Defective Interference in the Killer System of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Adaptive evolution of nontransitive fitness in yeast

A common misconception is that evolution is a linear ‘march of progress’, where each organism along a line of descent is more fit than all those that came before it. Rejecting this misconception implies that evolution is nontransitive: a series of adaptive events will, on occasion, produce organisms that are less fit compared to a distant ancestor. Here we identify a nontransitive evolutionary sequence in a 1000-generation yeast evolution experiment. We show that nontransitivity arises due to adaptation in the yeast nuclear genome combined with the stepwise deterioration of an intracellular virus, which provides an advantage over viral competitors within host cells. Extending our analysis, we find that nearly half of our ~140 populations experience multilevel selection, fixing adaptive mutations in both the nuclear and viral genomes. Our results provide a mechanistic case-study for the adaptive evolution of nontransitivity due to multilevel selection in a 1000-generation host/virus evolution experiment.

It is widely accepted in biology that all life on Earth gradually evolved over billions of years from a single ancestor. Yet, there is still much about this process that is not fully understood. Evolution is often thought of as progressing in a linear fashion, with each new generation being better adapted to its environment than the last. But it has been proposed that evolution is also nontransitive: this means even if each generation is ‘fitter’ than its immediate predecessor, these series of adaptive changes will occasionally result in organisms that are less fit than their distant ancestors.

Laboratory experiments of evolution are a good way to test evolutionary theories because they allow researchers to create scenarios that are impossible to observe in natural populations, such as an organism competing against its extinct ancestors. Buskirk et al. set up such an experiment using yeast to determine whether nontransitive effects can be observed in the direct descendants of an organism.

At the start of the experiment, the yeast cells were host to a non-infectious ‘killer’ virus that is common among yeast. Cells containing the virus produce a toxin that destroys other yeast that lack the virus. The populations of yeast were given a nutrient-rich broth in which to grow and subjected to a simple evolutionary pressure: to grow fast, which limits the amount of resources available.

As the yeast evolved, they gained beneficial genetic mutations that allowed them to outcompete their neighbors, and they passed these traits down to their descendants. Some of these mutations occurred not in the yeast genome, but in the genome of the killer virus, and this stopped the yeast infected with the virus from producing the killer toxin. Over time, other mutations resulted in the infected yeast no longer being immune to the toxin. Thus, when Buskirk et al. pitted these yeast against their distant ancestors, the new generation were destroyed by the toxins the older generation produced.

These findings provide the first experimental evidence for nontransitivity along a line of descent. The results have broad implications for our understanding of how evolution works, casting doubts over the idea that evolution always involves a direct progression towards new, improved traits.

Presence of non-suppressive, M2-related dsRNAs molecules in Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains isolated from spontaneous fermentations

Total dsRNA extractions in five killer K2 strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae isolated from spontaneous fermentations revealed the presence of a novel dsRNA fragment (which we named NS dsRNA) of approximately 1.30 kb, together with L and M2 dsRNAs. NS dsRNA appeared to be encapsidated in the same kind of viral particles as L and M2 dsRNA. Northern blot hybridization experiments indicated that NS dsRNA was derived from M2 dsRNA, likely by deletion of the internal A+U-rich region. However, unlike S dsRNAs (suppressive forms derived from M1 dsRNA in K1 killers), NS dsRNA did not induce exclusion of the parental M2 dsRNA when the host strain was maintained for up to 180 generations of growth.

New developments in fungal virology

Although viruses are widely distributed in fungi, their biological significance to their hosts is still poorly understood. A large number of fungal viruses are associated with latent infections of their hosts. With the exception of the killer-immune character in the yeasts, smuts, and hypovirulence in the chestnut blight fungus, fungal properties that can specifically be related to virus infection are not well defined. Mycoviruses are not known to have natural vectors; they are transmitted in nature intracellularly by hyphal anastomosis and heterokaryosis, and are disseminated via spores. Because fungi have a potential for plasmogamy and cytoplasmic exchange during extended periods of their life cycles and because they produce many types of propagules (sexual and asexual spores), often in great profusion, mycoviruses have them accessible to highly efficient means for transmission and spread. It is no surprise, therefore, that fungal viruses are not known to have an extracellular phase to their life cycles. Although extracellular transmission of a few fungal viruses have been demonstrated, using fungal protoplasts, the lack of conventional methods for experimental transmission of these viruses have been, and remains, an obstacle to understanding their biology. The recent application of molecular biological approaches to the study of mycoviral dsRNAs and the improvements in DNA-mediated fungal transformation systems, have allowed a clearer understanding of the molecular biology of mycoviruses to emerge. Considerable progress has been made in elucidating the genome organization and expression strategies of the yeast L-A virus and the unencapsidated RNA virus associated with hypovirulence in the chestnut blight fungus. These recent advances in the biochemical and molecular characterization of the genomes of fungal viruses and associated satellite dsRNAs, as they relate to the biological properties of these viruses and to their interactions with their hosts are the focus of this chapter.

Elimination of L-A double-stranded RNA virus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by expression of gag and gag-pol from an L-A cDNA clone

We report that expression of a nearly full-length cDNA clone of the L-A double-stranded RNA virus causes virus loss in a wild-type strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We show that in this system exclusion of the L-A virus is independent of the presence of the packaging site or of cis sites for replication and transcription and completely dependent on expression of functional recombinant gag and gag-pol fusion protein. Thus, this exclusion is not explained in terms of overexpression of packaging signals. Mutation of the chromosomal SKI2 gene, known to repress the copy number of double-stranded RNA cytoplasmic replicons of S. cerevisiae, nearly eliminates the exclusion. We suggest that exclusion is due to competition by proteins expressed from the plasmid for a possibly limiting cellular factor. Our hypotheses on exclusion of L-A proteins may also apply to resistance to plant viruses produced by expression of viral replicases in transgenic plants.

In vivo mapping of a sequence required for interference with the yeast killer virus

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae viruses are noninfectious double-stranded RNA viruses whose segments are separately encapsidated. A large viral double-stranded RNA (L1; 4580 base pairs) encodes all required viral functions. M1, a double-stranded RNA of 1.9 kilobases, encodes an extracellular toxin (killer toxin) and cellular immunity to that toxin. Some strains contain smaller, S, double-stranded RNAs, derived from M1 by internal deletion. Particles containing these defective interfering RNAs can displace M1 particles by faster replication and thus convert the host strain to a nonkiller phenotype. In this work, we report the development of an assay in which the expression of S plus-strand from an inducible plasmid causes the loss of M1 particles. This assay provides a convenient method for identifying in vivo cis-acting sequences important in viral replication and packaging. We have mapped the sequence involved in interference to a region of 132 base pairs that includes two sequences similar to the viral binding site sequence previously identified in L1 by in vitro experiments.

A deletion mutant of L-A double-stranded RNA replicates like M1 double-stranded RNA

X double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is a 0.52-kilobase dsRNA molecule that arose spontaneously in a nonkiller strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae originally containing L-A and L-BC dsRNAs (L-BC is the same size as L-A but shares no homology with it). X hybridized with L-A, and direct RNA sequencing of X showed that the first 5' 25 base pairs (of the X positive strand) and at least the last 110 base pairs of the 3' end were identical to the ends of L-A dsRNA. X showed cytoplasmic inheritance and, like M1, was dependent on L-A for its maintenance. X was encapsidated in viruslike particles whose major coat protein was provided by L-A (as is true for M1), and X was found in viruslike particles with one to eight X molecules per particle. This finding confirms our "head-full replication" model originally proposed for M1 and M2. Like M1 or M2, X lowers the copy number of L-A, especially in a ski host. Surprisingly, X requires many chromosomal MAK genes that are necessary for M1 but not for L-A.

The internal polyadenylate tract of yeast killer virus M1 double-stranded RNA is variable in length

The 1.8-kbp M1 double-stranded (ds) RNA from type 1 killer strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains an internal 200-bp adenine- and uracil-rich region. We have previously demonstrated that this region consists primarily of adenine residues on the plus strand of M1 dsRNA and on the full-length, in vitro synthesized (+) transcript (denoted m) of M1 dsRNA, neither of which contains 3'-terminal polyadenylate. We now show that there is variability in the length of the polyadenylate tracts of m transcripts synthesized in vitro by virions purified from either of the K1 diploid killer strains A364A X S7 or A364A X 1384. This variability reflects size differences seen in the corresponding M1 dsRNA genomes which, along with other data presented, localizes the variability in the length of M1 dsRNA to the adenine- and uracil-rich region.

Conserved regions in defective interfering viral double-stranded RNAs from a yeast virus

We have completely sequenced a defective interfering viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) from the Saccharomyces cerevisiae virus. This RNA (S14) is a simple internal deletion of its parental dsRNA, M1, of 1.9 kilobases. The 5' 964 bases of the M1 plus strand encode the type 1 killer toxin of the yeast. S14 is 793 base pairs (bp) long, with 253 bp from the 5' region of its parental plus strand and 540 bp from the 3' region. All three defective interfering RNAs derived from M1 that have been characterized so far preserve a large 3' region, which includes five repeats of a rotationally symmetrical 11-bp consensus sequence. This 11-bp sequence is not present in the 5' 1 kilobase of the parental RNA or in any of the sequenced regions of unrelated yeast viral dsRNAs, but it is present in the 3' region of the plus strand of another yeast viral dsRNA, M2, that encodes the type 2 killer toxin. The 3' region of 550 bases of the M1 plus strand, previously only partially sequenced, reveals no large open reading frames. Hence only about half of M1 appears to have a coding function.

Sequence of the M1-2 region of killer virus double-stranded RNA

A full-length complementary DNA (cDNA) copy of the M1-2 region of the double-stranded genome of the yeast killer virus was synthesized by reverse transcription, utilizing the m in vitro transcript as template and synthetic primers for both strands. The sequence lacks any long open reading frames (ORFs). The internal portion of the M1-2 region includes the sequence that is linked to the subterminal 229 bases of the M1-1 homologous region in the S3 defective-interfering mutant of killer virus double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). Thus, the probable site at which the deletion occurred in S3 has been identified.

On the mechanism of exclusion of M2 double-stranded RNA by L-A-E double-stranded RNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

L-A-E double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), when introduced into cells carrying L-A-H and M2 dsRNAs, does not eliminate the L-A-H dsRNA, but (i) L-A-E does lower the copy number of L-A-H dramatically and (ii) L-A-E eliminates M2 dsRNA from the cell. That these two effects of L-A-E are related is shown by the fact that mutants of a strain carrying L-A-H and M2 selected for their resistance to exclusion of M2 by L-A-E [effect (ii)] have an altered L-A-H whose copy number is not lowered by L-A-E [effect (i)]. Although the L-A in K1 strains (L-A-HN in all cases examined) differs significantly both genetically and physically from the L-A in the K2 strain studied (L-A-H), the L-A-HN from the K1 strains can maintain M2 dsRNA, and the L-A-H from the K2 strains can maintain M1 dsRNA.

Double-stranded RNAs that encode killer toxins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: unstable size of M double-stranded RNA and inhibition of M2 replication by M1

The sizes of M1 and M2 (but not L) change rapidly with growth, varying by perhaps as much as 33%. Size variation is seen within 76 generations. In addition, the exclusion of M2 by M1 or L-A-E [( EXL]) is mediated by inhibition of replication or segregation, not by enhanced degradation of preexisting molecules.

Double-stranded RNAs that encode killer toxins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: unstable size of M double-stranded RNA and inhibition of M2 replication by M1

The sizes of M1 and M2 (but not L) change rapidly with growth, varying by perhaps as much as 33%. Size variation is seen within 76 generations. In addition, the exclusion of M2 by M1 or L-A-E [( EXL]) is mediated by inhibition of replication or segregation, not by enhanced degradation of preexisting molecules.

Genome structure and expression of a defective interfering mutant of the killer virus of yeast

A large internal deletion in M1 double-stranded (ds) RNA from the killer virus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae generates a suppressive (S3) dsRNA molecule. Strains which harbor S3 dsRNA are defective in toxin production and immunity to the toxin. The biochemical defect in expression has been investigated and is apparently due to truncation of the protoxin polypeptide translation reading frame on S3 dsRNA. Transcription in vivo, and in isolated virions in vitro, results in the synthesis of a full-length positive polarity messenger RNA, denoted s. The s transcript contains no long poly(A) tracts as determined by its lack of affinity for oligo(dT)-cellulose, and as inferred by sequence analysis of approximately 87% of the S3 dsRNA genome. These data support a model for template coding of polyadenylate in transcripts derived from the wild-type M1 dsRNA. The orientation of the sequences conserved on S3 dsRNA with respect to M1 dsRNA has been determined. Some of the conserved sequences are likely to be required for the maintenance and replication of these viral dsRNA genomes in S. cerevisiae.

Superkiller mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae suppress exclusion of M2 double-stranded RNA by L-A-HN and confer cold sensitivity in the presence of M and L-A-HN

In an mktl host, L-A-HN double-stranded RNA excludes M2 double-stranded RNA at 30 degrees C but not at 20 degrees C. Recessive mutations suppressing the exclusion of M2 by L-A-HN in an mktl host include six ski (superkiller) genes, three of which (ski6, ski7 and ski8) are new genes. The dominant mutations in one gene (MKS50) and recessive mutations in at least two genes (mks1 and mks2) suppress M2 exclusion by L-A-HN but do not show other characteristics of ski mutations and thus define a new class of killer-related chromosomal genes. Mutations in ski2, ski3, ski4, ski6, ski7, and ski8 result in increased M copy number at 30 degrees C and prevent the cells from growing at 8 degrees C. Elimination of M double-stranded RNA from a cold-sensitive ski- strain results in the loss of cold sensitivity. ski- [KIL-sd1] strains lack L-A-HN, carry L-A-E, and have a lower M1 copy number than do ski- [KIL-k1] strains and are only slightly cold sensitive. The LTS5 (=MAK6) product is required both for low temperature growth and for M1 maintenance or replication. We propose that the elevated levels of M in ski- strains divert the host LTS5 product away from the host and to the M replication process. We also suggest that the essential role of L-A in M replication is protection of M double-stranded RNA from the negative influence of SKI+ products.

Double-stranded ribonucleic acid killer systems in yeasts

Images

Superkiller mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae suppress exclusion of M2 double-stranded RNA by L-A-HN and confer cold sensitivity in the presence of M and L-A-HN

In an mktl host, L-A-HN double-stranded RNA excludes M2 double-stranded RNA at 30 degrees C but not at 20 degrees C. Recessive mutations suppressing the exclusion of M2 by L-A-HN in an mktl host include six ski (superkiller) genes, three of which (ski6, ski7 and ski8) are new genes. The dominant mutations in one gene (MKS50) and recessive mutations in at least two genes (mks1 and mks2) suppress M2 exclusion by L-A-HN but do not show other characteristics of ski mutations and thus define a new class of killer-related chromosomal genes. Mutations in ski2, ski3, ski4, ski6, ski7, and ski8 result in increased M copy number at 30 degrees C and prevent the cells from growing at 8 degrees C. Elimination of M double-stranded RNA from a cold-sensitive ski- strain results in the loss of cold sensitivity. ski- [KIL-sd1] strains lack L-A-HN, carry L-A-E, and have a lower M1 copy number than do ski- [KIL-k1] strains and are only slightly cold sensitive. The LTS5 (=MAK6) product is required both for low temperature growth and for M1 maintenance or replication. We propose that the elevated levels of M in ski- strains divert the host LTS5 product away from the host and to the M replication process. We also suggest that the essential role of L-A in M replication is protection of M double-stranded RNA from the negative influence of SKI+ products.