools of satC in which H2 was replaced with 76, 38, or 19 random nt were co-inoculated with TCV helper virus onto plants and satC fitness assessed using in vivo functional selection (SELEX). The most functional progeny satCs, including one as fit as wild-type, contained a 38-39 nt H2 region that adopted a hairpin structure and exhibited an increased ratio of dimeric to monomeric molecules. Some progeny of satC with H2 deleted featured a duplication of 38 nt, partially rebuilding the deletion. Therefore, H2 can be replaced by a 38-39 nt hairpin, sufficient for overall structural stability of the 5' end of satC.

3'UTRs of carmoviruses

Carmovirus is a genus of small, single-stranded, positive-strand RNA viruses in the Tombusviridae. One member of the carmoviruses, Turnip crinkle virus (TCV), has been used extensively as a model for examining the structure and function of RNA elements in 3'UTR as well as in other regions of the virus. Using a variety of genetic, biochemical and computational methods, a structure for the TCV 3'UTR has emerged where secondary structures and tertiary interactions combine to adopt higher order 3-D structures including an internal, ribosome-binding tRNA-shaped configuration that functions as a 3' cap-independent translation enhancer (3'CITE). The TCV 3'CITE also serves as a scaffold for non-canonical interactions throughout the 3'UTR and extending into the upstream open reading frame, interactions that are significantly disrupted upon binding by the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. Long-distance interactions that connect elements in the 3'UTR with both the 5' end and the internal ribosome recoding site suggest that 3'UTR of carmoviruses are intimately involved in multiple functions in the virus life cycle. Although carmoviruses share very similar genome organizations, lengths of 5' and 3'UTRs, and structural features at the 3' end, the similarity rapidly breaks down the further removed from the 3' terminus revealing different 3'CITEs and unique virus-specific structural features. This review summarizes 20 years of work dissecting the structure and function of the 3'UTR of TCV and other carmoviruses. The astonishing structural complexity of the 3'UTRs of these simple carmoviruses provides lessons that are likely applicable to many other plant and animal RNA viruses.

Evolution of a helper virus-derived, ribosome binding translational enhancer in an untranslated satellite RNA of Turnip crinkle virus

SatC is a noncoding subviral RNA associated with Turnip crinkle virus (TCV). A 100-nt stretch in the 3' UTR of TCV contains three hairpins and two pseudoknots that fold into a tRNA-shaped structure (TSS) that binds 80S ribosomes. The 3' half of satC is derived from TCV and contains 6-nt differences in the TSS-analogous region. SatC binds poorly to 80S ribosomes, and molecular modeling that predicted the 3D structure of the TSS did not predict a similar structure for satC. When the satC TSS region was step-wise converted to the original TCV TSS bases, ribosome binding increased to TCV TSS levels without significantly affecting satC replication. However, mutant satC was less fit when accumulating in plants and gave rise to numerous second site changes that weakened one of two satC conformations. These results suggest that minor changes from the original TCV sequence in satC reflect requirements other than elimination of ribosome binding.

Functional RNA elements in the dengue virus genome

Dengue virus (DENV) genome amplification is a process that involves the viral RNA, cellular and viral proteins, and a complex architecture of cellular membranes. The viral RNA is not a passive template during this process; it plays an active role providing RNA signals that act as promoters, enhancers and/or silencers of the replication process. RNA elements that modulate RNA replication were found at the 5′ and 3′ UTRs and within the viral coding sequence. The promoter for DENV RNA synthesis is a large stem loop structure located at the 5′ end of the genome. This structure specifically interacts with the viral polymerase NS5 and promotes RNA synthesis at the 3′ end of a circularized genome. The circular conformation of the viral genome is mediated by long range RNA-RNA interactions that span thousands of nucleotides. Recent studies have provided new information about the requirement of alternative, mutually exclusive, structures in the viral RNA, highlighting the idea that the viral genome is flexible and exists in different conformations. In this article, we describe elements in the promoter SLA and other RNA signals involved in NS5 polymerase binding and activity, and provide new ideas of how dynamic secondary and tertiary structures of the viral RNA participate in the viral life cycle.

RNA-RNA recombination in plant virus replication and evolution

RNA-RNA recombination is one of the strongest forces shaping the genomes of plant RNA viruses. The detection of recombination is a challenging task that prompted the development of both in vitro and in vivo experimental systems. In the divided genome of Brome mosaic virus system, both inter- and intrasegmental crossovers are described. Other systems utilize satellite or defective interfering RNAs (DI-RNAs) of Turnip crinkle virus, Tomato bushy stunt virus, Cucumber necrosis virus, and Potato virus X. These assays identified the mechanistic details of the recombination process, revealing the role of RNA structure and proteins in the replicase-mediated copy-choice mechanism. In copy choice, the polymerase and the nascent RNA chain from which it is synthesized switch from one RNA template to another. RNA recombination was found to mediate the rearrangement of viral genes, the repair of deleterious mutations, and the acquisition of nonself sequences influencing the phylogenetics of viral taxa. The evidence for recombination, not only between related viruses but also among distantly related viruses, and even with host RNAs, suggests that plant viruses unabashedly test recombination with any genetic material at hand.

A balance between circular and linear forms of the dengue virus genome is crucial for viral replication

The plasticity of viral plus strand RNA genomes is fundamental for the multiple functions of these molecules. Local and long-range RNA-RNA interactions provide the scaffold for interacting proteins of the translation, replication, and encapsidation machinery. Using dengue virus as a model, we investigated the relevance of the interplay between two alternative conformations of the viral genome during replication. Flaviviruses require long-range RNA-RNA interactions and genome cyclization for RNA synthesis. Here, we define a sequence present in the viral 3'UTR that overlaps two mutually exclusive structures. This sequence can form an extended duplex by long-range 5'-3' interactions in the circular conformation of the RNA or fold locally into a small hairpin (sHP) in the linear form of the genome. A mutational analysis of the sHP structure revealed an absolute requirement of this element for viral viability, suggesting the need of a linear conformation of the genome. Viral RNA replication showed high vulnerability to changes that alter the balance between circular and linear forms of the RNA. Mutations that shift the equilibrium toward the circular or the linear conformation of the genome spontaneously revert to sequences with different mutations that tend to restore the relative stability of the two competing structures. We propose a model in which the viral genome exists in at least two alternative conformations and the balance between these two states is critical for infectivity.

The terminal loop of a 3' proximal hairpin plays a critical role in replication and the structure of the 3' region of Turnip crinkle virus

Plus-strand RNA viruses serve as templates for translation and then transcription by newly synthesized RdRp. A ribosome-binding tRNA-shaped structure (TSS) and upstream hairpin H4 in the 3' UTR of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) play key roles in translation and transcription. Second-site mutations generated to compensate for altering the critical asymmetric internal loop of H4 included a three- to two-base alteration in the terminal loop of a 3' proximal hairpin (Pr) located downstream of the TSS. Unlike the non-deleterious three-base alteration, single mutations in Pr loop were detrimental for RdRp transcription while enhancing translation and RdRp binding. One deleterious mutation in the Pr loop altered the structures of both the TSS and H4. These complex interactions in the 3' UTR support a compact structural arrangement likely permitting RdRp access to a number of residues within a 195-base region including the 3' end that are necessary for efficient transcription initiation.

Satellite RNAs and Satellite Viruses of Plants

The view that satellite RNAs (satRNAs) and satellite viruses are purely molecular parasites of their cognate helper viruses has changed. The molecular mechanisms underlying the synergistic and/or antagonistic interactions among satRNAs/satellite viruses, helper viruses, and host plants are beginning to be comprehended. This review aims to summarize the recent achievements in basic and practical research, with special emphasis on the involvement of RNA silencing mechanisms in the pathogenicity, population dynamics, and, possibly, the origin(s) of these subviral agents. With further research following current trends, the comprehensive understanding of satRNAs and satellite viruses could lead to new insights into the trilateral interactions among host plants, viruses, and satellites.

RNA conformational changes in the life cycles of RNA viruses, viroids, and virus-associated RNAs

The rugged nature of the RNA structural free energy landscape allows cellular RNAs to respond to environmental conditions or fluctuating levels of effector molecules by undergoing dynamic conformational changes that switch on or off activities such as catalysis, transcription or translation. Infectious RNAs must also temporally control incompatible activities and rapidly complete their life cycle before being targeted by cellular defenses. Viral genomic RNAs must switch between translation and replication, and untranslated subviral RNAs must control other activities such as RNA editing or self-cleavage. Unlike well characterized riboswitches in cellular RNAs, the control of infectious RNA activities by altering the configuration of functional RNA domains has only recently been recognized. In this review, we will present some of these molecular rearrangements found in RNA viruses, viroids and virus-associated RNAs, relating how these dynamic regions were discovered, the activities that might be regulated, and what factors or conditions might cause a switch between conformations.